New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

WIA LV reveals new planes

Posts

WIA LV reveals new planes

#1

WIA LV reveals new planes

Matt Robinette

The new planes were revealed yesterday at noon here at WIA. The planes are very interesting with interchangeable pitch frogs, different ergonomic handles or totes as one prefers and variable sized front knobs. The planes were substantial in weight with the mass low and somewhat forward on the plane. Before I had a problem deciding bevel up or down now it is which frog,tote and knob feels best,looks best. Good decisions to have non the less.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#3

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

TomD

You don't, but that is the nature of custom, the answer to can I have a 43.5 deg bed is yes. Must be slightly frustrating to LV to essentially be making the same quality of merchandise as say Hotley, but not being able to get the respect for it. There used to be a time when the consumer product was delivered in a condition where it was unusable. But everyone machines their parts today, the only difference is that the Chinese, and LV use bigger and better machines than the boutique makers. LV does more research and is probably closer to the market than pretty much anyone. Some of the custom makers don't really offer customs, they offer limited runs, you may not be able to get it your way.

This seems to be a smart move. Theoretically, variety and complexity are not the problem for CNC that they were for earlier forms of manufacturing. Still probably a nightmare for inventory. That is why you see relatively small players in something like the 1911 market offer a huge variety of distinctly different models, as Sig does. You can buy a brand new military grade 1911 for under 300 bucks, so why would you pay 2K for a pistol that isn't hand fit. Welcome to whatever is happening today...

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#4

Ellis Walentine

Inventory concerns

Ellis Walentine

I see the modular planes as a good solution to inventory problems. Instead of stocking planes at the module level (completed, assembled planes), LV gets to just stock the parts and pieces. They probably assemble the most popular combinations for stock, but they don't have to commit the parts to any other models until the order hits.

Ellis

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#5

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

You forgot to mention the adjustable mouth. If you're fighting tearout, closing up the mouth can be a valuable wepon in your arsenal. You don't need to remove the blade and loosen the frog to adjust it. Even if you have a Bedrock plane and don't need to disassemble your Stanley to move the frog, you don't even need a special screwdriver (or any tool at all) to move the frog. Like all Veritas mouth adjusters, it has a stop screw to prevent an accidental collision between the mouth and iron. The frog doesn't need to be adjusted (unless you want to change it's angle by swapping it out).

Another potential advantage is that if you are having trouble planing a difficult board, you can just swap frogs or chipbreakers or both, but then switch back to a lower angle frog or a chipbreaker with a lower angle bevel for your much more often used well behaved wood, and make the plane proportionally easier to push. If you need two planes with the same width blade, you can buy them with two different frogs, and swap out the frogs depending on the gnarlyness of the stock and the operation you need to perform.

Another advantage that might not be noticed in their description is the slow (precision) Norris depth adjuster. If you use the Veritas low angle adjustable mouth block plane, you might, like me, think that its adjuster is a bit too fast. A slower adjuster (think finer screw thread, but a Norris adjuster's differential threads are really more complicated than that) makes even more difference with a high angle frog, because the same turn of the knob gives larger change to the blade depth. If you want an even slower adjuster, a really, really slow one is available, but Rob's engineers think it's so slow that no one would really need it.

For those of us who have found the original Veritas totes too uncomfortable to use on our low benches or in our big paws, the new, fatter, lower angle totes might be the tipping point. I also like the low knob option, another tradition that Stanley foolishly abandoned in 1919 (type 12 and later). If you disagree with me on either of these points, it's not important, because you can choose from three differently shaped knobs and six differently shaped and sized totes.

If I'm having trouble jointing an edge square, I already have a fence that fits all of them, and you may have one too. L-V intentionally made them so I can attach my fence from their skew rabbet plane, even the fence from the left handed model. (OK, that's not so amazing, since the same fence attaches to either rabbet plane, and to either side of the new bench planes.)

I'm thinking I could probably build and carve a custom "sausage" for use on the shooting board that would take advantage of these tapped fence mounting holes. We'll see if I think I need one after I try shooting with it. Both its iron and the chip breaker are well rounded on top, so they won't dig into your palm if you prefer to push the plane from behind the frog when you are using it on its side. Vic Tesolin's video shows that he uses a different grip, in front of the frog.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#6

Re: Inventory concerns

TomD

Yeah, certainly easier than stocking 1000 different planes, not easier than when I started in the 70s and you could have any plane you wanted so long as it was the same one they sold. :)

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#7

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

Curt Putnam

It's not that you need 1/2 degree control over the frog - the amazing thing is that they can offer it so they do. On-demand manufacturing with modern CNC macninery combined with state-of -the-art inventory control and order entry systems is where the Western world needs to be. LV is positioning itself to be on top of the heap.

