New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Posts

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#26

Re: Summary and observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't think it was lost; I think most of us - including me - weren't paying attention in class.

Hi Bill

I agree, and this was a part of what I intended to indicate.

The other part is that the "teachers" of the day - the authors of the books of the past few decades, as well as the magazines and videos - made little if any reference to setting a chipbreaker, and those that did gave it little emphasis.

Obviously some paid attention - Warren obviously did - and some were taught this in a formal training session. The rise of amateur woodworkers, however, created a great mass of people who would be self-taught or taught by modern books, magazines and videos. That is what I mean by "lost".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#27

Re: Summary and observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't think the 42 degrees means anything.

Hi Tom

It means that the plane is dedicated to being used with a chipbreaker. The comment would be obscure if you did not know that I work with interlocked hardwood, and that my main weapon to tame this has been a high cutting angle. One cannot plane such wood with such low cutting angle, such as 42 degrees, without a chipbreaker. Even taking very fine shavings is not sufficient.

Why 42 degrees? The lower the cutting angle, the smoother the finish - however this is lost with most finishes. More importantly for myself, a lower cutting angle on a BD plane requires less effort to push and causes less wear on a blade. But it does require a chipbreaker to work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#28

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Kees

No! I can't make another wedge. I even have to be carefull where I remove material. Freshly cut the boxwood looks completely different and I don't think I can replicate this patina.

I really must make a dedicated effort to save this plane. The wedge now fits well, so maybe that line between the fingers and the capiron is just a slight chamfer. The iron also had problems, it didn't hold an edge at all. That was from Marples and maybe wasn't the original one either. It now features a French iron. That's just plain weird, but it's a good iron.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#29

Re: Ahh...the gimmick line

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A few people have mentioned mid 20th century references to the double iron plane. When I was learning to use the double iron forty years ago, I was completely unaware of these references. I considered 20th century woodworking to be degenerate and looked to historical sources for guidance. I was motivated by snippets of information like these:

Carruthers (1767)



Nicholson (1812)


Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#30

Re: I have a couple of other questions..

david weaver

...now knowing that the iron is not original.

Is the iron identical in width? An ideal situation for a plane in general is one where the iron is tapered a little bit or the mortise is tapered a little bit and the iron is flush fit laterally near the mouth (this is a temporary situation if the wood is not dry, but I'm sure yours is). If there are large gaps left and right, that is problematic, but maybe not terminal. It's better if there are really no or next to no gaps left to right, both for feeding and adjustment of the iron.

Second, the replacement of the iron appears to have caused some fitting problems with the wedge, and without having the plane in hand (which would make it easier to fit it), all I can say is that the fingers need to be trimmed shy of the end of the cap iron so that you have no catches, and the fingers themselves must be flush fit down at the finger area, top and bottom and with no gap between them and the plane body (you can get away with a very small gap, but nothing like a mm each side or so if you are going to skew the plane at all in use. There needs to be some point of contact up the abutment, too, even all the way up with tight fingers is ideal.

It's hard looking at the pictures to tell where the wedge needs to be fitted to get everything tight, the part where the hang up is could be further up the plane and the wedge would need to be thinned there (if the iron has less taper than the original). Whatever it is, it needs to be fixed.

If there is a hang up further up the wedge, when you get rid of it and push the whole wedge in further, that will create problems that need to be trimmed. I think if you have to trim the fingers at the end and where they stand proud of the abutment, you can probably get a decent color match for those parts with light danish oil.

That's why I suggested making another wedge. It wouldn't be difficult to make one with slightly different taper using yours as a template, and making it exact width to eliminate any lateral issues. I would still keep the old wedge, but use the new wedge to use the plane, even though you won't have boxwood to make it.

I think it's probably SOP to make a new wedge entirely when an iron is replaced and is not similar enough to the old. It's something I fought before I started making planes, because you want to save everything and use the plane as original, but it's much more pleasant with a tight fitting flush wedge.

(make sure those fingers don't hang over the edge of the cap iron - they don't need to, and I've seen many planes where the taper at the end of the wedge was clipped back a bit and steeper and those planes still fed well and worked chatter free).

