New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Posts

In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#1

In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

david weaver

It's no secret that I've taken a fascination with building double iron wooden planes out of beech. Years ago, there was a long discussion here about the shortcomings of double iron beech planes, and as far as the later planes that may have been made in haste or worn out when "experts" go them, I can't really discuss those. they frustrated me when I was a beginner, too.

Building these planes and learning from some good examples of them

The descriptions of the double iron plane shortcomings were thus (many from Larry):

* the planes were hastily made

* the cap irons created a problem with the wedge fingers where there was a choke point at the corners, and the fingers have to terminate at the top of the cap iron. The choke point forces a user to clip the corners of the iron to avoid clogging, reducing the effective width of the plane.

* it's not possible to have a tight mouth or a closely following wear because the wear in either of those situations becomes a clogging point for chips coming off of a closely set cap iron

Not to mention some extra steps have in that you need to mortise another slot in the bed with enough room for lateral movement, and you have to carve a slot in the wedge as most english cap irons have a large protrusion sticking off of the top of the cap iron.

Here's what I've found after building a half a dozen of these wedged planes (actually 7 now), and before I built the first, I went on a buying spree of buying high quality older double iron planes and examining the ones that worked well (that included planes that had tight mouths and wide open mouths). Invariably, all of the very tight planes except for one were made in england (the one US make was early-mid 1800s - I think it may have been a maker "lamb" (there were several using that name).

Anyway, here's what I have come up with in terms of the points above after learning to properly make the planes because of the buying spree that finally yielded some little used and well made planes.

* the earlier planes were not cheaply made. The work inside the mortise was extremely precise with very crisp lines and no loose tolerances. The wedge fingers neatly match the abutments on the tapers. The counter to this is that when you look at the later single iron planes, those are also poorly made.

* There is no problem with feeding all the way to the edge of the plane. The wedge fingers do not catch shavings and the wear does not create a clog point. If either of these problems exist, the plane is not properly made or has been user modified to cause the trouble

* the wear in a double iron plane does not follow the bed angle closely, it isn't an issue of any concern if the mouth opens with wear. Truing of the sole of the plane needs to be done only if the sole develops twist from poor lumber selection, and that's something avoidable. Wear at the mouth is no issue because the mouth is not controlling tearout.

There is also the notion, that I believe is false, that the finest planes ever made were the later single iron planes before the double iron was developed. It may be true that the moulding planes from that era were better than later planes, but the double iron planes from the early 1800s are demonstrably superior in use to any single iron plane. And frankly, the problems larry had described about reduced cut width, etc, exist only when you don't know how to set up a double iron plane or use one. I have had no clogging issues in any of my planes, though in one I did have to open the mouth to about an eighth of an inch. (that would be a discussion for another time, as a very tight mouth has no clogging issues and a mouth that is open a fair amount doesn't, but in between can be a trick situation to get a plane to feed. The problem is avoided by making a mouth of a tenth of an inch or so since the mouth on a wooden plane over time will allow reduction of tearout, but not elimination)

There are no makers making quality double iron planes in any volume, and I don't suspect there will be. Rather than the issues that larry and others may discuss (not the least of which is most customers not having the skill to use a double iron plane, most of the buyers are probably beginners), I think the true issue for not making a double iron plane is that it takes more skill and time to make one properly, it is a little bit more complicated and the cost to make the planes is higher due to the need to make a reasonably tasteful cap iron and slot the cutting iron. George Wilson had made that comment as being limiting for Larry, and Larry dismissed it as he could make a cap iron if he wants to, but the reality is it would cause an economic problem in the plane price - one that is clearly seen in old catalogs.

The real difference in performance of one vs. the other is in the penultimate step of stock preparation, and I think that most people don't do that by hand, anyway. Kees did the work this year to describe that a double iron plane stays in the cut longer, and this is something very easily observed (one of my biggest complaints about the spectacular single iron JT brown jointer that I have is that as the iron dulls, it doesn't stay in the cut very well, and this interval is very early compared to a double iron plane - maybe at 60% of the strokes made with a double iron plane)

I was originally sold by larry's arguments because he is so direct in making them, but I find that a lot of them are false, and as Warren has often said, based on conclusions made by someone who doesn't know how to use the double iron.

