Re: Surprises from Ian Kirby's Dovetail book
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
On suggestion of C. Stanford on another forum, I downloaded Ian Kirby's book on dovetails from the Kindle store. I read the first 4 chapters last night (which takes me through the explanation of the through dovetail).
There were a couple of surprises that I wanted to ask about:
1. He talks about splitting the knife line on the end grain of the pin board. Everything else I read talks about leaving the line. What am I missing?
2. He suggests using a hammer without padding block to close the joint. Need reassurance before I start waking on bare wood with a hammer.
Hi Tony
Mmm ... Charlie likes that book. I have a copy and have never been enamoured with it. I have no doubt that many on this forum could do better.
To repeat what I said before, marking out clearly is the key to accurate sawing and the best fit. If you cannot see the lines, then you cannot cut to the line.
Assuming you are sawing tails fits (I do), then you can mark out with a pen or pencil. I would recommend that you make the top lines with a knife as well, and use these to guide the saw. The most important saw cut is this one and it MUST BE PERFECTLY SQUARE to the board.
Once you have removed the tail waste, all subsequent marking MUST BE WITH A KNIFE. Throw away the pencil at this stage. The pencil line is too wide. A knifed line is really thin.
Now here is the thing: You plan to saw INSIDE the waste side of the line. The more you saw inside that line, the more the pin will be too small for the tail (tight). And the more you saw outside the line, the more the pin will be too large for the tail (loose). If you can saw right up against a line scribed with a knife, then you should have a perfect, first-time fit. (OK, this is to aim for. In reality you just want to get as close as possible, and then, as Bill suggested, pare to the line with a chisel).
Here are some pictures (and now you will see why using blue tape can be so helpful). Note that these are half blind dovetails, not through dovetails ..
Mark on top of the blue tape ..

Then peel the waste sections away ...

Saw as close to the line as you can ...

This is what I mean ...

Here are the cleaned out sockets ...

If lucky, you get a perfect fit ...

I emphasise that this is to aim for, and that it takes time to achieve. The tape makes it easier on the eyes only - you still need to learn to use your saw. I've been at this a few decades.
Regards from Perth
Derek