New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Planning the next build

Posts

Planning the next build

#1

Planning the next build

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm sure others also spend time between builds tuning up equipment, both power and hand. This time it has been with more caution in mind since I have a stack of rough sawn Makore to use - beautiful timber from West Africa .. but ...

http://www.wood-database.com/lumber-identification/hardwoods/makore/

... some say that it can cause skin irritations. Although I have not experienced any reactions to timbers to date, I am being cautious and tuned up the dust collection for the jointer and thicknesser. Now I am waiting on a good dust mask with filtration down to .3 microns, and will not start any machining until they arrive.

I'd be interested to hear any experiences with this wood.

The next build is a lingerie chest for Lynndy. She's been asking for one for a while, one that will fit into an alcove in the bedroom. Ideas have been percolating ...

I have in mind a cabinet that tapers to each side. I am not decided on the drawers but have strongly entertained the idea of concave drawer fronts ...


... not sure (although I like the challenge of compound angled dovetails! :) ). They would be quite unusual - convex is more common. However straight may be a less busy look. Your thoughts?

I made up a mock-up with a few lengths of MDF clamped together.

The chest needs to be at a height that enables Lynndy to see into the top drawer. So this is established as 54". The width at the base is largely determined by the alcove into which it will go: Lynndy wants it as wide as possible, and I want it to be as wide as is aesthetic (she has little concern for the latter - she just wants a chest of drawers!).

This is what it looks like in the bedroom alcove (those pictures will be going). This is 16" wide at the top ...


... and 20" at the top ...


In the end we agreed on 17" at the top, 25" at the bottom, and a height of 53" ..

Today I drew this full size on 1/8" MDF sheet ...


There are two narrow drawers at the top that will be used for jewellery and be filled with trays and lined in suede. These will have locks. The remaining drawers I decided to keep the same height as I thought that graduated heights might accentuate the taper. Looking at this drawing, however, I have changed my mind. The problem is that the shorter drawers look "blocky" and clumsy.

Here is the cabinet redrawn with graduated drawers.


The sizes of the drawers were decided by eyeballing them - no calculations, per se. The upper two are 2 3/4", the next two rows are 4 1/2", the next two are 5 1/2" and the bottom three rows are 6 1/2". They look right to me. Your thoughts?

The locks are going to move from the front to the side of the carcase. On the front they add a busier look. Now I need to find locks that work from the side. I recall one can get these for desk drawers. Any sources?

Comments and opinion gladly received.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planning the next build

#2

Re: Planning the next build

Bruce McCrory

Looking good from the start... My thoughts, after 30 seconds:

I would continue the tapers, at three sides, the carcase sides (front elevation) tapering back proportionally. Then picking up the base arc, the drawer faces would curve at increasing depth, gentle at the base, to greater depth as the whole shrinks. Because, the drawer centerlines won't taper as much as the carcase edges. Simple convex curves, vertically and horizontally--enough to drive you insane.

Finally, the top would get a moulding, probably a reverse curve.

Re: Planning the next build

#3

Looking forward to the next build.....

roger lance

Derek....

I trust all is well with you and your family. I've no experience with the proposed wood but feel you are prudent to prepare as you are.

I was attracted more to the case with the wider (20") top and less slope.....but that is so arbitrary.

I'm sure you have looked at the chest of Christian Becksvoort who is well known for that particular work....its A&C/Shaker....progressively sized drawers.....rectangular though.....and a challenge in its own right.....about the same size as yours.

I'm looking forward to following your build.....its Fall here and Winters a comin.....so I'll be a watchin.

Re: Planning the next build

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Planning the next build

Clint Searl

Derek, I wrote a spreadsheet program to calculate drawer heights in a precise linear progression for up to ten drawers, given the ratio of the top and bottom drawers and the overall height to be divided. From your description and dimensions, I figure the ratio is 1.444 and the height to be divided, exclusive of the top two drawers and the base up to the bottom of the bottom drawer, is about 42 1/2 inches. The sequence of heights, including the top divider at the top of each drawer, for the seven drawers would be in millimeters:

126.2

135.5

144.9

154.2

163.6

172.9

182.2

The spreadsheet is in Excel/Open Office if you'd like a copy.

Re: Planning the next build

#5

Re: Planning the next build

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Looking good from the start... My thoughts, after 30 seconds:

I would continue the tapers, at three sides, the carcase sides (front elevation) tapering back proportionally. Then picking up the base arc, the drawer faces would curve at increasing depth, gentle at the base, to greater depth as the whole shrinks. Because, the drawer centerlines won't taper as much as the carcase edges. Simple convex curves, vertically and horizontally--enough to drive you insane.

Finally, the top would get a moulding, probably a reverse curve.

