New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Shapening History

Posts

Re: Shapening History

#51

Microchiping failure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This photomicrograph shows a "dull" edge of a chisel made from M2. This M2 is a hardness of Rc54. At this hardness it does not deform, but also at this hardness it lacks toughness and microchips. These divots are about 10 micron deep (10/1000000 meters). One can feel that the chisel has dulled by lack of ease in cutting but you sure can't see it.

In this case metal is missing. Where as a few rubs of a deformed chisel edge on a hard stone will re-stratighten it more or less, dulling by chipping is irreversable and the edge must be restored by more metal removal.

Re: Shapening History

#52

Re: consider the possibility ........

Sgian Dubh

"I am looking at the edge with micron resolution and that your edges would look qualitatively the same at this magnification."

I hadn't realised your images were at high resolution.

"You have no idea how your edges are dulling if you are not looking at high magnification. You will not see 5 micron deformations, or chips, with the naked eye."

You're correct: I can't see deformation that small. On the other hand, it's not something that matters to me. I base a decision on whether to resharpen or not entirely upon how the chisel, plane, etc performs. If it isn't cutting efficiently, or tearing out grain, or crushing end grain, or whatever, I simply whack the tool over the stone again. But I suspect that's what you do, and probably most other people.

The precise nature, form, and cause of the dullness through whatever mechanism has never been something that concerns me much - a tool dulled through my use of it simply brings out the reaction, "Tool's blunt, better sharpen it, move on."

True, if a tool turns out to be one that needs sharpening too often for my subjective liking, or the edge breaks or folds over readily at the slightest strain, it's not much use to me, so it would probably end up in the bin fast. But to be honest I haven't come across too many edge tools that fail all my basic cutting requirements and also lack ability to hold a reasonable edge for what I judge to be a decent amount of time. One or two really cheap planes shown to me by students I've taught have fallen into that category, as have the odd saw or chisel made out of what we know as 'monkey metal', but that's about it. Slainte.

Re: Shapening History

#53

Why how edges fail mattered to me....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Summary: I am curious and had access to capability to investigate edge wear. Some practical results came from this work.

I began life with the blue handled affairs. There was nothing about them that I liked, not the least their high center of gravity. I bought a set of Sorby. They were heat treated to sharpen easily, but not optimized for dovetail chopping. So, some years ago a friend and I decided to build a set of chisels because I would not bear the cost of buying a set of high quality chisels.

About this time I met a knife maker who in turn introduced me to the technical rep. for Crucible Steel who in turn introduced me to the world of steel for edged tools. It became apparent that if one knew the steel attributes optimum for an edged tool application an optimum choice of steel and heat treatment could be made. Summary, if you are going to build a chisel why not build it with the best technology for the application, which might not be a steel made with 100 year old technology. (Turns out classic carbon steel properly heat treated makes a very good chisel- Swan, Witherby, Two Cherries all of which are better than the Sorby I had)

At the time I had access to a scientist in an industrial microscopy lab, who was a wood worker. We collaborated on looking at chisel edge failure/wear. It was apparent that chisels cutting across grain dull by a different mechanism than plane blades. Depending on the steel and heat treatment they dull by micro- edge deformation or micro-chipping. It follows then that the optimum steel will be one that remains tough at high hardness. This conclusion is supported by the choices Lee valley has made in introducing their premium chisels and incidental data from others. However, it remains a hypothesis to be confirmed or denied by additional work.

There is great economy of scale in buying the material, fabrication and heat treating. Hence, when we made tools we made many chisels, lathe tools and plane blades all from CPM 3V particle tool steel, an optimum choice at that time.

As an aside, to sharpen this steel required diamonds which set us off on another path of discovery which many of you have read about here on Wood Central.

Re: Shapening History

#54

Re: Great picture and comparison

AlanWS

I agree that the juxtaposition of edge and wood structure scale is very helpful. I wonder whether it would be possible to photograph the two together? It might be particularly nice to see the edge on the surface it planed, though contrast would be a challenge. Maybe a standard white maple would work for contrast and scale.

Re: Shapening History

#56

bridger

Re: Two things..

bridger

For razors, I've been going straight from coticule to linen. For chisels and planes I finish with green compound on hard maple. The maple was prepped with a plane and is kept in a tupperware type plastic container between uses.

Re: Shapening History

#57

Chisel chipping *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 2007 a fellow on this forum was so certain that double iron planes never worked that he said that I would find scratches in the escapement of my beech trying plane from clearing all the jam ups. He thought he could see the scratches from 1100 miles away, but he was dead wrong. There were no scratches at all in the plane I had used heavily for over 30 years. He was also certain there was tear out on surfaces he had never seen.

