New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shapening History

Posts

Re: Shapening History

#26

Re: Warren is right..

david weaver

A $40 vintage strop with a good linen and a single straight razor is pretty much enough to go forever. I can find a straight razor that is as good as any currently made for about $40 on ebay.

That's the minimum essential kit for a lifetime of shaves. I insist on a good linen because it makes edge sharpness a near indefinite thing without abrading off metal.

It sounds like your father's or grandfather's razor was dull, and your comments are factually incorrect because of it.

I think that the new era of straight razor shaving has to do with people who spend their lives working in jobs where they don't use their hands, and they're grasping at something that they can do that involves them being a part of it rather than just reading about it.

The same group of people who are less adventurous are going to the DE blades.

The expensive strop and brush and soap group is not a requirement to get a good shave.

At any rate, I have gotten several people to try straight razor shaving. Not a single one of them has complained about the sharpness of the razors I prepped for them, and very shortly after that, the maintenance they've done on their own.

I think you should probably not make any more generalized comments about straight razors, because you don't know enough about them at this point to know that you're not correct.

Re: Shapening History

#27

Re: Two things..

david weaver

... graded chromium oxide (though you can use your green crayon) on balsa (find it at a hobby store if you need to). If you use your green crayon, apply it on your strop with some oil, you can't have any clumps.

You can use your 0.5 diamonds, too, but in a very light concentration on a soft backing if you use them (on leather or something, or on balsa). It's difficult to disperse diamonds uniformly, and that's why they are sold as a spray.

That's number 1.

Number 2 is to make sure that your leather strop is smooth and clean. an ideal piece of leather for stropping a razor is smooth and clean, without any texture on the surface. I can take a brand new strop and literally dully my razor with it. A strop is something you break in, keep clean, and use broken in. I personally have never had much love for cowhide for keeping a razor in shape, but I suppose if one is broken in enough, you can do it. I think it's too soft to do the aligning of the edge that needs to be done to maintain a sharp edge.

With a good piece of horse butt (that eventually becomes reflective as the surface is broken in), stropping is trivial and the edge is excellent every time.

I'm not sure what the razor boards' fascination is with getting people to try to learn to shave straight off of 2 or 3 micron aluminum oxide stone, but I never had much appreciation for it.

If you get to the point where you feel like you'd appreciate having someone else set up your razor for you to get a good jumping off point, you can send it to me and I will sterilize it, set the edge up so that it's in ideal shape (including a stropping on linen and horse butt), and then sterilize it and send it back to you - gratis.

Re: Shapening History

#28

Re: Two things..

Lars Parrington

Ok, the strop I have is a two piece hanging one. It is cowhide, but is smooth and clean, and shiny in places, and the feels fairly hard (i can force my fingernail into it ~1/32"). I got it new, and never put anything on it except once some mystery strop dressing which I don't think had any abrasives in it.

The second piece looks very much like a piece of seatbelt webbing, except white, and somewhat thinker and stiffer. It is stamped "barbers best, fine weave, linen finish". I assume this is the linen. Should I do anything with this part of the strop? I have never used it.

I will try a green crayon loaded balsa step between the 8k norton and the stropping. How do you get the balsa smooth to begin with? Will sandpaper load it with coarse abrasives? I suppose I should just get it as smooth as I can with a plane. Think I could substitute basswood? I've got some of that on hand.

Also, I'm not sure my stropping technique is really up to snuff. Currently I pull pretty hard on it (putting the leather in tension), and then drag the razor along it with fairly light pressure. Maybe 10 strokes for every shave. I've heard of strops where the leather is glued to a piece of wood, would that be better? Should I do a whole lot of extra stropping before shaving with a freshly honed razor?

Re: Shapening History

#29

Re: Two things..

david weaver

wooden backed vs. hanging strop is sort of six of one half dozen of the other when you're a beginner, but as you go along, you'll prefer the hanging strop. I'd safe the hard strops for compound, etc, if you need it.

