New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

Posts

Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#1

Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

John in NM

I have some nitric acid available to sharpen rasps and stuff. The stuff I was given is quite strong, so it will get diluted. I would like to make up a solution for rasps and then dilute the rest further for making ferric nitrate stain.

Any idea what a good concentration would be for sharpening rasps? 10%? 15%. My understanding is that a slower etch leads to fewer hydrogen embrittlement problems, but too weak and this is going to take more time than I'd like (up to a week would be ok).

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#2

Re: useless conversation....

david weaver

well, since nobody else has answered, I can only add a few useless comments (because I've never satisfactorily gotten a good "sharpening" from acid etch).

I believe nitric acid is used at a 25% concentration or so to intentionally etch something into steel. Not doing that kind of thing, I don't know how long that etch actually lasts and how deep it's expected to go.

In my experience using phosphoric acid (which doesn't help you much), it seems that in what would be a weak solution for something else, the acid etching needs to occur before there is significant dulling of a tool, and the kind of dulling i'm talking about happens on the nicholson 49/50 style rasps where the teeth are very wide and flat (maybe that applies for cabinetmaker rasps, too). On the hand stitched rasps I have, as the teeth wear some, I don't notice much other than that they work a little smoother.

I recall Joel Moskowitz countering an argument that was made on the forums a couple of years ago where a guy was trying to shill some french rasps on the notion that a 30 stroke test showed superiority of one over the other because of a coating. Joel pointed out that they had used a machine to attempt to wear out some hand stitched rasps, but as the teeth wore they actually cut better after more strokes than most users were likely to put on a rasp - at least amateur users. (in my experience, that's not the case for the rasps with wide flat teeth, but those are not particularly desirable rasps to begin with - not being disagreeable, just making reference that I've learned to prefer hand stitched because they wear in a way that doesn't seem to impede cutting).

All that said, if nobody offers a qualified opinion, I'd go for 20 to 1 or 10 to 1 and see what it does. I understand that in the days of consumables being very expensive (which files definitely were - blindingly expensive compared to a craftsman's daily wage), I can see the idea of trying to stretch them as long as possible. After my experiences with phosphoric acid etch (kleen strip "prep and etch"), i've gone to the hand stitched rasps for mass removal and am waiting to see if they ever actually feel worn out. If my nicholson 50 gets the flat top teeth you find on used ones that are worn out, I'll probably throw it away. If the hand stitched rasps ever seem worn and slow, I'll probably send them to boggs tool. the tools I've etched have not been that far gone, but especially on files, the etching leaves tool that can be used but is not nice like a new sharp file. Maybe on a rasp, it wouldn't be a big deal since the embrittlement wouldn't remove a knife edge, but rather just something on a tool that "rasps" (tearing) rather than cuts.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#3

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi John

This past January I decided to sharpen a bunch of old and very dull files - a wide range that ran from large coarse files to small tenon and dovetail files.

Into a gallon bucket of warm water I added 3 small tubs of citric acid powder, each approximately 1 oz. The files went into this.

I checked them periodically over the next day, but little seemed to be happening. In the end I left then covered for a week.

At the end of this time they were covered in a little dark residue, which I removed with a brass wire brush under running water. The steel came up clean. A hot air gun was used to dry the files. I sprayed a little thin machine oil over the teeth in case of flash rusting.

To say that they were transformed would be an understatement. The teeth were sharp enough to cut/scratch if you ran a finger lightly over them. As it happened, I was visited the following weekend by a group of school (shop) teachers, and they had an opportunity to try the files out. They left with a mission to sharpen all the old files they could find.

Now I am not sure how my numbers match yours. It seems I was using a mild level of acidity - the citric acid powder came from the local supermarket. One week seems a long time to leave files soaking.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#4

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

John in NM

Actually, the length of time doesn't bother me much, I picked a week because I could leave my rasps soaking while I went off for a shift at work, then come back and have them ready to try.

From what I understand of the hydrogen embrittlement question, weaker acid and a longer soak is preferable in any case. I've heard of breaking teeth off after etching in too strong an acid.

