New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shapening History

Posts

Shapening History

#1

Shapening History

Stuart Johnson

I'm not a hand tool fanatic but do use what ever is the best for me at the time. There have been many threads and comments on sharpening and what is the best method.

My question is not about what is best but the history of hand tools and sharp tools. If hand tools are used because of historic use then what is the historic method of sharpening? I don't mean what is the best way to get the absolute atomic sharp edge but what was used in say 1750? And, what is the use or point in trying to get sharper?

Re: Shapening History

#2

a different objective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The point isn't to get sharper but to get sharper quicker. I don't have an apprentice to sharpen stuff and I don't find the activity rewarding, interesting, or stimulating.

Another point, if you are wedded to 1750 sharpening technology you may be stuck with 1750 steel.

I would be delighted to eventually see some quantitative data on the topic, but I hypothesize that most refine an edge beyond what is necessary because they can with modern media.

Re: Shapening History

#3

Re: Shapening History

david weaver

I don't know what was used in 1750, but slates, novaculites, silica based sedimentary stones of more exotic types, oxides, etc, were all well known and distributed in the early 1800s.

I am no historian by any means, but I would bet a cabinet or furniture maker of fine things had very sharp tools as well as an ability to understand the use of a piece of leather for a strop.

Remember at the time people (including barbers) would've used instruments suitably sharp (sharper than most woodworkers use these days, and it only takes a cross over into straight razor sharpening to understand that a good sharp woodworking edge is a step short of a good shaving edge).

Maybe some of the shop folks could tell us, but I wouldn't be surprised if an apprentice was charged with keeping the tools sharp. The greatest advances in sharpening have probably been on the coarse side (carborundum and coarse bonded abrasive wheels).

Re: Shapening History

#4

Apprentice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I spent two days with Alan Batty(English) some time ago. He trained apprentices. He mentioned that their first job was to learn and then do the sharpening for the shop/factory where he worked.

The one time I was at Colonial Williamsburg (an unpleasant experience enduring stuffy people acting the part) it was the apprentice that was sharpening.

Re: Shapening History

#5

Missing data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Edge tools are like cars. The edge rapidly depreciates as soon as it is driven. We lack data on how fast this initial dulling happens and whether ultimate atomic sharpening makes any meaningful difference after 10 feet (or pick a number) of use.

I know that I am still cutting nicely when the edge has worn enough to see the wear in good light or with modest magnification. It follows then that atomic sharpening is not necessary to get a plane or chisel to work satisfactory. Yet, there could be a benefit. Maybe this atomic edge prolongs the sweet spot of satisfactory use, or not. It would be nice to have data to know what level of sharpening provides meaningful benefit for those of us that wish to minimize this activity.

I am gravitating toward the school that the ancient art of stroping may be as good as one needs and that some relatively crude metal removal may be sufficient to precede stroping. Recently a strop has taken up residence on the bench, having moved from a less available shelf.

Re: Shapening History

#6

Re: Shapening History

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sharpening equipment in the 18th century consisted in grindstones, rub stones, ragg stones, and honing slates.

Grindstones were large sandstone wheels, usually 20 inches in diameter and larger. These were specially chosen for their sharpening ability. They had a crank or a treadle or a crank and were generally used wet.

Rub stones are coarse bench stones, usually sandstone also I think, that were used for grinding in place of a grindstone. Roubo illustrates one that is bigger than a concrete block.

Ragg stones are bench stones of very fine sandstone or schist.

Honing slates are fine stones. Although the stones we call slate today do work, this was a more general term for fine stones. Most honing stones were oil stones in England and America and the best were imported from Asia Minor.

I don't think apprentices were generally charged with sharpening. Sharpening is an art; and an important part of the process is discernment of the condition of the edge (feedback from use). In the most efficient sharpening the initial condition of the edge is a factor in technique. I certainly would not want someone else sharpening my tools.

If you are using a chisel and it is need of sharpening, it is probably easiest to do it oneself than to interrupt the work of an apprentice and have him sharpen the tool while you sit around and wait. It is certainly easier to teach a young fellow to dovetail a drawer or make mortise and tenon than to teach him to sharpen a chisel.

If I had an apprentice, I would want to sharpen the tools for him at least until he got a feel for how a good tool worked, when it needed sharpening.This plan has worked when I have had young people work in my shop.

Re: Shapening History

#7

Re: Missing data

david weaver

A strop to me is a check of an edge with stones that cut harshly (natural japanese stones cut relatively harshly for a natural stone when they are slurried, and all al-ox silicon carbide and diamond type things are harsh and cut deep grooves).