I have never used seat belt material as a linen, so I don't know how well it works. My linens are vintage flax linens that are treated, but not abrasive (the one that I actually use just says "beau brummel Silk Finish" on it. They're white and they look like they have wax in them, but they do great things to maintain an edge).

I know that the cotton felt that I tried didn't work. You can try the seat belt. The linen has two purposes - to make sure the razor doesn't contaminate the strop (for example after you hone a razor and wipe it, there will still be some stuff on it), and to prolong the edge. A good linen should step up the sharpness of most natural stones, and felt does the opposite. Seat belt, you can make the decision about it.

Far and away the most important thing about stropping is that the spine is on the strop when the razor is in motion. One roll of the edge and you have to rehone to get a good edge again. If you're keeping the spine on the leather, you're probably fine technique wise. I can't remember the last time I rolled an edge, it's not something you do often.

Basswood might work. Use plenty of oil on it to thin out the green (it doesn't take much green stuff) and drag the razor across it with very light pressure. You can sand it with good quality sandpaper if you want to make sure it's flat, and then vacuum it briskly and check with something else polished (like a chisel back) to make sure the back of the chisel doesn't get scratched.

Do what you normally do and then take 25 light laps across the basswood after your stone, and then strop and shave. Be deliberate with the basswood and make sure you're contacting the whole edge on both sides when you do it.

Keep the basswood covered with something when not use, even if you just lay a sheet of paper on top of it. It will collect dust faster than you can imagine, and some of the stuff that gets on it will not be good for an edge.

Re: Shapening History

#30

Re: Missing data

wilbur

Hi Bill,

We’ve had this discussion before. Sharpening is sometimes characterized in terms like “ultimate atomic sharpening” and “stropping is as good as one needs”. This somewhat obfuscates the factors involved.

Based on the physical characteristics of abrasives, stropping is in the same category as the end points of other methods of sharpening, including sub micron diamond paste, and waterstones in the 8000+ grit range.

To say that stropping is a suitable end point for a sharpening regimen is to also say that going to a 10000 grit waterstone is acceptable as well. There may be other reasons for going with a strop, but you can’t say that one is ultimate atomic sharpening and the other isn’t. More info here: http://giantcypress.net/post/11986688183/a-grit-too-far

So if you’re finishing with a strop, you are engaging in ultimate atomic sharpening whether you like it or not, at least in the sense that there isn’t a way of applying finer abrasives to the edge of your tool that’s available to most woodworkers.

There is data on how long an edge taken to ultimate atomic sharpening lasts. It’s all on Steve Elliot’s site. Here are the salient diagrams, at least for me.



On that page, Steve mentions that he would consider resharpening a plane blade if the wear bevel gets to 12 microns. Eyeballing the diagrams, that looks like about 200 lineal feet of planing under his conditions. In terms of real world projects, that’s like planing 10 panels for a standard 15” x 30” kitchen cabinet door with a Stanley #4 before resharpening. That’s a decent amount of planing in between sharpenings.

The bottom line is that the quickest way of sharpening is to maintain the edge by frequent honings, and not by letting the edge degrade to a noticeable degree and then sharpening at that point by going through all of your steps. And from that standpoint, it’s just as easy to maintain an edge at ultimate atomic sharpening levels with a strop, a 10000 grit waterstone, or sub micron diamond paste, as it is to maintain it at a lower level of sharpening. So if the incremental cost is zero, why wouldn’t you go with ultimate atomic sharpening?

Re: Shapening History

#31

Re: Missing data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I disagree, Wilbur. I think that there is a definite ideal time to resharpen. This ideal can vary a bit depending on the work at hand, but in general there is a point where efficiency dictates resharpening. And it involves more than just touching up on a strop or polishing stone. The skill is being able to discern when that point has come, having the experience to know the consequences of sharpening sooner or later than that ideal, and having the discipline to stop at that point and sharpen.

Toshio Odate wrote:

When your blades get dull and you go back to sharpening, start with the 1000X or 1200X, then go to the finer stones. Commonly 1200X is coarse enough to hone dull blades, so if it does not seem to be, perhaps you went to long without sharpening.

