New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

Posts

convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#1

convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

Lars Parrington

I'm looking for a better method of raising panels. Right now what i do is just bevel the edges of the panel. But that means when the panel shrinks, a gap opens up between it and the stiles of the frame. Instead, I'd like my panels to end in a uniform thickness tongue, like this:


As far as I'm aware, this is normally done with a router or shaper. I have routers, but not a router table or shaper table, and I'm not keen on getting one. I'd still be interested in hearing about solutions involving other common power tools, if there are any.

Barring that, it seems like my best bet is to get a panel raising hand plane. I'd probably still remove the bulk of the material on the table saw, but then finish it up with the plane.

I've got an old transitional jack plane that I'm thinking of modifying into a panel raising plane. I would cut two slanted grooves in the wooden sole, and grind off the corners of the iron to match. Then I'd add a depth stop and also a stop to control the tongue width.

Here's a photo of the candidate plane:


And here are a couple photos of the proposed modification. The tongue width stop is shown in green, and the depth stop in blue. The yellow piece screws gives the green stop somewhere to be screwed into. The yellow and blue pieces are attached by two screws each, into the sides of the original plane body. As such, they can be swapped side to side to convert the plane to left handed operation. That is also why there are two grooves cut into the sole rather than just one.



As shown, it will be able to cut up to a 5/16" wide tongue and raise the panel by up to 3/8".

It lacks a skewed iron, but otherwise it seems like a good idea to me. Any thoughts or suggestions?

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#2

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

John Veerkamp

Set your table saw blade back up straight. set the blade height to 1/4 ". using a high auxiliary fence run each side thru the saw making a cut parallel to the face.Be sure to leave enough meat in the wood when you make your first bevel cut ( 1/4") at the edge. Use a feather board .

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#3

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

Lars Parrington

If I'm understanding you correctly, you'd end up with a profile like this right? With a little step before the bevel:


I'd prefer not to have the step.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#4

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

William Duffield

The latest issue (November, 2013) of Popular Woodworking has an article and lots of additional online resources) by Willard Anderson on building a real "badger plane" from scratch. www.popularwoodworking.com/nov13

The feature, which all badger planes I've seen, including mine, which you don't get by starting with a transitional jack, is a skewed blade. This is important, because you can't turn the plane around when you encounter some squirrely grain. I think your plan to reverse and readjust both fences will prove to be impractical, because too much precision will be required to get the adjustments close enough to even make a shaving, and you will have to do it too many times in the course of raising all the panels required for your piece of furniture.

Also, your panel plan doesn't include a step between the field and the bevels. To include one would require a more complex blade and a nicker to be added to your plane. The shadow line provided by this step is an aesthetic detail that is important in many period styles. If you leave it out, when the original piece you are reproducing had it, your panel just won't look right. It's even more important than whether your tongues are tapered.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#5

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

chuck

I encourage you to try just what you propose. I'd be very interested in seeing photos of the modified plane body, the reground blade, and the panels produce from the effort. I'd also like to hear about the process involved with the modification and use of this plane. The risk seems low. With complete failure you'd need to replace the body and regrind a iron to get back to square one. I also have a transitional jack that I would love to put back into service.

Good Luck.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#6

I have altered transitionals in similar ways.

Chuck Nickerson

I started by making several new bodies. All my modifications were to the new bodies.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#7

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

Lars Parrington

Thanks for the insightful comments William. That article looks like a good one. It also looks like more trouble than I want to go through at the moment. But perhaps it is something I will revisit in the future.

The lack of skew could be a major problem. I'm interpreting your comment "you can't turn the plane around when you encounter some squirrely grain" to mean that the skew helps when planing along the grain. I'm actually not worried about planing along the grain at all. Since this plane has a double iron, I can set the chipbreaker close to the edge and that will handle 95% of squirely grain. For the other 5%, I'll go through the hassle of reversing the fences. The green, "tongue width stop" will retain its setting (because it stays attached to the yellow piece). So, the swap shouldn't be too much hassle.

Where I am worried about the lack of skew is when planing across the grain. I'll do some tests of this later today to see if it's a big problem. I know the resulting finish won't be as good as a skewed iron, but maybe it will be good enough. If it just takes a quick touch-up with 240 grit paper that's fine, but if I have to resort to something like 120 grit, I'd consider that unacceptable.

I hadn't considered the ability to plane in a step between field and bevels. I've never wanted to do that on a project yet, but I could easily see wanting to someday. I could change the design to accomodate it, at the sacrifice of some adjustability and the ability to convert to left-handed operation. I guess I'll leave that functionality out for the time being, but if this plane conversion works out well, I'll have to keep an eye out for another transitional plane to modify.

Cheers

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#8

Re: I have altered transitionals in similar ways.

Lars Parrington

what kind of planes did you make out of them, and did they work well?

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#9

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

Lars Parrington

Thanks for the encouragement Chuck. I'll definitely post some results if I do go through with the modification (which I probably will, unless the lack of skew turns out to be a major problem). Risk is low indeed. Just my time really, since I paid approximately $0 for the plane, and I don't use it as it is.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#10

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

William Duffield

Good points. There are lots of "right ways" to do something, especially with the information we have recently rediscovered about setting the chip breaker. The problem is there are lots more wrong ways. And, of course, there are lots of different styles to choose from, so the step further defining the raised panel is something that most people wouldn't notice anyhow, even if we are trying to reproduce a particular style.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#11

skew test results

Lars Parrington

Ok, I did some testing to get a handle on the quality of the surface that would result from using this plane across the grain. The testing consisted of using various bench planes to cut bevels on the ends of some boards. This allowed me to vary the skew angle from 0° to 30°, and also the shaving thickness from ~2 to 10 thou. Here's a summary of the results:

Cherry: 0° of skew resulted in a very small amount of tear-out, even with a fine (~2 thou) shaving. The amount of tear-out did not significanlty increase with a heavy (10 thou) cut. 30° skew left a very nice surface with a light cut, but heavy cut resulted in a similar amount of tear-out as 0° of skew. I hesitate to even call this amount tear-out since the resulting surface is at least equivalent to an exceptionally nice tablesaw cut. The tear-out is probably about 1 thou deep. The tear-out can still be seen after sanding with 320 grit, 2 coats of shellac, and a coat of wax, but you've got to be looking pretty close.

