New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

Posts

Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#1

Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the recent Popular Woodworking Chris Schwartz states a seldom discussed point, namely, that it can be harder to successfully transfer the dovetail pattern from tail board to pin board than it is to saw it. Amen to that insight. He then describes what I think is a better approach to dovetail marking than the cut-a-rabbit- on-the-end approach, a tedious solution at best. I used the approach described for the last chest of drawers I made except I clamped the “rabbit-making- strip” rather than nailing it. It works as advertised. Clamping has the advantage that the alignment of the strip with the base line can be adjusted by tapping it with a hammer. But if one can successfully nail without skidding, nailing will be faster.

However! I am facing making 18 drawers for the spice boxes, 72 dovetail joints. I need a reliable marking procedure that is quicker. I think I found it and it may be transferable to be built into the Moxon vise that some use. (I haven’t thought that through )





Picture 1 and 2 shows a walnut guide black with an alignment strip glued to one edge. This guide is made to be at right angles to the vise jaws. This alignment is easily done by clamping a flat board in the vise and using a square to align the guide, which is then fixed to the bench with the clamps shown. A pin board is shown in position ready to be marked (actually this one has already been marked to make it obvious to spot).


Picture 3 shows the tail board in position for marking the pin board which is fixed in the vise as shown in the previous pictures.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#2

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler tri

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

It was Rob Cosman that made the rebate technique popular.

With regard to aligning from the side ... well, no idea is sacred :) David Barron makes and sells "a dovetail alignment board" ....


link: http://www.davidbarronfurniture.co.uk/david_barron_tools.asp?pg=1&id=7

I am not sure why someone would pay all that money for a jig that takes 5 minutes to make.

For myself, I simply place a wide chisel against the sides being aligned.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#3

right handed version?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does he make a right handed version :)

Or is that the right handed version and I should have inquired about left?

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#4

that is the right hand version....but....

roger lance

if you rotate the jig, you'll have the left hand version !!

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#5

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler tri

Michael Brady

Bill, I don't see how your how your arrangement keeps the baselines of the pin and tail boards aligned. It does keep them square, but wouldn't you have to use Chris' ruler trick to keep the base lines even? Personally, I align them using a front vise and the LV screw holdfast to keep the horizontal board aligned with the one in the vise. None of these techniques, except cutting a rabbit, hides the over-cuts on the inside of the joint.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#7

Thumb`

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I experience two marking problems- skidding while marking and getting each leg to be in the same plane. This guide solves both these problems.

Aligning the length of the tail board with the edge of the pin board is trivial. Just feel it with thumb. I have seen others just slap the two parts together and successfully mark. Great if you can reliably do it. But even if you can something that makes 76 joint markings go quicker is of value.

But I may have not understood your question for I am unsure about what "base lines even" means. .

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#8

Re: Rule of  Thumb`

TomD

I just hold them with one hand and mark with the other. I have been developing an ability to measure over the last few years where I make a mark, then observe where it went, then cut to where I think I need to cut. It is a sort of body english thing. The advantage is speed, and developing feel. But I prefer to be on the button with dovetails, and with 72 joints to do, you might as well tool up to make it go faster.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#9

Making a spice cabinet too!

Kees

That's funny. I am making a spice cabinet too! But I think you are making a fancy 18th century one with all the bells and whistels. Mine is going to be more like a simple 17th century cabinet, and because I have no use for all these drawers, I only make three of them. And because they mostly just nailed this stuff back then, I don't even need fancy ideas for dovetails!

But I could use some advanced ideas to make all the shelf and divider dado's. That's a lot of work. Almost finished luckily.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#10

consult the main Forum for these details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These details were recently posted on the Main board. Search "Spice Box"

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#11

Re: consult the main Forum for these details

Kees

Yes, just what I thought, more 18th then 17th century design. I'm sure you're going to make it brilliant.

Mine will have some carving on the front, exposed hinges on the side and a moulding around the top. Here's a sketch of my design.



Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#12

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler tri

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I didn't see Chris' article, so my comments may miss a key point.