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#31

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

David weaver

Bob - thanks for the so called innocent bystander's point of view :)

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#32

Re: thanks Warren

David weaver

.. for retrieving this from the archives. I enjoyed reading it through the lens that I have now (one of much greater resolution). I see that todd later responded later in the thread with many of the same responses I had here.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#33

Re: I have a couple of other questions..

Kees

It looks like I want a new iron and capiron. The French one is almost 50 mm, while a 2" one is 50.8 mm. There is now room for 52 mm. I tried with an iron from a German iron plane which is almost 52 and has a thicker capiron. The fit of all the pieces is a lot better with that one.

Thanks for all the tips David.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#34

Re: Summary and observation

TomD

Sorry I didn't realize it was a task specific arrival point, I thought you were on a point of perfection. Japanese makers used that setting for maple like wood.

I have a plane that is set at 35 degrees I think, and it will cut anything, but I rarely cut your woods, probably never would be closer, maybe on the lathe. Just back from the US border so I am saddled with all my obfuscatory words.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#35

Re: Summary and observation

TomD

I guess one thing i don't get about all this is that the breaker was there to do something. It may well be true that it was never said set it at 6 thou, or even something general but very close, but did none of you try setting it closer and closer until you got some change, any change? That blows me away. Now the answer would be partly that there were other preposterous reasons given for it like stiffening the blade. But these are ridiculous on the surface. Perhaps they were the low hanging fruit Larry was dismissing. There were tons of suggestions the chip broke the shaving to the benefit of the cut. Now they may have shown non-events like breaking a shaving, but not holding it down, but again, once one knows the chip breaker is there to improve the cut, how does one not fiddle with it until it improves the cut, or dispense with it.

And in addition where would you move it. Away from the edge? Not likely. So you can only go so far towards the edge or you run out. Really 30-40 years of the revival and a lot of interest in all kinds of planes, and nobody every tried just moving it down. In full sight of all kinds of picture of shavings lying over the board in all the magazines and tool catalogs.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#36

Re: Ahh...the gimmick line

TomD

"If any gimmick ever hit successfully, it's the notion that a fine mouth and a steep iron are the ideal way to limit tearout. In the handles thread, you can see my attempt at that, an ugly, but functional 55 degree plane with a 3-4 thousandths inch mouth. It will take shavings up to 2 thousandths very effectively."

I never had much idea about that and was being influenced by Larry relative to his use of molding planes. Maybe that is part of it, while he probably believes the same about bench planes, he is the guy who makes the molding planes, and they have to work without breakers. Some of my best planes are very low, 35 to 40 degrees, and there are old articles, I think about tuning up block planes for fine work. The limit is the wood, it is one of those areas where everything seems to work, or if it doesn't the areas not covered are of no significance, but we keep dancing on the same absurd examples. There are design spheres in boats and such that have two extremes claiming the same middle ground, I normally split the difference to gain the middle ground. One problem in this area is we don't have repeatable testing. We need an iron byron. As in golf. Though they game the heck out of that. If all that is said is true, it amounts to fool me once, no twice, no three time, etc...

"It cost me 10 times as much for the materials to build it as it cost me for each of my stanley smoothers."

What material is this?

"(it was dimensioning wood entirely by hand for a couple of projects - furniture projects - to make me realize that taking 1 and 2 thousandth shavings wouldn't do)."

That is not the issue it is how you slope off. I wouldn't try to finish off with 4000 paper alone. But I assume you have had sharpening instances where the needed edge was achieved in 3 or 4 steps, depending on the tools, end point, wood... So what we are talking about is not using one plane for everything, we know they didn't do that in the past, we are far more guilty of that today. Any advantages are going to be based on lot more than what breaker you use. What I do know is I can cycle a single bit plane more comfortably and a lot faster, and with no tools. So the double bit starts in a hole. Also since I make both my planes and my blades I save time there. I can make any plane, but over hundreds less is more.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#37

Re: Colonial Williamsburg

TomD

There is still a performance dimension to that:

- Was furniture so close to the point of departure from the motherland that it was more refined at W, than elsewhere. Or was it less refined and therefore possible with these single blade planes, praise the lord they were never called upon to work anything more complex than a milking stool;

- Was the wood much easier to work (and no nasty veneers present, I accept the idea bad wood is bad wood and can change the tools we used, though the double bit is also the thing you get when the world eas moving away from complexity and into sanding, so it is hard to know for sure what was the dominant factor, plus scraping.