That may seem dismissive, but every time I've seen an assault on the double iron plane, it's based on comments that I could easily refute in person.

So, I am firing the first salvo to open this discussion again. The shortcomings of the double iron plane as described in prior discussions just do not exist. I didn't understand why they don't, or even how to properly fit an old plane that doesn't feed well until I started to make my own planes.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#2

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Bob Rozaieski

I've had similar experiences with double iron woodies. None that I've bought have had tight mouths and all have worked acceptably. The English double iron planes I've bought have been much better made than the later American made planes, mostly made by prison labor. The wedge abutments in the better made English double iron planes have to be chiseled because they dead end up against the wear. This required a lot more skilled chisel work because the wedge abutments cannot be sawn or floated. A sharp chisel and a skilled hand is the only way to make them. They are tougher to tune than a single iron plane, but once tuned, they work well. The wear angle in a double iron plane is higher, but it's of no detriment because the double iron does just as good of a job of reducing tearout as a super tight mouth, when adjusted properly.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#3

I use one....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

......didn't know that I might be called upon to defend using it.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#4

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Kees

So, now the question is, why were so many wooden double iron planes with less then ideal mortises made and sold in the later part of the 19th century and later? Somehow they got along with those too. Of course, not every woodworker was a furniture maker, that accounts for a lot of less critical users. Add more camber to the iron and a bit of shaving traps in the corners won't hurt them too much.

But how about the furniture makers, would they have converted to infills and Stanleys at that time?

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#5

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Years ago, there was a long discussion here about the shortcomings of double iron beech planes

Hi David

Will you summarise the shortcomings that were mentioned "years ago".

I am not sure what aspect of plane design and/or plane set up you are referring to.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#6

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

david weaver

Without getting one new, I wouldn't really be able to tell whether or not the planes were a problem initially, or if parts have moved (wedge vs. body) over time and that they are something I could recover. I have a couple of planes that were not too expensive that are not the ohio or late auburn planes (I tend to avoid those), and they feed fine, though the mouth is larger. They are worked with skill in the escapement and abutment area, but the mouth is pretty large. Whether that's because a quarter inch of height or something was removed from them, I don't know. I do know that while I had little luck getting them to feed back when I first started woodworking, I could probably modify them pretty easily now, and troubleshoot what the problem is a lot more easily.

I would like to have seen some of those new as they were made to be able to tell what one with its original fresh wedge and iron was like, they may not have been that bad.

The reason I don't buy the ohio and auburn planes is that they often aren't worth the cost to ship and they are hard to get rid of. As of now, I have only three old maker's planes that I haven't cut up and robbed the iron from, and those planes are nice enough to me that I will eventually sell them rather than robbing their iron and cutting them up - it would be a slight to the makers to part them.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#7

Re: well, it won't be like a conscription..

david weaver

....drafted up to the army of the double iron plane kind of thing, with compulsory service :)

I just saw where this discussion ended back then, with larry's assertions (and I believed larry at the time because I could make a single iron plane work pretty easily, but I can make a double iron plane work pretty easily now). I believe the whole of warren's posts in rebuttal was something along the lines of "you are not correct".

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#8

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

david weaver

warren is good with the archives, and might be able to find the original posts. I'd bet this was 7 or so years ago, so my memory might be kind of foggy, but I was absorbing this stuff back then, too....

The crux of all of the details was that larry believed that the cap iron to wedge finger fit created a booby trap of sorts that was doomed to catch shavings and force a user to clip the corners of the iron and use less of the effective width.

The more foggy memories are of stuff like the double iron allowing a maker to make a cheaper plane with less skill. I don't think that's correct, either, because there is no lack of skill in the earlier planes. There may be some defense that a double iron plane remains effective even when some of the parameters aren't made as precisely, but that would only be a positive of the type. the original english planes do not lack any tightness or precision in the work - the work around the mouth, the abutments, etc is superb in those planes. The only thing missing from them is grandiose bevels, as most planemakers had gone to rounded over easing of the sides (for both single and double bevels).

I recall larry describing the double iron as one of the most successful marketing schemes or scams ever foisted on woodworkers (larry's words would slightly different, but that is the description), and his web page goes through the details of why he believes that a cap iron doesn't offer a practical net benefit.

