New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Trying plane refit

Posts

Trying plane refit

#1

Trying plane refit

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wylie's recent thread on his fore plane re-kindled a flame that has been smouldering for some while. It also opened up a topic that others here may find of interest.

I switch between metal and wooden planes, and for periods will use just one or the other. The wooden planes are a mix of HNT Gordon and one's I have built. The plane of interest here is an HNT Gordon Trying Plane.

Terry Gordon describes this as good for "smoothing of any long timber surface or for jointing". This plane is 18" long, and has a 2" wide and 1/4" thick single iron bedded at 60 degrees, and set up with a camber similar to a smoother. The plane was no doubt inspired by Terry's years based in Malaysia with the airforce, yet is intended for the cranky woods of Australia. At this, it excels.


I love the way this plane performs, but I do not enjoy pushing it with the cross bar handle, and instead remove it, and wrap my hand around the body. This is quite uncomfortable as the body is square and the edges cut into the hand.


One may be excused for thinking that this plane is for pulling, as with a Japanese plane. The mouth is far back, compared to a Western plane. It is about half way. And there in lies the issues I faced - is there room for a handle, and how will this affect the balance?

For illustration, here is my 28" jointer and 15" jack plane alongside the trying plane ...


In the picture above I lined up the planes at the rear hand. Now look where the mouths are ...


The HNT Gordon is definitely the odd one out - including a Stanley #7 reveals that the others are similar in placement of mouth and handle ...


I did some research looking for information on the relationship of the handle to the mouth. I could find information on the mouth, but not where the handle should be placed. I do know, partly from experience, that the further back the handle, the less the control.

One other aspect that could change - probably would change - is the "feel". The reason I like the HNT Gordon planes in that they are low aspect with a low centre of effort. A handle would raise the centre of effort and change the nature of the plane.

The only reason I was prepared to go ahead was that the Trying Plane was stuttering into disuse as I now found it uncomfortable. And yet it worked so well.

So I built a handle. The white lines on the plane body indicate the position where my hand usually grips.



The body was morticed ...


And the handle was epoxied in. I figure that epoxy is reversible with heat.


There is enough room to swing a plane hammer (this was not by luck! :) ) ...


Trying out the new trying plane (ouch! Sorry!) ...


The handle is a good size, and fits my hand perfectly ...


How does it feel? In a word, different. A little squirrely at first, then I became used to this and it was solid. But definitely different. The higher centre of effort is noticeable. The performance, however, has not changed - still fantastic.

I did find one other way to hold the plane, and that was to use the handle as a hook for the crook of my hand. This restored the low centre of effort.


Any thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trying plane refit

#2

Re: Trying plane refit

Steve Elliott

Thanks for an informative post, Derek.

I share your preference for a low center of effort, as you call it. Planes feel the best to me when my hand is just behind the blade, and fairly low down.

The second grip you show, with your thumb wrapped around the base of the handle, is similar to the grip I like but a little further back of the blade.

The jack plane in this picture has the kind of grip I'm used to. My infill smoothers also give me the same sort of grip. They're unhandled and have a curved surface on the back of the infill where I can apply force comfortably.


I have a Lee Valley bevel-up smoother that has the low center of effort but the handle is much further back from the blade than I'm used to. It makes "steering" the plane a little different because I have to focus more on keeping the force lined up with the blade.

This is an issue that brings out the "different from what I'm used to" side of things. It's hard to make an objective judgment of what's actually better. My experience with plane handles is mostly wrapped up with my unpleasant memories of trying to get a new Stanley smoother to work well in the 1970s. That plane wasn't worth the effort.

Re: Trying plane refit

#3

Re: Trying plane refit

roger lance

Derek.....you know with that cross bar handle, your plane reminds me of a shooter.....how's that going anyway??

Re: Trying plane refit

#4

Re: Trying plane refit

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Derek,

The long front registration of the HNT Gordon plane can be very useful, for example, in trying a surface where the front edge you're planing has gotten a little low--the Gordon plane would bring that front edge level by registering further into the surface, rather than accentuating the problem by registering on the low place itself. Lee Valley's No.6 does the same thing. Same argument if you are worried about the entry edge of the working getting low--this plane has positive prevention against it.