I agree with this. I agreed when I first read it three decades ago. He is not saying go back to the strop or fine stone and touch up, nor is he saying wait until the tool stops cutting. Start with the 1000Xor 1200X. He is picking an appropriate time to resharpen and has the discipline to stop at that time.

I would not say that touching up does not improve the edge, it does, but I would say that if you are going to stop it is most efficient to really do a first class job of it not just some half hearted attempt to string things along.

Re: Shapening History

#32

Re: Missing data

TomD

Warren I have a problem with that discussion unless it is done in context of the work being done. Some planes or other tools can keep working long after they are hopelessly dull, others are useless after a cut or two. where one is on that spectrum will determine what stone one starts with when resharpening. My preference, is to go back at a certain point regardless of whether the tool has stopped working, but practically I sometimes loose track and don't do anything until I get the dull tool syndrome.

I think a similar argument can be made relative to tool value. I will be very prissy about my japanese tools because I remember the difficulty of getting where I got with them. At the other extreme would be tools I made myself. Good tools but I can have another one for a buck should I need it. I will hit those on the grinder until I feel a wire edge, and then go from there.

Odate's comments are made against one level of skill, one standard of tool, one type of work, and one condition of resharpening tools.

Re: Shapening History

#33

Edge maintenance:  a suggested test

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I'm parking this comment under Wilbur's, because I just read his sparkling commentary, and am reminded of some personal experience I'd like to share with the group. And before getting to it, would like to express appreciation for Steve Elliott's great work, and Wilbur's re-bringing it to our attention.

But here's what I'm getting around to...a typical fresh edge for me is about 25 degrees primary bevel, and 27 degrees honed edge. [These are estimates, I'm not measuring anymore, except when someone on the forum says something to prompt a check. And mortise chisels are a little higher.] Now I check this edge by testing its cutting angle on the bench top--holding the blade in my hand, I move it across the bench top and gradually lift it until it digs in--what angle is that? At what angle does it dig in?

Now after working for a while, iif I go back to a 1000g stone and re-edge, and do everything as before, it'll still be digging in at, say, 27 degrees or how I eyeball 27 degrees anyway.

But I tend to touch up, so as not to break concentration, especially with a chisel. Krenov suggested this in one of his books--he would touch up a chisel very often as he went along, on what looked like a black hard Arkansas in the book. The idea was that you're always working with a good-as-new edge, as Wilbur describes the result of frequent fine-stone sharpening. And it fits the rhythm of the work.

What I have noticed though, is that when I touch up, even if I am careful to maintain angle, and not round over by 'feeling for' the edge (DAMHIKT)--what I notice is that the touched up edge as often as not will be cutting a little steeper than the original 27 degree edge. I don't know, maybe it's about 30 now, but it's a little steeper than before. Now the collective and individual you out there may not experience this--not talking about you, this is just me...not generalizing from my data point...And I'm not talking about a dull chisel either; this is a chisel that is still cutting fine, maybe it's pared to the scribe line on 8 or 10 drawer side dovetail sockets, and I just touch it up for good measure on a fine stone. Kinda like that fellow in the cubicle next to me all those years ago, who I would hear through the partition constantly sharpening his engineering pencil in one of those rotary mill sharpeners...A habit really...But over time, the chisel keeps cutting a little steeper. Can't get back to 27 without starting over.

I reason this observation through like this--when one sharpens, one is either raising a new primary burr on the blade back, or one is not. If you're not, if the abrading is not getting through to the blade back, the cutting face, then what is happening? My guess, and it's only that, is that I have taken a little of the rounding off the worn edge (see Steve Elliott's graphic in Wilbur's post--worn edge gets round), but there is a piece of craggy, worn, slightly rounded edge right under the blade face, such that the chisel has to be raised just a little bit more to dig in. Now this may or may not what is really happening, but it acts like this is the case.

