New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Posts

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#51

Schwarz blog 2007 *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Steve, I agree that the Kato paper you brought to us years ago did not influence many people. At that time there was a cascade of criticism and a denial that the double iron actually worked in any kind of practical way. Many insisted that it would not work with tropical or Australian woods. The Schwarz blog is a good example. At the time I wrote that anyone who thinks that the cap iron needs to be within .004 inches (as Schwarz claimed) might reread the paper. Lee Valley, sponsor of one of the Schwarz blogs apparently still quotes that misinformation to discredit the double iron. Raney Nelson actually did reread the paper and apologized for being a "bonehead". Yet when I met Raney 18 months later he told me that I was the only one using the double iron and maybe I ought to give it up. In that era the fora were full of people trying discredit my words, questioning my integrity, sanity, and competence.

David Weaver admitted knowing how to use the cap iron in 2011, but called it clumsy and impractical. However on March 2, 2012, Bob Strawn wrote a long post on Sawmill Creek about how he loved the chipbreaker. Three weeks later David, who had responded to Strawn in that thread, was also a convert. When we talked about it on this forum, Bill Tindall actually asked us to hold off discussing it while he rushed to bring out the video. We did not.

The video came out in a very different climate than the Kato paper. Instead of just one person promoting the technique there were three, and two were former naysayers, which made for a very lively atmosphere. And shortly thereafter former skeptic Kees joined the converts with endless promotion. I think the atmosphere in which the Kato material was revisited made the difference, not the video.


Schwarz blog

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#52

Re: Singles Not More Efficient

TomD

"Single irons are not more efficient. Even at the same cutting angle, the double iron does appropriate work longer (as in doesn't require a significant amount of downforce to stay in the cut)."

I am not sure that is much of a measure of efficiency, you should see what I weigh. But more to the point, a point I have been making with zero uptake for a long time (we have all been there) is that the geometry of the Japanese plane is self-setting. If your plane wasn't heavy enough, or you weren't inclined to provide the force, you can cut with great effect using a Japanese plane if it had no weight at all. The net effect between the hands using a J. plane versus a Western (W) is that the J plane is like using an anchor to anchor a boat, and the geometry of a W plane is like sharpening a stick, tying a chaing to the blunt end, and throwing that in the water as an anchor.

"Couple that with the fact that it works at a lower angle and you can take a larger shaving."

That isopen to question. You seem to be just ponging from the fact you were originally in the 55 degree camp, but you could have been in the low angle camp. When you have high angle you have fiber setting force but less cutting power. When you have low angle you have more cutting power. When you have a double blade you have both built into the plane, which ought to be better, but in many cases is not necessary, and therefore is more trouble, and also more resistance to forward force. I could plane fly rods, or bows my whole life, and folks called bowyer, and fletcher did do just that with the archery tackle, and never need a breaker, and the list of such tasks is extensive. The simple folk with their adzes, axes, and draw knives just learned to work the wood.

"The comment about George being able to use anything he wanted to was literally that, if planes would've been made from pine and medium carbon steel, george would've done good work with them."

As may be, but how does this support your contentions. He isn't some mythical creature he is presumably close to the norm for actual woodworkers.

"The post suggested that based on feedback from CW, larry's point of view was more valid. My point was that people at CW didn't have a choice, they used the style of planes larry and the toolmaker's shop (george) were told to make for them. Double iron planes were out of the question."

I do think that needs corroboration, more than one source. Someone in the place you put Larry, would essentially be lying for commercial advantage. Since I don't see anyone else in this argument with that much to loose, I think we owe him, or the truth, more than that. Sometimes we compress arguments for what passes for brevity here. Maybe Larry compressed something like that they used doubles, then the history police cracked down, then they bought his planes, and the guys said to him they were better overall. Both sides are telling the truth, no win for doubles. There are many potential scenarios that don't require us to douse a guy who is a Tennessee living treasure.

And I still say, that unless the product CW makes is unusually simple in grain, or some other such thing, the fact they do their work with single blades still poses a problem for you. There is a Woodwright where he goes to see some guys at CW making panels, and most of the work is plane work, and my sense is they are dripping with enthusiasm over their planes that look just like C&W planes. Maybe I remember too much from the scenes, but it was as though they were holding a winning lottery ticket.

"At one point, I believed using a single iron plane was more efficient because you don't need to set the cap iron or take it apart, but I no longer believe that. The double iron plane allows you to do more work in the same amount of time."

