Re: Shapening History
TomD
"My question is not about what is best but the history of hand tools and sharp tools. If hand tools are used because of historic use"
Do you mean that if in your case that is why you use them? I don't think that is at all a general reason for their use. They continue to be used because they are superior in certain cases, the only way in other case, enjoyed by some, etc... Very few people I see are historical re-enactors with tools. For instance, nothing gets the hits around here like a thread about some meaningless improvement to tools that leads to a new product.
"then what is the historic method of sharpening?"
There has never been one method, but you can get a sense from the answers here, and from books of the period. CS published a book from an earlier period where the apprentice was counselled at a power grinder, probably steam, that was in use at one shop. Presumably a toolmaker.
"I don't mean what is the best way to get the absolute atomic sharp edge"
Metal tools can't be sharpened to an atomic edge, but the techniques to do as well as we do today were around before today. Remember peaople carved teeth, and metal, etc... Everything by hand for the most parts, so sharpness confers cutting power, and makes a job go faster. I don't really care how sharp my planer is untile the wood starts to show a poor surface, because it has a 2hp motor. If I had to do all that work by hand, I would want a wooden plane with a sharp blade, unless the wood was very soft.
" And, what is the use or point in trying to get sharper? "
I don't agree that we get tools sharper today, and in what context? The average hobby woodworker today still can't sharpen hardly at all, and jiggery continues to be a mainstay. One thing about he past was they had to learn to produce, and couldn't waste time on inefficient tools and methods. Today we have not so much improved sharpening, as stretched out the cycle time to get a blade sharpened. The one exception being the potential use of power tools, which they had in the past, but are more powerful today, to some extent. But you can cycle a wood plane in a few seconds. You can get a couple of wipes on a chisel in seconds if you don't need to fit a bunch of jigs to it.