Re: Two meager cents
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
avoiding the problem would suggest vacuum veneering in my mind.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Two meager cents
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
avoiding the problem would suggest vacuum veneering in my mind.
Re: Two meager cents
William Duffield
For sure, vacuum bagging will work, too. I worry a bit about the carcinogenicity of the urea formaldehyde glue, and about the vacuum pump or the bag springing a leak when I'm not watching, but there are all sorts of things that can go wrong with hammer veneering too.
Re: Planning the next build
Paul in NJ
Hi Derek,
I had some off time waiting for some information so I had a little fun with your design. First off I thought the taper of the sides a little severe for my tastes so I increased the top width to 21” and 22.5’ in the second version. Next I removed the arc from the apron and replaced it with an angular cutout. I thought the graduation of the drawers was too wide so I reduced the number of drawers to 8. My thinking was that you could have a sliding till in the top drawer to double the space. So here is my quick and dirty. The drawers graduate by 1/2'”.
click on the pdf symbol to see the drawing. I don't know how to have it open automatically.
I did a few versions, the middle is the widest at 22.5”. On either side you have 21” wide with one or two knobs. On the versions at both ends I added a drawer detail to add some interest. Below those versions is the drawer front. Can’t really call them concave or convex, how about innie or outie? Anyway, I tried to go with the theme of the angled sides, not sure how successful.
regards,
Paul Dzioba
Re: Planning the next build
Bruce McCrory
Nice. Very nice! More Burj Khalifa.
Following Richard's suggestion, hiding dividers might permit more flexibility in drawer sizing. You can stuff a lot of socks into that bottom drawer.....
Re: More fun.... with curves
Bruce McCrory
I am speechless...

If I wore dentures, I would be pulling them out of the monitor right now. Or, gagging on them....

I hope...
Bruce McCrory
....Derek has a sense of humor....
He has to.... To live with other wood people this long.
Love it!
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Someone needs to make this piece.
OK, this is how I originally planned it ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Paul, I love your drawings! What the last lot have made me recognise is that I should be discussing what I originally wanted to do, and not the compromise I posted earlier.
What I would like to build is a curved outline, not straight, tapering sides. Like this (I used one of your drawings and added a few mods) ...

There should be a rail at the bottom of the lower drawer. I could not draw this in (using Photoshop Elements 12).
Why did I go for straight tapered sides instead? I was thinking about the complexity of dovetailed drawers (which I do not wish to change from at this stage). The issue is that a drawer that runs from carcase side-to-side, the drawer sides will need to be coopered to fit. I just do not know how to dovetail such a drawer.
It is possible to make the drawer with through dovetails, and add a fitted front. What I dislike about this method is that the result leaves a side that is not flush with the front. I would like to build drawers with half blind fronts.
In a parallel-sided carcase - the typical chest - it is a simple matter to fit a drawer front, and then dovetail into a square side. While a little more complicated, a tapering straight side is not too different. But where does one start with a curved side?
I assume that the drawer front must also be fitted first. Drawer sides will then need to be shaped to the curve. And then they need to be dovetailed on this curve. Aaaaaahhhhh!
Now add in a curved drawer front!?? I'm still thinking of a slight curve (now convex - curve to the outside), but it may look better flat. This ups the complexity yet again - not that this is a problem ... I look forward to the challenge. I just need to have a method to follow, and I cannot get my head around this one ... and hence I went straight sides .. shame on me!
Curved cabinet sides are easy enough. I have a plan for that - shape curved frame, with a thin rebated panel that runs flush at the outside.
Sooo .... guys and gals .... how do you do these drawers?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: OK, this is how I originally planned it ...
Sgian Dubh
"Sooo .... guys and gals .... how do you do these drawers?"
That's easy. You don't curve the sides of the drawers. You make up a frame and runner guide system that contains the drawer box, and fits within the inside face of the curved side - a bit fiddly maybe, because every drawer width is different, but do-able. Attach the front with a sliding dovetail to the drawer side if you want to avoid the planted front option, the latter being easier to manufacture, and less prone to showing up errors, or at least any errors in dimensions are more easily hidden. Lose the horizontal dividers by hiding them - the front is cluttered. Your frame and panel idea for the carcass sides doesn't appeal. Too fiddly, visually cluttered, and the thin panel proposed might sound "tinny". I'd go for a laminated side using something like 4 mm ply veneered on both faces, and add a lipping at the front (and back if desired), although the back panel would take away most of the rear lipping.
Lastly, why not just be bold and resolve all the design issues for yourself? It's alright this designing by committee exercise you go through with quite a few of your projects, but at some point you're going to have to take ownership of the whole process, and then accept responsibility for both your design and technical choices or solutions. Slainte.