You are overplaying your case, at best you are talking about one kind of plane work, at one max cutting depth, and with one set of problems in the wood. For this we are calling Larry out? How many different types of planes do you think they use at CW? And the efficiency limitation you mention above is still there. It may be less in your boutique case, but that would be it.

"And why not a bunch of single iron planes? Because they take more effort to push and stay in the cut for fewer feet of work. I wish that weren't the case, if it wasn't, I never would've searched for a double iron plane to take over duties from the JT brown jointer, an expertly made plane from the early 1800s that I found in unused condition. It is a beautiful plane. It just can't hold a candle to the double iron jointers I have and have had in actual work."

I mean again, sounds like we work the same woods for the most part, walnut, cherry, beech, and maple in many wondrous forms. I have 5 jointers, I never set the breakers, i never get tear out. One is a low angle I got sold on when there was all the yapping about how great those are, no problem. It is possible, It just doesn't happen, maybe it is the predominant radial wood. Maybe I select wood with more care (though I doubt if for furniture). Maybe I never plane it against the grain, maybe I do something relative to the secondary grain. I would be a little worried about jointing a ton of stuff that was so bad I was essentially gluing end grain, or making legs out of crap grade. I just can't even get seriously excited about the problems of jointing wood. I can do it with my eyes closed. If I went blind I could still joint wood. I can see having a rocket plane for it, I have one for short joint lines with a low aspect ratio, but that's just because why wouldn't you... In fact if I got hair on the peach why would I want a better cut for gluing. But usually it is very smooth.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#53

Re: better wood... but not faster.

TomD

"It's not a supposition that you can't do good work with a single iron, it's the supposition that it's easier to do it faster with a double iron."

I don't believe that, but it would take some kind of competition that FK would then win just because he is better.

I'm sure there are some situtions where it is better, that is why they exist, but overall faster is a big ask.

If we started from the blade out of the plane to give a few seconds for the fiddle factor with doubles. I would be cutting in probably 5 seconds with my single. I can do a total resharpen cycle in under 20 seconds (without the actual sharpening, I did a report on cycling planes, maybe someone can find it). You would be behind, particularly if you had tools that needed to be reached for. From that point on my plane would be cutting at the efficient setting, a little fat, and the wood would be melting away. My wooden plane would slide like glass, no shaving would ever gets caught or needs to be removed by hand, and then as we came to the final passes, I would pass it to George who would finish it off as perfectly as if it had a breaker, according to you (George being just symbolic of that skill level in this instance). I would probably tap end grain to end grain to get a finer setting for George if he gave me the nod and before I handed it off. So exactly where are you picking up the speed? Unless the grain is something tragic like Osage where the wood can fail in huge chunk, a fatter shaving is not going to mater in the early going, and you have already conceded some human can make the final passes effectively. Best case you have training wheels. I do not see how you have presented any speed argument for doubles. There is a cut argument in very restricted cases.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#54

Re: It's not the plane you run...

TomD

I went through an identical period a while back and the posts where in my offer to sell my LN. I was feeling a little financially pressed at the time. Actually better off than now by a mile, but it is all psychological. I have said many times over the years that if my shop burned I would just restock with tools I had made, possible exception being saws, since I get by with cheap ones and they are time consuming to make. I have really been through it several times. Started out with Dad's tools, went all Japanese at the outset, then for fun worked my way through Chinese, German, UK, etc... When I initially went off the Japanese tools, I still use them, but went on a wander, it was that discovery, that one knew was out there that one could do good work with anything.

I am not a collector, but these tools have been with me for 35 years or more, so I don't really need to get rid of them. And I think there is unfinished business in which I may develop an interest the moment I sell some category...

There is still that Odate story. As a shooter i understood that good tools improve everyone more or less equally. But maybe the Odate story isn't about whether the beginer can gain from the better tools, maybe there is a point after you get to where we are. If we don't depend on the tool, why would we have bad ones. Is there nothing there? There is the story in the book or 5 rings where the samurai defeats a notable opponent with a stick, not even a sword, should such a master still not have the superior sword? He just had one opponent. In an actual life or death battle against many, where the master has the proven in the dojo the capability to beat all comers for several continuous days, an oar might not be enough. So one thing that is conspicuously absent, and which I had an interest in as a kid, was actually working a long day and doing a lot of work. Today, not interested, too sore. But there is still that level. You are not incorporating volume of work in any of your consideration. Real volume, piece work. And none of us does. Out of interest does anyone know how hard people work at CW? I assume not terribly hard between answering questions and all. But as a skill thing, having done fly tying piece work. I have always been interested in speed.