Here's what I believe:

* we have three bench plane makers now, larry, caleb james, and phil (can't remember his name, in the UK), and there may be others. Steve Voigt is making some planes in small quantity and I am making a very small quantity of planes as gifts. I'll leave steve out because I think he has the same buzz that I do with the double iron.

* For the makers making in volume, a double iron poses a budget problem. Their planes are already quite pricey, but that is not a slight, it costs money to run a business. If they had to add $50 for a cap iron for the additional work it takes to make a well bedded double iron plane tightly, and cover the cost of the cap and screw (which probably would be $50 these days to make nicely in the same style as the english ones with the beveled fronts). The way modern irons are made, I think the skill to make the subtly bent cap irons with the brass fixtures at the screw, and do it neatly in volume, etc, are gone. The so-called "improved" style cap iron is not the same thing.

* there is a user problem. it takes a more skilled user to set and use a double iron plane, and the average purchaser of a new boutique wooden plane is unlikely to be at that skill level.

* the two most useful things about a double iron plane, the use in the penultimate step of dimensioning and the thick smoother shaving are items that most beginners and power tool users don't do much of

* a double iron plane can be a little more difficult to set and adjust until you get the touch for it because of the spring in the cap iron under the wedge. It probably takes a couple of days of use to get past this, but beginners like things to work the first or second time they try. I've found that a harder hammer makes for easier adjustments, and prefer to use a metal hammer with a rounded face to tap the back of my plane to reduce depth - on something large like a jointer, a softer hammer requires a huge whack, but a metal hammer still only requires a light tap that will not induce damage.

It will probably be the case that the average power tool user who buys a few planes will be better off using a single iron, because it's simpler, and the true advantages of the double iron won't be needed. If they get fuzziness or chatter, they'll just sand it. For a user who is going to do much hardwood work, though, and do a lot of work with a plane by hand, I think such a user will prefer a double iron plane at a lower bed angle, and gain enough experience to use it properly and understand and take advantage of the aspects of it that are superior to a single iron wooden plane.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#9

2007 *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a thread from 2007 in which I made six posts. There are earlier threads, but this one is is rather rich. I wrote:

Adam, the double iron is a sophisticated instrument. For things to work well everything has to be just so. There is no shame in having trouble with it. If the idea of learning to use hot hide glue turns you off, the double iron is not for you. It takes a fair amount of practice to get a good feel for it. I can say that the benefits of learning are well worth the effort and I would not want to be without it.

and

In my experience people who disparage double iron planes invariably make comments which lead me to think they do not really know how to use them.

The other participants in this thread include Wiley Horne, Todd Hughes, Adam Cherubini, Pam Neidermayer, Steve Elliott, RJ Whelan, Stephen Shepard, James Watriss, Dean Jansen, Joel Moskowitz, Larry Williams, Wayne Anderson, Wilbur Pan, Denis Chenard, and Derek Cohen. One of Todd's posts is really precious.

There is also in indictment of double irons on the Old Street Tool website which predates my internet involvement.


Tread Carefully

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#10

Summary and observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, in 2007 you were the only voice arguing for a double iron. There was a comment by Wiley that referred to the Kawai and Kato research, as reported by Steve Elliott. I recall having watched the video around that time. No one (other than yourself) - including Steve - considered that the double iron/chipbreaker/cap iron was practical.

All the planemakers (Wayne Anderson, Larry Williams, Phil Edwards, and Konrad Sauer) used - and continue to use - single iron planes bedded at a high-ish angle (generally either 50- or 55 degrees).

Two points need to be made: the first point is that what gets lost in the mix is that all the single iron planes work, and work well. The second is that no one understood anything about setting a chipbreaker other than yourself. The description provided by Steve Elliott was not appreciated by any of the readers, including Steve! And the question is "why?". The answer is fairly simple - because no one had seen the chipbreaker being set up and used as we today can do. This is an illustration of information that has been around for a very long time being lost for some decades. An explanation and demonstration of the technique would have been extremely helpful. No one understood the point you were making at the time. It was not until very recent discussion about the method that the lights were switched on.