Now we have a guy who claims there are chips on my chisels, which he has likewise never seen. He guarantees it from 500 miles away. I reported chisel tests on this forum two years ago where I made 500 end grain cuts with no sharpening whatsoever and had no chipping visible at 200X. I also made 28 half lap dovetail sockets without sharpening or stropping, which also showed no chipping. In both cases there was visible wear like on a plane iron.

Working on end grain does not cause chipping; we do no see chipping when planing end grain because the iron is held securely. Chipping is not caused by compression. It is caused by bending. If the edge of a chisel is captured in the wood and the handle is levered the bending force becomes too great and the tip breaks. When the chisel's handle is struck while the chisel is being held at the bevel, the thing that restrains the chisel from flopping is the edge buried in the wood. This causes chipping. There is a reason historic pictures show workers holding the handle.




Chisel test

Re: Shapening History

#59

Re: Certainly

wilbur

Warren, I think you are misinterpreting what I’m trying to say.

I don’t have a problem getting to a sharp edge.

I don’t have a problem maintaining that sharp edge with frequent touch ups.

When I do drop back to a lower grit waterstone for sharpening, it’s most often because I got lazy and waited too long to maintain that sharp edge, at which point it is more convenient to start at a 1000 grit waterstone or thereabouts.

I am surprised that you would make a comment like, "So you touch up the edge maybe five times at 20 or 30 seconds a pop without ever getting a good edge out of it”. That assumes that I’m touching up the edge without maintaining the sharpness of my tool, or that I don’t recognize that I haven’t really sharpened my tool, neither of which is true.

I don’t have the same experience that you do, but I hope you don’t think so little of me that you think that I have no idea what a sharp edge is.

You’re rightfully taking others to task for making assumptions about the conditions of the edges of your tools as you use them without seeing them, but it seems that you’re making similar assumptions about my tools as I sharpen them.

Re: Shapening History

#60

Re: Certainly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am sorry, Wilbur. I thought I had put enough qualifiers in there to suggest some uncertainty about what I wrote. I do see some people who touch up the edge several times without sharpening past the wear bevels, settling for a poor edge.

It is very hard to judge someone's sharpening ability from afar.

Re: Shapening History

#61

Re: toughness tension

Rum

There is clearly some tension between ease of sharpening and hardness/toughness (and between hardness and toughness for most steels). Old style high carbon is easy to sharpen in (in relative terms) so one could argue it's more efficient than some of the tougher to steels because although it dulls faster you can reform the edge faster as well. This of course requires a modicum of capability with your sharpening setup (which we could, with equal validity, argue that many people lack). You can see this same trade off being made in chefs knives where a lot of pro chefs prefer a softer but more easy to sharpen knife whereas for a home chef that sharpens less often a harder knife that holds its edge better might be a better choice. This is ignoring the quantifiable differences in edge quality the different steels deliver (intentional simplification)/ Pretty clearly the new Lee Valley steel is trying to hit the best of both sides of this divide.

The best way I've seen to discuss this is a spider diagram like Lee valley used which clearly illustrated the tradeoffs of the various options. Saying any one is better is somewhat meaningless unless you define what vectors you are taking about.

Re: Shapening History

#62

Re: view the Kato video

AlanWS

I suggested that it would be good in microscope images to see the wood and edge to show scale. I was also implying that variations in wood surface correlate with types of edge wear.

I'm not sure how the Kawai and Kato video bears on this. I am aware that sharpness helps avoid tearout, but that was not the most informative part of the video.

Re: Shapening History

#63

Re: Two things..

david weaver

I have dropped all of the pastes, powders, etc after the stone, too (though I don't have a great preference what the stone is - could be a coticule, a natural japanese stone, etc...whatever. )

A true vintage linen is a wonderful thing. It conditions a very sharp edge over time, but without being harsh.

I can't say my edges are any sharper than they were a couple of years ago when I finished razors with compound, but honing a razor is rare and the in-between using just a stone and a linen (as opposed to using powders in place of a good linen) is an edge that lasts a long time between honings.

Re: Shapening History

#64

Re: Sharpening - Still has Staying Power

david weaver

After all of the years and arguments, the sharpening discussion still has staying power, and people still get offended when talking about it! :)

Maybe we can do japanese vs. western or double iron vs. single iron for old time's sake!!

Re: Shapening History

#65

Re: Sharpening - Still has Staying Power

Steve Voigt

Maybe we could go meta and argue about the arguments! Is it better to argue about sharpening media or sharpening techniques? Discuss.

Re: Shapening History

#66

Re: Sharpening - Still has Staying Power

david weaver

that would be like the derivative of the sharpening discussion......

Sharpening calculus...

..All i know is whatever anyone else is doing, if it's different from me, they're wrong!!! That's the spirit of sharpening discussions.

You should see the razor boards. People post their sharpening routine in a long list as if they are showing their registry entries in an anti-virus ..