For something more gradual (coticule, arkansas stones) that cuts a wider and shallower groove, the strop has to remove any bits of wire edge.

I've noticed when using only the washita that the time of use of the plane doesn't necessarily seem like less, that's dictated more by clearance, but that the initial slickness and waxy shavings that come from a very fine sharpening do not ever occur with the washita. Thin shavings are still no problem (nor is a quick shave test), but their quality is a little different. The resulting surface is still excellent and bright with a double iron, though.

My assessment would be that razor sharpness isn't required for longevity, but a sharpening method that leaves decent clearance and eliminates chipping is.

Re: Shapening History

#8

Re: a different objective

Curt Putnam

Wilbur Pan (may be on his website) had/has some graphs that illustrate the point, which is that highly polished edges add enough to the working life of an edge to be worth the effort. For me, the few strokes it takes on the 13K stone is insignificant compared to the overall process.

Re: Shapening History

#9

Razor sharp

Bruce McCrory

David said:

Remember at the time people (including barbers) would've used instruments suitably sharp (sharper than most woodworkers use these days, and it only takes a cross over into straight razor sharpening to understand that a good sharp woodworking edge is a step short of a good shaving edge).

I remember stories of Native Americans using tin can lids for shaving. Probably fictional.

I think the edge quality of a straight razor after Norton and Horse-butt-belt is confused with the whole experience of a cut and shave; if not influenced by the mists of time, nostalgia. A neck shave was tolerable only because the hot towel, warm lather, and massage was my goal. And, it was included in the price. I have all the tools for a straight razor shave but buy the sharpest double edge blades on line.

I leave straight razors to burn and nightmare-ish imagination.

Re: Shapening History

#10

Re: Shapening History

Roy

I would think the Japanese sharpening method would be of historical interest. They are big on traditional ways and I imagine the sharpening techniques haven't changed very much over the years. I saw pictures of a workshop where they sharpened a plane, put it on a board and then tilted the board until the plane started sliding down, meanwhile cutting a very fine shaving.

Roy

Re: Shapening History

#11

Re: Shapening History

TomD

I think your basic point is correct in that the sword culture had certainly been accompanied by a sharpening culture in Japan. One version of the story holds that following the 1876 edict banning the carrying of swords, makers fell on hard times. They then diversified into other fields such as making woodworking tools, and many other things. Those products then saw an increase in standards through the application of sword making techniques. If any of that is true, it would suggest that the Japanese tools business and the sharpening that went with them were not always as we see them now.

I thought the story about the plane cutting under it's own weight was apocryphal. I would love to see such a picture, it would make my day.

Re: Shapening History

#12

Re: Razor sharp

TomD

Bruce, I am not sure I have your meaning, but if you are suggesting straight razors were not sharp, that would be contrary to my experience. They are generally more sharp than the run of the mill double edge razor in my experience. For some reason I can shave with a double razor, but can't shave with the same blade in a straight razor. It is not comfortable at any rate. It takes a better grade of razor blade to offer a shave equivalent to a hand sharpened straight razor.

On the other hand, a straight razor has more cutting power in part due to a more acute edge geometry.

About the tin can lid, sounds unlikely, but then at some point wouldn't they have used copper based tools to shave with, they just didn't last as long. So shaving with steel that was soft should be possible if you could sharpen it.

Re: Shapening History

#13

Re: a different objective

TomD

"Another point, if you are wedded to 1750 sharpening technology you may be stuck with 1750 steel."

Uh, no. I don't know of any modern steel that can't be readily sharpened with normal hand processes. The only steel I don't have familiarity with is that stuff you made your chisels out of before everyone changed horses to the LV stuff. You can sharpen carbide tools with japanese water stones.

"I would be delighted to eventually see some quantitative data on the topic, but I hypothesize that most refine an edge beyond what is necessary because they can with modern media."

There seem to be a lot of subjective qualifiers in there for any serious study. For the most part, what you seem to think of as oversharpening, in one place in this thread described as an edge you can see (a fairly universal description of dullness by the way), has been commonplace over a long time. I think if anything high standards are more part of hand methods. The great thing about power sharpening where possible is it is so fast people tend not to care if it is good or not. That attitude is also part of the reason that soft tools and repeat sharpening are common. These are all good methods in their place. There is not one correct method, if one built only Paulonia boxes one's needs would be different than carving headstones (or the wood equivalent).