I've been doing a lot of comparisons of different plane configurations, especially over the past few months (with the release of the Veritas Custom planes - I have a couple of them). It is clear that there are many ways to skin a cat. There will always be pros and cons for every method. I've grown fond of using a chipbreaker to control tearout, but I do not assume that this is going to be taken up by many. Some will find a plane with a high angle frog as it is just easier to use (although there are negatives here as well). Others will prefer a bevel up low angle plane with a high bevel angle as their choice (and there are good reasons for this). I can get equally good results with any of these configurations.

Perhaps it says something, however, that I have ordered a custom 42 degree frog for a Veritas #4.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#11

Re: Summary and observation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"This is an illustration of information that has been around for a very long time being lost for some decades."

Well, yes and no; my copy of "Planecraft," which Woodcraft continued to reprint for years, discusses the setting of the chipbreaker for various tasks and woods quite clearly. What the authors failed to do was explain and emphasize its importance. As I recollect, many, maybe most, of the classic hand tool texts talk about it too. Certainly, the work done by Kato, Kawai, and the several folks who brought their work to our collective attention was important, because it provided clear, intuitively obvious explication of what the old mechanics* had known forever.

I don't think it was lost; I think most of us - including me - weren't paying attention in class.

-------

*I've grown increasingly fond of that word, although it's not commonly used for woodworkers, for its implications of practicality and field smarts.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#12

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Steve Voigt

I think I will make a resolution, a few days short of the new year, to avoid any arguments about single vs. double irons. If people get good results with either, I'm happy for them.

It seems to me things have changed a lot since you guys first started talking about double irons here (I'll leave myself out because I was a relative latecomer to using the double iron properly). We've seen the article in Popular Woodworking, and copycat articles are sure to show up in FWW and elsewhere, if they haven't already. Mr. Schwarz, to his credit, has admitted he was mistaken about the double iron, and has become a proponent of using it. So, I think the information is reaching a lot of people; what they want to do with it is up to them.

A couple thoughts on the diverse topics touched on so far:

- David, you and I had a very productive discussion on SMC, sussing out the differences between the throat geometry of early, English double iron planes vs. later English and American planes, exactly as you've described above. One thing I want to add to that is that I later got a copy of the Seaton Tool Chest book, and the drawings of the throat geometry are almost exactly as we discussed. So in the 1790s, if not before, double iron planes were being made quite differently, and better, than they were later.

I have an American double iron plane in great shape from the 1830s, and it has the later style of throat geometry with the gaping mouth and the abutments that go all the way through. I'm sure they made them that way to facilitate machine work. As a former machinist, I've broached keyways in shafts many times, and I'm fairly certain they did something similar. It's an easy thing to do, and you could train any fool to do it pretty quickly. So, the geometry of the throat was changed to accommodate automated procedures. If one compares one of these later planes to a finely made, narrow-mouthed single iron, it's pretty understandable that they would find the single iron better made.

- Kees asked,

…why were so many wooden double iron planes with less then ideal mortises made and sold in the later part of the 19th century and later? Somehow they got along with those too. Of course, not every woodworker was a furniture maker, that accounts for a lot of less critical users. Add more camber to the iron and a bit of shaving traps in the corners won't hurt them too much.

But how about the furniture makers, would they have converted to infills and Stanleys at that time?

I think he mostly answered his own question, but just to add a little: First, furniture/cabinet makers were always a pretty small population compared to carpenters and joiners, so the former never would have been the primary market. But the other thing is that in 1800, cabinetry was almost entirely handmade. By the mid 1800s, most (though not all) American furniture was being made in factories, by machine, so the demand for really fine handplanes would have been almost infinitesimal. In England, stuff was made by hand much more, for much longer, so that would seem to account for both better made woodies, and for the infill makers. I'm not aware of any 19th century American infill makers, but there were scads of them in Britain.

- Back to David, I think making a cap iron is not as difficult or expensive as you suggest. One thing is that they don't need the brass or steel plugs for the threads. Early cap irons were made of wrought, which doesn't hold threads very well. With a mild steel like 1018, there is no problem with an 1/8" thick cap iron holding the threads.

I should have some more to say about this pretty soon, but for the moment I'll hold off.

