New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Posts

Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#1

Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, I have finally begun. There is an introduction to the project ..

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChair-Introduction.html

... as well as the start made, here ..

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChair-BuildingTheLegs.html

As always, any advice and discussion is welcomed.

Best wishes from Perth for the New Year

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#2

Just enough Jarrah for "The Chair"

Bruce McCrory

I see a complication from the start; perhaps induced. Surely, this is not the only curly jarrah available?

Starting with the easy parts (and restricted) makes definite sense. ;)

Am in the peanut gallery and rooting for you!!

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#3

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Derek

I can't wait to see the finished product!

My only input is I made a chair seat similar to this and made a large needle out of the wire frame from a politician's campaign sign (3/16" dia. steel x the width of the chair + 3"). I heated it with a torch, flattened it, and put an eye in it with my Dremel tool and a metal cutting disk.

Work safe,

George

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#4

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Tom

Congrats on starting such a demanding project!

Wishbone! Wishbone! Wishbone! The Chair is crap compared to the Wishbone.

I'm thinking it would be way better to do the mortises before the turning. None of your arguments make sense. The tear-out is just excuses, and you could surely plot the mortise positions. But on the flip side there are hand tool ways of getting her done, or maybe some cool jig? Looking forward to it. I'm sure you have it all planed out in some cool way.

Your turning is like watching the guy on the Delta forum discuss chisels.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#5

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm thinking it would be way better to do the mortises before the turning. None of your arguments make sense. The tear-out is just excuses, and you could surely plot the mortise positions. But on the flip side there are hand tool ways of getting her done, or maybe some cool jig? Looking forward to it. I'm sure you have it all planed out in some cool way.

Your turning is like watching the guy on the Delta forum discuss chisels.

Hi Tom

I did consider cutting the mortices while the blank was square. However I was daunted by this as there are too many angles involved to determine up front. Not only are the stretchers offset on the horizontal, but also on the vertical. I think I can work (mortice and tenon) more accurately with the completed (round) leg that trying to guess their location on a square face. I do have a plan. I will post pictures of the angles later.

Is my turning so obviously basic? :)

At one stage I started using a HSS parting chisel for the depth markers. I managed just of these (at 1/8" width) before the edge was dull. By comparison, I completed 3 1/2 cylinders before changing to a fresh carbide face, and I am still on the second face at the end of the legs. The four legs took all day to turn, and I am sure that they would have taken twice that time with the frequent interruptions from sharpening HSS. Allied to this was my constant concern that this Jarrah requires a sharp edge to avoid chipping out. As it was I did get some when turning the cylinders, but was fortunately able to remove this when finishing up.

There was also one leg that had a deep check that I thought might explode. I had filled the crack with superglue, let it soak in, refilled, and left to dry overnight.


This worked well, and the final turning shows only a very fine line that will pass for figure.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#6

Re: Just enough Jarrah for "The Chair"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I see a complication from the start; perhaps induced. Surely, this is not the only curly jarrah available?

Hi Bruce

Ideally one wants all the wood to come from the same tree, and same part of the tree, to maintain uniformity of colour, figure and grain. Derek-The-Timberman had exactly two "sections" of wood from which I could choose: this curly Jarrah and some curly Marri. The curly Marri was the wood I used on the Kist, and I really do not wish to go there again. It was a mongrel to work, the most interlocked wood I have ever come across! The curly Jarrah is quite rare wood, and he did not have more. Keep in mind that a dry 6" x 6" rough sawn post takes years and years to dry. In the video you will see the wood is still a little wet, but once cut is kiln dried. Final shaping is with dry wood. I have to begin with dry wood. There is not much around in this dimension.

I lost about 25% through some severe checking. It took careful planning to maximise the yield - keeping in mind that the curl has to face in the same direction as well.

I decided that the section I have put aside for the chairback will be cut last. It is the most spectacular piece of all, and I will be sad if it cannot be used for the back. However it is my reserve because it matches in colour and grain, and the one section that can be different is the chairback. A contrasting wood there will be acceptable. Hopefully I do not need to use it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#7

Re: Minerals, Silica in OZ woods?

Bruce McCrory

Derek said: At one stage I started using a HSS parting chisel for the depth markers. I managed just of these (at 1/8" width) before the edge was dull. By comparison, I completed 3 1/2 cylinders before changing to a fresh carbide face, and I am still on the second face at the end of the legs.

HSS is standard in US. Typically, the only bad wear in US woods, as I understand--Desert Ironwood excepted--is from mineral deposits, or high silicate woods like our Black Locust. Nothing like you describe, however.

How do shops in Australia deal with such abrasive woods and walk away with any profit? One even specializes in Karri.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#8

Re: Minerals, Silica in OZ woods?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

That should read, " managed just 5 of these (at 1/8" width) ..." before I returned to the carbide chisel.

Here is a picture (look at the right side of the cylinder/leg) ..


And here are the 4 cylinders/legs. You can see that I need not return to the parting chisel.


What can I say? Jarrah (and many other Oz woods) are abrasive. What do turners in Australia use for chisels? As far as I know, the serious guys long ago gave up on HSS and instead use M4 and carbide. I know a number of turners that use diamond disks ($$$) on their grinders. I do not know what the norm is - my turning is limited (by the small Jet) to spindles and tool handles.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#9

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Patrick Gibbons

Derek, I have two comments about your jigs. For templates you could use plastic. Lee Valley sells sheets. These won't deform like MDF with use. I really liked your lathe rest idea. A solid bar of W1 might not sag like a pipe does. Adding a center support would help. The project is going to be fun to follow.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#10

Re: Minerals, Silica in OZ woods?