Good lord, Bruce, that is a LOT of curves :)

I did consider the sides tapering back ... but ... think about it ... your toes are pressing about the base/bottom drawer, and the top draw is another 6" further away than you expected it to be! So, no, there will not be a carcase that also tapers backwards.

If I curve the drawers, my thoughts were to make all the fronts to the same width and the same curvature. The curve would not be great - very gentle .. just enough to soften the drawer front. Using the same curvature would enable the line to be maintained.

I have been considering lamination or sawing from solid. Laminating would be easier but the concern I have with a lamination is whether it will be solid enough to dovetail (I have laminated demilune table stretchers, which received mortice and tenons).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planning the next build

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Planning the next build

Clint Searl

Now, if you'd like the top and bottom drawers to be in the Golden Mean ratio (1.618..), the heights would be:

117.8

129.9

142.1

154.2

166.3

178.5

190.6

Re: Planning the next build

#7

Re: Planning the next build

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Clint.

Here is more detail.

The carcase is planned to be 3/4" thick, with the drawer dividers 1/2" thick.

My thoughts were to keep the top two drawers top two drawers the same height. Originally, these would have each been half the height of the remaining drawers (when they were all to be the same height). Now the drawers have graduated heights and it seemed to me to continue this in pairs. That is how I arrived at the dimensions I have. I'd be interested to see what permutations you can come up with.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planning the next build

#8

Re: Planning the next build

chuck

Derek-

Looks like another winning project coming out of your shop and your mind. I'm unclear what type of lock you are looking for and where you want to place the lock on the chest. I'm looking forward to your build and progress reports.

Re: Planning the next build

#9

Clint Searl

Re: Planning the next build

Clint Searl

Derek, I'd be inclined to do some averaging on the original stack calculation:

126.2

140.2

140.2

158.9

158.9

177.6

177.6

Or without the dividers and in inches:

4.5

5

5

5.75

5.75

6.5

6.5

Re: Planning the next build

#10

What? No legs swooping....

Bruce McCrory

... diagonally away, into the floor? Whale tails? :D With the proposed taper, there is already an implicated need for steel toes. Or, stubbies.....

I thought you always reach for greater challenges.....

The concave faces you show in the drawer sample have the same compound curves I suggest. I don't think there is a case depth noted yet. And, I don't measure to top board--that can always grow and shrink. So, 25 (-) 17 = 8/2 = 4 case side taper. (That is still a lot in a single plane of taper.) If you measure to the top, that appears to lip little. I think the top needs more overhang, to compensate for the taper and "psychologically push you away from the case."

Why implode a frame with concave drawer fronts? Unless the bulk is bothersome. Or, they increase the challenge factor. To me, practicality prevails, so convex drawer faces is the next better solution.

The third plane of taper:

I will assume a maximum depth of 16 (no whale tails) at the floor. To detail my earlier third taper suggestion, I was thinking about half or third of the side taper at about 2. At the time, I was pushing and poking at jello, or clay. No numbers. The actual face angle (fall away) at draw centerline could be there but only fractionally.

As usual, this is the fun part for the audience. And, why, why do I keep thinking "parallax" with this design?

Re: Planning the next build

#11

Re: Planning the next build

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Clint

Your dimensions start with a drawer that is too high. The top two drawers are planned for jewellery or similar. Essentially a built-in jewellery box. The drawers need to be shallow. What you have is too deep. I like the idea of progressive heights.

Start with 2 3/4" and progress through to 6 1/2". What do you calculate?

What do others think of these drawer heights, that is, the lowermost drawer being no deeper that 6 1/2" (outside) and 6" (inside)?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planning the next build

#12

Re: Planning the next build

David Hay

Looks like it will be a nice piece!

How did you come up with the knob layout? I can't quite put my finger on it, but something seems off to me, especially down towards the bottom. I was wondering if the bottom knobs moved inward a bit (lining up the remaining knobs in a straight line, like you have done) if that would help?

Looking forward to the progress photos and writeup!

David

Re: Planning the next build

#13

Clint Searl

Re: Planning the next build

Clint Searl

I don't think it can be done with an even progression in nine steps between those values (2.75-6.5). So, I would go with an even progression, thinking it looks better than blocks of steps, and compromise on the utility. For instance:

MM Inches

88.0 3.45

97.0 3.84

107.0 4.22

117.0 4.61

127.0 5.00

137.0 5.39

147.0 5.78

157.0 6.16

166.0 6.55 or:

77.0 3.03

89.0 3.52

102.0 4.02

114.0 4.51

127.0 5.00

140.0 5.49

152.0 5.98

165.0 6.48

177.0 6.97

Re the concave drawer and divider faces: It would be an interesting design statement if they were shaped in a widening catenary that was of a constant center depth of about 3/4".

I'll cease kibitzing, and look forward to the finished product.

