New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

Posts

Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#1

Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One of the members of the Aussie forum recently posted an interesting smoother. He collects Siegley planes and the #3 (type 7, around 1897) he showed is simply beautiful ...




What caught my eye was the adjustable mouth ...


What is also particularly interesting about it is that it is a single iron plane, at the time Bailey/Stanley were building planes with double irons.

The relevance of this is that there has been much discussion over the past year about the lost art of setting the chip breaker (in a double iron) for interlocked grain when smoothing. This is done in combination with a larger-than-average mouth (otherwise the shavings will jam it).

Here we have a single iron plane (i.e. no chip breaker) that instead uses the mouth size to control tear out. I asked him what was the angle of the frog on the Siegley. He replied it was 48 degrees (I suspect it is actually 47 1/2 degrees, the same as UK infills).

The issue is that the "lost art of the chip breaker" argues that this information faded into the background only fairly recently, somewhere in the last 20 or 30 years when most of the leading educationalists (video and books) in modern times only referred to the size of the mouth or the cutting angle as methods for controlling tear out.

Now the Siegley plane represents a design that precedes these years, is smack in the middle of the Stanley chip breaker period, and yet is not following that theory/method. Indeed, Siegley were purchased by Stanley and then continued to offer this design (rather than converting it to their format, or simply scrapping it to reduce competition).

What is suggests is that there may have always been two schools of thought for controlling tear out, and both with a history of success in use.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#2

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

David Charlesworth

Derek,

That is interesting. It seems to me that the question is "does it work?"

Colen Clenton sent me some interlocked, old growth Tasmanian Blackwood, as an example of an unplanable wood. I'm sure you could find something equally difficult in your workshop.

47 1/2 degree bed could be easily simulated with a 2 1/2 degree back bevel in a bedrock.

I very much doubt that this set up, even with the finest possible mouth is going to suceed on a really fractious timber.

Perhaps you could do some experiments and report?

best wishes,

David

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#3

craigd

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

craigd

For me and the woods I work with, 50° seems to be the knee of the curve where a single iron performs as well as a double. This seems to match Old Street, who use 50° single irons for their wooden planes. I don't have the skills to plane the nasty woods in my "collection" (some tropicals and some garbage softwoods), I can't even scrape them. Note that there is nothing scientific about my testing.

My fleet includes 45° Stanley's (with various mods), 45° BD/SI smoother, 47.5° Stanley copy, several 50° BD/SI smoothers, 50-55° BU smoothers, 55° BD/SI smoother and 60° Gordon smoothers. Mouth openings are anywhere from 0.0015" (stupid small but actually works) to 0.030". My preference is 0.006-0.009" for single irons.

Something I need to try is a 50° double iron.

Maybe Wilbur can send Warren a chunk of his nasty to see what happens.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#4

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The issue is that the "lost art of the chip breaker" argues that this information faded into the background only fairly recently, somewhere in the last 20 or 30 years when most of the leading educationalists (video and books) in modern times only referred to the size of the mouth or the cutting angle as methods for controlling tear out.

Where in the world did you get the idea that this skill faded in the last 20 or 30 years?? I can assure you that very few people were planing fine surfaces 40 years ago. Faded in the last 150 years is a lot closer to the mark. The golden age for double iron plane use was probably around 1800.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#5

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Where in the world did you get the idea that this skill faded in the last 20 or 30 years?? I can assure you that very few people were planing fine surfaces 40 years ago. Faded in the last 150 years is a lot closer to the mark. The golden age for double iron plane use was probably around 1800.

Warren, I think that you have misunderstood my comment. I am not referring to a "golden age" for double irons, but simply that 100 years ago there is some evidence that there was likely to have been a similar choice, perhaps even debate, as we have currently in methods of controlling tear out. I am not advocating one method over the other - simply taking note of a single iron plane design that contrasts with the Stanley double iron as evidence that the duality of methods existed.