TEST: So I suggest, as a control on touching up, to do an angle test on the retouched chisel or iron. Check the angle where the retouched blade is actually digging in. Is it the angle you want?

CAVEAT: I'm agnostic on how sharpening is done. It's situational, as Tom D. says, and we all decide for ourselves. At the same time, I don't think there is a free lunch--if a primary burr is not raised, there are consequences for edge maintenance over time--a debt of work put off is being created that will have to be made good at some point.

Wiley

Re: Shapening History

#34

Certainly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, that is what I was getting at earlier, Wiley. You are either getting rid of the wear bevels or you are not. And if you are not, you are just making the rounding of the edge more pronounced, more work later on and a low quality sharpening. That it why Odate says to start at 1200X; get rid of the wear bevels and get a real edge on the tool.

Re: Shapening History

#35

Chisels don't wear like plane blades

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't know about Krenov but coincidentally a hard ARK stone sits on the bench when I am chopping dovetails. Its purpose isn't to remove metal, but rather to straighten a deformed edge, for that is how a chisel that doesn't microchip gets dull. We plane feet. We remove dovetail wast by the inch. It would take a carver to dull a chisel by abrasion.

PIC





top picture is bottom of chisel and bottom picture is top of chisel

This picture shows the edge of a Sorby chisel after a session of removing dovetail waste. There isn't any metal worn away from rubbing against a few inches of wood (I no longer remember the details of how many inches of waste was pared away but I think it was 10 tails in 1/2" lumber). There isn't any metal missing. Rather it is folded over and such a chisel can be brought back to life on a hard stone that will rub these deformations somewhat back into shape.

What is important to a chisel is toughness to resist microchipping, which does remove metal, and hardness which resists folding/deformation. Abrasions resistance is irrelevant.

Re: Shapening History

#36

Re: Chisels don't wear like plane blades

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Boy that is really gruesome, Bill. My chisels don't wear anything at all like that. I am sorry but I guess without actually watching you work I don't know what causes a problem like that. I hit my chisels with a 30 ounce mallet but have no troubles with bending or chipping.

Re: Shapening History

#37

Re: Certainly

Steve Voigt

I am of the full resharpen, rather than touch up, persuasion. But I change which stone I start with, depending on where I am in the grinding/honing process. I normally (for planes/chisels) grind a primary with either the dry grinder or a coarse India stone, then go 5° higher for a freehand secondary. If the primary goes all the way to the edge, and is nice and clean, I will go straight to my hard black Ark for the first secondary. My goal is to make the tiniest possible secondary that gets rid of all the scratches from grinding.

On my next trip back to the stones, the secondary is too big to start on the hard black, so I will I will start on a soft Ark, then to the finish stone. By the third honing cycle, I'm starting on a fine India (and skipping the soft Ark). Subsequent honings stick with that two-stone combo of fine India followed by hard black. I can usually get three or four more of these before I have to re-grind.

This sequence might sound goofy or backwards, but my goal is to maximize the number of honings between regrindings of the primary, since the honing takes so much less time.

Anyone else do this?

Re: Shapening History

#38

Two comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Have you ever used a Sorby chisel? I will guarantee that if you use a chisel hardened in upper Rc 50's to cut cross grain hardwood the edge will look as illustrated.

2. Have you ever looked at a used edge on the micron scale? Check out the images on the Lee Valley web site where they discuss testing chisels. The best chisels look the same except on a smaller scale. However, some steel hardened to a high degree microchips if it lacks toughness, M2 for example.

Re: Shapening History

#39

Re: Two comments

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have some Sorby mortise chisels and last night I remembered that I had a Sorby framing chisel that I bought 1n 1983. I don't know the Rockwell hardness; not listed in the catalog. I sharpened the Sorby chisel and had no trouble cutting cross grain without chipping or folding. I prefer 19th century chisels.

