New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

#20 circular plane

Posts

#20 circular plane

#1

#20 circular plane

Joe shelton

Can't get this plane to work. Can't get to the screw to adjust the frog. Can't get the blade and breaker assembled so that the mouth doesn't jam almost immediately. Anyone know how to fettle this beast?

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#2

Re: #20 circular plane

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

i'm sure you've heard some tools described as a solution looking for a problem. That plane is a problem looking for a solution. they do look interesting on a shelf though.

Robin

Re: #20 circular plane

#3

Re: #20 circular plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Can't get this plane to work. Can't get to the screw to adjust the frog. Can't get the blade and breaker assembled so that the mouth doesn't jam almost immediately.

Hi Joe

I must be a little dense, but on my Record #020 (same as the Stanley #20), there is no provision to adjust the frog. There is a screw underneath but this appears to lock the frog in place, not adjust it. To get to the screw you will have to open up the curvature of the sole as much as possible, and then use a right-angle screwdriver (which I have never done, or needed to do).

The blade and chip breaker is a #3 size. Make sure you have the original. I do not know if the #3 smoother parts are exchangeable or not, but incorrect replacements may be a factor.

The #020 does not get used much, but it is great for ensuring curves are fair. This is not as easy using a spokeshave.

I cannot recall setting up the #020 in any special way. The chip breaker is not as critical as on a smoother as one can plane down the grain. Ensure that the plane is orientated the correct way to do this. Of course, if you over-reach the curve and head into the grain, then you will discover this very quickly. If you are attempting to set the chip breaker right at the edge of the blade (perhaps to control this situation), a convex curve may affect the clearance of shavings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: #20 circular plane

#4

Re: #20 circular plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Derek said, "Make sure you have the original. I do not know if the #3 smoother parts are exchangeable or not..."

According to Patrick Leach's information on the Stanley No. 20, "Also, the cap iron is unique to this plane - the slot that engages the adjustment fork is situated nearer to the top of the cap iron than it is on the bench planes. Be sure to check the iron's depth adjustment range to verify that the cap iron is correct, otherwise you'll be left with a plane that can only accommodate a very fine set." From the context, cap iron in this case is the same as what many folks call a chipbreaker. So it would seem the cutting iron would be interchangeable, but not the chipbreaker.

I've been following this thread with some interest, hoping to glean information for the day that the 20-1/2 that followed me home from a yard sale is called to duty. While I've been in my remodeling mode on the house, there hasn't been a lot of occasion for circular work - no Gothic archtop doors or anything - but, once I get some shop time, I've got a project on the list for which this could be a quite useful tool.

Re: #20 circular plane

#5

Re: #20 circular plane

Joe shelton

Derek, that's the screw I was assuming would allow adjusting the frog. My frog sits a trifle abaft the mouth. Actually, moving it forward would likely worsen my problem. I cannot install the double iron with a sufficiently open mouth. As Bill mentions below, some 20s may be fitted with bastard components, and now fear I've bought a "pig in a poke."

For sorting out, I held an IBC iron bevel up in the plane, and could (briefly) make a nice shaving. This leads me to believe that, first, I have a makepiece tool without collector merit, and second that an open mouth is the way to solve my problem.

I'm contemplating re-grinding the blade, with the bevel on the wrong side, thus allowing enough clearance for a shaving.

I'll hope for some added instructional comments before I go off that ledge. Thanks for your remarks.

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#6

Bill, I think you're right

Joe shelton

I went and read that, too. When installed, the cutting edge wants to interfere with the leading edge of the mouth. Please see my response to Derek; I may alter the blade to bevel-up to try to make it work.

As to the intent for the plane, I'd like to use it on a harvest table's edge. Just sounds like fun. Thanks for your help.

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#7

DUDE. That's cold.

Joe shelton

Didja have, like, a bad day? Or do you have one on your shelf? Maybe we should trade out.

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#8

Before you do that...

Doug Trembath

Post some pics, and I'll compare with mine. I have Stanley and Record, so we can compare sizes and such. I use the planes regularly as I do quite a lot of curves in my work.

When I first got the Record, I couldn't figure out how to get a cut. Frustrated the heck out of me until my buddy demonstrated how he did it, and the process became simple and provided really good results. I was under the impression that you set the curve to the profile you wanted to end up with. It just seemed obvious to me, but I couldn't make it cut reliably at all. Kind of a shame to have to admit it, but all I needed to do was make the curve tighter than the curve on the profile (on inside curves), and roll the plane base until I picked up a shaving. After the first time, I had it. On outside curves, I set it to a lesser curved profile, and it works quite well. Go figure that a guy would struggle with such a small technique adjustment.