However, I see three separate ideas raised in this thread:

First, hold the tails and pins boards rigid while marking, cause if anything moves, the marks and sawing will be off. The jigs being discussed will ensure this, and quickly.

Second, keep the drawer sides and front even in elevation. The jigs will do this, and quickly without fiddling

Third, keep the drawer bottom surfaces (bottom edges of sides and front) in the same plane, so for example, the assembled drawer will not rock if plopped down on a granite plate. I don't see how the jigs being discussed will do this. What makes a flat, coplanar drawer is the baselines (scribe lines) on tails and pin boards being marked square, and kept square and plumb during the chiseling. For example, if the tails board socket bases are chiseled non-square to the bottom of the drawer side, the drawer side will end up cattywampus to the front, and probably the other side, no matter how carefully the pins are marked and chiseled.

But again, I may have missed something.

Wiley

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#13

easy enough to make.....

roger lance


I also like the Christian Becksvoort method of cutting the dado for the drawer bottom into the drawer parts and then using that dado with a small piece of bottom stock to help align the parts.....I don't have a pic of that....maybe someone else might.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#14

Main Forum

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I thought this was the Main Forum. Main means hand in French. The last time I posted on the Auxiliary Forum (2008) a lawyer from New Jersey told me I was not welcome there. A fellow from East Tennessee defended me, but I never posted again.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#15

Coplaner drawer parts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Roger has treated us to yet another example from his extensive jig collection. It will be easier to see how this device ensures that the parts are coplaner from his picture than from my hastily assemble parts. If the two stops are in the same plane and the parts to be dovetails are pushed against these stops for marking, it follows that the dovetailed parts will be in the same plane when the joint is assembled.

The end result is the same as if the pin and tail board were placed on a flat surface on edge, as they will be in the drawer, and the pins marked. The only degree of freedom is the pin length.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#16

Error analysis

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I'm all for the jig--yours or Roger's--in a production situation like you describe, with all those joints to be made. It will be a big help in the pin marking, and will also provide a sort of 'second opinion' on the accuracy of the original baseline marking.

Yet I find that the co-planarity of the drawer will depend more on the original baseline marking, and the chiseling at the baseline of the tails board, than on the pin board marking. The fundamental reason is that when the parts are hammered together, the scribe lines of the tails and pin boards will come together to form a line at the inside corner of the drawer. These two lines will meet with a squareness and plumbness which depend mainly on (1) the original tails board scribe line marking, (2) and accuracy of tails board socket chiseling. Pins board scribing and chiseling will mainly affect the tilt of the drawer side in or out. Analysis follows below to illustrate these points...

Consider a shallow drawer, 2" high sides and front, 20" deep. Analysis of an error of 1/128" at various places in its making:

1. Tails board scribe line marked or knifed off-square by 1/128". Results in rear corner of tails board 10/128 (0.078") or more than 1/16" high or low, if every other operation done with zero error.

2. Tails board sockets chiseled on a skew of 1/128". Same result: rear in the air by better than 1/16".

3. When transferring marks, pins board and tails board tops and bottoms misaligned by 1/128". Result: linear error, drawer side elevation 1/128 above or below drawer front for its length.

4. When transferring marks, tails board laid 1/128" skew to the pins board (which is held in the vise). Result: Pin side slopes will be a little off; fit of the join may not be visibly perfect; does not affect coplanarity of drawer.

5. Pins board scribe line off-square by 1/128". Result: Drawer side will tilt inboard or outboard by 1/128"; will not affect coplanarity.

On the other hand, maybe my analysis is incorrect. Please show where.

Really and truly, I like the jig for the speed and certainty it brings to the marking. But coplanarity of drawer happens at the tails board scribe lines IMO. Neglecting offsetting errors etc etc yada yada.

Wiley

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#17

Re: easy enough to make.....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The pictures and explanations of C. Becksvoort demonstrating the technique are probably copyrighted by Taunton Press, as the article appeared in FWW several years ago. I don't have my copy with me this week, so I can't even look up the issue number for you. Of course, it would be easy enough for someone to set up and take the pics again.