- Should modern woodworkers put more effort into getting good wood. I was looking at a case in the new Gallery, and the maker matched the top and bottom patterns on the door as Krenov did, but actually offset the top one so it did not center. Sloppy. Now in guitar, boat, archery, or Japanese work, one would not accept that kind of thing. But I have a stalled stool project where I let a leg with a knot slip through... Maybe we should be working better wood. If all the structural wood was clean, and only some burly panels existed, almost all these issues would be irrelevant.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#38

Re: Apparently Mostly Not...

david weaver

When we were going to publish an article, I mentioned to Bill Tindall (or maybe it was someone else) that we would get many responses from folks either claiming that it doesn't work or that they already knew about it.

The bulk of the responses of that type had discussion going with them suggesting the people trolling the responses had no clue how to actually use the cap iron. They had just been going through their references after the fact and mentioned planecraft or something else and quoted it. Many followed that by suggesting that they knew how to use the cap iron but they keep steeper angle planes for difficult wood because the common pitch planes can't handle them.

I remember your response to the article being one of very few that was accurate in describing how you'd set the cap iron.

I never had any of those books, I came along to this hobby too late. I don't read old literature, either, my only motivation was suspecting that warren might be right because he won't some competitions at WIA, and knowing that he makes a living doing what he's doing.

Six years prior or so, I had an argument with warren and I set a cap iron (but too close) and noticed it made my common bench plane hard to push. I came back here and reported that it was of no advantage compared to a steep angle because it was practically the same thing.

I'll bet there are or were at least hundreds of people who set the cap iron in dailu use because it works, but they don't read the internet and sharing what they know is of little interest because they have more pressing concerns.

Maybe the most interesting part of the whole scenario (other than going back and reading the old posts where I can only conclude what warren has, that the posters don't know how to use a cap iron and argue against it without really knowing how useful it is in the first place) was that I answered "you need to learn to use the chipbreaker properly, you don't really need a new plane" to every tearout question where the person in question was using a double iron plane. You'd be surprised how many people got really angry by the suggestion that they had more to learn if they were still having problems with tearout. I did that mostly on SMC, because the forum is so full of beginners coming by.

I see that there is still something from time to time, including a discussion on woodnet that suggests some lack of exposure.

If we (the people who read the forums) are 10% of the market for supply houses like LV and LN, then at least this 10% gets a leg up on things like LN's ridiculous recommendation that using the cap iron is too fiddly and they suggest turning your plane into a (my opinion) 55 degree boat anchor with one of their frogs.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#39

Re: Ahh...the gimmick line

david weaver

Materials:

Bois De Rose for the infill (though the person who sold it to me though it was a 50 year old cocobolo block, and the price was cocobolo block price - $75), $140 for a brese cap iron and iron, probably about $40-$50 in O1 steel, and a couple of files and some 80 grit PSA stick down (and two hack saw blades, etc).

Probably comes up somewhere around $280-$300. I could've used cheaper materials, but it would've made the already 75 hour job (for a person working mostly by hand) longer.

As far as using one plane for everything and historical accuracy, I'd imagine most woodworkers 150 years ago used fewer bench planes than most of us have. I'm guessing at that a little bit, but thrift would've been more important.

There may be talk of some of us using "a #4 for everything" for whoever has recently seen sellers using a #4, but I'll bet the people claiming that use at least half a dozen planes regularly. I doubt most of us spare the dime when it comes to getting another tool and using it. Just a hunch. And that's without folks who start buying all kinds of scrapers, etc, to use....after they machine plane wood and before they sand it....

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#40

Re: better wood...

david weaver

..

Two things...

1) with a single iron plane, if you had to do any coarse work, it would've just taken longer if the wood wasn't good wood.

2) yes, on the good wood. It's worth everyones' time to try to source local wood if it's available that is cut by a sawyer. Living in the center of the world of cherry and walnut, I guess it's probably easier here. It's also easy for a person who doesn't want to look hard to just pay market price for substandard commercial mill wood.