I would imagine that weaker is also better with a strong acid like nitric. Citric or acetic could probably be used at higher concentrations, but college chem was many years ago and I've forgotten much of it.

I suppose the thing to do may be to mix up some 5% and check it daily, then perhaps leave it a week.

Assuming your citric powder was pure, that 3 oz makes roughly 2.1% concentration. Vinegar is typically 5% IIRC, so your citric was pretty weak. Good to hear it worked though, overnight soaks I've tried with vinegar didn't seem to do much, though I have dissolved steel wool with it in about that time frame (for making ferric acetate).

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#5

A lot of the idea here...

John in NM

Is etching before the teeth get flat.

I can see very small flats in reflected light, and the rasp is much less aggressive than when new - or than the curved side which I rarely use. The cut is smoother though, so it may really be in the sweet spot for a hand stitched rasp - what I gather Joel was talking about. I'm not sure I would say it cuts better, depends on how one defines better. Better surface finish, but slower cutting.

Maybe I should get off the dime and buy a coarse rasp too :D

I'm off to work for a week, so I can ruminate before dunking the rasp in some acid. I also have plenty of dull mill files to play with, those are pretty useless at the moment. I suppose I could also try one of the machine rasps I have around. I've never found those to be good for much, but that could be that they're dull - I've never bought one new.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#6

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

david weaver

Derek - how have those files held up?

Most of the files I etched were mill files, but I may have let them wait too long. They were intially sharp, but not new "good" file sharp, and their durability was less.

They had been used to draw file the pins and tails off of several planes, which is pretty hard on a mill file, and the files were not up to doing it again.

I'd do it on a double tooth file I intended for wood without a thought - a slight increase in brittleness wouldn't be an issue there. I have never had a "really good" fine hand stitched rasp because the double cut files here available NOS in various profiles are so cheap and they do a very good job if used to follow a coarse rasp.

(I had no luck at all with taper saw files, but filing spring steel is something one should expect to be terminal, I guess).

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#7

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

roger lance

John.....I've no idea what concentration/time would be best.....but I think you've hit on the right approach.....test some acid with an inexpensive tool (not an Auriou) and let us know how that did.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#8

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Bob Rozaieski offers some useful experience, with comments, in this post on his video podcast, Logan Cabinet Shoppe:

http://logancabinetshoppe.wordpress.com/2010/12/03/quick-tip-7/

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#9

send them to a company that sharpens files

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We did and they came back sharp as new. At the time it was about $2 per file

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#10

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

Peter Evans

I use citric acid, and the concentration is not critical (weaker takes longer), however if files are left for an extended period in the solution, the crud deposit that is on the surface can be hard to remove. Therefore check the files regularly, and when suitably sharp, take out and treat as Derek describes (I do not oil the files but do wrap in paper after driving out the moisture with a hair dryer).

Forget saw files, the edge teeth (the teeth that matter) are usually too far gone.

Wood and cabinet rasps sharpen well, and are smoother than when new - because the teeth are more rounded over. However these days I use hand stitched. Flat/hand files come up well, roughly filing a grade smoother than when new. I recently filed a brass saw back with a freshly sharpened old 2nd cut 14" hand file (used and rusty but not abused, one of a free bucket load of files/rasps in similar condition), and it was perfect; the longer file is great, and where do you buy one this quality today anyway?

A friend sharpens files in full strength nitric (mad engineer), he leaves them in for minutes. Citric is so much kinder all round, especially to hands and lungs.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#11

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

So far the files are holding up well. Some are used on wood, some on steel. There has not been any dramatic wear on steel, nor signs of teeth breaking. In general, they still feel sharper than new.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#12

Re: Rasp sharpening, Citric acid powder?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Derek,

For those of us in the northern hemisphere, can you provide a little more detail on the '3 small tubs of citric acid powder, each approximately 1 oz.' that you used?

Thank you,

Bob in NJ

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#13

Re: Rasp sharpening, Citric acid powder?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bob

I looked up the citric acid I used. The 3 tubs in about a gallon of water was more concentrated than I recalled:


75 gm = 2.64555 oz

so, 3 tubs = approximately 8 oz.

