Edge maintenance: a suggested test
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
I'm parking this comment under Wilbur's, because I just read his sparkling commentary, and am reminded of some personal experience I'd like to share with the group. And before getting to it, would like to express appreciation for Steve Elliott's great work, and Wilbur's re-bringing it to our attention.
But here's what I'm getting around to...a typical fresh edge for me is about 25 degrees primary bevel, and 27 degrees honed edge. [These are estimates, I'm not measuring anymore, except when someone on the forum says something to prompt a check. And mortise chisels are a little higher.] Now I check this edge by testing its cutting angle on the bench top--holding the blade in my hand, I move it across the bench top and gradually lift it until it digs in--what angle is that? At what angle does it dig in?
Now after working for a while, iif I go back to a 1000g stone and re-edge, and do everything as before, it'll still be digging in at, say, 27 degrees or how I eyeball 27 degrees anyway.
But I tend to touch up, so as not to break concentration, especially with a chisel. Krenov suggested this in one of his books--he would touch up a chisel very often as he went along, on what looked like a black hard Arkansas in the book. The idea was that you're always working with a good-as-new edge, as Wilbur describes the result of frequent fine-stone sharpening. And it fits the rhythm of the work.
What I have noticed though, is that when I touch up, even if I am careful to maintain angle, and not round over by 'feeling for' the edge (DAMHIKT)--what I notice is that the touched up edge as often as not will be cutting a little steeper than the original 27 degree edge. I don't know, maybe it's about 30 now, but it's a little steeper than before. Now the collective and individual you out there may not experience this--not talking about you, this is just me...not generalizing from my data point...And I'm not talking about a dull chisel either; this is a chisel that is still cutting fine, maybe it's pared to the scribe line on 8 or 10 drawer side dovetail sockets, and I just touch it up for good measure on a fine stone. Kinda like that fellow in the cubicle next to me all those years ago, who I would hear through the partition constantly sharpening his engineering pencil in one of those rotary mill sharpeners...A habit really...But over time, the chisel keeps cutting a little steeper. Can't get back to 27 without starting over.
I reason this observation through like this--when one sharpens, one is either raising a new primary burr on the blade back, or one is not. If you're not, if the abrading is not getting through to the blade back, the cutting face, then what is happening? My guess, and it's only that, is that I have taken a little of the rounding off the worn edge (see Steve Elliott's graphic in Wilbur's post--worn edge gets round), but there is a piece of craggy, worn, slightly rounded edge right under the blade face, such that the chisel has to be raised just a little bit more to dig in. Now this may or may not what is really happening, but it acts like this is the case.
TEST: So I suggest, as a control on touching up, to do an angle test on the retouched chisel or iron. Check the angle where the retouched blade is actually digging in. Is it the angle you want?
CAVEAT: I'm agnostic on how sharpening is done. It's situational, as Tom D. says, and we all decide for ourselves. At the same time, I don't think there is a free lunch--if a primary burr is not raised, there are consequences for edge maintenance over time--a debt of work put off is being created that will have to be made good at some point.
Wiley