New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Speaking of Shooting Boards

Posts

Speaking of Shooting Boards

#1

Speaking of Shooting Boards

Paul in NJ

With the intro of LV's new shooting plane I thought this might be a good topic for discussion.

How many of you have and use one? Could you live without it or is it indispensable? Is it a crutch or is it different strokes for different folks?

I have one and ergonomically modified a plane to use with it. It works well but frankly I don't use it much. In my small shop it takes up both storage space and space on my bench when I use it. I don't have room for a dedicated shooting bench. I mark all my stock with a marking knife and try to cut accurately to the line. Many times that sawn surface suffices and does not need to be planed smooth. If I need a smoother surface or need to sneak up on a fit, I just overhang the stock on my bench hook, lay the plane on its side, and take a shaving to the middle, flip the stock over and and plane the rest.

What does a shooting board do that sawing to an accurate line or my bench, bench hook, and plane cannot do?

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#2

Michael Donaldson

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Michael Donaldson

I use my shooting board all the time. I use either my #5 or #6 when I shoot. I mostly make small things, so it makes squaring up two sides of a board really fast. Probably my second most used appliance after my bench hook, and although I could live without it, I wouldn't want to. The Lee Valley shooting plane has managed to work its way to the top of my tool wish list....

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#3

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have gone at least 30 years without using a shooting board. I made one around 1981 in order to make some very small boxes. In those days workers used shooting boards for very small pieces or for very thin pieces, stuff that would be difficult to balance a plane on. In 1962 I was taught to shoot end grain with the board held vertically in the vise.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#4

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

wilbur

I would argue that your bench hook method of planing the end of a board is a shooting board, of sorts.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#5

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

zug

Warren,

You said you were taught to plane the endgrain by holding the board vertically in a vice. Can you describe the process as you were taught.If it has worked for you for 50 years, I am game to learn.

In 1962, I was taught to play catcher in Little League. I wish I was taught to woodwork instead.

Thank you~!

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#6

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My bench hook is designed the the backrest as close to perpendicular as I can get it. Works for me. If it quacks like...

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#7

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Patrick Gibbons

I shoot end grain with the board held vertically in the vise. I'm not happy with the results. Does a shooting board reduce or remove entirely the occurrence of chipping the corners off the board?

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#8

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I plane to length before planing to width. I knife the board all the way around, then saw with a back saw and side hook on the bench, or with a hand saw on a low trestle. Then I make a small bevel on the waste edge of the board and then plane to the knife line.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#9

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Paul in NJ

Hi Wilbur,

Of course you are right! However my bench hook is not a single purpose tool. I would give up my shooting board before the bench hook.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#10

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Tom

Go fast, eliminate skill, leave a continuous length cutter track, cut to a predetermined length.

There are several ways of using planes and SBs, but one advantage the SB has on side grain is that it can be set up to automatically shoot a dead straight edge. Planes automatically shoot concave edges, sprung joints. At certain aspect ratios a sprung joint can't be rubbed, or even forced together at all, and would lead to a starved joint or no joint. Stiffness varies as to the cube of board width, so short wide boards have to have straight edges, as can be easily shot. So for stuff like a guitar joint it is a considerable convenience, though not a necessity.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#11

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Tom

You are correct in saying one can get by without a shooting set-up, though the simplest one, like what I use, is basically a bench hook, and costs little. I have never been swayed by the fancy ones I have seen. I think part of the greatness of the concept is how simple it is.

I would be curious to know what roll the SB played in a well equipped shop. The amateur can always win his case by claiming penury or lack of space. But larger pro shops had highly specialized tooling that they used to achieve specialized results or greater production. I am not too sure where the SB fit in. The cast iron ones are very expensive tools and would not be purchased lightly, but they arrived during the period of decline in manual arts. Were they there to make up for the workmen, or were the very productive. What is the record from earlier times?

I guess I am suggesting SBs are faster, but that is not always true. They speed up certain aspects of layout, and so forth, but one can often do roughing a lot faster with a different plane.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#12

Shooting board of sorts

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Agree Wilbur!! I hadn't thought about it before Paul's query, but what I call my shooting board is in fact a bench hook. The bench is the bottom plate. The bench is kept flat for many reasons--using it as a shooting platform is one; another is so you can flatten boards without planing swales in them. There are others--flat is good. Plumb aprons are good too, but that's another story.