Re: Shapening History

#14

Re: Shapening History

TomD

"My question is not about what is best but the history of hand tools and sharp tools. If hand tools are used because of historic use"

Do you mean that if in your case that is why you use them? I don't think that is at all a general reason for their use. They continue to be used because they are superior in certain cases, the only way in other case, enjoyed by some, etc... Very few people I see are historical re-enactors with tools. For instance, nothing gets the hits around here like a thread about some meaningless improvement to tools that leads to a new product.

"then what is the historic method of sharpening?"

There has never been one method, but you can get a sense from the answers here, and from books of the period. CS published a book from an earlier period where the apprentice was counselled at a power grinder, probably steam, that was in use at one shop. Presumably a toolmaker.

"I don't mean what is the best way to get the absolute atomic sharp edge"

Metal tools can't be sharpened to an atomic edge, but the techniques to do as well as we do today were around before today. Remember peaople carved teeth, and metal, etc... Everything by hand for the most parts, so sharpness confers cutting power, and makes a job go faster. I don't really care how sharp my planer is untile the wood starts to show a poor surface, because it has a 2hp motor. If I had to do all that work by hand, I would want a wooden plane with a sharp blade, unless the wood was very soft.

" And, what is the use or point in trying to get sharper? "

I don't agree that we get tools sharper today, and in what context? The average hobby woodworker today still can't sharpen hardly at all, and jiggery continues to be a mainstay. One thing about he past was they had to learn to produce, and couldn't waste time on inefficient tools and methods. Today we have not so much improved sharpening, as stretched out the cycle time to get a blade sharpened. The one exception being the potential use of power tools, which they had in the past, but are more powerful today, to some extent. But you can cycle a wood plane in a few seconds. You can get a couple of wipes on a chisel in seconds if you don't need to fit a bunch of jigs to it.

Re: Shapening History

#15

Re: Missing data

TomD

I think it is tough to get decent data because there are so many ways of working. How does one compare people that pry, or use different tools or woods. The general idea that super sharpness may prolong some sweetspot, or at least be worth the extra effort can probably be studied. Gillete theoretically had a marketing campaign that was based on upping the number of blades when what they really did was up the edge quality. If you knew anyone there, they might have some info.

Re: Shapening History

#16

Re: Razor sharp - Not Correct

david weaver

I gather the implication here is that a straight razor is harsh and comes up short compared to a double edge razor.

That's probably true if a razor is not sharpened and maintained properly, but a straight razor shave that is lacking in comfort compared to a DE shave of any type is not a straight razor shave that is appropriate for comparison to anything.

The norton 8k followed by leather is not a suitable shave, it would require a couple of weeks of shaving and periodic trips to a linen to eventually build a smooth edge. A skilled shaver with a broken in hard arkansas stone could do much better than the norton.

I don't know of anything that is sharper than a DE feather blade, but I also have problems with that type of blade with razor burn and weepers. The blades I use in a DE when I travel are astra stainless platinum or whatever they call them, a middle of the road blade, and my straight razors give up nothing to them in sharpness, and I can get a closer shave without weepers, burn or ingrown hairs with a straight razor.

The towel and such at a barber, presumably, is to get your hair in a condition that it would be in if you just jumped out of a shower, but it's something that you would do if you walked in cold to a shave with a DE blade or anything else. I shave every day with a straight razor after stepping directly out of the shower.

Probably the most common stones I've seen pop up from retiring barbers are graded coticules. A barber or a skilled shaver can maintain an edge with a proper (flax) linen and leather off of something like a coticule that is better (sharper) than any edge anyone will get off of superfine hones. The nonsense of honing all the time using modern stones is a modern thing by the DIY crowd, and it leaves an edge that is not comfortable compared to a properly maintained edge.

Re: Shapening History

#17

Re: New blades and coatings

david weaver

The reason the disposable single edge razors don't shave very well is they lack weight, and mechanically they lever against your fingers holding the tang of the razor.

With a gilette slim or super speed, you have a substantial hunk of brass to pull directly in line with the cut. Feather apparently did a work-around for this by making a very heavy rigid carrier for their blades (their very expensive straight razor style disposable user). Merkur makes some super heavy DEs that people remark about how close the shave is, but every one like that either has a huge opening with a lot of blade exposure, or more often is very heavy.