My identification of the last 20 or 30 years is also a reference to the influence of the internet, woodworking magazines, and other media in which a "modern" breed of teacher defocussed use of the chip breaker in controlling tear out.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#6

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That is interesting. It seems to me that the question is "does it work?"

Colen Clenton sent me some interlocked, old growth Tasmanian Blackwood, as an example of an unplanable wood. I'm sure you could find something equally difficult in your workshop.

47 1/2 degree bed could be easily simulated with a 2 1/2 degree back bevel in a bedrock.

I very much doubt that this set up, even with the finest possible mouth is going to suceed on a really fractious timber.

Perhaps you could do some experiments and report?

Hi David

I have done considerable "experiments" over the years. I largely work with West Australian timbers, and these are all interlocked and hard. No doubt this has to do with the ying and yang of living in paradise :) ..... sunshine forever, the best beaches and watersport in the world, great breweries, amazing vineyards, BBQ and crayfish ... and the world's hardest, most interlocked woods imaginable. However they are beautiful ... eventually.

Amongst others, I have a 47 degree Spier infill smoother and several Stanleys. Pre-chipbreaker, these were discarded long ago for woods such as Jarrah, Karri, She-oak, etc. They were fine on Tasmanian Oak and Tasmanian Blackwood, which are relatively tame, straight-grained woods. Even a couple of LNs (#3 and #4 1/2) with 55 degree frogs struggled to tame tear out (again, pre- chipbreaker). The only planes that I could rely on were HNT Gordons (60 degree bed) and LV BU smoothers (62 degree cutting angles).

I do not find much difference (on my woods) between a 45- and a 50-degree cutting angle. A significant jump from 45 degrees is 55 degrees. Consequently, the 47 1/2 degrees of the Siegley (as with the Spier) is not enough to call it a high angle plane. It may be sufficient for US woods, however.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#7

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It turns out that this plane has an adjustable, integrated chip breaker!

http://www.handplanepatents.com/no-510096-bench-plane-jacob-siegley-1893/

Who cares if it worked or not. More relevantly, it was intended to work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#8

Re: Have we...

david weaver

Have we seen a top level plane (I'd consider a bailey plane to be top level because it doesn't lack any functionality, and a common pitch single iron late 1800s ohio tool plane to not be top level) that was developed before the recent era of gentleman woodworking that didn't have a double iron?

Not scrub planes, as those have generally not, but bench planes designed for medium heavy work and finer?

A year and some on in this whole experiment and I am convinced so much by the cap iron that I suspect that the list of commercial successes without a double iron *before* the bulk of sales to beginning woodworkers is probably going to be pretty short. Just a hunch of mine.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#9

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

cstanford

Somebody send some to Warren. Soon. Please.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#10

Re: Have we...

William Duffield

It has happened before, as evidenced by the Stanley #62 and #164, low angle bevel up adjustable mouth jack and smoother planes, which had a much shorter production run and never sold nearly as well as their Bailey design planes. I once saw a Stanley #164R rabbet plane. It evidently never got beyond the prototype stage. The #10, #10-1/4 and #10-1/2 carriage makers rabbet planes had a much longer production run. I don't suppose Rob or Tom would divulge relative sales of their improved versions of these, and we don't have any sales numbers for Stanley either, but it would be an interesting comparison. It would become even more interesting as the current generation of dilettante woodworkers begin to accept the evidence shown by the Kato-Kawai experiments.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#11

Re: from Wilbur  *LINK*


Erratum

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#12

Re: Have we...

david weaver

The carriage maker planes were double iron planes, and B&G says that stanley advertised the #62 as a plane designed for heavy across-the-grain work (I don't know if he means end grain or strictly face work directly across the grain - neither of those two get any benefit from a chipbreaker, though).

I was thinking about the #62 when I said that, but since the volume was pretty low, I didn't mention it.