Also when you are at the stage you are at, where you are brand and even for the most part, type uncoupled. That is the time to go back to wooden tools. It's not the plane you run, it's how you run the plane you have. When you are there there is zero reason for anything but wooden tools, as simple as possible, by definition.

Getting back to where we started with doubles. You used to be... Hotley guy for the sake of argument, but now you are wooden plane with a double guy. You know someone who can do it all with anything. Guess where you are going next.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#55

Re: 2006

david weaver

I didn't start woodworking until sometime in 2005 or 2006, I can't remember which because it was a novelty back then and a coworkers husband was getting me into a form of woodworking that is not discussed much on the forums (the guy is a fanatical machine shop user literally to make metal fixtures and metal patterns to work wood - he's a mechanical engineer and believes the further we are from the wood, the better the results will be).

The only videos I didn't view with skepticism were David Charlesworth, and the first thing I did before I even had a tool to sharpen was watch David's plane sharpening video that someone else lent me. Most of the rest of the stuff I ignored if it wasn't a pro.

Anyway, there was a big burst of people picking up woodworking mid 2000s, at least it seemed that way and I spent a lot of my early time on woodnet, which is sort of like the groundhog day of woodworking forums.

Whereas your era of stuff was memorable, my era of starting was forgettable. It was pop wood bloggers on a major upswing and "need to see" sessions of rudimentary instructions at conferences and that type of stuff. I never paid attention to much of it and will never quote anyone religiously the way some people quote tage frid or the way people send me stinky PMs if I say that I'd pay attention to a professional woodworker before going to the blogosphere to look around in bizzaro world where you're required to write about something before you can actually do it competently.

I got what I need to get out of the internet, and now what I need is time at the bench. I suspect that is the case for a lot of us, except for the folks who view the internet as an alternate social environment. I guess that's OK, but I'm not a social guy and I can live without it. I'm sure you could, too, but once you've been woodworking for 40 years as you have, it's like looking at the moustache of the lady working at the register at wendy's. It does you no good to look at it, but it satisfies a morbid fascination of some type and creates an entire tree of hypothetical questions and scenarios to run through your mind.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#56

Re: before 2011

david weaver

I suppose I knew how to use it hypothetically but not practically. Because of an argument where I set the cap iron very close and had no tearout but concluded it was cumbersome to use because you had to fiddle with it and you still had a hard to push plane.

20 years from now, I won't remember any of this stuff. 20 years from now I won't remember how I learned to shave with a straight razor, either. The way I learned to shave with a straight razor is the same way I learned to use the double iron - I didn't use anything else for a month or so. Maybe that helped me move toward the double iron, though, but getting competence in something takes a couple of weeks (or days or months, depending on what it is). Or as my old college professor (who taught the courses in my professional area) said, (gaining) "knowlege hurts".

I recall bob strawn talking about it at the time, and I recall raney mentioning that he had only ever met one other person (other than warren) who used a double iron.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#57

some corrrections and comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would have been satisfied to stay out of this dead horse beating but my name came up.

Schwartz- Indeed he did not read and/or understand the abstract of the Kato and Kawai paper on cap iron for his response to the information in the paper is way off base. To be clear, the link is to a summary of a translation of a scientific paper by Kato and Kawai posted on Elliot’s web site. The objective of the Kato and Kawai paper was to investigate wear on Super Surfacer blades as a function of cap iron position. The pictures in this link are not from this paper but rather from a video Kato showed at a scientific conference mainly to illustrate that they could take the pictures. While the data in this abstract is useful for illustrating that the cap iron works to mitigate tear out,**** this data was never meant to suggest optimum settings for the cap iron or describe how to optimally set the cap iron.***** This fact has been lost on many readers. We should have been more clear in the abstract that the settings were not recommendations.

In a tutorial we have not fully translated or abstracted these authors, who are teachers at a technical school, describe how to optimally set the cap iron for a given planning situation. We would have been better served to translate and abstract this paper and not the other but this paper was sent to me later as an afterthought by Professor Kato. It is clear that the Japanese authors regarded setting the cap iron as common knowledge to be imparted to beginning students of the trade.