I wish I could point to one thing that would help avoid these issues for you. Here is the best wisdom I can offer. A chisel that is not tempered enough will be brittle and prone to chip. A chisel that has been over tempered (overheated) will be be soft and prone to bending or folding. What we are looking for is a window between these two conditions. My feeling is that good technique results in a larger window where these problems do not occur. I am thinking of both sharpening technique and the technique of using a chisel. One can get to a point where the window is large enough that the actual tempering is a bit less critical. A person with poor technique will have a small window and be running into these problems.

I looked at the Lee Valley chisel testing material and I thought it was pretty far from real world situations. We do not pare with oscillating motion with the chisel held at 2 degrees or drop a weight on a chisel from 300 mm. I don't recall that they mentioned sharpening technique or media. Personally I don't know if I have ever used O1, A2, M4, or PM VII steel. As you know, many manufacturers do not disclose this type of information.

Re: Shapening History

#40

Re: Missing Context

William Duffield

To give everyone an idea of the scale of the physical sizes of what we are discussing here, I have superimposed the edge that Wilbur provided from Steve Elliot's studies onto a photomicrograph of radially cut Prunus serotina (Black cherry) at approximately the same magnification.


About 3/4 of the 500 micron bar is shown. I found the original here:

http://www.microlabgallery.com/gallery/images/Prunus%20serotina%20TS%2050XBF.jpg

This site provides many excellent photomicrographs of many (mostly domestic commercial) species of wood, with scale, so you can decide for yourself what type of damage an edge anywhere on Steve's wear curve will do to whatever it is you're trying to cut.

http://www.microlabgallery.com/WoodSectionFile.aspx

The little round circles, which are end sections of parenchyma (ray fleck) cells, are about 5 microns in diameter, still an order of magnitude larger than the diameter of 0.5 micron abrasive grit or a Shapton 30000 stone.

Cherry is a relatively fine grained, diffuse porous hardwood. Comparing the cutting edges to a coarse grained wood like red oak is even more surprising.

Sorry for the lack of clarity in my composite image, but the small file size and vast difference in the scales of the objects we are working with make it difficult to provide a clear and also comprehensive picture.

Re: Shapening History

#41

Clarification

wilbur

Just to clarify: Of course I don’t only hone my tools on the last step of my sharpening process forever. Eventually I drop back down to a 1000 grit waterstone and work my way back.

For a real world example: Let’s pretend I’m making some boxes with dovetails at the corners. I’ll chop one dovetail joint or two, go to my fine grit waterstone and touch up the edge of my chisel (takes me 30 seconds max), chop another dovetail joint or two, touch up the edge of the chisel, and so on. Maybe after a total of a couple dozen dovetail joints I’ll go back to my 1000 grit waterstone.

Please note that the numbers above aren’t absolutes, especially that couple dozen dovetails one, and do vary depending on whether I’m working with pine, cherry, or oak. But I can say that the honing time is definitely 30 seconds, max.

One last thing: here’s a quote from an article that David Savage wrote about sharpening in his shop:

“The essence of the technique is little and often. We don’t worry too much about buying chisels that hold their edge forever because our attitude in this workshop is to, when your concentration breaks after ten or fifteen minutes of detailed work, you raise your eyes from the bench, blink and just walk over to where the sharpening bench. Touch up that blade in your hand. The blade never gets blunt. You’re always keeping it in that really sharp, keen area. Sharpening in this context takes a minute, minute and a half. Don’t begrudge doing it little and often.”

http://www.finefurnituremaker.com/news/blog/sharpening-again-merciful-heaven-a-makers-year-49/

I should note that I don’t completely agree with everything he says in this article, including the bit about how he sharpens his chisels to 4,000-6,000 grit, and the use of microbevels on Japanese chisels. But this excerpt makes a lot of sense to me.

Re: Shapening History

#42

Re: Certainly

wilbur

I alluded to this just now, but it probably could use some elaboration.

All wear bevels are not the same. If one was disciplined enough so that they resharpened when the wear bevel looked like the 100 LF profile, it wouldn’t take very much to refresh the edge. So frequent stropping might carry you for a while.

