Re: consider the possibility ........
Sgian Dubh
"I am looking at the edge with micron resolution and that your edges would look qualitatively the same at this magnification."
I hadn't realised your images were at high resolution.
"You have no idea how your edges are dulling if you are not looking at high magnification. You will not see 5 micron deformations, or chips, with the naked eye."
You're correct: I can't see deformation that small. On the other hand, it's not something that matters to me. I base a decision on whether to resharpen or not entirely upon how the chisel, plane, etc performs. If it isn't cutting efficiently, or tearing out grain, or crushing end grain, or whatever, I simply whack the tool over the stone again. But I suspect that's what you do, and probably most other people.
The precise nature, form, and cause of the dullness through whatever mechanism has never been something that concerns me much - a tool dulled through my use of it simply brings out the reaction, "Tool's blunt, better sharpen it, move on."
True, if a tool turns out to be one that needs sharpening too often for my subjective liking, or the edge breaks or folds over readily at the slightest strain, it's not much use to me, so it would probably end up in the bin fast. But to be honest I haven't come across too many edge tools that fail all my basic cutting requirements and also lack ability to hold a reasonable edge for what I judge to be a decent amount of time. One or two really cheap planes shown to me by students I've taught have fallen into that category, as have the odd saw or chisel made out of what we know as 'monkey metal', but that's about it. Slainte.