Re: Planning the next build

#14

Re: Planning the next build

William Duffield

Without a micrometer and a spreadsheet, most people can't tell the difference between drawer heights that are linearly proportioned and heights that are proportioned by the golden ratio or the Fibonacci series, which is a first order approximation. One effective proportioning method is to make each drawer hight equal to the height of the one above plus the blade thickness. I'll leave the derivation of the formula as an exercise for the interested student. Starting with the blade thickness and the numbers of drawers and the overall inside case height. Once you've figured out the top drawer height (or the second drawer height in your case), you can lay the whole thing out with two pairs of dividers, one large and one small. Or you can guess at the top drawer height, step off the case, adjust the large dividers depending on how much you were over or under, and repeat. Usually about 3 tries gets you as close as you could do it with a tape measure.

Re: Planning the next build

#15

Re: Planning the next build

William Duffield

I would strongly suggest an ergonomic layout for the lower drawer knobs, and a bit above center, to put the minimum stress on them from repeated opening of the drawers.If you put them too close together, the drawer will have a greater tendency to rack. If yo put them too far apart, too much effort will be wasted pulling the knobs together instead of out.

Re: Planning the next build

#16

Re: Planning the next build

William Duffield

Have you considered serpentine front drawers? Of course, if you put the same curve into all of them, the upper drawers would probably be bow front, and the farther down you went, the more pronounced the concave ends of the serpentine curve become.

Re: Planning the next build

#17

Re: Planning the next build

Sgian Dubh

"What do others think of these drawer heights, that is, the lowermost drawer being no deeper that 6 1/2" (outside) and 6" (inside)?

Something's going to have to give if you incorporate those top and bottom drawer front height restrictions Derek. You might have a wee look at this article of mine which describes a method for calculating incremental progressive drawer front height development. http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/jones/jones1.shtml In your case, you've added those restrictions that seem to me to make it near impossible to devise that.

Switching from imperial to metric you've set the top drawer front height at 70 mm and the bottom height at 165 mm. With the overall cabinet height at 54" or about 1370 mm, I've assumed 1300 mm as the available internal cabinet opening height - could be a bit smaller. Your MDF rod shows 9 drawers meaning that between the bottom of the top drawer and the top of the bottom drawer there are 7 openings to fill. This comes to 28 increments. Take 1300 and subtract from that (165 + 70) = 1065 mm. There are 7 drawers to go in there, each of which must >70 mm. Therefore 70 X 7 = 490 mm. next 1065 - 490 = 575 mm. 575 mm / 28 increments = 20.54 mm per increment. Therefore the second drawer down would be 70 + 20. 54 = 90.54. The third drawer down is 90.54 + 20.54 = 110.54, and so on. The end result is that the second drawer up calculates out at ~213 mm, which is roughly 48 mm taller than your bottom drawer.

Even if you pair the drawers so that the top two are both 70 mm and the bottom two are set at 165 mm tall each, you can't treat the rest of the stack as pairs because there's an uneven number, 5, to work with.

After all that I think where you said "The sizes of the drawers were decided by eyeballing them - no calculations, per se" ended up with a progression that looked pretty good. And if that's the case I ask why try to impose a formulaic solution onto something that doesn't need it? Sticking to aesthetic considerations, I think there are too many distracting horizontal lines. I'd set the horizontal dividers further back in the cabinet and project each drawer front downwards to hide them, if you can do it, although there may be a challenge there in relation to the curves in the drawer front that are being discussed. Slainte.

Re: Planning the next build

#18

Re: Planning the next build

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

A most useful and handsome project! Am looking forward to the dovetail angles.

I agree with Sgian Dubh to use the eyeball method on the drawer sizing. As someone mentioned, the exact vertical placement of the pulls will be a more tedious problem (or would be for me anyway :) ). So they all look centered, given the viewing angle from above.

My one suggestion has to do with the bottom section. I suggest giving more visual weight to the bottom, using more air under the lower apron, a deeper apron, and a horizontal base board or web between the apron and the bottom drawer. This is only a first impression, but suggest you give it a moment's thought. This would of course change the drawer calculations, and maybe number of drawers. In the mockup, it looks to terminate so close to the floor that aesthetically there's not enough foundation. And will Lynndy want to use that bottom drawer? You might check with her as to the elevation she wants on the bottom drawer, and go from there. Maybe some other chest of drawers in the house will suggest an ideal lower drawer elevation.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Planning the next build

#19

Ellis Walentine

Two meager cents

Ellis Walentine

Hi Derek,

Yet another challenging project, eh? I've worked solid makore with no adverse side effects. It's not that heavy and it works well with hand and power tools but it does dull blades pretty quickly.

My thoughts coincide with Wiley's in regard to the lower rail. I think it should be wider, regardless of whether it's elevated further from the floor. I see where you're going with the bottom of the facade curving down almost to the feet on the sides. That works for me.