As I read your post, two statements made the biggest impression:

"This is quite uncomfortable as the body is square and the edges cut into the hand."

"I did find one other way to hold the plane, and that was to use the handle as a hook for the crook of my hand. This restored the low centre of effort."

In other words, the thing you like best about the plane, the low center of gravity was not accessible because you couldn't find a handhold that worked. Then later, after the modification, you did discover a handhold that worked, but it wasn't the designed handhold.

When I look at this plane, I see a lot of Krenov inspiration in it, and maybe Krenov had an Asian inspiration. Anyway, a typical thing that Krenov did was to mound up a palmful of wood right behind the iron. That's where the hand naturally falls, and that's what your hand seems to be looking for in the pictures.

I am wondering if a palmful of wood right behind the iron is not the best solution for you, in mobilizing the low center of gravity.

Wiley

Re: Trying plane refit

#5

Re: Trying plane refit

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oh Roger, you do try it on! :)

But no more pics until the shooting plane is released (in September, I believe), and then I shall post a full discussion, with many photos, just for you! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trying plane refit

#6

Re: Trying plane refit

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am wondering if a palmful of wood right behind the iron is not the best solution for you, in mobilizing the low center of gravity.


Hi Wiley

I see it this way as well. I'll leave it for a while, work with it to see what I learn, but it is likely that I shall create a completely different type of hand hold. Fortunately I am not a stranger to changes ;)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trying plane refit

#7

Re: Trying plane refit

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

That ECE hand hold, or something similar, may be in my future.

Interesting comment about the LV handle being too far back for you. Not that it is too far back - it feels fine for me - but, generally, moving the handle further away from the mouth on a plane, control is lost. Moving the handle closer to the mouth restores this. Moving the mouth forward also adds to control, as long as the handle is not too far back. Here I fear that the mouth needs to move forward if I want to use a Western handle. I suspect that this design gets its control from the low centre of effort, which is reinforced by not having a high handle?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trying plane refit

#8

Re: Trying plane refit

William Duffield

You might consider this one, by Yueng Chan.

http://wnwoodworkingschool.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/P32122351.jpg

I tried the one on the right in his toolbox. It's very comfortable when pushed with the right hand, but unusable left handed. In other words, specific shaping to fit your hand is necessary.

http://www.bayareawoodworkers.org/sept07/yeungtoolbox.jpg

The "tote" is low enough that it doesn't get in the way of your plane hammer.

Re: Trying plane refit

#9

A watched pot never boils.....

roger lance

until September....

Re: Trying plane refit

#10

Re: Trying plane refit

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

Thanks for the links. Yueng's hand hold is one I was thinking of as well. It takes me back to the photo where I gripped the body of the plane (and later when I cupped the handle).

It becomes clearer to me that the placement of mouth and handle/hold is a compromise between the factors that promote stability (i.e. keeping the two as widely apart as possible) and maneuverability (i.e. bringing them closer). A higher centre of effort may make the mouth placement more critical (i.e. it needs to be further forward), while a lower centre of effort reduces this (i.e. the mouth can be moved back). The ideal is having the mouth further back as this increases registration - which, incidentally, is a feature on the LV bevel up planes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Trying plane refit

#11

This center of effort...

Joe shelton

... It's somewhere around the belt buckle, right?

Joe

Re: Trying plane refit

#13

Re: Trying plane refit

chuck

Sir,

I read 50 years a Planemaker and User by Cecil E Pierce last night. He seemed to be convinced of the benefits of razee style planes. I've seen photos of some of the planes you've built with razee stock. To lower the hands for control this seems like a fine solution. What problems would be caused with a razee style closed tote on any plane? Small smoothers are the only limitation I can think of. Thanks.

chuck

Re: Trying plane refit

#14

Too many metaphors...

Joe shelton

I'll surrender the buckle, if you'll give up the Sumo belly.

I say we stick with nautica, since you already have yachts, razees, and CoE. When you take that yardarm out of the HNT Gordon, you're before the mast and close-hauled.

Get the helm alee, and run.

Joe