New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

Posts

Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#1

Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have seen many tool boxes displayed here and there since Christopher Schwarz began popularising them. I see the point of their use for travelling carpenters and cabinetmakers. I understand if you simply lack the storage space. However I am not convinced of their purpose for the average woodworker with space in a dedicated workshop. Chris makes an argument for his tool box, but it is just not convincing to me. I just like to find my tools without having to rummage for them.

Perhaps the biggest issue I have with tool boxes are the tool trays. It is that the tools that are left loose to slide around and bang into one another. Marking knives, screwdrivers, rules, a compass, scribes .... the list is endless .... all of these with sharp blades or clean edges just waiting to be dinged. Not to forget cutting or stabbing oneself as you reach in.

I prefer a cabinet with shelves or hang it on the wall. Out of harms way.

So why the tool cabinets in your shop? Is this just a senseless fashion?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#2

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

Edward in Vancouver

I built myself an anarchist's tool chest about two years ago and I love it. On the top till, I split the height and built in 4 shallow drawers that I keep my dividers and other small stuff in, larger tools go in the other two tills, and every screwdriver, chisel, saw, plane, and marking guage has a safe and comfortable "home".

Why?

Good question.

I work out of a two car family garage, with aprox 2/3 of the space given to storage of old restaurant equipment and packaging materials. This leaves me with a strip of about 12' by 20' with a window and a door on one of the "long walls", my cheap-o lathe and associated tools takes up one short wall, so I don't have much--actually very little wall space. I do have pegboard mounted on the other short wall and have odd-job tools mounted on that: Pipe wrenches, hammers, wrenches, screwdrivers and very beat up chisels and saws. This is important because other family members need these tools and I am only too happy to provide them with the lousy tools. I once made the mistake of leaving my "good" panel saw on the bench, only to find it covered in tree sap and rusting lightly a day later, chisels do double duty as paint can openers. Combination squares are mistaken for Smith & Wesson 45 caliber pistols and used accordingly, and....well you get the picture.

The chest is locked up, the tools are safe, and I'm a happy camper.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#3

Da** kids!!

Bruce McCrory

Hah! That's how I got my start!

One of the last things my dad said to me was "Where is the screw driver?" I also inherited his affinity for Great Depression ingenuity. Or, fix it with what you can find. Sometimes, we even dug up what we lost, a few months later.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#4

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

Patrick Gibbons

There is a misconception about tool chests that needs to be put to rest. While they are portable if necessary, they are not meant to be moved on a regular basis. If one considers the use of chests as a major piece of furniture from medieval times on, it is easy to see how this was used in the shop as well as the home. Indeed, Hayward shows a stand for the tool chest to elevate it and make it easier on the back. The chest is permanently located close to the bench so tools are stored within reach. There are no tools rolling around because the chest is not moved.

I find it hard to understand why someone would want a tool cabinet located at some distance from the bench and requiring a walk to it each time a tool is needed when a chest is positioned at the bench and puts the tool at arm's length. One would quickly know where all tools are in the chest from use.

A chest provides economy of space. Does anyone actually have too much space in their shop that needs to be filled? A chest is highly protective of its contents.

When was the last time you moved your cedar chest or blanket chest in your home? I would suspect it was when you moved into your house and that all your other furniture got moved as well. I would also bet you secured the contents so there was no rolling around.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#5

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

William Duffield

As I see it, a tool chest only works well if you have been trained to use it, and you use a very specific set of tools to do a specialized type of woodworking. For people like you (or me) who is more interested in building something completely different every time and trying out new tools with every project, it is much more difficult to develop the discipline to make a tool chest efficient. The tool chest can save you time,because you never have to stop and put tools away when the bench top fills up with them. Also, tool chests were usually used by journeymen, in shops with several people working, where it is of critical importance to protect your tools from borrowers. If you are the only one using the shop, then you can find the tool when you need it. If you have friends and family that doesn't believe in tool ownership or tool maintenance, and that leaves them out under the cherry tree, then you need to keep them under lock and key.

There is a technological answer to the problem of tools rolling around in your tills, even if you are constantly modifying your tool set. It's called Kaizen foam, from FastCap. It's inexpensive, and very easy to achieve the functional advantages of French Fit tills.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#6

My handtool space is 6'x9'

Chuck Nickerosn

and only bounded by walls on two sides. So I'm short wall space and when I can work in the driveway it's nice to be able to roll my tool chests out to the work.