The technique has some disadvantages, however. Since the alignment blocks are short, it doesn't help to keep the sides square with the front and back. It aligns the front and sides vertically, but isn't so precise with aligning the sides with the back, since there is usually no groove in the back. The blocks would collide with the bench top and front, so the grooves needs to be hung over the end of the bench while the marking is done. In reality, it needs to be hung over both ends of the bench, one end for the left drawer side and the other end for the right drawer side. If you fit it a little too loose, the blocks fall out onto the floor. I think the appliance with the fence shown in this discussion makes a lot more sense. Like the Becksvoort technique, if it is to be dropped into the bottom grooves, it should be planed to exact thickness, matching the groove width. In any particular project there is a large commonality of groove widths, enough to justify making and tuning an appliance for each width you use. Even in a complicated desk or secretary, probably appliances with two different groove widths will suffice for all the drawers.

When you make one, either with side fences or fences to fit in the bottom grooves, you will want to make it symmetrical, so you can rotate it, top to front and front to top to position the fences on either side.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#18

A practical problem stemming from not coplaner

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My discussion was focused on precise and accurate transfer marking. This step has three requirements. The parts must not move whilst marking(most critical), the mating of the height and depth of the parts must be near perfect and the two legs must be in the same plane. Those skilled in drawer making can mount the pin board in a vise, coax the tail board into position and mark. I can't reliably, especially on a drawer that is shallow and long. Roger's refine version of the thing I cobbled together meets all the needs for reliable transfer marking but unskilled labor not adverse to crutches. I think it quicker and more reliable than end rabbits.

That said, this is not the only essential element to drawer building. The ends of the drawer parts must be square(most important ), the scribe marks must be precise(trivial) and the sawing and chiseling accurate as your error analysis illustrates.

If the tail board is skewed while marking, either the top or bottom pin will be too small(simple case of 3 pins). Where ever the pin is too small there is no force forcing the joint together. The tight pin will tend to rotate the joint. Without clamping the baselines will not pull together. (been there, done that)

Drawer clamping to hold the dovetails together has its own problems. When clamping it is ever so easy to get a drawer out of square, or what ever shape it needs to be if the case is less than perfect. I consider it a joint preparation failure if the drawer does not tap together and become square and plumb. I may use a clamp to pull a tight joint together but I strive to not need clamps to hold the baselines tight. It means that I have loose pins somewhere.

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#19

Excellent point Bill

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

and a good argument for making sure the marking lineup of tails board over pins board (vertical in vise) is square. My analysis deficient in bringing this point out.

Wiley

Re: Thoughts on the C. Schwartz Dovetail Ruler trick

#20

Re: Excellent point Bill

TomD

Fingers can pick up stuff one can't see. So a simple gliding of the finger over intersecting surfaces is as accurate as any jig, or moreso. When you turn a page, you are discerning the presence of 4 thou. I would doubt most woodworking is laid out a whole lot more accurately than that, though the results are often more accurate. Wooworking has a process that gets some pretty incredible fits, but it isn't the layout always. I guess that is another subject. Jigs by the way, rely on the accuracy of the parts in woodworking. In metal working layout is normally done off reference surfaces, and so forth. That eliminates the error introduced by measuring from the parts themselves. To some extent, woodworking has a bias that fitting is more important than, measurement, layout, or jig accuracy. That is a pretty traditional truth in a lot of crafts.

If you look at FK he actually said he wasn't all that super until he undertook a large project. I think about the same number of drawers as Bill is doing joints. He said after that he was good to go. Most people ascribe magical powers to FK, but the rational explanation is that he did certain things and relatively rapidly reached his current level. Like a lot of other apprentices. That is basically what he says about himself. No doubt he is special, which is why he has so many areas of success, but his actual evolution as a craftsman evolved over fairly conventional lines. So when faced with a large job, one option is to gear up for it, with jigs and all that. Another is to do it with feel, and at the end of that one job, actually own the technique for ever. It takes practice, but it isn't a competitive sport.