Citation- Planecraft, Hampton Ltd, Sheffield England 1934 republished by Woodcraft 1974, page 43. Setting the cap iron for "hard woods with irregular grain". Set " as close as you can get to the cutting edge" [according to the Kato and Kawai tutorial this recommendation is a simplification of the setting]

Teaching- Making claims and vague descriptions don't and didn’t provide much benefit. Actually teaching someone does. If you have taught anyone how to set the cap iron or otherwise motivate them to successfully try it you can claim some credit. In recent history, Kees comes to mind as providing the greatest contribution.

“Bill Tindall actually asked us to hold off discussing it while he rushed to bring out the video. We did not.” Not according to my memory but it is good that you prevailed against my nefarious scheme if in fact I was trying to stifle someone teaching how to employ the cap iron effect. For the record I made the video available to anyone interested as soon as I got it from Professor Kawai. Professor Kato asked that it not be used for commercial purposes which delayed putting it up on commercial web sites until his request could be clarified.

Why are we beating this dead horse? The Kees and Pan article in Popular Woodworking and Weaver’s in WoodCentral describe how to set up the cap iron for all to see and learn. (A tip in the Kato and Kawai tutorial would also be useful). If people want to try it they can learn how from these sources and in short order decide to use it or not in their work. What more needs to be said?

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#58

Re: I guess...

david weaver

..and I really can't conclude anything differently. I have experience only in using metal planes, and then using wooden single iron planes and now double iron (wooden) planes. Unfortunately, I've gotten better at working wood along the way and I can't state definitively what it is that made that, true.

Here's my shot at why double iron planes are faster, especially if you consider dimensioning from rough. Invariably, they only add a little when needed to the jacking part of the work. The middle part of the planing work, though, they basically allow you to work without risk with and against the grain, leaving nothing that can't be removed with a coarse and then couple of fine passes with a smoother. The coarse pass with the smoother is also something a single iron plane can't do neatly.

The removal of risk means I can work a heavy shaving (heavier than I'd be able to work at a steeper angle, and one that wouldn't be without risk if the plane was single iron at a lower angle) and work right to the top of a marked line, then removing the remainder of the line with a couple of smoother passes.

That just wasn't a luxury I had with single iron planes, though I tried it a couple of times and got burned. My first set of wooden planes were all single iron, and proper - I kept the JT brown jointer I refer to. It is a good plane, but it is not as capable as a double iron plane when it comes to speed. I can't take the heavy shaving without risk, the finish isn't as good and sometimes it's enough poorer that it's problematic working to a mark. And with the same type of iron as the double iron plane, it needs to be sharpened more often, which negates the time screwing and unscrewing the iron and the 10-15 seconds or so it takes to set the cap iron on a double iron plane.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#59

Re: Pushing discussions

david weaver

I kind of threw up in my mouth a little about the words super here, but I do push discussions. I push people to get a little bit on edge so that they'll discuss more and I don't faction with anyone (it's like politics, something I don't participate in either - I don't think I should be banned from agreeing or disagreeing with anyone).

If it makes anyone feel better, I don't have any better manners in real life and don't have the "small talk" skills it takes to have a discussion with folks I have nothing in common with, or to present a fake smile when someone says something offensive or incorrect.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#60

Re: wood...yes..

david weaver

..It might not be clear. I've been using mostly wooden planes for a couple of years now, though I have squared edges often with a metal jointer and still use a stanley 4 for smoothing. Smoothing is such a quick part of the process after the rest is done properly that it's only 10% of the effort at most.

I agree, though. I have gone in every direction. The double iron thing opened up a whole world of decent planes that most woodworkers will never figure out how to use for fine work - double iron planes that seemingly have a large mouth and somewhat coarsely made cap iron. I have a couple of japanese planes that I use regularly, but unlike most folks, more for coarse work than fine work, and mostly because a person in my physical shape will need some variation if they think they are going to work for a multi-hour period. I don't like the cap iron on japanese planes quite as much because it can lose its relative position to the iron and I can't set it as quickly as the western planes, which get set once for each sharpening and that's it.

(crossing posts maybe, this might've been in another post) I did defend holtey, I still like Karl and would love to have one of his A13s, and was probably at 50/50 of buying one 5 years ago (which would've been significant money for me and demanded that I use the plane). I like Karl still even though I'm not the type of person who would be a customer any longer, but because karl does things to karl's standards that karl has spent a lifetime determining. i admire individuals who really are experts, and think very little of a new woodworker who pretends to know that karl should somehow magically make the same planes for a tenth of the price.