From Wekipedia:

Citric acid is an excellent chelating agent, binding metals. It is used to remove limescale from boilers and evaporators.[8] It can be used to soften water, which makes it useful in soaps and laundry detergents. By chelating the metals in hard water, it lets these cleaners produce foam and work better without need for water softening. Citric acid is the active ingredient in some bathroom and kitchen cleaning solutions. A solution with a 6% concentration of citric acid will remove hard water stains from glass without scrubbing. In industry, it is used to dissolve rust from steel. Citric acid can be used in shampoo to wash out wax and coloring from the hair.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#14

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

David weaver

Thanks, Derek. Sounds like citric acid is worth a try. Phosphoric results either can't match that, or at least I can't get them to.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#15

That makes more sense

John in NM

Almost 18%, that makes much more sense with the 7 day time frame and a weak acid like citric.

I'm thinking now I may just use the nitric acid to make ferric nitrate and use citric as you did for file sharpening.

I was also looking at sharpening companies as Bill suggested, prices still seem to be very reasonable, though some have 10-25 minimums. May do that too if I can come up with a bunch of dull ones.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#16

Iron dissolving chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ferrous metals dissolve better when the ferrous or ferric product is tied up as some sort of complex, citrate or oxylate for example. Chloride, as in HCl, works dandy too and would be the preferred means of quickly dissolving a sample for analysis.

Nitric acid can oxidize (passaivate) the surface of some steels and render then very slow to dissolve. For this reason I never tried dissolving a steel in nitric acid, so I have no idea what the rate might be for a file. But if it is slow, I have an explanation. Nitric works for metals that are difficult to oxidize to dissolve them- copper and gold for example.

For all these reasons instead of turning file sharpening into a research project, send them off to be sharpened as good as, or better than, new. It is not hard to find 25 dull files, especially if you have a friend with dull files.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#17

Most of the reason for all this...

John in NM

I grabbed the available nitric acid for making ferric nitrate stain for maple. It has a more pleasing color in my view than does ferric acetate, and is supposed to be a single step rather than two step process.

Figured that if I have to get iron into the solution, I may as well benefit from some sharp files too :D I've basically talked myself out of that though, going to mix it all up into a dilute solution and dissolve a bunch of steel wool. That's how I got the ferric acetate too, nothing much to it.

Thanks for the chem info Bill, its always good to hear a better informed explanation.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#18

color differences

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Since I never dissolved iron in nitric acid I don't know, but it may be that nitric, because it is an oxidizing acid, makes ferric iron. Acetic acid will definitely make ferrous iron. I don't know if acetate is a good enough complexing agent for ferrous to keep it ferrous. Oxygen will want to oxidize ferrous to ferric if it can.

Chloride makes a powerful bright yellow complex with iron which I would think undesirable. Oxalate and citrate products are colorless which is good for removing iron color from wood.

When acetic acid dissolves iron it makes hydrogen. Nitric can, depending on concentration, make some oxides of nitrogen that are not good to breath. If you get brown fumes, seek ventilation.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#19

Re: citric acid - ebay, also  use outside!

Rum

You can get bulk citric acid on ebay quite cheap from some quasi-industrial suppliers there. LOML uses it as part of some of her fiber dying processes and we got 10lbs for $25 shipped. I've also used it as a rust removal solution.

If you do use it use it outside otherwise the fumes can rust all your other tools (not as bad as having sulphuric acid in the shop.. but still not great - keep those old batteries outside as well!)

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#20

Fumes?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Citric acid is not volatile. The only volatile product in use is hydrogen.I would not expect any problem using it indoors.

HCl is another story. Hydrochloric acid is HCl gas dissolved in water. It does outgas and it will rust everything it encounters if there is an open container, or even a not well sealed container.

Nitric acid can produce oxides of nitrogen in use and some of these are not good to breathe. Happy gas (nitrous oxide) is not one of the products so don't expect a happy result of shorting the cleaning fumes.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#21

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

Steve Voigt

Not to discourage anyone from doing the acid thing, but what a place like Boggs does is fundamentally different. The way it was explained to me at my old machine shop was that the files are placed on an inclined surface, and an abrasive bath is forced past and over the files. So, they're only sharpened on one side, whereas with the acid you don't really have any control over how the metal is removed.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#22

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The way it was explained to me at my old machine shop was that the files are placed on an inclined surface, and an abrasive bath is forced past and over the files. So, they're only sharpened on one side, whereas with the acid you don't really have any control over how the metal is removed.