As for tools bumping into each other, I fastened tool dividers onto 1/8 luan ply and dropped those into the drawers. I have not yet regretted that deviation from the ATC Kool-Aid.

(I got to take the ATC class from Chris last August. What a great learning experience for me.)

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#7

I prefer shelves...

John in NM

Simple, too easy, and everything is at hand and easily findable.

I also have an old tool chest I bought at a second hand tool store. I will eventually get rid of it, once I have adequate storage for the "used once a year" tools that live in it. That chest was a good buy though, for $50 it cured me of ever wanting to build my own! :D

I would do a wall cabinet if I didn't have a better plan already - drawers in the work bench base. One day before I die that darn bench might actually be finished :D

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#8

I considered building one...

Christopher Fitch Memphis

but I decided against it. I like my wall cabinet and a tool chest would take up more floor space that I don't have. My shop is 13'x19' and floorspace is at a premium while wall space is relatively plentiful for me. A tool chest is a waste for me....but that's for my situation. Others probably have different needs.

Also, the "it's too far to walk to a tool cabinet vs a tool chest" does not seem to add up for me. Of course it just might be that my situation is different than others.

I've attached an image of my tool cabinet.


img

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

Jack Guzman from Maine

The way I see it,everyone has a different way of doing things. I just finished doing some plumbing repairs in the basement of a friend. Her grandfather was a woodworker. His tools are all in chests and boxes .All he had was a bench in the basement. No actual workshop space so his tools had to be in chests.

I have to have all my tools where I can see them. When I put something in a box I forget about it and work around it. So I don't use cabinets or chests unless I'm putting tools in storage.---Jack

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#11

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

BrianMonumentCO

A couple of points;

1. the design presented in ATC is not a CS original as it bears a striking resemblance to the chest presented in "The Handyman's Book" by Paul N Hasluck page 258. It has 3 trays, and a same saw rack.

2. CS is not popularizing the tool chest as such he is repopularizing it. I have seen many pix of old tool chests with trays vs drawer tills.

3. in one of CS's vids he is seen using his chest, removing a roll of chisels, some planes and the arranging the trays in the chest so they give easy access to all 3.

4. in the ATC CS is putting forth an axiom that a select smaller set of carefully chosen tools is better than lots of loosely chosen tools.

5. while it is neat to have a cabinet with drawers that have been customized to your exact tools, it is far easier to make a chest with several trays.

6. combined with the above factors, a book about a tool chest and a set of "build your own ATC chest" courses with the author and sometimes other celebs of the trade make it easy to choose the ATC type chest.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#12

Adam of Oakland

cuidado! hornets!

Adam of Oakland

yaknow, i read your post and thought to myself how every hornets' nest i see stimulates that thought of "what if i threw a big rock at it?" I mean that in a jesting manner, friend, honest!

Derek, i hear ya. for one thing, I like having an enclosure for my tools that perhaps a wall cabinet could also provide. I might go that way. I was heavily influenced by Christopher Schwarz's book; a fair bit of it in a positive manner. In fairness, i needed something to house my tools outside of junky IKEA shelves where you could watch the rust accumulate. I hurried through a Japanese style encasement, riding on a caster-enabled task table, such that I could have any context specific tools parked on the deck, out of the box, but off the bench.

The loose tools thing doesn't bother me much with edge tools as I know I can sharpen them if need be, and I honestly don't see much trouble with them in my chest as it is largely stationary. it's my precious measuring tools that scare me. I really dislike having my starrets in a tool tray and I try to place them nicely each time but I think a French fitting design might be appropriate for the stuff that needs to be "SAFE".

for me it's an evolution and i'm very glad i didn't spend more than the 90 minutes it took to make my "toolchest". As I slowly develop, I realize what i might like for my workflow is a hanging cabinet near my bench, with an enclosure to stave off dust. for my workflow, having a roller table near my bench is absolutely essential. I've spent a lot of time in hospitals and to me, it's not much different in that they need to have a modular cart where stuff is placed, and can be rolled around.





more details here if you're curious:

http://19711007.blogspot.com/2011/11/small-box-for-ralph-and-look-inside-my.html

PS: hope your chair progress proceeds apace.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#13

Re: cuidado! hornets!