Hard Maple: No perceptable difference between skewed and non-skewed cuts. No tear-out evident. Surface does feel slightly fuzzier than when planed with the grain, down the bevel.

Ash: Similar to hard maple.

Basswood: Similar to hard maple

White Pine: Much more tear-out than cherry at 0°. 30° is a big improvement, but does not entirely eliminate tear-out. The tear-out is approximately 10 thou deep.

I also did some testing of ~10° skew, as I figure I could mount the metal parts of the transitional plane mechanism at a 10° angle to the wooden base (using a new piece of wood for the base). In all cases 10° was equivalent to 0°, and did not evidence any of the benefits of a 30° skew angle.

Conclusions: I don't envision making a lot of pine raised panels, so the performance there is not a big concern. I use a lot of cherry, so that tear-out is a problem. However, I wouldn't expect to be able to get a better surface from any power tool. Nor from a proper skewed-iron plane, unless I stopped to adjust it very fine before taking the last pass.

So, I think it makes sense to go ahead with this transitional plane modification. It would be a useful tool. If I had a better way to clean up after the plane than sandpaper, then the tear-out would be a total non-issue. I did try a card scraper but without much success.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#12

Re: I have altered transitionals in similar ways.

Chuck Nickerson

I did a jack rabbet , a panel-raiser, and a convex compass plane.

They worked OK. Next time for the rabbet and panel-raiser I'd take the trouble to include nicker and to skew the iron. Done correctly they will work better.

Next week I'll be building a transitional concave compass plane to match a 48" radius.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#13

Re: I used my "78"

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

to raise some panels for a toy box. I planed the tabs, penciled some lines for where the chamfer ended on the inside of the panel and went to town. I made 8 20 x 20 panels in a couple hours. The wood was cherry and the plane set fine planed very well.

I still would like a real dedicated plane someday but this works well for now.

Work safe,

George

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#14

Re: I used my "78"

Lars Parrington

interesting. did you use the fence or just freehand it?

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#15

Re: I used the fence. I put 

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

a board under the panel to raise it up in the air so the fence didn't hit my workbench top. Although you may find a better way to hold the panel, I held it between dogs in my front vise and bench.

I don't mean to hijack your thread but here is a picture of the end result:


Work safe

George

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#16

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising pla

AlanWS

I might try a lesser modification first. If you have a separate rabbet plane, you could plane the edge rabbet first. Now the only modification needed to this plane to enable it to raise the panel would be to remove some of the stock at the corner at 45 degrees, so it will allow you to cut right to the edge of the blade. The material left would behave as a depth stop when it encountered the rabbet. And if you want to plane both directions, all you need to do is modify both sides of your plane the same way.

If it's not satisfactory, you could then make the bigger changes to sole and plade profile you suggest.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#17

well, i did it

Lars Parrington

Well, I did it. Initial results are good, although I haven't tested it beyond the one board pictured here. I have a few panels to make tomorrow so I will report back with further results.






closeup of mock panel



blade grind



chipbreaker

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#18

Clever

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Minimal changes to the body of the plane; the "outrigger" additions are nice and simple. First tests looking good.

It occurs to me that the same approach could be used with an all-wood jack plane, too.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#19

Very nicely done!


Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#20

Re: well, i did it

chuck

Top Notch! Thank you for showing the plane sole/body and the chip breaker/blade modifications. You've led the way for me to try to follow. Thank you.

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#21

Re: well, i did it

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

I love it!!! It looks like the test cut is very smooth! What is the angle on the edges of your blade?

Work safe,

George

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#22

Re: well, i did it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Really a nice job, Lars! Most workmanlike. Very accurate job on the chipbreaker as well. Well done!

Wiley

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#23

chip breaker

Steve Voigt

Lars, that's very impressive. Well done.

How did you do the chip breaker? Once you ground the corners off, the bottom of the chip breaker would obviously not have contacted the back of the cutting iron evenly. How did you bring everything back into the same plane?* I would have guessed that you bent the corners down, but it doesn't look like you did.

Thanks,

Steve

*plane as in geometry, not tool :)

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#24

Re: well, i did it

Chris K in MD

Nice JOB!

Re: convert transitional jack to panel raising plane?

#25

Re: panel-raising plane -- final results *LINK*

Lars Parrington

At long last, I'm reporting back about how this plane worked on actual panels. I used it to refine the bevels on four cherry panels, each about 11" tall and 15" wide.

Overall, it worked great. There were no problems with tear-out along the grain, and in the course of making 4 panels I never felt the need to switch to left-hended operation. Across the grain also worked well, tear-out / surface fuzziness was very minimal and could be cleaned up with 320 grit sandpaper.

One interesting observation is that the first pass or two of the plane really gouge the surface and make a mess. Presumably because the plane is only cutting in one narrow strip. Subsequent passes clean the damage right up. Here's a photo of the damage (note that I had cut a bevel with the tablesaw first to remove most of the waste) :


And here's a few shots of the final surfaces. I believe the first two were taken before any sanding:




I posted a write-up of this conversion on my blog at the link below. There's really no more info there than you've already seen here, except that there are some dimensions posted at the end that may be helpful to anyone considering make the same conversion.


panel-raising plane blog post