Re: Ahh...the gimmick line
TomD
"Materials:
Bois De Rose for the infill (though the person who sold it to me though it was a 50 year old cocobolo block, and the price was cocobolo block price - $75), $140 for a brese cap iron and iron, probably about $40-$50 in O1 steel, and a couple of files and some 80 grit PSA stick down (and two hack saw blades, etc).
Probably comes up somewhere around $280-$300. I could've used cheaper materials, but it would've made the already 75 hour job (for a person working mostly by hand) longer."
Thanks for that. Based on earlier pictures I was wondering whether there was a new market for plane making beech. I have a lot of it, though not for sale as yet.
"As far as using one plane for everything and historical accuracy, I'd imagine most woodworkers 150 years ago used fewer bench planes than most of us have. I'm guessing at that a little bit, but thrift would've been more important."
I grew up with woodworkers whose idea of a chair making kit was an axe, literally, I guess they had a drill also. So sure that exists. Some of those guys who may have had a few more tools, but there is some evidence to the contrary on that, also built beautiful boats.
But those guys are not the cabinetmakers of their day. The cabinet guys, I just naturally assumed we must be spending the 1 million words to discuss, because if anyone did get this deep into it, it would have been them, and not some guy with one plane and a cow. The cabinet guys had lots of planes. It was a distinguishing feature.
One has to assume that this discussion is going somewhere. At some point we will know what the best approach is for the average. I can't say I know but I am still sceptical it is the plane with the breaker, though anything with more screws has a better chance in the market. But we aren't at the end point, we are in the middle, and we have yet to see the next commercial response.
Again, the Japanese plane is great in this regard, because the breaker adjusts separately from the main blade, and goes in after it, and I would say is more troublesome to deal with when you are learning, though like everything a nothing once you have it. That is a test bed that allows one to tell whether the breaker is worth it because you just leave it off when you don't want it. I would be interested where you would end up after 10 or 20 years with that.