I had a couple of LV low angle planes at one point. I should've tried them across the grain!!! Maybe I would've kept them if I did.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#13

Re: Have we...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It has happened before, as evidenced by the Stanley #62 and #164, low angle bevel up adjustable mouth jack and smoother planes, which had a much shorter production run and never sold nearly as well as their Bailey design planes. I once saw a Stanley #164R rabbet plane. It evidently never got beyond the prototype stage. The #10, #10-1/4 and #10-1/2 carriage makers rabbet planes had a much longer production run. I don't suppose Rob or Tom would divulge relative sales of their improved versions of these, and we don't have any sales numbers for Stanley either, but it would be an interesting comparison. It would become even more interesting as the current generation of dilettante woodworkers begin to accept the evidence shown by the Kato-Kawai experiments.

Hi William

I do not see that one can compare the vintage BU planes with their modern counterparts. The vintage versions were hamstrung by the materials from which they were constructed, namely grey iron. this was brittle and fragile. A low 12 degree bed did not last long. I have a vintage Stanley #62 which such a mouth. A very nice plane, but it is retired to the shelf as I have better planes.

The modern versions are, as you are aware, built from ductile iron, and are a different beast altogether.

While I appreciate the value of a chip breaker in my Bailey-type planes, the fact is that the BU planes with high cutting angles made it possible to work on a much higher level when I began using them going on 10 years ago. Today they are no less an important part of my plane collection. I have added Bailey planes to the "more complex wood" armoury, but the BU planes and the high angle woodies are still easier to use on the woods I have.

If you have not used a BU Jack (with a low cutting angle) across the grain when jointing panels, then you are in for a treat.

The object of my original post was not to stimulate a BU vs BD discussion - for some reason forumites like to do this. It was really to indicate that there are two options available, not just one.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#14

Re: Have we...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Yes, of course, I mentioned the #10 planes as a contrast to the #164R. I have a #10 Stanley with a L-N replacement blade. The Stanley blade was totally used up when I got the plane.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#15

Re: Durability...

david weaver

If stanley had decided that bevel up was important, they could easily have produced many planes with a 20 degree bed, at which they would have less or no durability issues.

I believe their old literature suggests a honing angle of 25 degrees for their irons (I think they hold up a lot better at 30, just like pretty much every other iron ever made), which would have still been around 45 degrees.

One could almost guarantee that there were people at stanley developing and testing all kinds of things we never saw.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#16

oops...

david weaver

..pardon my misinterpretation of what you were saying about the carriage maker's planes.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#17

Re: Have we...

William Duffield

But you can compare them. People do it all the time. There's even a large Sour Grapes contingent out there who claim that the Lie-Neilsen planes and other tools, all of them, are nothing more than pirated copies of the Stanleys.

I don't believe that any more than you do. On the other hand, there are huge numbers of cast (not ductile) iron Stanley, MF, Sargent, Record, etc. planes out there which have not self destructed. I also have a vintage Stanley #62, which was worked hard for many years, but which still has a perfect mouth. I also prefer ductile iron planes, with thick blades of improved steel, but I don't retire my Stanleys.

Another argument against the #62 is that Stanley advertised it as a "block plane" and for planing cross grain. Really, the text says for "cross grain and end grain," but this may just be a semantics issue. I think some people may have used them for flattening end grain maple butcher blocks, a brutal task for any pllane. Also, some people suggest shooting end grain with them, but unlike a Bailey, there's no place to put your thumb if using it on a shooting board.

Stanley's advertising certainly hasn't inhibited modern manufacturers from advertising them and modern woodworkers from using them for a wide range of functions, thus the more appropriate term "bevel up jack." "Different," yes, but "different altogether" seems a little strong.