William Duffield

M4 is a HSS. Usually, HSS turning tools are made from M2, however, so if a turning tool is made from M4 instead, the manufacturer or retailer will clearly make the distinction.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#11

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

Thanks for the idea to use plastic for templates. Pity that Lee valley don't live nearby .... no, not such a good idea! :D

I will stick with 1/8" MDF for this project. The MDF will last long enough. I have several sheets of the stuff. It's great for drawing a full size plan.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#14

Vibrant Grain!

Bruce McCrory

First, pro forma. I can see potential of this thread going disjointed due to diversions by how the mechanics of WC are made up. Disjointed, because this comment is not so much "on task" but also premature... Of course, abbreviating the construction process will likely shorten the Q&A conundrum, and, possibly, minimize the details that will turn the thread into a mess. 8)

So now, my next diversion>

I finally see the nature of the grain "curl" in your seat stretchers. [BTW, not the separate lighter color piece on the table.] The grain in this chair is going to be wild!

Wegner chairs (the Chair) avoid the grain patterns you are introducing. As such, they exhibit overall form. Due to the bulk of parts, however, wood grain does play a secondary role. It would be a less appealing piece if painted.

Counter to moderate grain, I can see the punch of grain texture for this piece competing adversely with the chair's primary design, form. The amount of paper (cord) and texture that has will be extremely important in balancing the secondary design feature.

My two-bits...

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#15

Re: Vibrant Grain!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

On walking into the livingroom, where this chair will be used, each person will be handed a pair of sunglasses to shield them from the brilliance of the figure. :)

Actually, I take your point, and I agree. The wood can detract from the form. We shall only know at the end (hoping that the end is a happy one).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#16

Possibly, an overreaction...

Bruce McCrory

... on my part. I forgot. Jarrah lends itself to high end bordellos. I was going to align it with Walnut and Mahogany, but those woods convey a certain somber mood better suited to funeral houses. But, as mentioned, paper ligature, should be less flaunting than a minimum of polished, rich leather.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#17

What do high end bordellos ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... know about furniture? I ask this simply because my wife won't let me indulge, and you seem to know. :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#18

Jack Guzman from Maine

Tool rest

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek, that chair is going to be stunning. One comment about your tool rest. I have the same lathe,with the extension. I use it to make windsor chair legs. I dislike moving my tool rest back and forth so I built one of wood. I got the idea from Curtis Buchanan's videos on chair building. I built a slotted base that is adjustable in and out and sideways.It has two threaded bolts sticking out the front edge. I have different sized rests that slide onto the bolts and hold in place with wing nuts. The rest is a 1"x6" with an angled top edge and a piece of steel flat bar screwed to the edge.This does the job for me. The large one has some vibration issues though and I am thinking of building a dedicated one for 20" spindles that is beefier but not as versatile. Just a thought. If you want to see pictures I can take some.Looking forward to seeing your finished chair.---Jack

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#19

Re: What do high end bordellos ...

Patrick Gibbons

While I have never been to a bordello, I would guess that if you're noticing the furniture than something is amiss.

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#20

I would like to see pictures


Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

Will do


Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

See new thread for pictures


Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#23

I must confess

Bruce McCrory

What is the fun paying for an apple at the market, when down the road, you can sneak into the orchard for free? Hollywood paints the picture for me and my imagination. They distort many businesses and eras.

Back to task>

The intent was to dispel some of my initial warning about contrasting finish color. Darker wood will resonate less garishly than light, such as maple. To my eye...

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#24

Re: Tool rest

Tom

Conover had an interesting method which consisted of a post for the tool post that was reduced in diameter so it would fit into a 1x2. This allowed one end to be well supported so that it could be moved around easily. The right side was supported by a clever hook that is fitted to the end of the tailstock. The advantage was a full length support that could be adjusted in length from from the right end. Some thing similar could be crafted with a simple receiving bracket of wood at the left end.

http://wood.woodtools.nov.ru/books/lathe_book/lathe_book.pdf

Page 25 which is PDF page 31

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

#25

Re: Building Wegner's "The Chair" - a start

Tom

That is brutal Derek, I have turned wood with Silica in it, but this one sounds like a beach in comparison. I'm sure I could turn it without too much sharpening... :) But it may be that in the real world there is a reason for the fact that a lot of the expensive wonder steel turning tools seem to come from Oz.

I would hate to see someone with reasonable skill fall for this method on more normal woods. It is not normal to have so many reference points on a piece that is basically a convex curve. Mark the main points and go for it. I will admit it can pay to have more than 4 sticks of wood...

In cases where I have had to drudge it out. An example being the very shallow convex dishes upon which guitars are built, what I do is develop the curve in CAD. Print it out, paste it to a piece of ply and cut that out, then I hold it on top of the rest while the piece turns, and work the scraper back and forth until it fits perfectly. One can use the form to hold sandpaper to it for the final licks. These dishes are say 24 inches in diameter and can have as little as about an 1/8" of concavity to them, and they need to be perfectish. Sometimes the concavity is so shallow, you can't take a chip in some cases, so out come the scrapers. This is fast and repeatable.