Re: OK, this is how I originally planned it ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
That's easy. You don't curve the sides of the drawers. You make up a frame and runner guide system that contains the drawer box, and fits within the inside face of the curved side - a bit fiddly maybe, because every drawer width is different, but do-able. Attach the front with a sliding dovetail to the drawer side if you want to avoid the planted front option, the latter being easier to manufacture, and less prone to showing up errors, or at least any errors in dimensions are more easily hidden. Lose the horizontal dividers by hiding them - the front is cluttered. Your frame and panel idea for the carcass sides doesn't appeal. Too fiddly, visually cluttered, and the thin panel proposed might sound "tinny". I'd go for a laminated side using something like 4 mm ply veneered on both faces, and add a lipping at the front (and back if desired), although the back panel would take away most of the rear lipping.
Richard, using guides for the drawers is a method I want to avoid. I've never liked drawers-on-runners.
I am also not keen on boxes-with-added-faces, which is a solution some use in such situations. I think that your method (in your article, link above) of using a sliding dovetail was very clever, however I would prefer more traditional joinery if possible. It does remain an option. Thank you for that.
I agree that horizontal dividers may add to a busier look and I am considering the option without them. It was easier to use the existing drawing with included dividers. My question was not about the aesthetics of the front elevation but about the practicality of fitting the drawer sides.
The frame-and-panel construction I have in mind should not be "tinny". I envisage a frame with a 3/8" - 1/4" thick panel with cross-bracing on the inside (for the drawers to run against). there will be several cross pieces as there are several drawers.
Lastly, why not just be bold and resolve all the design issues for yourself? It's alright this designing by committee exercise you go through with quite a few of your projects, but at some point you're going to have to take ownership of the whole process, and then accept responsibility for both your design and technical choices or solutions. Slainte.
Do you believe I post my proposals because I lack confidence with my own ability to design?
Just look how involved the forum has been. Most for a long while. Isn't it just wonderful to talk about woodworking and design?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: OK, this is how I originally planned it ...
Sgian Dubh
"Richard, using guides for the drawers is a method I want to avoid. I've never liked drawers-on-runners."
Derek, all drawers run on runners. I wasn't suggesting you employ metal drawer slides. I was suggesting you make rectangular openings with traditional wooden runners and kickers. You already have the horizontal front divider, although I'd prefer it hidden. What I'm suggesting is you incorporate the runners and kickers into those dividers. If the dividers are, for instance, a piece of plywood that extends the full depth of the cabinet, you already have the runners and kickers in place. All you need is something to stop the drawer box racking from side to side. At its simplest this would be a stick of wood running front to back, but more elegant would be to scribe something to the carcass side to hide the gap between the drawer box side and the carcass side. This would work with your frame and panel carcass construction, and would work equally well with a laminated side.
"Do you believe I post my proposals because I lack confidence with my own ability to design?
Just look how involved the forum has been. Most for a long while. Isn't it just wonderful to talk about woodworking and design?"
No, I don't think you really lack confidence. Discussing the potential 'doing' can be both entertaining and a useful learning tool, up to a point. But in the end you've got to do the 'doing', and it doesn't get 'done' until the talking (design development) stops and you start dealing with the making, which leads to the end result, the last being (to me anyway) the important bit. It's after the job's 'done' that the evaluation and lessons learnt to carry forward bit is undertaken. Slainte.
Re: OK, this is how I originally planned it ...
John S
My guess would be, that if you drew a straight line from the top corner, to the bottom corner on the side of any draw (except maybe the bottom). The concavity at it's deepest would be less than 1/2 inch. If that is the case, and if you think of the outside of the drawers being like the inside of some barrel / bucket staves. Which are scooped / planed with a concavity so that the inside of the bucket is curved.
This is how I might try to do this (totally making this up, I have never done anything like this):
1) Fit the drawer front, but leave the side straight from top corner to bottom corner (no concavity). The top and bottom of the drawer front would fit in the opening. But the sides of the drawer front would overlap the casing / face frame, along their length but not at the corners.
2) Build your tapered drawers to the drawer front, using lightweight 3/4" or 1" wood for the sides. Build them complete with dovetails, but do not glue them together.
3) Remove the drawer front from the tapered drawer and then fit / cope it to fit the drawer opening with the curve on the sides. Transfer curve to the back of the drawer, coping the curve etc.
4) Re-assemble the drawer and mark the curve on the front and back edge of the side.
5) Using an appropriately sized plane with a cambered blade (or possibly curved sole and blade). Scoop / plane the concavity into the side.
My sentiments, too.
Ellis Walentine
Good one, John. Keep it simple and doable and get the functional objective done. You could even make the cabinet sides out of solid wood and hand plane them to the curvature you want. That's how bombé chests were done, right?
Regarding the drawer runners. I'm an advocate of side-hung drawers. In this case you'd let hardwood runners into your side panels (or frame-and-panels) and groove out the drawer sides to slide on the runners. No fussy traditional runner/guide assemblies and no blades to take up space and clutter up the appearance. Plus, if you eliminate eight 1" blades, you could end up with probably about 10% more storage space. Of course, dust panels aren't an option, but that shouldn't be too big a problem.
