New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Speaking of Shooting Boards

Posts

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#26

Re: Historical usage?

Kees

I think it means Gehrung, which is a mitre.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#27

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Kees

Now you make me curious. What exactly do you use a mortice or cutting gauge for, registring from the end?

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#28

Re: Historical usage?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Good reference, Kees! What do you suppose the stosslade looked like? More like a bench hook, or more like a true shooting board? Did it provide for miter cuts and end-grain (square) cuts?

Josef Greber, in History of the Woodworking Plane, discusses mitre planes (vergatthobel) in Germany, especially iron mitre planes, tracing them back probably to being fully developed by the 16th century. Greber quotes two German encyclopedists, Hubner and Krunitz (umlauts over 'u' in both names), who state that the miter plane was used with a 'miter jack'. Unfortunately, I couldn't find the full Hubner and Krunitz references in the text.

Hubner says (quoting from Greber),

"The miter plane differs from the smooth plane in that it (1) is somewhat longer and wider; (2) is pitched at about 20 degrees; (3) has its bevel turned upward; (4) has a very narrow mouth and an extremely smooth sole. Those entirely of iron or with an iron sole are better than those of wood because they do not slide as easily. They are used mostly for mitering corners with a miter jack." [NB: he must be saying the wooden ones don't slide as easily].

Wiley

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#29

Re: Historical usage?

Kees

I have absolutely no idea how it looked like! The book doesn't have pictures.

Here is the text translated as well as I can. Probably a real German can give a better translation.

The mitreplane differs from the smoothing plane in: 1. Being somehat wider and longer. 2. The iron isn't steeper as 20 degrees. 3. The bevel is facing up. 4. A very tight mouth and it needs a very flat sole. That's why the iron ones, or at least with an iron sole, are better then the wooden ones, because they don't wear so much. The use is mostly to mitre frames or to shoot mitres on a shooting board.

I don't know where Greber reads mitrejack.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#30

Re: Historical usage?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't recall shooting boards in Felibien, or the plates of Roubo or Diderot. Nicholson (1812) gives a description of the shooting block:


The fact that he does not mention cross grain planing for the shooting block does not mean that it was not done, but it does suggest that it was not a major use. Earlier he describes shooting (jointing) long grain for glue joints in the bench screw (vise). I think the use described for panels in shooting block section refers to thin stuff.

Holtzapffel (1843) says shooting boards are for thin stuff, with the grain, across the grain, and mitres. Shooting boards are often used for joining pieces for soundboards for harps, harpsichords, etc. Harpsichord soundboards are around six feet long and 1/8 inch thick. Here is Holtzapffel's illustration.


Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#31

Re: Historical usage?

Steve Elliott

Hi Wiley,

Regarding your note on iron miter planes and wooden ones, I believe the original German text says the iron planes are better because they don't "run away" as easily as wooden planes. It may be an advantage in controlling the plane to have some friction working against you as you push.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#32

Re: Historical usage?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Oh, my goodness! The German text you showed is precisely what Greber translated! Except that he translated stosslade as 'mitre jack'.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#33

Tight mouth

Kees

I wouldn't translate "weglaufen" to running away. You have to consider the context of the sentence. It's the tight mouth and the flat sole which are "running away". In other words, they wear faster in a wooden plane. Nothing new in fact, a wooden plane sole wears faster then an iron one.

Which brings me to another question, why do you want a tight mouth in an endgrain plane?

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#34

Re: Tight mouth

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Which brings me to another question, why do you want a tight mouth in an endgrain plane?

Good question, Kees. My first thoughts as well. Then ...

If only shooting end grain - which does not tear out in the way face grain can, then I absolutely agree - a tight mouth is unnecessary.

A tight mouth does have two other uses: it is easier to judge how fine the projection is, that is, easier to set up. And, secondly, the plane is likely to be used for side edges as well, and tearout may be reduced with a finely set mouth.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#35

Re: Tight mouth

Kees

Yes that sounds reasonable. And if I remember correctly, some people think these planes were used for planing delicate veneers and marquetry too.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#36

Re: It is not about the ends ..

William Duffield

For marking tenon shoulders, you can use a cutting gauge and mark from the ends, but as Kees points out, using a square (or in special cases, your bevel gauge) is more accurate, although not as quick. For marking tenon cheeks with a mortise gauge, OTOH, the beam rides on the end, but the registration (and the fence) is off the show face.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#37

Tenons and dovetails

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm. and all,

On a tenon-bearing rail or a case side, the reference for length will be the shoulders and the reference for the long dimension will be the outer edge if we're talking about a case door, or the upper edge if we're talking about a case side, won't it? So wouldn't marking the shoulders off the reference edge with a square be sensible? Maybe leave the tenons a little long, and trim them after they're sawn--not really a precision operation, trimming a tenon to length.

