New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

Posts

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#26

An injection of reality

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given the arcane points debated in these discussions it is little wonder that traffic has withered to a few participants, a fact to be considered in selecting discussion topics. Most people actually building stuff face more prosaic problems than a planing demonstration on some wood seldom used with planes few have heard of or could afford. And they might be attracted to sources for solving their prosaic building problems.

A more useful discussion for those building stuff would be how to handle a problem like the one illustrated in the picture.


The situation: Here is a drawer rail that stands proud of the leg (by design for it is easier to adjust a rail than a leg) by about 1/64". The wood is ash, a wood somewhat problematic to plane, and the rail may have grain reversal somewhere along it length. Tear-out at this point of the build would be a disaster. Everyone has a Bailey type plane or could own one inexpensively. Few have any plane more expensive or exotic than a LN equivalent.

I submit that adjusting the cap iron very close is the easiest, cheapest, most reliable rout to fitting this rail, a typical need in building stuff. This is not to say that the need could not be met by harder, more expensive or less reliable means.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#27

Re: An injection of reality

david weaver

I would agree with your answer entirely. Just do it, don't over cut it and hold the plane askew at the end of the cut in case it does get into the stile. Check for progress while you plane and the whole process will take about 30 seconds.

My power tool buddy would find the longest straightest thing he could find and scrape the crap out of it.

As I M&T the face frames on all of my kitchen cabinets, they all of little bits to remove here or there (I don't have any fancy dancy dowel jigs, pocket screws or mechanical router holders to make the joints dead solid perfect flush). I could sand them all at the corners and try to blend them, but it's quicker to use the plane. They will all ultimately be sanded anyway, because my wife wants "the bought look".

Same with the doors, even though I'm just using a router set for them "for the bought look". The rails and stiles don't all go together perfectly and I'd rather not come up with an arcane apparatus to clamp them. Just plane it flush later and then sand "the bought look" into it.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#28

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate 

Charles Stanford

No, it's not a trick question. My question was directed to Warren.

Warren, what about smoothing the drawers on this piece:


Or this piece (these are all Jeffrey Greene pieces; the Bombe' and Serpentine front chest are all made from solid mahogany)


The drawers here are obviously the star of the show. You can't put a No. 4 on these.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#29

Re: An injection of reality

Charles Stanford

That's fine and all, but one works the woods one can get. For Derek and guys in his neck of the woods the problems are real. And by and large if a set up will handle their hard timbers they'll handle most anything we in the U.S. could throw at it. There may be a few minor exceptions, but not many.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#30

Re: An injection of reality

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The situation: Here is a drawer rail that stands proud of the leg (by design for it is easier to adjust a rail than a leg) by about 1/64". The wood is ash, a wood somewhat problematic to plane, and the rail may have grain reversal somewhere along it length. Tear-out at this point of the build would be a disaster. Everyone has a Bailey type plane or could own one inexpensively. Few have any plane more expensive or exotic than a LN equivalent.

Hi Bill

This is exactly the point where you are forced to decide which plane is your most reliable, which one you feel most comfortable and confident will do just the job you ask of it, that will not let you down and damage all the work you have put into the build to that near-final point.

Which you choose has nothing to do with which others say is best, but the one that experience has demonstrated to you is most reliable. This is not the moment to experiment, to take a test swipe.

I know which plane I would reach for.

For some it won't be a plane.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#32

Re: An injection of reality

roger lance

Would it be that LV shooter??? :D

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#33

Re: An injection of reality

Charles Stanford

Great post.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#34

Tea table and photos of plane

Winton

>tea table

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#35

Re: An injection of reality

wilbur

"This is not the moment to experiment, to take a test swipe."

There wouldn't be some scrap wood around from the project at hand to test your plane setup?

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#36

Re: Have we...

Tom

Well, there were Japanese Single blade planes that were considered to be superior to the double bladed planes. So I am told. By the time I happened along in the late 70s they were are double blades. And some say that was adopted from western practice for one reason or another.

The Old Street guys 'discovered" single blades as did a number of us, as being all around preferable, something I still feel. They say they were typical at some period in England, at the highest levels.

At the end of the day, wood determines what works as much as skill or technology. I have no immediate need for a plane that planes Oz wood. Though there is a certain amount of interlocking grain. I can handle it fine.

And equally at the end of the day, it depends what one wishes to plane to. No sandpaper, no scraping, wild woods, all flat etc... There isn't any one right way.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#37

Re: An injection of reality

Tom

"Given the arcane points debated in these discussions it is little wonder that traffic has withered to a few participants, a fact to be considered in selecting discussion topics. Most people actually building stuff face more prosaic problems than a planing demonstration on some wood seldom used with planes few have heard of or could afford. And they might be attracted to sources for solving their prosaic building problems."

I don't think that is why the pace is going down.

1) Realistically, there are posters, and there are readers, I post, and I figured out how to solve virtually every problem you have ever posted decades ago. So I'm here to stay up with the Zeitgeist, and learn anything new, by definition at this point, arcane. People who want to know how to cut a 90 on the end of a board hang out somewhere else.

2) This is a mannerly and general respectful place, but at the same time there is some fizz at times, and when that happens (and I am not the direct cause of it :)), it turns me off. As I have said I have tried to write with the reader in mind, but I don't always manage it, and I notice the same it true for others. Maybe this is happening because there are few posters, and we pretty much swim in circles.

3) I think the biggie is that forums are passée. One forum I hang out at was set up by a guy who sell boat plans, so he can connect with his clients and potential clients. I put a question up on that board in January, and the next post was when it hit it's 6 month anniversary. A reminder from me that no answer had been given. Now I know several insanely busy forums, but facebook, torrents, youtube, and a whole pile of stuff I am out of touch with, are were it is at today. As far as I can tell.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#38

Re: An injection of reality

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

("This is not the moment to experiment, to take a test swipe.")