"can someone look at my 15 step process and let me know where it needs to be improved?"

Re: Shapening History

#67

bridger

Re: Two things..

bridger

I don't know about vintage linens other than my own, but it has a hard surface that although pretty coarse weave is sort of a "closed coat". The blade almost rattles across it.

Re: Shapening History

#68

Re: Two things..

david weaver

Yes, that sounds like any of the vintage "silk finish" type linens. They are stiff and there is something rough feeling about them, but they don't actually harm an edge.

there is nothing else that I know of that compares in terms of maintaining a razor - they keep the razor sharp and remove almost nothing in terms of metal. It's taken years to get only a slight gray tint on mine, and some of that is probably contamination from refurbished razors.

Re: Shapening History

#69

another sharpening question

Patrick Gibbons

I have a stick that was made for poking others in their eye. It is either birch or maple. It came from a barn auction I attended in Kentucky. There is no reference in Salaman or Roubo on sharpening this tool. I do know that it was sharpened by the user as such sticks were commonly sold dull so the user could fettle it according to whether they were left or right handed. I have also seen many user-made sticks that provided many years of good service to the maker.

My questions are as follows; which is the best type of knife to establish the basic point? Bowie, Jack or pen? Or did one progress from the Bowie to the pen? What is the best way to hone the point? With scrapers or was sandpaper used? Could diamond media be a modern improvement to consider? Also is there any historical evidence for the use of flame hardening?

I also wonder about what other woods were used in other parts of the country. I seem to remember my father mentioning that his father had a stick he treasured that was made in Jackson, Mississippi out of yaupon, a wood more common here in Texas.

Re: Shapening History

#70

Re: another sharpening question

Patrick Gibbons

I did find one historical precedent for flame hardening. It comes from The Odyssey and did involve eye poking. I would imagine this practice continued in Western woodworking traditions.

Re: Shapening History

#71

Re: another sharpening question *LINK*

William Duffield

Cedar's good enough. Why waste money on the exotic woods? I start with the yellow sticks labeled "Ticonderoga". I have this ingenious sharpening devise with a crank, much superior to the later electric versions. Can anyone offer advise on sharpening the spiral cutters in the sharpener?

I always cut the erasers off the other end, because they are way too dangerous. I might poke myself in the eye if I were tempted to try to put the eraser end to use. They ought to be against the law.


img

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ee/Apsco_Vacuhold_pencil_sharpener_09.jpg

Re: Shapening History

#72

Re: Why how edges fail mattered to me....

Sgian Dubh

Bill, all the reasons you enumerate seem reasonable enough to me for your research, investigations and results. I haven't had those coincidental or fortuitous connections and contacts so it has never occurred to me to conduct such an investigation. I've always tended to simply buy or acquire a tool - chisel, plane, saw, etc and relied upon the manufacturer of that tool to have a decent idea of what they're doing, and for the most part that's worked out pretty well for me. Every now and then an edge tool has turned out to be a turkey; won't hold an edge, breaks easily, difficult to sharpen, etc, but the turkeys have been very limited indeed, and usually the level of 'turkeyness' (sic) has been associated with price, but not always. Slainte.

Re: Shapening History

#73

Re: another sharpening question

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

:D

JR

Re: Shapening History

#74

Re: Why how edges fail mattered to me....

TomD

The conundrum seems to me to be, it isn't that hard to get to a reasonable level of serviceable sharpness. When you get beyond a certain point, who are we supposed to trust to do the research. The people asking the scientific questions are not all that good at that part of the task, and they are a lot worse at any high level sharpening skills. The people with the high level skills usually only have them in a narrow band of options, and they usually aren't disposed to vary their process, or they would be lifetime dilettante investigators, and not masters.

Another fun thing to think about is sharpening techniques of the modern masters. If you think of some of the better known names at least. Carpenter, Nakashima, Krenov, Maloof, Castle, etc... Sharpening appears to have played no part in differentiating their work. Design excellence and self-promotion would appear to be nearly 100%.

There are a number of reasons for pursuing sharpening excellence, but few of them have anything to do with sharpness, and even less to do with the work. At one point I had to learn to sharpen. But beyond that point is was about measuring up, seeing if one could do what one read in the books; and then getting better than any of the people one read about in the books, in at least some respects; Occasional it is a about ritual, re-visiting the time I spent on my knees when I started out, just for the memory lane aspect. The fact that on can have so many different relationships to sharpening should not be confused with there being any practical reason for having such interests. If you want to get good at crafts, you need to learn to sharpen for many of them. By the time one is good at it, it gets in the blood, and one keeps on going with it. But one shouldn't confuse (if anyone does) the fun we have at it with any realistic needs.

Re: Shapening History

#75

correction

wilbur

The episode you allude to is often mistaken as an example of flame hardening. It is really a demonstration of protein quenching. ;)