I made a big 45-45-90 triangle out of some leftover beech (if I had it to do over, I'd use Baltic birch ply, but right then I had the beech). Sides are approx. 15", 15", and 21". Inserted that beech triangle into a 2x6 cleat with a groove ploughed lengthwise down the center. The cleat was then sawed and planed to provide zero-clearance backing for both the square shot and the miter shot. I catch the cleat in my twin screw end vise, with the beech triangle resting on the bench top. And pull the plane through the work.

Paul also brought up the fact that long edges can be shot simply by fixing the work so that it's edge extends over another board of sheet of ply--the idea is to lift the work up into the blade of the plane. I like to do that, using either the bench itself as a base, or a sheet of ply as an ad hoc base. Here's an example, of shooting some 1/8" veneer prior to hammer veneering, with BB ply used for underlayment and for lifting the work up. I used underlayment here, not for flatness, but because there were a zillion chips and what not on the bench top, and I didn't want the sawn veneer getting dings or marks or embedded steel wool, whatever. The clean underlayment solved that:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8261509377/in/set-72157632172323442/

Normally you don't need to plane to a reference surface--the plane itself rides up against the work and serves as reference. Plane from the inside out, just as if you had the work held vertically. There are variations: if the work has curl you can't control well, it can be clamped in a sandwich between two boards. Or you can clamp two adjacent edges bookmatched together, and shoot both at the same time, though it invariably works better for me to shoot them singly.

More generally, I need to shim miter cuts half the time, and this would be true with a shooting board or lion miter trimmer, whatever, no matter it's precision. For example, this desk top:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9276142351/in/set-72157632172323442

That 2" edge banding (1/8" thick) needed to be mitered to make a gapless fit at all 4 corners. To do that, I first mitered the long side pieces to as close as I can get to 45, glued them up against the center core, and waited for them to shrink back to dry size. That left the end pieces which had to be fit to the long pieces that were already installed. This invariably turns out to be a shimming job, or in fact, a free-hand miter. What I actually did was make the end pieces a little long, with 45 degree cuts. Then I did the final fitting with freehand cuts, adjusting slightly by eye, a little more off the heel of the miter on this one, a little more off the pointy end on that one. The fit doesn't come until the last 1-thou shaving is taken--it suddenly comes into fit.

All this to say....I admire really nice shooting boards, and admire the makers for getting them so precise. But for me, I enjoy working to eye and hand, and also find that the final, final, final fit often requires a shimmed or freehand cut.

I also think a big, heavy, skewed shooting plane would be nice to have, whether you use a shooting board or a bench hook :) .

Wiley

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#13

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Bruce McCrory

Exactly the way I was taught, in shop, in 1965. Mine was a 2x4 Walnut Lamp column.

That's where I learned how to sharpen the xxxx out of #4 Stanley irons. We used #4s freehand. Even with a crappy iron, I think doing it with a shoot board would have been better.

The squares we not-square. Fiddle, fudge, fiddle... Look for a better square. Coerce for a better one.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#14

Pushing precision

Bruce McCrory

I am thinking machinery pushed precision to a higher level. Handwork was, and is, caught in a hamster run, imitating the machine.

Just my philosophy...

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#15

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Bob Rozaieski

I do as you describe, Paul, and knife all four sides and saw as accurately as i can to the line. Usually that's good enough. I find it a rare occasion when end grain has to be planed. Usually, I can make my saw cuts square enough for things like dovetails. And since I try to hide end grain in the finished piece whenever possible, I don't have a need for a finish ready surface in end grain in most cases. When I do need to plane the ends, I've more or less resorted to working end grain like Warren describes. I knife a line on all four sides and plane to the line with the board held vertically in the vise. I built a shooting board years ago but probably haven't touched it in years. These days it gets used only for really small pieces that can't be worked easily in the vise.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#16

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I built a shooting board years ago but probably haven't touched it in years. These days it gets used only for really small pieces that can't be worked easily in the vise.

Hi Bob

Isn't that the job description of a shooting board?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#17

Add another dimension

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What does a shooting board do that sawing to an accurate line or my bench, bench hook, and plane cannot do?