It's not that we need all the knobs, totes and frogs - when do we actually NEED anything? Now you can have whatever you want, at a very reasonable price, almost immediately. What's not to like? It's an industry first.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#8

Thoughts (long)

Doug Trembath

I guess, from the responses I have seen on a multitude of different forums, that I'm in the solid minority, but like you I can't for the life of me imagine how the small differences in usage would manifest themselves, absent enough scientific testing equipment to fill a room, duly calibrated and double checked for accuracy. Has no one else noticed that this may be a bit extreme when it comes to marketing? Has the tool minutiae grown to the extent that we have created a new religion, in which established "experts" pontificate upon the ultimate edge geometry, level of sharpness, and angle of attack? Guys, they are tools to precisely remove wood, right?

I believe it was our own TOMD who once said, (and I am paraphrasing here, and hope I haven't missed on the attribution), "Don't make it a religion" and that statement resonated with me...

Tool manufacturers will certainly attempt to create a need for additional tools, and some who believe it is the tool that provides the desired "perfect" result, who will purchase them. Is that wrong? Probably not.

Then again, while I am using a plane that is around a hundred years old, which has been adequately fettled and sharpened, to perfect a finished surface in preparation for assembly of a nice new piece of furniture, and observing the result with a refined, informed perspective, my mind does tend to question the need for "major improvements and customization ability". I, personally, find that it can be just a bit disturbing that the more recent woodworkers, absent enough experience to develop tool familiarity and wisdom, may be led quite far afield as to what is truly necessary, and even useful.

Obviously the result is good for the tool manufacturers, less so for the individuals spending the money, trying the tools, and finding that it actually wasn't the panacea that was promised, and eventually expected.

The biggest issue, I think, is that the new owner feels it isn't a failing of the tool, but of their usage, when in fact the tool is probably working just fine. The problem is not with the tool, but with the unreasonable expectation...

Wanna know how I know this? I was there, once, as well, hence the quantity of tools in my arsenal which see less and less usage as time goes by. A number of others, many looked upon here as "experts", have traveled this road, come back to the basics, and divested themselves of many new and improved tools just like these in the classifieds. I know that I can certainly find more rewarding things to spend my tool budget on, like replacing all of my Baileys with flat-sided Bedrocks, just cuz I wanna... Are they necessary? Nope, they just look way cooler, and have 30% more horsepower...(grin)

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#9

craigd

Re: Thoughts (long)

craigd

cutting angle ... I can't for the life of me imagine how the small differences in usage would manifest themselves, ...

I'm betting that [Lee Valley's] rational was more along the lines of "we have/can do on demand manufacturing so why not?". Japanese planes are the only planes that don't seem to have endless debates about the best bed angle, this decision voids those debates.

These planes aren't for me but man, I'd have loved to this choice a long time ago - get a #4 & #7, two frogs at different angles and boom, I'd be set for high angle, low angle, mouth opening, single iron, chip breaker, good steel. You can even use them bevel up, so you have a scraper plane. You could test out almost every idea of the moment with no additional investment.

Rob Lee has posted some of their rational about these planes on various forums, he'll probably post here too. I'm amazed at what what they have managed to provide us and hope they sell zillions.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#10

Re: Thoughts (long)

TomD

I think, and I have no problem with this, that LV has to a certain extent being fighting a rear guard action. As I say, it is perfectly plausible that nobody knows more about planes than they do, given where they stand and all that, or can better manufacture them, but what do you do about that, how is that a product. The materials war was part of that, They had O1, which pretty much takes the high ground on carbon steel, and they developed their own super better at everything steel. Now they can (among many other things), give you whatever bedding angle you want to an absurd degree of granularity (absurd to quibble it should be more granular, not absurd to offer it). I think they are just dealing with objections, which is normally what a salesman used to do in the old days, now "they" just give you what you want, and leave it at that. Should work for another six months.