BrianMonumentCO

I have been interested in the Japanese style cases. I have been waiting for the article that was pix'd on the cover of the December 2013 woodcraft catalog. Too me this pattern looks more reasonable than the massive boxes like ATC.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#14

Re: Beyond the Kaizen Foam

William Duffield

I've been slowly but systematically transitioning a lot of my sets of specialty hand tools, especially those that I need to use away from the shop and those that have lots of interchangeable parts and accessories, to these:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=68750&cat=1,43326,68749

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=64653&cat=1,43326,64664,64653

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=64655&cat=1,43326,64664,64655

I realized this could be a good idea after getting used to using my Festool power tools out of Systainers. They're a lot lighter than a traditional tool box, and a lot easier to move around in the shop than a tool box on wheels, and I don't need help to move them in and out of the shop. I can get them closer to where I'm working than if they were on shelves or hanging in a tool cabinet.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#15

Odate Asian box, Military Field Box...

Bruce McCrory

I made one of SYP thinking I had my mess solved. A couple detractions (for me):

1. Portable ... For an elephant. Take your Golden Lab for walk. You walk and carry the Lab.

2. I sorely lack the horizontal space it requires. Park it on end, and Derek will froth at the mouth after gravity does it's thing. I leaned mine over on the wrong end, the top fell out, and a Bailey #6 followed.

A super Uber' concept, but only for small, light containers; and horizontal storage. Mine now supports a portable shop vac. while awaiting a re-purpose.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#16

Re: Beyond the Kaizen Foam

Tom

I like wooden boxes, they can be light, cheap, and fitted to specialized tasks. I never get this downgrading of wood that woodworkers seem prone to.

There was supposed to be a photo with this, but they keep changing Flickr, and I have no idea where they are hiding the photo urls.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#17

Re: Beyond the Kaizen Foam

William Duffield

I like wooden boxes. I've made lots of them for holding tools, etc. I like systainers too, for different reasons. They are light, they stack and lock together, and lock to the top of my vacs, and lock to the dolly, they are easily moved around, it becomes a no-brainer when I acquire a new tool what to do with it and how to get it from Point A to Point B, and I can get right to using the tool for what I purchased it for, instead of figuring out a box to put it in. I don't think a #6 would fit in one, and I'm sure my #7 and #8 wouldn't.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#18

Thanks!

John in NM

I'd forgotten about those, I need something with which to lug projects to work, and one of those would be better than building a cedar box, which is what I was thinking after looking at Adam's post below.

Currently I'm using an old finger jointed dynamite box, but its a shame to risk damaging it. Even though I have several, I'm fairly attached to them. Plus it doesn't have a lid and a handle!

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#19

Re: I prefer.....

roger lance


:D

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#20

James Pickering

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

James Pickering

It depends on your working environment. During my apprenticeship, senior craftsmen had their own permanently assigned benches and wortk areas where they stored and maintained their tools in accordance with their personal tastes. Apprentices were itinerents - constantantly being re-assigned to different senior craftsmen for varying periods of time - and therefor used tool boxes to store their tools which they could park on the bench of the senior craftsman to whom they were currently assigned.

Link: http://jp29.org/wwtoolbox.htm

James

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#21

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

BrianMonumentCO

James did you build a tool chest like ATC?

Do you have pix?

Thanks

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#22

Storage space for me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My shoplet, which is dedicated to everything I do around this place - wood, auto, household mechanicals (plumbing, electrical), and so on - is too small for me to store many of the tools in any practical way except boxes. These boxes are auto mechanic's rollaways and top boxes, because they let me get things stored quickly.

On my (long) round tuit list is making divider-like things that will hold the rasps to keep them separate from each other. They're currently loose, but I'm very careful how I put them back, for what that's worth.

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#23

James Pickering

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

James Pickering

Hi Brian. Apprentices made their own tool boxes (wood, hardware and time provided by the company) based on a standard pattern. I don't have any pics, sorry, but I will try and come up with a rough sketch based on my somewhat fragile memory.

James

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#24

Sick! 


Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool box

#25

Re: Why loose tools in a tool box? Why even a tool

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

Hmm.... I'm finally finishing up an ATC, building the tills and drawers, so this is on my mind.

I think part of the answer is that tools with delicate blades and precise sides tend to live in defined places in the bottom of the chest. Saws in particular get dedicated space, but so do (most) planes.

My chisels and marking knives tend to live in rolls or have caps, which isn't perfect but makes me worry much less about issues in loose drawers. I don't like dividers with super-sharp points anyway, and keep my compasses in a separate box.

I'll see how it goes in practice, but at least in the design phase, the chaos definitely seems manageable. The good quality (not damp) space I have is very limited, so the tool chest makes a lot of sense for my situation even with these compromises.

Thanks!