I'm all wood other than a smoother from here on out, though. This whole planebuilding thing has been all about that, and the unloading of all of the LN planes has been my desire to not look at unused planes on a rack - they cannot get me 5 hours in the shop with the same level of fatigue as wooden planes.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#61

Re: as I recall..

david weaver

.. we had the discussions here, and Bill sent me an email through the system. It said something like "based on your discussions, I have something I think you'll be interested in but I don't have it yet".

I think I started fiddling with the double iron as the only way to plane in february, I used a couple of guinea pigs on SMC (via PM) and brought it up here. The guinea pigs were just to see if I relayed what I did, would they get the same results, and they did. And warren already specified the date when it came up here and I said "you were right, warren".

I don't recall a delay request, but I don't ever do anything when someone else tells me to, anyway, so I wouldn't have noticed it.

I made a big stink on another forum when I got one too many PM's telling me that the origin of the wave of cap iron discussion was Chris Schwarz. They would've never seen the video without Bill and Steve's efforts, and nobody had any regard for my advice otherwise (which I gave before the video, but with little effect).

We are, of course, way past the part where people are getting taught to use a cap iron (or at least more realistically, the starting point to learning to use one), but this is wood central, and as long as I can remember, we go deeper into the rabbit hole here than anywhere else. It has only been calm the last couple of years because Todd and Larry have taken a hiatus, as have some of the other old-time names that have disappeared from recent posting.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#62

Re: OT Persuasion over the Internet

wilbur

There are different types of learning, and different approaches to teaching. The internet certainly makes learning about a subject more accessible to someone who may not have access to a local source, but it still doesn’t completely substitute for all kinds of learning methods.

There’s a thing called kinesthetic learning, sometimes called tactile learning. This is the sort of learning that you can only do by engaging in the activity you’re trying to learn. In my day job, part of what I do is teach medical students about pediatrics. I can talk to them all I want about doing a physical exam of the heart in a kid, and play recordings and run simulations, but until the medical student actually listens to a whole bunch of kids, they will never really understand what a murmur sounds like.

Many aspects of learning woodworking are the same. I know that until I physically saw a fine shaving that my neighbor made with a hand plane and tried it myself, I had no idea what a hand plane was capable of doing, and that my concept of a fine shaving really was not what it should be. The same goes for a sharp edge, a tearout free surface, a tight glue line — the list goes on and on.

Which brings us to disseminating the knowledge of the chipbreaker and its function. I think that showing what a chipbreaker can do in terms of controlling tearout would be super easy if we were doing this in person. Trying to convey that over the internet would be much harder, because this really is something that is best learned in person. That’s probably why Steve’s website, or Warren’s relating of his experiences, didn’t make much headway for such a long time. It’s not because of their lack of effort. I think that this was inherently a hard task to accomplish.

I don’t think it’s fair to blame the folks that were not convinced by reading this information on chipbreakers, either, especially since there are other methods of achieving a tearout free surface with hand tools. You may disagree as to whether a higher effective cutting angle, or going to a card scraper, will give you a better result than using a chipbreaker, but I do think it’s easier to get those concepts across at a distance than how to effectively use a chipbreaker.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#63

Re: Ahh..this is the post I was looking for

david weaver

.. above.

You're right about the holtey thing (funny I suppose that even when I thought single iron and 4 thousandth mouth was the voice of authority - and it still may be for someone who doesn't use many planes and who has a very good machine jointer and planer), I always admired the form that holtey makes that has a double iron.

I could do the work with the single iron planes, part of the reason I'm so insistent on double irons any time someone asks (and it seems like they're experienced) is like a wrestling gimmick. The truth is that I can work so-so wood much faster now than I could before, same with good wood that's quartered. Faster work, less risk. Result any different than before? No, just faster and physically more satisfying to do.

I still would LOVE to have a holtey A13 in boxwood. I don't suppose with two kids to put through college in the future and working in a dying industry that would be responsible on my part, though.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#64

Re: Summary and observation

William Duffield

I have ordered a custom 42 degree frog for a Veritas #4

Derek, What do you expect to accomplish with the 42° frog?

Sure, you can make it work for smoothing with a closely set chip breaker, especially if you regrind the leading edge of the Veritas chip breaker at a much higher angle, but it seems to me that the most important reason for the frogger :) is to allow the plane to be used efficiently for shooting end grain.