On the Japanese planes, I do have a list of a wide range of bedding angles for specific woods. I don't know that the suggestion there is that one needs 20 planes angle wise, as much as their manufacturing was pretty specialized for hundreds of years, and guys working in a tiny space would make the ancestral object, that if a boxwood comb, might as well have the right angle plane for the purpose. And of course the stuff suggested above applies also. Give them what they want. I find both high and low angles work really well for the same thing, which presumably means medium angles work well also.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#11

Thoughts (short)......

roger lance

When I look at ww forums, I'm struck by the ratio of actual work verses other thread topics. People showing something they've made are in the minority.....a small minority. So, IMHO, the real core interest of most people on most ww forums is not to make things but to own things (tools).....and to discuss various characteristics of these items pro and con.

If that observation is somewhat accurate, LV has hit the bull's-eye. They certainly are meriting their logo....."Veritas....innovation in tools".

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#12

I think you missed the point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Accept that there is a market for new hand tools. There is a growing body of new-to-hand-tool woodworkers. If you are Woodcraft you take a Stanley plane to China and get manufacturers to bid on reproducing it. No risk and no opportunity for improvement with this route. People that believe that 100 year old products made with 100 year old technology can't be improved will be satisfied with this business strategy and the products it produces.

Alternatively, if a company, in this case Lee Valley, has a staff of creative design and manufacturing engineers and state of the art manufacturing capability, this company has the option of creating a new design that does the same job as the Stanley plane, or potentially an ever better job, without reproducing the Stanley.

After my tour Lee valley design and manufacturing I have no doubt the conversation went as follows.

Mr. Lee to design and manufacturing staff, "Hand planes are the largest part of the growing hand tool market and we want more market share. Can you come up with something that does the job of the Stanley plane that will work better and keep the manufacturing cost to where we can make it at Veritas Tool here in Ottawa?

If you look at all the hand tools they have recreated you see this philosophy in them, for example the vastly improved shoulder plane, router plane, much cheaper and better shooting plane, etc. Where possible they all have better ergonomics, better function and lower manufacturing cost.

I doubt the main target market for these tools are people that already have a traditional Stanley version, although the vastly improved ergonomics of the shoulder plane has tempted me to abandon the Stanley design and the ergonomics of the spoke shave did lead to abandoning the Stanley version.

In summary, the line of Veritas hand tools provides woodworkers with updated versions tools that perform hand tool tasks. These tools were not designed to be different. They were designed to be better and economically practical to make in Ottawa.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#13

It will be interesting 100 years from now...

Ron in Sterling, CT

when someone attempts to do "type study" on the new Verital planes.

Ron

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#14

Re: It will be interesting 100 years from now...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

A hundred years from now all the documentation will still be available to anybody who is still interested. Researching documenation on tools made a hundred years ago was and is a slow, painstaking, highly esoteric process, and much of the documenation has been lost, or was never created in the first place.

Lie-Nielsen hs been making a choice of (three) frogs for their bench planes for a few years now. If Veritas can design a manufacturing process that allows them to manufacture frogs in a wider range of angles by changing one parameter in a CNC mill, why shouldn't they? Even if almost no one would want all of them, some may want more than one. Kees would probably have been able to use one of each, and I suspecct they might have reduced his expenses on his latest study. (Ref. his recent post.)

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#15

LV missed a bet

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're offering it as "design your own plane," but they could also offer a comprehensive kit of all possible frog, body, tote, knob, etc. combinations. Say, $5,000* for everything, including a custom-made screwdriver for switching frogs and totes, and a fitted cart, with a padded assembly surface on the top for switching all the parts around, and a chart printed on a hard backing that slides up from the back of the cart, guiding you in applications for the different frogs/iron compositions/etc.

Maybe that's what the cart was, under the cloth; a teaser for the Ultimate Bench Plane Kit.

---------------

*Number picked out of the air; it might well be more expensive to make all combinations.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#16

Documentation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sir William, your statement assumes that the documentation now available on the Internet will be transferred to the next technologies. How many of the musical performances on Edison's wax cylinders can you buy on CD?

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#17

Re: Documentation

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Yes, I agree it is a really big assumption. IMHO, there is a better chance that all of modern industrial civilization will go to he** in a hand basket between now and then. OTOH, preservation of information has always been important, and modern technologies are making it more practical and less expensive all the time. It would be a lot more difficult to destroy all the servers on the internet than to burn down the Library in Alexandria.