All of the newer razor blades that are coated are better than the old bic disposable razors we used to use. The new multiblade razors are fairly nice if you keep your touch light with them and manage to keep the hair from clogging them between blades. It's probably the coatings and applying them that are the innovation, but they make a blade truly disposable, and still inconsistent.

The straight with a good linen operates in a range that is much narrower in terms of sharpness, and they are the only thing I have ever been able to shave closely with and avoid razor burn.

Re: Shapening History

#18

Re: Razors - another topic

Bruce McCrory

My bad. What prompted my earlier reply was my "long ago, and far away" experience with neck shaves during a haircut. That's the only time a straight razor touched me. The barber could have used any stone. He tested on his wrist, and I do the same now, for grins.

BTW, to beat that other horse, a couple years ago I got tired of a forty-year-old full beard, threw away the disposable reasons for it, and dug out my high school razor. For those who are sick of the double edge replacements-- plastic disposables, they are all worthless, no matter the blade count--the garden variety store branded DE, made in USA, is second to Feather (Yellow, and world's sharpest) in baby-smooth finish. There is a day between a Feather finish and disposable plastic [can edge] best effort.

Just my Styptic-pencil thoughts.... :)

Re: Shapening History

#19

Re: Razors - another topic

David weaver

Unexpected weepers... The sign of a very keen blade....

(there are definitely barbers giving bad shaves still, but I suspect that they are the result of the shave not being that important to the Barber.)

.1 micron iron oxide on a good razor will make for unintended Weekes, but the effect is transient... Fortunately.

Re: Shapening History

#20

Plane cutting under its own weight

John Pappas

"I thought the story about the plane cutting under its own weight was apocryphal. I would love to see such a picture, it would make my day."

I too, find it hard to believe.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJHrSmZQx10

Re: Shapening History

#21

Re: Missing data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, back in 2007 someone wrote about a sharpness test that involved cutting newspaper. Here is what you wrote at the time.

>If someone can cut newsprint and then after planing 10' they can't I would suggest that this is an irrelevant measure of sharpness for woodworking. Lets here it from the news print cutters.

I resharpen when I can't cut wood. I presume that is well beyond the dullness that won't cut paper.

I had not used this test before, but in response to your post I spent half an hour planing, taking apart the plane and testing, planing some more et cetera. Of course the test worked long after ten feet. I reported my results just three hours later, but you did not even thank me for my efforts. Nobody wants to do this stuff for free for someone who is going to ignore the results and then say data is "missing".

If you are not constantly evaluating your edge as you work, you are throwing away data wholesale. The way to learn how to preserve an edge and get better performance is to constantly evaluate how various techniques affect the edge. You need to learn to evaluate an edge by discernment and feel.

Re: Shapening History

#22

Re: Razors - another topic

Bruce McCrory

David said:

"Unexpected weepers... The sign of a very keen blade...."

This is one good thing about Feather. I can re-contour my face and not feel the change ... ... for quite a while. Straight gouge carving, so to speak. When someone asks, the scars are 50-cent plastic surgery. :D

Re: Shapening History

#23

Re: Razor sharp - Not Correct

Lars Parrington

An 8k norton followed by a few strokes on leather is my usual straight razor sharpening regimen, and I agree, it doesn't make for the most comfortable shave.

What additional treatment would you recommend after the 8k? I don't have a hard arkansas to try, but I do have an uf spyderco, 0.5u diamond paste, and green wax on hand. I have noticed some improvement from the spyderco.

Re: Shapening History

#24

Re: Razor sharp - Not Correct

Bruce McCrory

This is my postscript, epitaph for this topic.....

I am from the stainless double edge generation. Single use carbon went into the wall cavity a couple years before. The straight razor was too much trouble--and too dull (and, scary)--for a teen. Tending to follow Dad and Grandpa was the norm.

What I see of the straight razor craze/fad is really just costly gimmicks. No one went to the trouble current marketing wants to foist onto customers. The stainless DE blade was (is) the pinnacle of sharp shaving tool.

Carbon blades are just as bad, if not worse than the current second rate crop of stainless blades.

Re: Shapening History

#25

straight razors

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You just have no idea what you are talking about. My grandfather taught me to shave with a straight razor in 1965 when I was a teenager. He gave me a lightly used razor but I did not really use it until 1969 when he became ill and gave me his strop. I am still using the same razor and the same strop. I really could get a new strop, but the razor is fine. How much have you spent on blades since 1969?

Get yourself a nice razor, a good razor strop and some real instruction (not just beginners on u-tube). Get a few years of experience under your belt and get back to us.