New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Posts

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#26

Re: Link to solid version dims.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

The original chairs were built in many woods. I think that the first one I build willlikely be Jarrah, partly because I have stock and like the warmth of it, annd partly because it will be a good contrast for the straw-coloured Danish cord.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#27

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the link Jesper.

The Wegner chairs were apparently also built for a short while in Melbourne, Australia. Here is one in Tasmanian Blackwood ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#28

Jesper, Denmark

Re: excuse the typo's

Jesper, Denmark

Looks terrible now that I re-read it, but the meaning should come through OK.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#29

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

That wood looks more uniform in tone and color than acacia melanoxin, or at least the stuff we have growing in California. I've got a confrence table I need to make out of the stuff this winter and as beautiful as it is i'm not lookin forward to it.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#30

Ellis Walentine

Nice photo, Wilbur *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

It's a spittin' image of the one we published in American Woodworker back in October 1995. Our West Coast editor (and long-time pal) Simon Watts had just alerted us to this young Chinese woodworker in the Bay Area, Yeung Chan, who was recreating original Chinese antique furniture designs. We showcased some of his work in that issue, and he went on to become well known for his handmade tools and over-the-top workmanship.


Chinese Chair Joints

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#31

Ellis Walentine

What I'd do...

Ellis Walentine

... is to imitate the original faithfully and not embellish or change any of the dimensions or proportions. When a chair reaches the iconic status of the Wegner chair, its look is so familiar to viewers that any deviation is immediately noticeable. Not to mention that it would be pretty difficult to make a chair "almost" like this one that was actually an improvement on the original. You might consider doing something with the general proportion but entirely different detailing, which is what I tried to do with this design that I made back in the early 1980s.

Ellis


Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#33

Re: Nice photo, Wilbur

wilbur

Yup, that's where I got it from. Sorry I forgot to include the info.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#34

Thanks- Hail to Balans Kneeling Chair

Bruce McCrory

Hi Wilbur. Thanks for the explanation. As this post title represents, I think we have an idea what chairs were preferred, but not used, by the study authors....

The lumbar adjustment is usually the first mechanism to fail, so I did mine early on.

Back to Hans ...

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#35

Solid version dims. for shop DWGs

Bruce McCrory

With gross dimensions given for the chair and pretty good "three-views"--no perspective manipulation required--one can import the images into CAD and recreate the shop drawings for the chair. I don't know SketchUp, but suppose that can be used also. SU used to accept DWG import.

The only other variable is your comfort level with drawings. ...

Looks like you want to spread wings into free form shaping. Scrape rust off rasps and spoke shaves..

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#36

The post was so useful that

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

the typos did not even register :) .

Wiley

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#37

The wrap and the joint

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Wilbur and all,

I like the wrap too. That top rail is pretty big and husky; the wrap softens it and balances it visually against the seat. There is also the definite benefit of sticking to the original, for reasons Ellis and Ron point out.

The joint. That triple birds beak is a scarf of course. From the outside, it conveys the idea that the saw cuts are all horizontal--and maybe they are. But not necessarily. Here's the joint:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9621881451/in/set-72157635012252891

Now here are some Japanese crossed birds beak joints:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9625125324/in/set-72157635012252891/lightbox/

Take a look at the one in the middle. That original joint may be, but is not necessarily, sawn with all parallel cuts. It may have some vertical webbing in the interior--or could be given some--either by sawcuts like the middle Japanese joint, or by inserting a vertical key in the interior of the joint.

Wilbur's point was aesthetic, and the Ming joint certainly is beautiful. On the other hand, the triple birds beak to my eye fits with the vernacular of the woven seat and back. If the seat and back were finished in silk, the Ming joint would be my pick.

Did Hans Wegner write anything? What was his aesthetic? This is all educational to me.

Wiley

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#38

Typos? (OT)

Alex Y

No apology needed. We all do it (lots for me). And while I like to spell correctly and use good grammar, the following gives me comfort when I send out typos:

Aoccdrnig to rscheearch at an Elingsh uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer in waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are, olny taht the frist and lsat ltteres are at the rghit pcleas. The rset can be a toatl mses and you can sitll raed it wouthit a porbelm. Tihs is bcuseae we do not raed ervey lteter by ilstef, but the wrod as a wlohe.

Curious how well that works when English is a second language.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#39

Re: AM and FWW

Tom

I still have those issues, they were great. I think FWW also did s chair that was inspired byt the wegner. But it was simplified to make it easier to make and probably avoid the rights issues. It may have been more a cow chair though. I have all those issues, but am not too sure what issue it was in. Not that you would want to go that route I assume.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#40

Great looking chair Ellis


Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#41

So Tasmanian Blackwood isn't black?

Patrick Gibbons

And a Tasmanian Devil isn't really a devil at all. That wood does make a beautiful show.

Re: Hans Wegner "The Chair"

#42

Reading and video material

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've been researching and collecting data, and thought I'd share some of the references in case others have similar designs. For copyright sake, I cannot share any drawings and measurements that are not in the public domain. If anyone here has drawings and measurements, please contact me via email.

A popular book on Danish chairs is - wait for it! - "Danish Chairs" by Noritsugu Oda. Great on the collection of Wegner's chairs (there is even a "Safari Chair", which is the Swedish version of the campaign chair that Chris Schwarz so loves) ...


There are basic drawings of all chairs but no measurements.

I went searching through my Woodwork mags ...

Woodwork, Winter 2011, has a 6-page article on Hans Wegner.

Woodwork, Winter 2011-2012, has an equally long article, "Notes from the Study of a Ming Dynasty Arm Chair", which would be right up Wilbur's alley.

And there is a great video here of the constriction of The Chair ...

http://www.pp.dk/index.php?page=gallery&cat=14&id=173

Regards from Perth

Derek