After enough time, though, the wear bevel will look more like what you see in the 700 or 800 LF profile. More metal needs to be removed. So you use your 1000 grit waterstone at that point.

The ease at which you can maintain that 100 LF profile and how long it takes to get to the 800 LF profile has to be very situation-dependent. The species of wood you’re using, the type of work (chopping, paring, how much end grain is involved), and the quality of your chisels probably all feed into when and how often you strop or go to 1000 grit.

Re: Shapening History

#43

Great picture and comparison

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It illustrates why one has no idea how the edge got dull unless you are looking with micron resolution. When you do you find that chisels get dull different from plane blades which directly leads to the conclusion that the optimum steel attributes for a plane blade are different from what is best for a chisel.

Re: Shapening History

#44

Re: Certainly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wilbur, if what you are doing by this intermediate sharpening is straightening out or removing pieces of the edge that have become bent over during use I have some sympathy for this. However, like Wiley said earlier, you are either removing the wear and the damaged areas or you are not. Just the fact that you eventually have to do a real sharpening is evidence that you are not really removing the damage each time.

So you touch up the edge maybe five times at 20 or 30 seconds a pop without ever getting a good edge out of it until you finally break down. In contrast I spend 65 or 70 seconds every time and have a very nice edge every time I feel the need. If you look at the Elliott charts you posted, the amount to be removed jumps quite a bit from 200 feet to 600 feet. It is a lot more than three times the volume of material to be removed, more like twenty times, the penalty for waiting. And in the meantime you're getting poor performance from the tool.

Maybe I am misinterpreting this, but it appears as if you are spending more time sharpening and having more time with a dull edge.

Re: Shapening History

#45

Edge Maintenance - "Stropping"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It appears to me that there are just two ways to maintain an edge:

1. Hone on media that ensures that the bevel meets the back of the blade. this could be divided into two camps: (a) lift the blade and hone at a higher angle, or (b) maintain the current bevel angle.

The temptation is to do (a) since it requires less work. This may be misleading since later one has to restore a lower bevel angle.

2. Strop the blade. Again there are two methods here: (a) use a leather strop, either plain or with an abrasive. What this appears to do is create a fine, round secondary bevel. In essence, this is the same as 1a. (b) use abrasive (such as green compound) on a piece of wood or MDF - which we may call a "strop", but is it really? It seems to me that this is really a version of 1b.

Again, the temptation is to do 1a in the belief that it will be quicker. Indeed it may be, but eventually one will need to flatten the bevel.

What do I do? Well I swing back-and-forth between a hard horse butt leather strop and compound on hardwood. At the moment I am doing the latter.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shapening History

#46

Re: Great picture and comparison

William Duffield

Oops, there's one important aspect of the comparison that I forgot. The orientation I chose for the cutting edge and the wood is specific to planing long grain. For shooting end grain, and especially for chopping dovetails with a chisel, the image of the edge needs to be rotated 90° with respect to the wood.

Further insights that this collage might start to provide is the scale of the planed surface in comparison to the thickness of the film finish that might be applied afterwards, but that would require further photomicrographs of the interface.

Further, Steve's image illustrates abrasive wear, but does not show the failure modes (or their scale) you are most concerned with, chipping and rolling, and how they compare in scale to the structure of the wood which is the object of our controlled demolition.

Re: Shapening History

#47

The technique eludes me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the past few years I have dovetailed just shy of 100 drawers, several cases that some of these drawers went into, and a trunk. Some of this activity has been mentored in the Mack Headley and Sons shop, and with Will Neptune. Yet the technique that enables one to cut cross grain with a chisel without the edge damage illustrated in the microscope image still eludes me. (I picked Sorby from the many steel images we have because the effect is most severe with this steel and therefore easiest to illustrate) It apparently eludes Will too for he had a novel solution to the problem. When chopping out dovetail waste he used a Stanley butt chisel for the bulk of the work and then did the final cut to the base line with a finely tuned chisel.