It's not a supposition that you can't do good work with a single iron, it's the supposition that it's easier to do it faster with a double iron.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#41

Re: Summary and observation *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

ThomD wrote:

I guess one thing i don't get about all this is that the breaker was there to do something. It may well be true that it was never said set it at 6 thou, or even something general but very close, but did none of you try setting it closer and closer until you got some change, any change? That blows me away. Now the answer would be partly that there were other preposterous reasons given for it like stiffening the blade. But these are ridiculous on the surface.

I tried setting the cap iron closer in 1973, got good results and refined the technique over the next four years. I have told readers of this forum that if there is tear out then the cap iron is not correct, tirelessly for nine years. I have countered and ridiculed the arguments of detractors. Todd Hughes was particularly adept at this kind of ridicule. I do recall that in 2006 you questioned the argument that the cap iron was just a blade stiffener or was even effective as such, but said nothing about cap iron placement.

It would have been helpful to have had another voice noting the "preposterous reasons". In fact when David Weaver became a second voice promoting the use of the double iron on March 26, 2012, things really moved along.


2006 discussion

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#42

Re: Another Excellent Quote from the Archives *LINK*

david weaver

This one from a short conversation occurring about David Denning - quoting Warren.

>>Also on pages 82-83 Denning writes "As jack, trying, and smoothing planes are made with both double and single irons, it should be said that the latter, though cheaper, are not suitable for cabinet work.

<<

The interesting thing is that single iron planes being popular with current woodworkers and planemakers is brought up as proof of what works well. I have no idea why we would judge what works well in general based on what works well for wealthy customers and beginners.


Denning Quote

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#43

Re: And another one I hope nobody believes! *LINK*

david weaver

This quote from another discussion (I never knew how to get into the archives before).

For finish carpentry a double iron cancels out a lot of the plane wear. For uber finishing you can't beat a single iron with a super-fine mouth (just like C+W planes).

I sure hope nobody believes that quote!!

Warren of course followed that up asking if the finish carpenters were using the curled and cross grain wood referred too by various texts as being planed well by double iron planes.


Makes no Sense

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#44

Sound of dead horse being beaten.......


Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#45

Re: I guess this is my version of historical text.

david weaver

Since I don't read older texts, and I only this week figured out how to read the archives, I've only been able to read the little snippets that come up from time to time.

Reading all of these things at once (though the search function still vexes me a little bit) is like a free movie.

It's only 8-9 years ago, but it is strange how different the flavor is.

It's a change that some of us have gone through. Especially the posting of very precisely made infills, I used to follow those threads and those fine tools gave me more reading joy than any discussion of method.

8-9 years later, I don't really have much regard for expensive tools and most of mine are gone (the exception being some infills that you take a bath on if you unload now - the market for those has really tanked, and just a few japanese tools).

Truth be told, if someone came to my door tomorrow with a wad of cash that was 75% of my "valuable" tools (except the ones that were gifts), I would trade them all of my "valuable" tools. I vaguely remember this discussion when I first started, and I thought maybe warren was a nut (because I was a beginner and he talked in fewer words).

Reading through the archives is like bizarro world, and it's maybe my last bit of entertainment before I take a break from forums for a while.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#46

OT Persuasion over the Internet

Steve Elliott

Finding a way to persuade other woodworkers that a piece of information would be helpful to them is difficult, at least for me. There are a few aspects of woodworking that have especially caught my interest, plane performance being one of them. One controlled test using a closely set cap iron, based on a summary of the Kato/Kawai video, proved to me the value of cap irons. A write-up on my website certainly didn't change many minds even after Christopher Schwarz linked to my site. Seven years later (early 2012) the video version of the Kato/Kawai work became available and soon the counter-arguments pretty much stopped. Watching the shaving as it is cut and seeing the difference in tear-out is much more persuasive than still pictures or words.

I'm not saying that David's "second voice" wasn't helpful; I'm sure it was. It just seems to me that with all the voices speaking on the internet, some of them quite loud and persistent, even well-informed and articulate arguments often don't change people's minds.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#47

Re: Apparently Mostly Not...

TomD

I am always inventing things that probably are invented before. I have 6 new versions of the bowline I invented. What are the odds on that? I still think it is cool to mess about and improve stuff, right?