I have one for my #4-1/2, but my intent is to use the wider blade with a ramped (admittedly a conceit) shooting board. I'm almost tempted to grind the top of one side of the body flat and parallel to the sole (imitating a Bedrock) so it causes less wear on the shooting board track. I decided a long time ago I didn't need a 604-1/2 in my arsenal because of the price/performance ratio, but the new Veritas custom planes have significantly changed the equation. I ordered mine originally with a 45° frog (on the day it was introduced) because I knew I wouldn't need a higher angle frog.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#65

Re: Summary and observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, What do you expect to accomplish with the 42° frog?


Hi William

I have been able to plane interlocked hardwood pretty well well with a 40 degree frog and chipbreaker. The finish is smoother than with a 50 degree frog and chipbreaker. Once a finish is applied, the difference disappears. It is on interlocked softwood that the lower frog angle scores. Higher frogs leave a more noticeably matt finish.

Regards fom Perth

Derek

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#66

Doesn't jibe *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thom, you write:

I had no idea people didn't know [how to use the double iron], still blows me away as I keep saying. And it is possible there are others out there who felt the same way, so they wouldn't say anything either.

I am having trouble reconciling that with with a statement you made in 2010. It was in response to a statement Larry made that there were problems with the wedge on a double iron plane that were never solved. You did not say "lots of people know how to use a double iron plane." Instead you wrote:

Thank you Larry, that is an interesting perspective on the double irons. I dropped those decades ago when I noticed they didn't really seem to affect my cut much though they do interesting things for the shaving.

So you knew how to use the double iron but it did not seem to affect the cut? When Larry wrote "cutting geometry is more effective with difficult grain than cap irons", it did not seem odd? And now concerning stock preparation you write:

Unless doubles are better in the situation, or better overall, why bother. Singles are more efficient.

This does not sound like someone who has learned the art of the double iron.


2010 discussion

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#67

Re: Huge shift in the vibe

TomD

The vibe has changed here. Super planes in the past were fine shavings and polished surfaces. That is what earlier discussion relater to. Today post breaker it is all about tear out free surfaces at shaving sizes two to five times thicker. That is what I thought you guys were talking about. If so, what are you talking about? There isn't any comparison between what you use in the former discussion with what you use in the latter discussion.

As far as Larry is concerned, I have way more than one agenda. Some time ago I developed an interest in the kind of planes he made. I was looking for new fields to conquer, and was sorta feeling I have planes from a lot of cultures but not my own. My grandfather was a joiner, and I have never thrown myself into investigating the tools from the UK cultural background. I have used some of them, but never made a proper set. I was frame by frame studying CW videos where the planes are used, and copying and measuring planes off the C&W site, and so forth. I got some great assistance off this site on reproducing a try plane. I wish Larry had made the promised bench plane video.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#68

Re: wood...yes..

TomD

"..It might not be clear. I've been using mostly wooden planes for a couple of years now, though I have squared edges often with a metal jointer and still use a stanley 4 for smoothing. Smoothing is such a quick part of the process after the rest is done properly that it's only 10% of the effort at most."

Bingo, I have mostly used wooden planes since the 70s; and mostly in the sense of vs machines since moving into my current shop which is cold, most of the time, and where I try to keep dust down for a variety of reasons. I have also use a metal jointer ever since having several wooden ones that didn't hold the way I want them to, probably just a luck of the draw thing. I had a wooden jointer of Jap. manufacture that went like a banana. And my dad bought me the metal jointer, so there is that. That was back in the Kirby days stage 1 (the FWW chronicles) when he advocated it as the only plane one needed

"I agree, though. I have gone in every direction. The double iron thing opened up a whole world of decent planes that most woodworkers will never figure out how to use for fine work - double iron planes that seemingly have a large mouth and somewhat coarsely made cap iron. I have a couple of japanese planes that I use regularly, but unlike most folks, more for coarse work than fine work"

I am a big advocate for that. I have one japanese plane that has a huge mouth, and sees so much use It needs it's second sole replacement.

"mostly because a person in my physical shape will need some variation if they think they are going to work for a multi-hour period."

And even if you had an adjustable bench, which I don't. though I have several, you never have the work at the most efficient height, so just by reaching for a different plane I can get a different mechanics.