Re: Shapening History

#48

NEW DATA *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, last night just before retiring, I remembered that you held your chisel at the bevel when chopping dovetails. Here is a link:

So I went out to the shop and tried this technique. Holding a chisel like this makes me a little sick to my stomach, so I used a 1971 Stanley #60 that I had resurrected the previous night trying to find a chisel that would chip or fold. After about a dozen hits I looked at the edge. It was chipped all along the edge. Completely abused. This morning I sharpened the chisel and got the same results. The same chisel that had not chipped at all a day earlier. After much more use in the same piece of timber.

I have mentioned many times that it is much better to hold the chisel in the traditional manner. Here is what I wrote on this forum earlier this year:

I also hold the chisel by the handle when striking. If you hold the chisel by blade, or even if you have a short chisel, you have very little control of the angle of the chisel and it flops around. When the edge is buried in the cut, it is vulnerable when struck as if you were prying. It is worse if the chisel is hollow ground because the edge is more buried in the cut and it is more vulnerable because there is greater leverage.


Tindall dovetailing

Re: Shapening History

#49

Re: The technique eludes me

Sgian Dubh

Perhaps the reason for the damage to your chisels, Bill, is because you're taking a too aggressive cut. I'm assuming the damage is occurring as you chop the waste between either tails or pins as you work your way down to the shoulder line.

Here's how I work. It may help. If the wood is fairly soft, e.g., mahogany I saw the rakes of the tails or pins and then whack the waste out with a mallet and chisel working steadily from a narrower chisel to a wider chisel as and when necessary. If the wood is hard, e.g., oak or maple I usually cut the rakes as before, nip out the bulk of the waste with a coping saw and then start chiselling, again starting with a narrow chisel set on the shoulder line of the show side and push this through to the far shoulder line. Then I get a wider chisel, and using the existing cut face as a guide for the flat face of the chisel nip out some more waste, repeat with a wider chisel again until I've excavated all that needs paring out.

This sequence matters more between pins than tails because there's typically a larger gap, although sometimes a similar strategy applies between tails too. A typical sequence of chisels is widths of 6 mm to start, executing a couple of parings perhaps, then 12 mm, 16 or 18 mm and, if needed, finish with 25 - 32 mm wide chisel. It may superficially appear that all the swapping about from chisel to chisel is time consuming, but it's not because all the chisels are laid out handy. It's chop, drop, pick up, chop, drop, pick up, etc.

I find it rather strange that your Sorby chisels are breaking up as your earlier image shows. My chisels are nothing special being mostly Stanley 5001 and Stanley 5002 types, with some odd ones of different sorts that I've acquired over the years. I seldom get the sort of damage your images show with my chisels, and I can get pretty hairy chested and aggressive with the darned things. Slainte.

Re: Shapening History

#50

consider the possibility ........

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that I am looking at the edge with micron resolution and that your edges would look qualitatively the same at this magnification.

" I seldom get the sort of damage your images show with my chisels, and I can get pretty hairy chested and aggressive with the darned things." You have no idea how your edges are dulling if you are not looking at high magnification. You will not see 5 micron deformations, or chips, with the naked eye.

Astonishingly some of you believe that my chisels get dull as a result of my flawed technique rather than considering that this is how chisels dull. Maybe someone else with the capability to obtain high resolution images of worn edges can render a second opinion.

Can we all agree that chisels get dull? Then consider what dull means for a chisel that got dull after traveling inches cross grain not tens or hundreds of feet with the grain like the plane blade images Steve shows. One is led to the conclusion that abrasive wear is an unlikely mechanism. My testing of a variety of chisel steels suggest that dulling is by microchipping or deformation. To conclude otherwise you have to believe that I tap on a chisel during cross grain cutting different than the rest of the world.

I believe that Lee Valley came to an identical conclusion about chisel dulling which led to a steel selection that had superior toughness at high hardness. We recently had a report on a 440C chisel heat treated to Rc 56. It failed miserably at dovetail chopping, by edge deformation. It's more data consistent with my dulling theory and the critical importance of high hardness for a chisel steel.