I always toss off that stuff about back when the revival happened in the 70s, as if just because that was when I started, there is actually some historical marker in the sand. I do think there sorta was, but time does seem to start from one's own perspective of it all. You have kids, so you know what I mean. So, sure, you can't get there from here, and you just find the world as it is when you enter it's various rooms. If that makes any sense.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#48

Re: OT Persuasion over the Internet

TomD

O yeah, the interner, where nobody agrees with anything one says. And I don't mean that they are unmutual. As I have said before (feel required to say that because I am being redundant, even as I realize it is also redundant to say it), the one of the most fascinating side issues to me about the net is how completely differently everyone thinks about stuff. It is refreshing really, because up till then i thought maybe I was the only one out there who didn't agree with almost everything. Really explains stuff like political deadlock.

I was thinking the other day about how in the late 70's and early 80's Fly Fisherman mag was the mag of record, and had about the only fly column, and when they took a fly and placed it in a centerspread article, that would be major news. But in all those years, and the years since, we have few examples of flies that got the treatment in FF or elsewhere that actually took off. It takes a lot, which I guess is why brand is so important. When someone figures out how to brand this, it them becomes worth making. Up till then they are just going off brand for something of questionable value anyway.

When i make objections or whatever comments, it is just as much an explanation of why something isn't being picked up, possibly, as it is a negative point.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#49

Re: Summary and observation

TomD

"I do recall that in 2006 you questioned the argument that the cap iron was just a blade stiffener or was even effective as such, but said nothing about cap iron placement."

I had no idea people didn't know, still blows me away as I keep saying. And it is possible there are others out there who felt the same way, so they wouldn't say anything either. The blade stiffness reasons, etc... are clearly preposterous, not that they can't be right in a particular instance, but I see no reason they are the only way to get there. Clearly the only way to get a breaker there though. The words breaker and sub blade say nothing about stiffening, and in the sub blade case you would be hard put to stiffen one of those blades. A low angle double bevel blade with the same cutting angle would be way stiffer.

"It would have been helpful to have had another voice noting the "preposterous reasons". In fact when David Weaver became a second voice promoting the use of the double iron on March 26, 2012, things really moved along."

David is kinda an internet super hero, he gets discussions going. Which is both a force for good and whatever else comes along in-between. I am mostly a critic, in the positive sense of that, but the effect is rarely positive.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#50

Re: Ahh...the gimmick line

TomD

"Materials:

Bois De Rose for the infill (though the person who sold it to me though it was a 50 year old cocobolo block, and the price was cocobolo block price - $75), $140 for a brese cap iron and iron, probably about $40-$50 in O1 steel, and a couple of files and some 80 grit PSA stick down (and two hack saw blades, etc).

Probably comes up somewhere around $280-$300. I could've used cheaper materials, but it would've made the already 75 hour job (for a person working mostly by hand) longer."

Thanks for that. Based on earlier pictures I was wondering whether there was a new market for plane making beech. I have a lot of it, though not for sale as yet.

"As far as using one plane for everything and historical accuracy, I'd imagine most woodworkers 150 years ago used fewer bench planes than most of us have. I'm guessing at that a little bit, but thrift would've been more important."

I grew up with woodworkers whose idea of a chair making kit was an axe, literally, I guess they had a drill also. So sure that exists. Some of those guys who may have had a few more tools, but there is some evidence to the contrary on that, also built beautiful boats.

But those guys are not the cabinetmakers of their day. The cabinet guys, I just naturally assumed we must be spending the 1 million words to discuss, because if anyone did get this deep into it, it would have been them, and not some guy with one plane and a cow. The cabinet guys had lots of planes. It was a distinguishing feature.

One has to assume that this discussion is going somewhere. At some point we will know what the best approach is for the average. I can't say I know but I am still sceptical it is the plane with the breaker, though anything with more screws has a better chance in the market. But we aren't at the end point, we are in the middle, and we have yet to see the next commercial response.

Again, the Japanese plane is great in this regard, because the breaker adjusts separately from the main blade, and goes in after it, and I would say is more troublesome to deal with when you are learning, though like everything a nothing once you have it. That is a test bed that allows one to tell whether the breaker is worth it because you just leave it off when you don't want it. I would be interested where you would end up after 10 or 20 years with that.