New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Wish me luck - first dovetails!

Posts

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#26

Here's a suggestion

Hank Knight

After all your practice and you are ready to tackle the floor board for your chest, start with the board long by several inches. Make your cuts on one end. If you are satisfied with them, cut the board to length and make your cuts on the other end. If you screw up the first set, you'll have enough length to simply cut them off and start over. By the time you finish one end, you'll feel more confident and the other end will be easier. Leaving the board long at the beginning gives you several shots at getting the first set of cuts right and reduces the chances of ruining your money board.

Good luck.

Hank

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#27

I'm a bit surprised...

John in NM

Even if the demonstrator were correct, that is terrible salesmanship! :D

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#28

One thing about dovetails...

John in NM

You'll get tons of conflicting advice and opinions :D

You can strive to make them perfect first time out, or you can make a functional joint. Which one you shoot for depends on whether you want the function or the admiration of your peers.

Honestly, I'm more in the get it done and move on camp. Getting a functional joint is super easy, you almost can't get it wrong. All the angst on the internet and in how to books comes from trying to make them "perfect", which is to me not the goal.

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#29

Thanks for all the help

Tony Wilkins

As has been said = the only thing to it is to do it. Don't think there is anymore book/theoretical that I need at this point. I'll let y'all know how it goes :)

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#30

Re: Agree entirely

TomD

Why would that be hard? 3/8 vs. 3/4 vs. 1.5 as an example. I can't imagine goofing it either way. Not really the right mindset, why set up a perception of failure when the next cut could be the narrow on, in some other part of the piece.

One has to consider whether the saw was designed to cut whatever width, though that is an easy choice to get right. Most actual dovetail saws, are not set up for 1.5, but then that is kinda on the crude side.

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#31

Re: bad idea for beginners

TomD

I hope to never fit them. I just saw to the line and then put them together. I don't think beginers should really try anything else either. Fitting is a good skill to have, but a bad habit if it isn't required. Of course if you purposely miss the line, you need the line to see where to pare to. That reminds me of when I took up golf, and spent as much time picking my ball retriever as my clubs.

There are many aspects of wood working or metal working, where fitting is best practices, dovetails are not one of them. I have never heard of someone inletting a lock in a shotgun without fitting. Many people manage dovetails without, seems obvious to me.

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#32

Re: Surprises from Ian Kirby's Dovetail book

TomD

I use a pencil for all of my layout on most dovetails. But I take a blunt pencil and sand it slightly so I get a parabolic sharp edge. This lays in a line that will work very accurately in many materials. I also use knives for very hard woods (maple and more). Just how I started. I know a lot of your woods are very hard Derek. Immaculate work by the way.

Moving on. I think the main difficulty with dovetails is knowing where to cut. It really isn't anywhere, you just have to get the feel for it. It doesn't have to take long, but if one never takes the time make some cuts that might go astray, one never gets the feel of it.

I find my layout is getting sloppier all the time. I take a tape, I strike a mark, I note where it was, I make a cut, it may not be near the mark. I goes faster than getting the marks perfect, and the cuts land in the right place. It keeps things interesting. Of course that won't work with dovetails as I could never memorize all the marks, but it is a point that trying to split lines or make perfect lines is one way to do stuff, and another is to use the eyes. If one doesn't develop their ability one remains at a certain level. Some of this may come from shooting where very accurate stuff happens from working with the eyes, and trusting in some of their natural functions like what they do with light, and how they center things, and so on.

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#33

Re: The prevalent view

TomD

This forum is often the same people, on diverse subjects. So I feel somewhat justified in comparing the view on dovetails to the recent view on jointing boards. Of course, the people advocating various things, may not be the same, and therefore any conclusions might not be meaningful.

But, it does seem as though with dovetails, we have a lot of talk of square cuts, adjusting stuff, micro marking things, and relying on certain crutches. . With edge joints the talk was about how curved blades run who knows where, with a little practice, would lead to magical results, who needs square edges, put the clamps to the work, and let the glue fill in the hollows. More like Tage Frid on dovetails. Just saying.

Re: Wish me luck - first dovetails!

#34

I've gotta say, though

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't think I'd like to be the one telling Jeff Headley he was doing it wrong. :D