I agree with you, there are two very valid options available. The B U planes are easier to buy and easier to set up and use, and some of the Bailey/Bedrock advantages are very subtle, and difficult to explain, especially to beginners and especially concerning the interaction between the chip breaker and different woods with different physical characteristics. I know I was puzzled for quite a while about why it was called a chip breaker, and I only slowly came to realize that that's really what it does. The Kato-Kawai studies and translation finally clarified it all, and I understand why I still have some wood that is almost impossible to plane without tearout. But I haven't given up and taken it to Warren, yet.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#18

Re: One thing...

david weaver

.. if you talk to any machinist or manufacturer about the quality of the LN planes vs. the stanley, it's pretty clear that they are much more impressed with the LN.

If you talk to a beginner, they're impressed with how hard the LN irons are (and that they're thicker).

LN planes are better made if you make any objective criteria other than preferability of an experienced craftsman, and then if you do that they may still be preferable.

BUT, it's clear to me that they had no idea how to use the cap iron properly because they have a rash of planes out there where the cap iron is drilled such that it literally can't get close enough to the end of the iron to do smoother work. I have a #7 that is so far on the bleeding edge of adjustment for a jointer setting that it's almost not contacting the adjuster. If it was a smoother, I may not be able to get what I wanted out of it (I'm sure the iron and cap iron of that pattern were used in 4 1/2s).

They have also stated that they recommend buying a high pitch frog as tearout mitigation because using a cap iron is too fiddly (or I have heard third-hand that is deneb's suggestion).

Their cap iron is a more glitzy more expensive to produce item than the stamped cap iron that stanley used, but in use, it is no improvement and I actually don't like it quite as much as the stanley type, which out of all of my planes is the best functioning design to mitigate tearout without any fiddling. Everything works well as stock.

So I don't think it's really an improvement, but I don't know their motivation for making it, either.

I don't expect they're going to have a lot of regard for my opinion on the things, though, as I've been running around calling the bailey design the closest to perfect that I've seen on any plane. All of the things that I thought were drawbacks before have been eliminated as such with the use of the cap iron, including how soft the irons are and how thin they are.

Even for coarse work now, I like the stanley stock thickness items and the original design chipbreaker better.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#19

Re: oops...

William Duffield

No, my fault. I have about as much difficulty as Mahler with keeping to a single subject. I don't know if it's ADD or CRS. :D

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#20

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate 

Charles Stanford

What would you use to smooth the turrets on this tea table?


Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#21

Re: One thing...

Charles Stanford

They added beef and they added glitz where none was really needed. The overall machining is nice but performance is not vastly improved over a relatively minimally fettled Bailey. A thicker iron and overall mass helps stop chatter at the start of a cut. So does skewing a Bailey until it's on the board and running. And one should plan to trim ends anyway when the construction will allow -- just like trimming ends to eliminate snipe when using machine tools. You plan for it.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#22

Re: One thing...

david weaver

Can't disagree with any of that. Spent the last week building kitchen cabinet #4 using stock irons and nothing but a lilywhite and liberal pressure on bare leather right after it. the hardness of the iron makes a lot of sense when used on the washita and the cap iron lets the whole works continue to work well without mangling the wood despite less than perfect sharpness.

The other thing the thick irons do is pretty much eliminate the ability to easily grind an iron, especially if someone is not using diamonds.

But in a showroom test where you're not allowed to break a sweat, the heavy plane with the thick iron always feels better. It's the cadillac effect.

By far the best iron I have used so far in a smoother though is the tiny thin iron that tsunesaburo makes that has a super hard wafer thin cutting edge and is laminated. It can be ground easily by hand if you want (I still power grind it) but it holds an edge like carbide and hones like carbon.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#23

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

William Duffield

Is this a trick question? They're veneered, and then they're scraped.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#24

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate

david weaver

If they are hood turrets, I'd knock them down with a bismarck smoother.

Re: Adding to the chip breaker-single iron debate ...

#25

Re: the only thing worse...

david weaver

...than spending all of the time and learning the skills to make that table would be having to display it in my house.

It reminds me of continuous sweep picking on the guitar. Takes a lot of practice and timing, sounds awful.