Anyway, I like double irons too. I like that they can make fluffy shavings like this:

 photo cp5_zpsb1d24987.jpg

But I especially like that they can make shavings like this (pic taken before plane was finished):

 photo photo-217_zps7633d909.jpg

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#13

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

david weaver

I have accumulated about 30 double iron sets since going on a tirade, and I don't have a really stiff opinion on how they would be made new, though the later american cap irons were made the way you suggest. They were bent but the cap irons were steel and they are flush at the top of the cap iron (no brass fixture or brazed or welded on piece of material like the old wrought cap irons had).

Though there is no function to that part, I think it is classy. It does, however, necessitate a groove in the wedge, which is an "extra cost" item vs. not doing it.

For someone who had a good method for making them, they should be cheap. These days, it seems as though the tool makers don't want to stamp something like that out, they want to machine it. That creates the problem.

Even the flush ones that I have, one with a laminated butcher iron, have a bent cap iron instead of one machined.

I never paid much attention to where the abutments terminated in my cheap US made planes, I threw them away before I got to that point, and sold one for $10 to someone because it had a nice cap iron and iron. Fortunately, the two US made planes I've had left after that (aside from the JT brown single iron plane, brown was a baltimore, md maker) had abutments that terminated in the wear (in my simplified terms, I'll call that "made properly".

It should be fairly cheap to make a cap iron like the english made, especially if the decorative brass threaded fixture is not added above the threads for the nut, but sourcing the nut might be trouble (because it doesn't just look like any industrial supply nut and it's slotted), and the folks who like to machine everything would be vexed trying to make something that varies a little from cap iron to cap iron and then they'd probably fiddle around trying to machine on the facets instead of just filing them (which wouldn't take very long and could be done very tastefully).

Having no machine tools, these kinds of things don't present any problem to me, except the brass fixture and nut, I guess, but I have been buying them for $9 per from the UK and I think I have a supply that will last the duration of my plane making.

One of the reasons I'm not going to make planes for pay once i get it all ironed out the way I'd like it is that I want to control who the planes go to. I can't imagine selling a *good* double iron plane to a beginner or a bunch of beginners as it would invite them to tell me about how "their plane doesn't work right" and "I want a refund"

But other than the few I will give them to, I think I'll probably end up making myself a huge pile of various designs that I like but am too cheap to have someone else make.

Anyway, long way of saying that I think the cap irons should be cheap to make, but it looks like the current crop wants to machine everything from flat stock, and that would create problems. Presume that all of their plane patterns are rough machined out of patterns so a cap iron that would vary from plane to plane would cause problems. It's so nice to do everything by hand so as not to have any constraints like that.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#14

I can emphatically answer a couple of those!!

david weaver

I can emphatically answer a couple of those!!

I have no instances of anything on the four good double iron planes that I've seen (those that were not late and that are not sloppily made) of any damage of any sort in the wear. The wear, and the tapers that the wedge fingers make are in remarkably ideal shape. If there is some damage, I've never seen it on a good plane.

None of my planes was unused except for the single iron JT brown plane, I suspect it's unused.

As far as the wedge fingers go, I think larry neglected to notice a variable, and that is that as far as the wedge fingers go, they do not need to terminate right at the cutting edge. They terminate somewhere just up from the hump in the cap iron, and I have seen older ones that have been clipped slightly yet the plane never chatters.

Why? The same reason the lever cap in a stanley plane does not need to go all of the way to the edge - the cap iron does instead, and the lever cap and wedge fingers need only to put pressure on the cap iron for the iron itself to be bedded tight against the bed of the plane.

I have some chatter in the JT brown single iron plane if I make a heavy cut (a very heavy one) and that's OK. I wouldn't call it detrimental to work.

On the double iron planes I have literally never experienced any perceptible chatter - the plane will stand you still before you can get it to chatter. If I set the cap iron way back, I may be able to get it to do that.

I think larry is 0-2 on that argument (I would've bought it in the old days, though), and I can conclude (from experience now) that he just didn't know what variables to examine, where to draw the line about quality (as in, comparing a later double iron plane made when single iron planes at the time were also poorly made doesn't draw a valid conclusion about double irons) and made some errors in his conclusions.

My wedge fingers terminate just prior to the point that the abutments terminate in the wear, and no part of them other than the lateral wedge shape of the fingers ever touches a shaving (certain one never gets under a finger or stuck on it in any way). I would suppose that the well made older planes were made with considerations so that the wedge stays sprung in the mortise as the plane shrinks. In my case, that means cutting the wedge wood off of the top of the blank if it is large enough. The plane will shrink the most at the mouth side and the wedge wood that comes flatsawn off of the top of the blank will shrink slightly less if the two dry any additional amount from their current state.