Again, post or send some pics and I'll see if I can help identify any real differences.

Doug Trembath

Re: #20 circular plane

#9

Wait!  Wait!  Another alternative

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Or you might be able to recut the slot for the adjuster. I'm struggling with a severe virus right now, but if I have energy tomorrow, I could measure the distance from leading edge to slot on my 20-1/2 (same as the 20, except painted black) and send you the dimensions.

Re: #20 circular plane

#10

Like Doug said

Mark Hennebury

You have to have a smaller radius on the plane then on the wood, and kinda roll in and out of the stroke. I wont say that they are easy to use but they get the job done.

I used a record.


img

Re: #20 circular plane

#11

Dimensions, and, no, that's not a solution *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I measured the distance from leading edge of chipbreaker to bottom (closest to chipbreaker) edge of the slot for the depth adjuster on my No. 3 plane and on my No. 20-1/2, with these results:

No. 3: 3-1/2" strong

No. 20-1/2: 3-9/16" weak

In other words, less than a 16th of an inch, which is less than the width (about 3/16") of the slot.

One possibility, then, would be to hold the chipbreaker back an extra 16th of an inch from where you might normally set it. This should give you the normal range of adjustment, at the cost of the chipbreaking function of that part.

You could also get in touch with one of the folks who carry parts. I had good service from Clarence Blanchard at Fine Tool Journal in the past, but am not sure he's still doing this. Walt Quadrato at Brass City Records is good, but call him, don't e-mail him, and be sure to have a cup of coffee or similar at hand; he likes to talk it all through. Both of these can be found through Google. Pete Niederberger, a county south of me, is good, but a tad pricey; his e-mail is pniederber@aol.com, or it was last I corresponded with him.

I suppose you could look into having Ron Hock or one of the other specialty iron/cap iron makers make a custom one for you. I've never dealt with Ron Hock, but have heard he's willing to make minor changes; and I was pleasantly surprised, just now, to find how affordable his cap irons are, only $1 more than Lee Valley's.


http://www.hocktools.com/default.html

Re: #20 circular plane

#12

Thanks, everyone.

Joe shelton

Bill, the dimensions you gave me are the same for my components, so I no longer think I have incorrect parts. Doug, I appreciate your offer to compare with pics; I couldn't figure out (even with the FAQ) how to do that, but a co-worker has a 20, and we compared the two. Again, the parts on mine seem identical to his. The only difference is that my blade's cutting edge is near as dammit against the mouth, no matter how I jigger the setup.

I've found (cobbled up) a workaround: using a captive-nut from a fence, I installed a thick Ray Isles blade, bevel up and without the chipbreaker. The special nut rides just above the adjusting lug, and serves as a shim to allow the lever cap to tighten down. Althogh the lateral adjuster works, the cutting depth adjuster has nothing to bear against, so I tap the blade gently until it cuts.

That works, and works well. Taken with Doug's tutelage for setting camber, I've just gotten a fair curve with no tear out, and am no longer frantic about an expensive paperweight.

Someday, though, I've got to sort out what's wrong. I think I'll try re grinding the bevel, from 25 to 30 degrees or so, to see if that will allow clearance for shavings. When I do so, I'll come back and let y'all know.

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#13

You know, Joe...

Doug Trembath

Seems like when we begin to accumulate tools for Hand Tool work, the options are less than optimum, especially in the beginning. It's difficult when we read about someone's incredible find of a tool we cherish and only wish we could acquire, but to no avail.

Sometimes, like buying a car, we receive a lemon. No getting around it, manufacturing processes determine the actual percentages for success, and we have all ended up on the short end of the stick at times, in our search for Nirvana.

Been there, done that, got the T-shirt...

I don't need two circular planes, but I have two, one a gift from a highly esteemed friend who, at one time, moderated this forum.

I'd be happy to share the good fortune, in his name, and send you one that will provide the benefit you're looking for.

Send me an email and we'll discuss further.

A radius plane that works is a far cry better than one that will never do, and the opportunity to make a new friend is way better than the alternative.

My email is attached to my reply...

Doug Trembath

Re: #20 circular plane

#15

Robin, you're right.

Joe shelton

I apologize for my rant. Hope I didn't offend you.

Joe

Re: #20 circular plane

#16

Re: Robin, you're right.

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I wasn't in the least bit offended. Didn't mean to rain on your parade either. There are however a few tools that just look like they would be the bees knees and end up being about as useful as a spill plane.

Robin