I do think that the top needs to stick out further and be thicker, perhaps with a wide underside tapered edge to lend the visual benefit of a crown of sorts. Skip the cove molding. As is, the top looks too diminutive and makes the whole piece look like a bit like an optical illusion, an exercise in perspective, a trick of the eye. To me at least.

I'm not fond of pairs of drawer heights, or of visible blades. I'd consider an orderly progression of differing heights, whether computed or eyeballed, and the cleaner look of uninterrupted drawer fronts.

The curvature question is more complicated. If you make all the fronts with the same radius, the sides will have to taper either from top to bottom or bottom to top to accommodate the increased depths at different drawer widths. The alternative would be to keep the sides parallel as you are thinking, and vary the curvature from top to bottom. That would make each front a variable curvature. If you keep it a small enough radius, you could get away with bandsawn fronts, possibly with straight rear faces, which could make your life a whole lot easier. Bandsaw each drawer front to the lower radius and then hand plane the contours of the entire front as a single unit after you fit the drawers to the case.

Side locking drawer locks are common in the contract furniture industry. I've lost most of my contacts there after a twenty-five year absence, but they do exist. Retail suppliers may be further between.

Finally, a possibly interesting design feature you might consider would be a hinged top with a mirror inside. I've designed a similar feature on a dresser I've been waiting to build for a long time. Since this is apparently going to be a jewelry chest, the mirror might be a pleasant surprise for your wife. It might call into question a source of light. It would also mean the top would have to remain clear of other stuff.

Maybe that's more like four cents. I'm sure you'll come up with a great solution.

Ellis

Re: Planning the next build

#20

Re: Two meager cents

Dick Darin

What does your wife think! One small point MY wife and myself are well over 70 years old and opening the bottom drawer should be a consideration, bending way over and pulling can be a bitch. We have mostly emptied the bottom drawers of our old Stickley bedroom suite even though it's well off the floor.

Re: Planning the next build

#21

Thanks all ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... lots of very helpful ideas.

Priorities: get the drawer progression right, and the pull position along with this.

I like the idea of the mirror inside the top. To do this I suspect that I shall need to lower the height of the chest by a couple of inches.

Wither concave or convex? It will be one or the other - flat leaves too hard a surface for the shape. I thought that a gentle inward curve would be quite feminine. I'm not sure ... a gentle outward curve adds a little boldness.

Then there is the decision whether to laminate or build the drawer fronts out of solid wood. Has anyone experience of dovetailing into the ends of laminated boards?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planning the next build

#22

Re: Two meager cents

William Duffield

I haven't worked with makore, so I don't know anything about it beyond what Google image search shows me. Am I correct that it is always as highly figured as the images show? If so, sawing curved drawer fronts from solid stock, as Derek proposes will result in drastic differences in figure from drawer to drawer, depending on how far from quarter sawn or flat sawn each particular piece of stock is.

If this is a problem, I would suggest an alternate strategy: veneering the drawer fronts. If the drawer fronts will have varied curvatures, then building a unique form for each drawer for glue up will take a lot of time. Avoiding that problem would suggest hammer veneering with hot hide glue, yet another skill to be learned.

Re: Planning the next build

#23

Re: Thanks all ....

Bruce McCrory

Then there is the decision whether to laminate or build the drawer fronts out of solid wood. Has anyone experience of dovetailing into the ends of laminated boards?

In veneered, the lamination is usually exposed as part of the half-lap. There is always a "second look" of odd grain at both faces when looking onto the end-grain.

Full laminations remind me of baltic birch plywood. And you still need to deal with compound curves, plus, the integrity of the form.

Re: Planning the next build

#24

Veneered drawers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

I much agree with Sir Wm's recommendation to veneer the fronts. Preferably with quartered material, if you can find it. Sawing a curve into plain-sawn wood will yield really wild swirling figure, and you can't anticipate it very well.

If you veneer, I suggest make the drawer box first, using through dovetails, then glue on approx. 3/16" of veneered front. At least, that's how I've done it.

Wiley

Re: Planning the next build

#25

Not the way I would do it.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Definitely I would use sequential cut veneer. I would saw and fair the inside curve on a piece of poplar. Veneer it. Cut dovetails, half blind, but deep, using untouched outside of the board as the reference surface. Saw outside concave curve and fair it. Veneer with 1/16" thick veneer. Trim and assemble drawer.

Fairing the inside curve will be difficult. The outside is easy with a hand plane using band saw tooth lines as a guide for uniform material removal.

Now, the top and bottom edges become a problem with this approach. One needs a good bond at the edges or they will chip. Traditionally the chipping problem was solved by cock beading. The cock bead also covered the interior wood, what ever it was. In this case one could glue a strip of "show wood" to the top edge of drawer blank.