CDs are rapidly becoming obsolete, but anything currently recorded on them can now be copied to a DVD, or a flashcard,, or whatever smaller, faster and cheaper medium is invented in the future. That's due to standardization of digital data formats, at a higher level than the physical media.

While "Come here, Watson. I need you." may have been lost forever, there is still hope for the audio recordings Edison made.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cylinder_Preservation_and_Digitization_Project

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#18

Re: LV missed a bet

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Lie-Nielsen has already done the "Custom screwdriver," with curly maple handles, no less. For this kit, it would have to be a custom allen wrench, and I suspect L-V uses metric.

"All combinations" is still not enough. You'll need multiple chip breakers in each width, to provide a selection of angles on the leading edge.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#19

Re: It will be interesting 100 years from now...

TomD

Though, i hear stuff all the time about how we got where we are that I think is quite false. In the future, they will hire someone like Nick Offerman, to narrate and the cheapest journalism student they can find to do a summary on the Discovery channel and it will be 100% false.

Just as if this generation characterized the motivations and behaviour of people in 1914. Not a clue.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#20

Re: +1

TomD

I agree 95% with that, my only disagreement is that the idea is probably to survive at all, not grow market share, though I greatly prefer your explanation. If they just make good stuff, they are doomed, they don't do anything, by doing that, that isn't China capable. They have to better understand us, and bring out boutique stuff.

The other point of separation is I don't really believe they have improved much. At first they seemed to be doing the Loblaws thing of going noname, spending money to turn out ugly stuff like expensive sensible shoes, but it turned out they had too many good ideas so they moved into ergo, etc... I really don't think there are points in any of that stuff. If I could only use my wooden planes, it wouldn't change a thing in my shop, except possibly block planes, though sidestepping those would be ok. I don't think the gold is in making better planes but in being perceived as making the better planes. The most linear way of getting there is to just make actual improvements. LV is very ethical so that is how they would want to get there.

Boaters desperately needed, and still need more enviro motors. Polluting for pleasure established that 2 stroke created as much pollution as all cars, due to inefficiency. Climbers need better gear, modern climbing is in an unrecognisable place compared to 100 years ago. Hunting doesn't really need for everyone to use ARs, though that is the direction it seems to be going, and we don't need better planes, it can't hurt anything, well actually it can, but still... There are probably people with horrible arthritis that need better planes, but they probably aren't the ones we are getting.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#21

Re: LV missed a bit

John S

Lee Valley did miss. Along with buying a second blade, you should be able to buy a second cap iron and blade carrier (with screws). Then you could just swap in the hole unit already set up, when you change blades.

Re: WIA LV reveals new planes

#22

Re: LV missed a bit

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Remember, this is the initial introduction of of both new, extremely flexible hardware, and complicated softwre to support it. I would be very surprised if they had managed to "cover all the bases" on their first attempt. I think they've done a really good job of addressing the most probable combinations. That they did not address variability in the chip breaker geometry is not surprising in light of the widespread denial of, or at least attempt to ignore, its utility, by the user community and the manufacturers. If you can't see the almost fanatical denial of the results of the rigorous, scientifically controlled tests of Kato-Kawai and Kees Van Der Heiden, et. al., and the years of experience of professionals like Warren and many others, you shold go read some of the other fora for discussions of these planes. For example, over on WoodNet there are some pundits who are dismissing all the really important innovations and claiming that the most important features are the capability to remove the chip breaker entirely and even turn the blade over (bevel up). Personally, I didn't even look for that capability, so I don't know if it is feasible, but I don't really care. Lee-Valley's engineers did their own tests of chip breaker geometry, but they didn't discuss their results except in very general terms with me. I can only speculate on the reasons: It could be that their results were very difficult to explain clearly, or they may have been inconclusive, or they my be concerned about their adverse effects on and potential radicalization of the low-angle bevel-up factions. While I strongly doubt my third option, I won't yet totally rule it out. After all, everyone knows that low angle bevel up planes do give completely acceptable results in most cases. I suggested to the head of their "skunkworks" that he might find tests with some curly purpleheart to be enlightening. I didn't suggest a test with wenge, nor did I suggest testing with a late Triassic log from the Petrified Forest, either. Neither one would have been a fair test.