On the other hand, the total length of a drawer front and back, including their pins, will be the reference for drawer width, I think? And the total length of the drawer sides will be the reference or control for drawer length (so the drawer doesn't stick out the front of the case). If this is right so far, then for both pins and tails, the total length of the front or the side is the reference, and all the scribe lines are then backed out from the total length to match the thickness of the mating parts and the amount of lap you want on the front.

So that's why one would shoot drawer parts to length (or saw if you're good enough!), and then mark or cut scribe lines from the ends.

There are many ways to de-fur the cat, and folks can do as they please as far as I'm concerned, but this is how it seems to me.

Wiley

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#38

Depends

Ron Harper

Paul asked a couple of questions. The most obvious answer is a shooting board corrects inaccurate sawing. If you are as good as you need to be with a saw, then a shooting board will not be needed. Not many recreational craftsmen can stay that good with a saw,so thy touch up the work with a plane. Many were taught to plane to a line with the board vertical in a a vise. I have done this and achieved good results. The shooting board makes it quicker for me. YMMV

Ron

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#39

Some notes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For tenons the important layout lines are the shoulder lines. It is much more accurate to clamp the rails together and mark the shoulder lines together than to mark from the ends with all the cumulative error. For through tenons, we generally saw them a little long , then plane flush after assembly. For hidden tenons there is no need for precision in length. In both cases, planing the end grain is wasted time. I can't imagine marking from the end and getting a good line on the edge of the rail when the tenon is 2 1/2 inches long or so. Maybe it works for a stub tenon.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#40

Re: It is not about the ends ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William and Kees

On reflection, I do tenons both ways: marking the shoulder line with a square and knife (referencing from the side). This ensures accuracy to the shoulders at each end of the stretcher. Or, with a cutting gauge on one end only, and then a square from the other end (leaving the tenon cheek length longer). This does require a squared end for the cutting gauge, but is quicker to mark than with a square and knife.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#41

Quicker?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Quicker to mark than with a square and knife?? You can't add extra steps and then talk about being quicker.

This morning I found a scrap of white pine 13/16 X 2 X 20. I marked the shoulder length and a 2X2 tenon on each end, four knife lines, each all the way around. I sawed both ends square, marked both tenons with a mortise gauge, and sawed the two tenons. Total time elapsed, marking and 10 saw cuts: 5 minutes and 25 seconds. I can't help wonder how long it would take you to do the same work with the methods you outline.

Of course white pine, Pinus strobus, is faster to saw than swamp kauri, Agathis australis, but it also helped that I did not have to unearth my shooting board or unpack and adjust my router plane. Just one knife, one square, one saw, mortise gauge and rule. And both the router and the plane are just as sharp as they were before the exercise.

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#42

Can be. Let me show you ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

I agree with the method you describe. It is one I also use when gang marking a bunch of stretchers. However there is also value in doing it with the cutting gauge when you have only a couple of stretchers. Just another strategy.

I took a few photos to demonstrate. The sequence was timed to give an indication but don't take this literally. There are too many other steps that could be done instead. This is not a race, the stopwatch ran on a bit at the start until I realised I could stop it when I took a photo.

Here is the beginning. A pine stretcher out of the waste bin, and tools. The plan is a 1" tenon created with the cutting gauge, then marking a 12" section shoulder-to-shoulder, and creating the second shoulder with a square.


We're off ...!


This is the time taken to shoot the end square to the reference side. (I'd deduct about 5" for the photo) ...


Here is the fully marked shoulder (all the way around) ...


One observation is that this is a good, clean and even line all the way around the board ...


Now mark off the shoulder-to-shoulder distance - this would not be needed if ganging several stretchers ..


... however, one still needs to mark the ganged stretchers all around, and this requires the same marking as for one, albeit with extra care when setting up.

The face line is marked ...


All lines are now completed using the square ...


The observation here is that the lines require a great deal more attention to keep clean and aligned with the square than with the cutting gauge/shooting board.


I have not attempted to work out times. It is not really a competition. Gang marking should win if there are several stretchers to do. Alternately, using the cutting gauge for half may be preferred if doing only a couple as it requires less fussing with aligning boards for gang marking.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of Shooting Boards

#43

Quicker?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I still have no idea what you think is quicker about your method. I did layout and sawed a pair of 2X2 tenons in 5:25. You did your work in half the time, but you conveniently left out sawing to length, shooting the other end, marking with the mortise gauge, sawing the cheeks, and sawing the shoulders.

The little work you accomplished I was able to do in 71 seconds.