New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Posts

Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#1

Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My next project is to build one, possibly two, chairs. I am inspired by "The Chair" by Hans Wegner. It is a classic Danish design, no doubt familiar to many of you.

The version I am interested in is the original dovetailed design, with a woven seat (which I plan to do). The only aspect of this I do not like is the binding at the top rail (which was done to hide the dovetailing, and then omitted on later versions).


Here is the solid seat version without the binding ...


Here is the dovetailed rail ...


What I am after are dimensions, especially the thicknesses and widths of the rails, legs and arms. I have dimensions of the heights and width.


This is a machine-made chair, but I will build it with hand tools.

I do like the clean lines of Scandinavian designs. This is one of The Wegner chairs that appeals. Please do post any designs that you like.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#2

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Tony Wilkins

I'll definitely be watching this with great eagerness.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#3

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Paul Dzioba

Nice design and it looks comfortable. I like the woven seat too. The 'dovetailed' rail looks more like a finger joint though, maybe you can make it a real dovetail.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#4

Woven Seat looks nice ...

Bruce McCrory

I says, as I limp to the home pharmacy for back pain medicine. Must be for patients--or, parents of same. That seat reminds me of commercial chair seats, designed specifically for discomfort.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#5

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair" *LINK*

Mike Hamilton

Hi Derek,

You might contact Caleb James. He makes Windsors and Wegners and other stuff too. His blog contains references and pictures of CH20 (Elbow) and CH36/37 (dining chairs) he has made. Also some tutorials on weaving Danish paper seats. He is the fellow who did the drawings for the chair that Curtis Buchanan chronicled in his videos. He seems to have a number of other drawings on his blog. Perhaps he has detailed knowledge of "The Chair" as well.

Can't hurt to check.

Regards,

Mike


Caleb James CH20

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#6

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the link Mike. I had discovered Caleb's site a little while ago when researching weaving with Danish Cord (which is made from twisted paper). I shall do as you suggest and contact him for any plans.

I am torn between trying to copy the original - because a lot of thought went into the design to begin with - and building into it variations to personalise it. What would the forum do?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#7

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Tony Wilkins

Do your personal touches Derek.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#8

Definitely personal touches......

roger lance

just don't glue in anything backwards.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#9

What would the forum do?

Winton Applegate

Hi Derek,

Well since you asked . . .

Here's what I think :

The wrap at the back rest . . . I like it ! I find it visually interesting because it seems to gather the rays of the seat into it . . . or if you prefer, the rays of the seat radiate from the back.

to copy the original - because a lot of thought went into the design to begin with -[ or] building into it variations to personalise it.

When people asked me these kind of questions, especially in a retail enviroment , me being the sales person :D , I nearly always answer this way :

Buy, get, enjoy, MAKE, BOTH !

For instance you know the Kindle e-readers, from Amazon ? The big DX ones for looking at magazines and PDFs ? Should I get the black one or the white one ?

I bought one of each !

I have my reasons but mostly I just wanted both "colors".

Just between you, me and the lamp post I bought both used and the pair of them cost me a bit less than one new one so I don't think that was tooooo extravagent.

But anyway . . .

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#10

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

As much a i'm a huge fan of Danish modern it's largely derivative. I would suggest looking to Wegners inspiration for how to personalize one of his designs. If you take a look at his wishbone chair you can see how it is his version of a ming dynasty chair. I think three chair your interested in is a further refinement of the Dane design.

With your interest in campaign furniture and fondness of Scandinavian design I'd also point you to Ollie Wanasher's still, which is derivative of a 3000 year old Egyptian still.

Robin

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#11

Make it better...

Bruce McCrory

I already alluded to a fatal flaw. Also, check the lumbar support.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#12

Chairs

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Robin

I must say that I find the chairs of Ole Wanscher very boring and pedestrian.

This is possibly the pick of the bunch ...


Mostly they are like this ...


Hans Wegner, on the other hand, has chairs like these ..

The Wishbone Chair ..


The Cow Horn Chair ..


.. and this gorgeous "folding chair" ...


And, of course, "The Chair" (a nickname, as it was once voted one of the best chairs every designed), in my original post.

A modern derivative of the Wegner style, in my opinion, is this one by John Vogel, a designer in South Africa. Lots of fun!


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#13

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Patrick Gibbons

I think the binding on the top is a detail that adds very much. I would build it first as close as possible to the original. Become familiar with it, so to speak, then change it.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#14

Re: Make it better...

wilbur

Lumbar support seems to be highly overrated in its ability to help with lower back issues.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18425875

I'm unlucky enough to have a job that requires lots of sitting. The good news is that the chairs at work have lots of adjustments. In my experience, the comfort of a chair depends most on how high the seat is and the tilt of the seat, much more so than the lumbar support.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#15

Agree!!