I thought all of these things (where the fingers go, how far they go on the wedge, etc) were a sea of confusing items and when I was new to the hobby bought two wooden planes at an antique shop. I could sharpen things just as sharp as beginner as I can now (maybe not as fast), and couldn't figure out why with a very sharp iron, I could never trust the planes on anything in cuts other than agreeable grain. I concluded at the time that people in the 1800s were just used to working with inferior tools, but the real problem with that conclusion was that the user was inferior. In some case, the tools were, too, but I could work with them just fine now, even if I had to make a new wedge and work the wear a little.

(thanks for bringing that back, warren. There were other discussions after as I don't think I was paying attention this early on. Todd Hughes used to always irritate me because he would make conclusions and then state that he didn't use the tools. Often his conclusions were right)

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#15

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

Kees

Maybe I can answer my own questio, what were the furniture makers using later in the 19th century? At least in Brittain they still had very nice wooden planes. I remembered my boxwood plane. I had forgotten a bit about it. I think it is a Marples plane, maybe even from the 20th century. They didn't make much boxwood planes earlier on.

It came with problems with the wedge. the fingers had bowed in a lot. I had started to repair it, but never finished. The mouth is now wide open, about 5 mm, which I think wasn't original. The ends of the fingers now end up beyond the top of the curve of the wedge.

But I think you can see in the picture that the plane body itself is still in good nick and looks well made. I have rounded the corners of the iron a bit and I can now take 4.5 cm wide shavings without any clogging issues. The iron is 2" wide (5.1 cm).

I really should work on this plane, but I am not sure now if I want to do something about the mouth or not.


img

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#16

Re: Summary and observation

TomD

"The second is that no one understood anything about setting a chipbreaker other than yourself. The description provided by Steve Elliott was not appreciated by any of the readers, including Steve! And the question is "why?". The answer is fairly simple - because no one had seen the chipbreaker being set up and used as we today can do. This is an illustration of information that has been around for a very long time being lost for some decades. An explanation and demonstration of the technique would have been extremely helpful. No one understood the point you were making at the time. It was not until very recent discussion about the method that the lights were switched on."

The evidence people knew is out there. That the people that wrote here did not know is also evident. We now have a revisionism based on the ignorance of a few vocal people who arrived on the scene when single blades were the thing. Japanese planes have had the close set, and it has been reported in our press for decades. While the Japanese study sought to quantify the numbers, they didn't invent the fact. SSs that lay the shaving over the plank in normal operation are using the principle/setting which was in every magazine back in the 70s when they were sold widely over here. But all that aside, even those who didn't know how to use the breakers in a specific way, were using them because they were the norm, and did have to deal with the real or imagined problems Larry spoke of, or others.

When you say that the information was around for a long time but was lost, are we in agreement that the earlier people knew that the breaker could be set close? But this info was lost (meaning current newbies weren't aware of it).

You are spot on that the other methods work, both as the methods you mention. But also relative to real wood, if the wood is easy, you can work it with many methods, and most wood is easy. And also relative to depth of cut. And also relative to stage of work say finishing to roughing or shaping. Also relative to cross sections, so molding is mostly out. Relative to sharpening. Relative to where all hand tools vs, real world which uses sanding, and has for centuries. Basically when you set out the matrix you have this cell which is fairly small, interesting, and largely playing.

I don't think the 42 degrees means anything.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#17

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

david weaver

The wear is original. if it has opened from where it was when it was new, it's due to running some of the sole off of the plane.

It looks like there's space between the top of the cap iron and the wedge fingers, I'd make another wedge. use that one as a pattern, but make it with a little less taper so that the ends of the fingers are fatter.

That's a little unusual to see a wedge that doesn't fit at the tips like that (with the space between the wedge and the cap iron).

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#18

Re: Demonstrably superior?