Hi Paul

Your bench hook is a shooting board.

Just as a bench may be used as a shooting board for long edges (plane the work piece on its side raised off the bench).

The point is, that just sawing may get you square across the width of the board, but this may not be square across the edge. One is easy. Both are harder. A shooting board does both at the same time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#18

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

Kees

My shooting board lives a quiet life too. It's somewhere inside the wood pile at the moment.

Rarely do I need true square ends to the boards. M&T joints? The end lives inside the mortice. Dovetails? The end protrudes a little bit and is being planed after assembly. Visible end grain like in a table? It doesn't need to be abslutely square, just needs to look tidy.

When I want to smooth the endgrain a bit for whatever reason I prefer to put it vertically in the vice. The plane is much easier to manipulate in this fashion anyway. You can skew the plane, you can use all of the edge so you don't need to sharpen as often. You can even use the handles of the plane!

My little theory is that shooting boards weren't a big thing in ancient times. They probably wanted to avoid planing endgrain as much as possible anyway. Time consuming, and the blade wears fast.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#19

It is not about the ends ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Rarely do I need true square ends to the boards. M&T joints? The end lives inside the mortice. Dovetails? The end protrudes a little bit and is being planed after assembly. Visible end grain like in a table? It doesn't need to be abslutely square, just needs to look tidy.

Hi Kees

Shooting the ends of boards is not about the finish on their ends, but about preparation for marking them for joints, such as tenons and dovetails, using a mortice gauge and a cutting gauge, respectively. There are other ways to mark tenons (such as with a square - but that requires that the sides are perfectly parallel ... so swings and roundabouts). I would argue that ends for dovetails require even more precise marking than tenons. I do not know of any other way I'd want to do it.

Then, what about fitting drawer fronts and backs?

Ends of tables? I concede that, but the I've never considered that important, and also never thought of it a task for a shooting board.

Of course, there are many alternate techniques (happy to hear of these), but for those of us that do it this way, a shooting board is very helpful.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#20

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Kees

I vaguely remember we went through this once before.... :D

The M&T joint is the perfect example where you really don't need a shooting board. In a frame and panel, 4 squaring the members is typical and not very difficult. The degree of perfection you want in this is up to the builder, but if three sides are square, the 4th isn't too important anymore, as long as you register your square from the same edge. Marking from the sides is easier then marking from the ends, because the registration surface is a lot longer.

For dovetails it's similar. Learn to saw to a line, and the shooting board gets less and less important. With all the mitreboxes around, the Langdons in America, the Ulmia in Europe, even that skill isn't critical. Mark the baseline with a square from the side, and you're good to go.

Anyway, it's a choice. Avoiding endgrain planing could be a timesaver in a handtool only workshop.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#21

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Kees

As you say, it is indeed about choice.

... however somewhere along the line I suspect that there was a good reason why down the ages, the mortice and the cutting gage were invented, and found popular use across many Western and Eastern continents. Coincidence? :)

These do require a reference side.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#22

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Kees

Euh yes, but not the end of the stick? They register from the side, don't they?

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#23

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Euh yes, but not the end of the stick? They register from the side, don't they?

Hi Kees,

Even in Australia (where most things are upsidedown) they register from the ends! :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#24

Historical usage?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

What historical references are there to shooting board use, or mitering in general? I recall that Moxon describes mitering freehand using a strike block plane, with the stick in one hand and the plane in the other.

I routinely shoot all ends of all drawer parts, and scribe the dovetail baselines off the end grain. But in reading the dialogue above between Derek and Kees, I can see that it doesn't have to be so.

What references do we have from earlier centuries?

Wiley

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#25

Re: Historical usage?

Kees

The oldest i know from google books is in German.

Curieuses und Reales Natur- Kunst- Berg- Gewerck- und Handlungs-Lexicon

from Johann Hübner, 1714

Here he describes the "Vergathobel", an early type of bevel up miter plane often with an iron sole or even an iron body. The shootingboard is a Stosslade in German, and this word is used in this text. To be used for:

Mitering frames and mouldings.

And something I don't really understand. Shooting the ends of "Gohrunge". I don't know what the last word means.

It's in the last two sentences of this text.


img