Steve, I am struggling to imagine how this could be done.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#23

Re: Fumes?

Rum

Hmm, I can't say its not de minimis, but I always believed that it did aerosolize some especially if hot. The risk of having a bunch of rusty tools never seemed worth the risk of direct experimentation :D

The MSDS and the original derusting guide I followed for using citric were also cautionary (it wasn't clear what the "irritating fumes" in the msds referred to, I - perhaps naively - figured likely either aerosolization citric or less likely aconitic acid - since I ?think? the latter only happens under anhydrous high temperature conditions, but my chemistry is much to weak to know for sure).

http://avogadro.chem.iastate.edu/MSDS/citric_acid.htm

"Hazardous Decomposition Products: Carbon monoxide, irritating and toxic fumes and gases, carbon dioxide."

http://www.tttg.org.au/php/tttg_Page.php?n=15&a=28

"Do your de-rusting outside; acid fumes are corrosive and may cause rust to develop on exposed metal surfaces. Whist this is a problem mainly with stronger acids, may also be caused by citric in some circumstances." (sic)

Having said all that I'm certainly not claiming you're wrong - if you decide to test please let us know the results :D A simple experiment with a box a solution of citric acid and a piece of freshly cut steel would be easy enough to do.. hmm.. if I get motivated this weekend I just might try that, I certainly have more than enough citric acid already.

The nitric passivation is an interesting comment.. I always thought that was more for stainless where it removed free iron from the surface leaving behind a layer of the chromium (or other non ferrous metals..) which would after the acid soak form an oxide layer on exposure to air (oxygen). I hadn't heard of using it for passivating non stainless iron... Turns out at sufficiently high concentrations it forms an oxide layer, neat. You can still learn something every day:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitric_acid

"Although chromium (Cr), iron (Fe) and aluminium (Al) readily dissolve in dilute nitric acid, the concentrated acid forms a metal oxide layer that protects the bulk of the metal from further oxidation."

I didn't know it even dissolved chromium! Double huh... now I need to read more on stainless passivation.

The gold part proved somewhat more complex and even more interesting:

"Some precious metals, such as pure gold and platinum group metals do not react with nitric acid, though pure gold does react with aqua regia, a mixture of concentrated nitric acid and hydrochloric acid. However, some less noble metals (Ag, Cu, ...) present in some gold alloys relatively poor in gold such as colored gold can be easily oxidized and dissolved by nitric acid, leading to colour changes of the gold-alloy surface. Nitric acid is used as a cheap means in jewelry shops to quickly spot low-gold alloys (< 14 carats) and to rapidly assess the gold purity."

Cool - thanks for mentioning that... although I'm unlikely to mess much with nitric of high concentration nowadays being somewhat of a wuss. I do use a dilute phosphoric and nitric solution (5 star acid line cleaner http://countrymaltgroup.com/downloads/MSDS-sheets.pdf) for cleaning bear lines (every 5-10 cleanings) and for passivating stainless brewing equipment (generally only if I have to drill a hole or similar). I've recently learned from a tank welder that citric may actually be better for passivating stainless.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#24

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

david weaver

It's like a liquid sandblasting. No etch or anything to the surface, just fresh abrasion.

I recall george wilson or someone telling me files are sharper after their (boggs) treatment than they were when the file was new.

No clue how much they can save (I wouldn't send them saw files, I clap those out completely before throwing them away).

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#25

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I have been aware of their excellent reputation for a good many years. I am not questioning that.

I am questioning this:

The way it was explained to me at my old machine shop was that the files are placed on an inclined surface, and an abrasive bath is forced past and over the files. So, they're only sharpened on one side, whereas with the acid you don't really have any control over how the metal is removed.

How can you have (liquid) acid flow on "one side" ... one side of what?

Regards from Perth

Derek