I still like the graduated drawer height progression.
Ellis
PS remind me to discuss how I install side-hang runners sometime.
Question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Attaching the framing to the sides seems the design challenge to me. The top of this case could be easily dovetailed, but what holds the bottom together and how is it attached? Or, in the case of side hung drawers how are the runners fitted and attached to ensure the running surface is parallel to the floor?
Re: Question
William Duffield
What holds the bottom together and how is it attached?
You could use mortises in the carcass sides with through wedged tenons in the case bottom and veneer the sides after assembly. Of course that might require developing the skills to use hot hide glue and hammer veneering, since a vacuum bag would be huge, and without extreme internal bracing, would probably crush the carcass. Summer is coming in Perth, so setting up of the glue would be less of a problem for Derek.
don't build dust catchers
ian in Sydney
Hi Derek
while I appreciate that you don't like planted fronts, a drawer with a concave curved front will be a dust catcher at the internal corners.
You need to think about what will go in the drawers, and how the contents will snag or catch on the drawer front and the internal corners.
I encourage you to investigate a contemporary bombe look -- gently curved sides enclosing rectangular drawer boxes, convex curved drawer fronts. there's no reason the fronts couldn't curve in two dimensions.
just my 2 cents worth
Re: OK, he's not off his rocker...
Bruce McCrory
.. You had me worried, guy. 
Being polite can really be a pain .... and, waste of energy.
Yup, who's at third; who at first in this observation?
Now, let's get that stringing back onto the drawers....
Re: don't build dust catchers
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
Derek,
While you're not trying to reproduce a bombe style chest, the principles for laying out and cutting the dovetails should be very similar. Before you decide you can't manage to do that, you should at least research the literature on the subject, and study it to see how much is pertinent to your problem.
If you can do the Wegner chair joint by hand, you should be able to master a doubly curved and sloped drawer front.
Start by Googling "bombe dovetail layout". Note that there is more than one way to do the drawer joinery. Some methods simplify the inside shapes of the drawers, in the process losing some space and a lot of the elegance, but they look the same on the outside when the drawers are shut. I'm sure there are articles in FWW, and videos by Tommy Mac and others. Worse comes to worst, you could try taking a class in the process from one of the schools in New England.
The method I use to divide is simple enough to do
Keith Newton
in my head. Whatever the height for the drawers is, lets say 45", and there will be 9 drawers. The middle or 5th drawer will be 5", or the same as if all were even height. Going up, I might reduce 1/2", so I add that 1/2" to the one under. The next one up would be 1" less, or 4", so the second one below the middle would get that inch, and be 6", and so forth. The top would end up being 2" less, or 3" high, and the bottom would be 2" over the average, or 7".
Re: don't build dust catchers
TomD
It is just a dovetail, I think on could teach oneself how to do it faster than the time it takes to clear security on a trip to New England. Major advantage of classes is getting oneself in the mood, which never seems to be a problem for Derek.
A methodology for the drawers
Paul in NJ
Hi Derek,
Curved drawer sides are not too hard once you have a methodology. Here is what worked for me when I built a bombe’ chest some time ago. First you make the case. Next you scribe and fit the drawer fronts and backs to the case. Now mark a baseline for your dovetails that is tangent to the curve. See the crude pdf drawing I attached. The dashed blue line is the dovetailed baseline. Use your bevel gauge to pick this angle and transfer it to your drawers sides. The drawer sides go from a right angle rectangle in section to a parallelogram. Now there is no debate which comes first, layout and cut the dovetail pins on the fronts and backs. Scribe the dovetails from the front and back to the sides and then cut the tails. Assemble the drawer and you can scribe the area you need to remove. Disassemble and plane the sides with a scrub or hollow plane. The hardest part of all this is the marking and scribing. In the drawing I exaggerated the curve so in reality you will not have a lot material to remove. If you decide to curve the front of the cabinet this will add another variable to the marking but it is not a show stopper.
This is a bit of extra work but as amateurs we can do what we want! I will say matching the drawers to the sides is very elegant and impresses all who open a drawer.
Re: A methodology for the drawers
Doug Trembath
Absolutely +1!!! Whenever I see a tapered design with drawers, if the curves match, it's a winner. if not, not so much...
If you are going to take the time to build it, even if no one but you will see it, do it right. If not, you will agonize over it, every time you think about it, even if you never look at it again...
Just my opinion, and experience, folks...
Doug Trembath
question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
How are the drawer dividers and runners fitted and attached to the sides?
Re: question
Paul in NJ
Hi Bill,
If you are talking about the bombe' chest, the dividers are scribed and dovetailed to the case sides. The runners are morticed into the dividers and a verticle support in the back, glue only in the front and float in the back.

I built this from an article by Lance Patterson (North Bennet Street school), FWW #45 1984. The construction in the article was not all period corrrect but built a solid and pleasing design.
regards,
Paul Dzioba