" I don't like the cap iron on japanese planes quite as much because it can lose its relative position to the iron and I can't set it as quickly as the western planes, which get set once for each sharpening and that's it."

My early planes all had those stamped ones, and I don't like those at all, so I tossed them. The difficulty setting them was part of how I know what it is like to get right down to the edge with a breaker. I think scribe marks help, or a point on the design. I also don't like drilling the holes, because I figure I may blow the shot, and then all the work has been done.

"I did defend holtey, I still like Karl and would love to have one of his A13s, and was probably at 50/50 of buying one 5 years ago (which would've been significant money for me and demanded that I use the plane). I like Karl still even though I'm not the type of person who would be a customer any longer, but because karl does things to karl's standards that karl has spent a lifetime determining. i admire individuals who really are experts, and think very little of a new woodworker who pretends to know that karl should somehow magically make the same planes for a tenth of the price."

I like infils, but it is the type that has lost out the most in scampering all over the place in my quest for other types. There is only one I regularly use, and it has a blue steel blade in it. Most people in Hotley's position are more in need of raising prices

"I'm all wood other than a smoother from here on out, though. This whole planebuilding thing has been all about that, and the unloading of all of the LN planes has been my desire to not look at unused planes on a rack - they cannot get me 5 hours in the shop with the same level of fatigue as wooden planes."

Interesting to hear, because I have been there for a very long time. I minorly hurt my back while I was still bull strong and learned the difference on one commission around 82, where I planed out a table with a 7 pound jointer, the one my dad gave me, and a Japanese jointer plane that weighed about 1.5 pounds. My back doesn't like the compression, or the lifting on the return stroke. There are many who have had these experiences though, and I still marvel that people think the bailey planes prospered in anything but a declining build environment.

I have a ton of specific uses, but when I go though the planes I particularly prefer they are actually the gamut of almost every type. That is probably a random thing, but how things evolved over time. For instance I keep the low angle ones because they shoot some endgrain well. I use the infill block plane where I need a fine cut plane, and the LV one where I need a more open mouth. These could all be wooden planes, I actually have a 35 degree Japanese block plane I used to use a lot, but it needs some tightening up, and so it goes. The best thing about making planes is where some other expensive trailer queen of a plane might start to grind on a nerve, I find I am willing to stay with a plane that I made if it more than does the job. There is a certain absence of objectivity in that. But it serves keeping the dollar in the pocket, rather than buying every new thing. Should that count for anything.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#69

Re: wood...yes..

david weaver

Twisting planes are usually because of the pith being sawn off center. I haven't looked that close at old vs. new planes, but when I got my wood, I asked horizon to pull me sticks that weren't sawn off center (and that's what they did). A member on sawmill creek had graciously given me beech that he bought for bench legs, and one of the sticks had pith off center part of the way because the tree wasn't straight (but it still had enough straight wood for a couple of smoothers).

I've had planes that had unreal amounts of twist in them (who knows how long they sat) and needed to have an eighth taken off of their soles just to get rid of twist.

I don't know what it would be like for some of the guys who want to build a couple of planes, but a good 4x4 stick of something to make a plane out of that's sawn perfectly on center and close to quartered is not common.

Long way around of saying that I think I've done as much with my few planes to make sure that they don't twist as I can do, if they still do, so be it. It's not that I can't fix a plane that twists, it's that it wastes the sole, and truing the bottom of a double iron plane is a seldom thing.

I got a chance to use my batch of planes in heavy work yesterday (you know, actual project stuff). I have a power planer and use it on projects that I don't really want to do that badly, so the planes are relegated to jacking, jointing and smoothing. I didn't have to spend much time doing those things yesterday.

I also waited for a while to see if larry would release a video on bench planes, but at the time I didn't know the details and differences between single and double iron plane innards. I'm glad larry didn't release a video yet, because I would've made single iron planes. Larry's moulding plane video was the first planemaking video I've seen and it made it possible to make excellent moulding planes without having to do much research, but my single iron planes don't have as much to offer in bench planing when you're doing it as a matter of preparation and not wood show planing (that being the type where you take thin shavings and smooth everything, or get out a jack plane and plane white pine quickly - I don't do much of either of those things in a real shop).

I suspect that this stuff doesn't interest most people as much as it does me, but that's OK. The last year or so of fiddling with old wooden double iron planes and making some of them has been the most productive of my tool making rabbit holes in terms of giving me planes that are more practical on projects.