Wilbur wrote:

There wouldn't be some scrap wood around from the project at hand to test your plane setup?

Hi Wilbur

You could - and possibly may - test the plane on scrap. However this is not the point of my comment above. The issue is in having confidence in your tools, which comes from a longer, wider time frame. It is not about a single moment in time, although it comes down to this at the end.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#39

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Sgian Dubh

Well, I'm certainly not Warren, but in my case if the task had to be accomplished primarily with hand tools, the drawer fronts you've laid down as a task to complete would, after roughing out on something like a bandsaw, be worked with a mix of a compass plane, spokeshaves, chisel plane, chisel(s), scraper(s), some bloody minded determination, and a selection of abrasive papers wrapped around conveniently shaped sanding blocks.

On the other hand, nowadays a CNC machine would make a pretty good job of getting the surfaces down to pretty much scraper ready, and possibly even just needing a touch up with some abrasive paper. Understandably I don't imagine this option would be first choice for most visitors to this forum, but it's likely it would be considered seriously in a customer focused production environment, even if the work would need to be sub-contracted to a firm with CNC capabilities, which is something that is becoming more and more common even among small to very small woodworking businesses. Slainte.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#40

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Charles Stanford

Yep, you're right.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#41

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

david weaver

>>I don't imagine this option would be first choice for most visitors to this forum<<

If I was doing it for pay, it sure would.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#43

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate 

William Duffield

I'm relieved that you weren't asking me, Charlie, because I've not built a bombe chest. I would attack it as Richard suggests in his first option.

I called it a "trick question" only because I agree that a Bailey/Bedrock would be practically useless.

Interested parties should note that your second example, the serpentine front chest, is immensely less complicated to join and shape than the bombe chest. First, all the dovetails and other joints are rectilinear, so they can be laid out just like a rectangular chest with drawers. Second, the front curves in only one dimension, so the rough shaping can be done with a bandsaw, and you can go directly to smoothing from there. A compass plane might be useful.

This image gives a much better idea of the complexity of the joinery and shaping that are required to build a Boston bombe chest. Note that the sides, as well as the front of the chest, are curved. This adds another order of magnitude to the complexity of the joinery, not to mention the significant additional expense of the much thicker mahogany required for the sides.

It is not my work! This guy might build one for you for only $18000.

http://www.custommade.com/mahogany-boston-bombe-chest-reproduction-2/by/kizerwoodworks/


img

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#44

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

William Duffield

That's curious. Mr. Greene stresses that he builds Newport, RI, furniture. The bombe chest, OTOH, is AFAIK, is a form that only originated in Boston. (We're excluding the French forms, here, which I find as repulsive as David finds the Philadelphia turret top tea table.) You have to dig deep into his site to verify that he builds both of these furniture forms.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#45

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

david weaver

Several is an understatement.

It's unlikely to change what most of us can plane or not plane, though.

Looks like one of the nicer more straight-forward furniture making operations I've seen.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#46

Re: An injection of reality

roger lance

The reality is that this type of subject is what is popular on this site. But, I did have to get out the dictionary and look-up "arcane" and "prosaic".....and that's a good thing.....we just don't talk like that here in these parts.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#47

learn to cut your joints more accurately


Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#48

Reality . . . that's OK for some folks

Winton Applegate

but I prefer this stuff.

That's a quote from a Douglas Adams book. Any hoopy froods over here ? Not a one on Neander.

Any way, two points/questions (ope there's three now):

I have been told I sound like " I think I invented woodworking" . OK I will stop pounding the table about the small kernels I have discovered in the vast field of HAND TOOL woodworking. Again I would emphasize that what I know is very limited and very small but diamond hard because it has stood up to countless proofs.

For example, I could use several of my planes and with full confidence plane the rail KNOWING there would be no tear out. It's not me or the plane but the method that counts. The sharpening method I use is not mine just the one I learned from trying them all.

IN THE SAME BREATH I will say David has solid argument for his FASTER method of machine grind and a stone or two and a REAL strop. Many of the best REAL woodworkers do just that. I can't argue with that.

Secondly (actually early on in the discussion ) I posted a question that didn't fully post maybe because I posted from my iPad and cut and pasted a word or two and then went back to my font from the pad; near as I can tell that was what caused the failure to post. I'm on the desk top now.

any way

on my end I can't see Derek's original photos just tiny blue rectangles with a question mark in each. Can some one tell me what I do to get the photos to show on my end ? I see the other photos just fine.

Thirdly I come here for the fine details and esoteric stuff and insights.

I and others can get the everyday stuff out of books or other sites.

Keep the weird stuff coming,

I may not be able to own all the tools or do all the work discussed but I sure as heck want to learn about it.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#49

Re: Reality . . . that's OK for some folks

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have been told I sound like " I think I invented woodworking" .

Nope. It was someone else on this forum. I think his name is Charles :)

IN THE SAME BREATH I will say David has solid argument for his FASTER method of machine grind and a stone or two and a REAL strop. Many of the best REAL woodworkers do just that. I can't argue with that.

I do believe that there are other "real woodworkers" on this forum, although Charles may tell you otherwise :)

Hey Charlie, you know I am just yanking your chain! :D

Winton, here are the photos again - I linked them originally from the Australian website. Now I have them on Photobucket.





Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#50

Re: Reality . . . that's OK for some folks

Charles Stanford

I'll start reinventing the wheel when I can out woodwork the finest cabinetmakers from the 18th century and also those from Alan Peters' era.

Needless to say, don't expect any new inventions soon.