Ron in Sterling, CT

Derek,

I agree with Patrick. By the time you have experienced the build of the first one as a copy, you will have a firm handle on what you want to do to the second one to personalize it. My 2 cents.

Ron

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#16

I vote for the wrap

wilbur

I like the wrap. It's more interesting than the solid back, and the one thing I dislike most about this style of chair is the dovetail/finger joint. It just looks very out of place in the context of the overall clean design of the chair.

If there was a cleaner way to execute that joint, that could be an alternative. Ming dynasty chairs were mentioned earlier, and the keyed scarf joint (probably the wrong term) used to join the pieces used to make the back rail looks nicer to my eye.


Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#17

Re: I vote for the wrap

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was thinking of the scarf joint in a Chinese chair also, Wilbur. Your picture is a little nicer than the one I found. Some Windsor chairs have a "continuous arm" from steam bent stock, but the heavier versions have a lap joint. The lap joint is usually pinned by a spindle going through both members and sometimes by a small pin as well. Wegner's joint does not look sturdy to me; I would hate to have to repair something like that.

There is a keyed scarf joint in my great grandfather's barn (1918), only a little bigger scale. The chestnut timbers are about 12"X16".

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#18

Re: Chairs

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I agree with you about ole's chairs vs wegner.s taken a whole body of work. Although Wanscher's t chair has a nice elegance it is his Egyptian stool that I find exceptionally elegant. In fact I tHink it could be paired quite well with Wegners 'chair'.

Robin

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#19

Re: I vote for the wrap

Bruce McCrory

The keyed scarf is always a pretty detail. I would not rely solely on glue to resist shear loads, however. But, then you won't want to slouch anyway.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#20

That is, the keyed scarf thought

Bruce McCrory

For me, the wrap/no wrap is still out to lunch. Use the right kind of finish and you can put wood stain racing stripes onto your shirts.

For the scarf/finger joint conundrum, I don't think there is enough horizontal room to include the water buffalo horns and scarf(s).

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#21

Re: Make it better...

Bruce McCrory

I must be dense, Wilbur, regarding the lumbar studies study. Were they studying chairs, belts, beds? [Just a rhetorical question.]

My original caution was directed to the full chair design--seat and back. Any chair including a back must take into consideration lumbar positioning. Ignored lumbar design examples are straight ladder-back chairs. I read that Shakers butchered backed benches, too.

The minimalist styles being bantered about in this thread weren't designed first for sitting comfort. They are first, form; if any more. Wegner actually made a nod to function with the w-buffalo horn-back chair.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#23

pick of the bunch ...

Winton

The first two have a hint of Maloof , or Maloof has a hint of that guy?

Not sure of the time line.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#24

Re: Make it better...

wilbur

Here's the plain English version of that study:

Numerous studies have been done looking at whether lumbar support, customized to the patient and his/her work/home environment, either prevents or treats lower back pain.

In looking at these studies as a whole, there's reasonable evidence that lumbar support is no more effective at preventing back pain than education on proper body positioning, or even doing nothing.

In addition, for patients who have lower back pain, using lumbar support to treat back pain was no more effective than doing nothing in four different studies. In other studies, the results were mixed at best.

So in the best case scenario, lumbar support might be of some benefit in treating back pain if you look at the right endpoint. More likely, it's not any better than doing nothing.

This is how I relate this study to chair design: If lumbar support does nothing to prevent back pain, it seems to me that this is a minor consideration when designing a chair.

This is not to say that chair design has nothing to do with comfort. I do think that there are certain parameters that have a lot to do with how comfortable a chair is, namely, seat height and seat tilt. As I mentioned before, whenever I'm adjusting an office chair, I'm constantly trying to dial in the seat height and tilt. Sometimes I'll adjust the tilt of the back. I almost never touch the lumbar support control.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#25

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Jesper, Denmark

Traditionally, the Wegner designs have been vigorously defended. I am not sure who has the drights to the design at the moment - I thopught it was a company called Frtiz Hansen, but it is not in their production program now. Probably it has passed to another manufacturer.

The chair is very popular, and there are many copies produced with just enough design changes to avoid infringement. I can tell you that I have test-sat both the original and compared with the copies. There is just something about the Wegner chairs, which make them much more comfortable that the knock-offs.

There is an exhibition of about 40 of Hans Wegner's chairs in the old watertower in Tønder, where he worked. Unfortynately, the website is only in Danish, and does not have much about the chairs, but it is a very impressive collection. Each chair is very comfortable in it's own way, and a testimony to Wegners expertize in chair design.

http://www.museum-sonderjylland.dk/siderne/Museerne/Kultur-Tonder/04f-Wegner.html