New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

Posts

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#26

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

david weaver

I think that the bath is probably not acidic, just abrasive. I get the sense that it's blasted into the file at an angle to remove metal from the surface fasting the blast/liquid bath.

Think power washer with aluminum oxide in the water.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#27

Re:  page says liquid and also steam

david weaver

I can't tell if that means that the liquid process is actually steam or there are various processes, but they use the term "blast" instead of steam.

It'd be lovely if there was a video.

http://www.boggstool.com/

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#28

more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never stuck a file in citric acid. If it reacts vigorously, which I assumed it would would not, it will make an aerosol that would settle and become corrosive to what ever it settled on, as you pointed out.

And I have never tried dissolving carbon steel in nitric acid of any concentration. As you know some highly alloyed steel will passivate to such an extent in nitric acid that the dissolution rate will be imperceptible. I am sure nitric acid will dissolve carbon steel, I just don't know the rate. It may be slowed down in nitric compared to something more conventionally used like HCl. Or may be not. Carbon steel does passivate to some extent. The oxide layer formed is referred to as "partially or imperfectly" passivating. Whether nitric acid aids the formation of the protective oxide layer or not, I don't know. It might which may be why HCl is the preferred acid for dissolving steel samples.

Gold and platinum dissolve in nitric acid when there is a complexing agent present, such as chloride. The chloride wounds the passive surface oxide layer and nitric acid oxidizes the exposed gold, platinum , etc. to put it into solution. There seem to be various theories as to the details of how chloride wounds the oxide layer.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#29

The company we use

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

http://www.saveedge.com/resharpening.html

Xenia, Ohio

This company started by sharpening horse hoof files. Now they do any file.

Sharpening was cheap and the results were good as new files. Shipping is not insignificant. However, Priority Mail flat rate boxes are your friend when shipping 25- 10 to 14" files.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#30

Shipping

John in NM

I also like regional rate boxes. The cheapest is an A box and slightly smaller than a medium flat rate. Would work well for 25+ files with some reinforcement to keep them from poking through the box.

Basically, the box is flat rate within the various regions and with lower weight limits than regular flat rate boxes. Saves you a few bucks compared to regular flat rate boxes.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#31

Re: more (drifting further ot)

Rum

Citric isn't incredibly vigorous but it does bubble in a noticeable fashion.

I'm guessing the bubbles are mostly hydrogen but am not sure how much vapor, suspended acid, etc.. they bring up with them which would be the area of possible concern for secondary corrosion.

On the nitric side this has definitely reached and surpassed any level of surety on my part. I do know nitric is a strong oxidizer so presumably at high concentration it reacts to form an oxide layer fast and deep enough to prevent further attack (assuming nothing else to attack the oxide layer), although the literature I'm finding on this isn't as helpful as I'd like. I also know that nitric is used as an etch for steel but not at super strong concentrations (15-30%)

Chlorides seem to mostly attack at "interface layers", that is if you put chlorine bleach into water in a stainless container (don't!) the pitting and eventual pinholes will appear at the interface between the water and the air (don't ask how I know this :| ). The reaction in that case appears to be mostly an galvanic one where its popping atoms off due to small electrical discharges between the different metals (existing flaws grow larger much faster than smooth surfaces). http://www.estainlesssteel.com/corrosion.shtml : "Stainless that had had its passivation penetrated in a small spot becomes an anodic, with the passivated part remaining a cathodic".

How it interacts when used with something like nitric or on other metals I don't know (tentatively claiming the galvanic reaction still makes sense but is probably incomplete) since there wouldn't be a defined interface layer like there is in the chlorine in a pot case, presumably it would be a more even reaction (or you end up with a multitude of interface points presumably causing uneven corrosion/pitting).

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#32

Re: send them to a company that sharpens files

Steve Voigt

Hi Derek,

I'm not sure what's so confusing. As I said, it's abrasive particles, not acid, in liquid (presumaby water?). The liquid only flows one direction, so only one side of a tooth gets sharpened. David's analogy (power wash with al ox particles in the wash) seems right, although my impression is that was very low pressure. But that was twenty years ago, so maybe their process has evolved.

Re: Rasp sharpening, what concentration?

#33

Re: The company we use

Steve Voigt

Thanks Bill, that's good to know. When I lived in San Diego, Boggs was a better option, but it's nice to have something closer.