Re: Singles Not More Efficient
TomD
"Single irons are not more efficient. Even at the same cutting angle, the double iron does appropriate work longer (as in doesn't require a significant amount of downforce to stay in the cut)."
I am not sure that is much of a measure of efficiency, you should see what I weigh. But more to the point, a point I have been making with zero uptake for a long time (we have all been there) is that the geometry of the Japanese plane is self-setting. If your plane wasn't heavy enough, or you weren't inclined to provide the force, you can cut with great effect using a Japanese plane if it had no weight at all. The net effect between the hands using a J. plane versus a Western (W) is that the J plane is like using an anchor to anchor a boat, and the geometry of a W plane is like sharpening a stick, tying a chaing to the blunt end, and throwing that in the water as an anchor.
"Couple that with the fact that it works at a lower angle and you can take a larger shaving."
That isopen to question. You seem to be just ponging from the fact you were originally in the 55 degree camp, but you could have been in the low angle camp. When you have high angle you have fiber setting force but less cutting power. When you have low angle you have more cutting power. When you have a double blade you have both built into the plane, which ought to be better, but in many cases is not necessary, and therefore is more trouble, and also more resistance to forward force. I could plane fly rods, or bows my whole life, and folks called bowyer, and fletcher did do just that with the archery tackle, and never need a breaker, and the list of such tasks is extensive. The simple folk with their adzes, axes, and draw knives just learned to work the wood.
"The comment about George being able to use anything he wanted to was literally that, if planes would've been made from pine and medium carbon steel, george would've done good work with them."
As may be, but how does this support your contentions. He isn't some mythical creature he is presumably close to the norm for actual woodworkers.
"The post suggested that based on feedback from CW, larry's point of view was more valid. My point was that people at CW didn't have a choice, they used the style of planes larry and the toolmaker's shop (george) were told to make for them. Double iron planes were out of the question."
I do think that needs corroboration, more than one source. Someone in the place you put Larry, would essentially be lying for commercial advantage. Since I don't see anyone else in this argument with that much to loose, I think we owe him, or the truth, more than that. Sometimes we compress arguments for what passes for brevity here. Maybe Larry compressed something like that they used doubles, then the history police cracked down, then they bought his planes, and the guys said to him they were better overall. Both sides are telling the truth, no win for doubles. There are many potential scenarios that don't require us to douse a guy who is a Tennessee living treasure.
And I still say, that unless the product CW makes is unusually simple in grain, or some other such thing, the fact they do their work with single blades still poses a problem for you. There is a Woodwright where he goes to see some guys at CW making panels, and most of the work is plane work, and my sense is they are dripping with enthusiasm over their planes that look just like C&W planes. Maybe I remember too much from the scenes, but it was as though they were holding a winning lottery ticket.
"At one point, I believed using a single iron plane was more efficient because you don't need to set the cap iron or take it apart, but I no longer believe that. The double iron plane allows you to do more work in the same amount of time."
You are overplaying your case, at best you are talking about one kind of plane work, at one max cutting depth, and with one set of problems in the wood. For this we are calling Larry out? How many different types of planes do you think they use at CW? And the efficiency limitation you mention above is still there. It may be less in your boutique case, but that would be it.
"And why not a bunch of single iron planes? Because they take more effort to push and stay in the cut for fewer feet of work. I wish that weren't the case, if it wasn't, I never would've searched for a double iron plane to take over duties from the JT brown jointer, an expertly made plane from the early 1800s that I found in unused condition. It is a beautiful plane. It just can't hold a candle to the double iron jointers I have and have had in actual work."
I mean again, sounds like we work the same woods for the most part, walnut, cherry, beech, and maple in many wondrous forms. I have 5 jointers, I never set the breakers, i never get tear out. One is a low angle I got sold on when there was all the yapping about how great those are, no problem. It is possible, It just doesn't happen, maybe it is the predominant radial wood. Maybe I select wood with more care (though I doubt if for furniture). Maybe I never plane it against the grain, maybe I do something relative to the secondary grain. I would be a little worried about jointing a ton of stuff that was so bad I was essentially gluing end grain, or making legs out of crap grade. I just can't even get seriously excited about the problems of jointing wood. I can do it with my eyes closed. If I went blind I could still joint wood. I can see having a rocket plane for it, I have one for short joint lines with a low aspect ratio, but that's just because why wouldn't you... In fact if I got hair on the peach why would I want a better cut for gluing. But usually it is very smooth.