TomD

I think that supposes we all work the same way. There are so many ways of using planes, what is the baseline you are using.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#19

Re: Demonstrably superior?

david weaver

Ability to take a larger shaving with the same amount of effort and do so with less tearout than a single iron plane.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#20

Re: Ahh...the gimmick line

david weaver

Quoting Larry

>>I think the idea that double irons are an improvement may well be the most successful marketing fabrication and gimmick of all time. That nonsense still shows up in almost every woodworking book published today.<<

I read all of this stuff through the lens knowing what i know now (and I don't mean larry's posts alone, but all of the folks talking about super fine shavings and completely missing warren's points.

If any gimmick ever hit successfully, it's the notion that a fine mouth and a steep iron are the ideal way to limit tearout. In the handles thread, you can see my attempt at that, an ugly, but functional 55 degree plane with a 3-4 thousandths inch mouth. It will take shavings up to 2 thousandths very effectively.

It's not quite as good at eliminating tearout as a stanley with a cap iron, and it doesn't work in as wide of a range, so I don't use it. It does work about as well as a plane of that type will work, it's simple, it takes a good edge, etc.

It cost me 10 times as much for the materials to build it as it cost me for each of my stanley smoothers.

I especially like the part about not finding old single iron planes because they were used too heavily!! (I have a feeling that the machine planer caused a lot of bench planes to be thrown out, and the iron plane caused more - as mel fulks relayed, one of his relatives (? maybe? or maybe an acquaintance) recalled people burning wooden bench planes at parties when they acquired metal bench planes. What a leap! tread lightly, indeed!!

(it was dimensioning wood entirely by hand for a couple of projects - furniture projects - to make me realize that taking 1 and 2 thousandth shavings wouldn't do).

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#21

Re: Colonial Williamsburg

david weaver

One of the arguments made about the superiority of single iron planes is their use at Colonial Williamsburg and the users' gushing over planes that larry made (and presumably that would extend down to the planes that George Wilson made before).

Well, we've since met George. The reason single iron planes are used at colonial williamsburg has more to do with curators than it does with practicality. As george put it, they were told to use single iron planes. They didn't ask to or discern what they should use. Single iron planes were dictated as the only choice because of the period the museum was emulating. Understandable....and not due to performance.

Another one up in smoke. I can call George (who is not an ardent supporter of the double iron, George doesn't much care - he can make spectacular work with anything) to find out if I worked it perfectly if it's necessary.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#22

Re: Demonstrably superior?

TomD

Heavier? Why is that important, faster to work down from oversized?

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#23

Re: Colonial Williamsburg

TomD

Worded it perfectly? (not being picky my wordsmithing leaves a lot to be desired, just wondered what it was).

I think that is the point. If you can work them just as well with a single blade, or many situations, why bother. That is what I really took from Larry. Unless doubles are better in the situation, or better overall, why bother. Singles are more efficient. What is the worst that could happen, you might end up with more planes.

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#24

Re: Demonstrably superior?

david weaver

Yes, faster to work from jacked wood, and with the smoother, faster to have a surface that is ready for a couple of fine shaving passes.

I had been a single iron fanatic until I went to doing most or in some cases all of my work by hand. it became a problem at that point with substandard stock (2nd growth cherry).

Re: In defense of the Double Iron wooden plane..

#25

Re: Singles Not More Efficient

david weaver

Single irons are not more efficient. Even at the same cutting angle, the double iron does appropriate work longer (as in doesn't require a significant amount of downforce to stay in the cut).

Couple that with the fact that it works at a lower angle and you can take a larger shaving.

The comment about George being able to use anything he wanted to was literally that, if planes would've been made from pine and medium carbon steel, george would've done good work with them. The post suggested that based on feedback from CW, larry's point of view was more valid. My point was that people at CW didn't have a choice, they used the style of planes larry and the toolmaker's shop (george) were told to make for them. Double iron planes were out of the question.

At one point, I believed using a single iron plane was more efficient because you don't need to set the cap iron or take it apart, but I no longer believe that. The double iron plane allows you to do more work in the same amount of time.

And why not a bunch of single iron planes? Because they take more effort to push and stay in the cut for fewer feet of work. I wish that weren't the case, if it wasn't, I never would've searched for a double iron plane to take over duties from the JT brown jointer, an expertly made plane from the early 1800s that I found in unused condition. It is a beautiful plane. It just can't hold a candle to the double iron jointers I have and have had in actual work.

(if I used a machine jointer and planer, it would make much of any difference either way).