New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

"Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Posts

"Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#1

"Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

Finally, a proper workbench. My interpretation of the LN Improved workbench. Hard maple, LN vise hardware, oil/varnish finish. I couldn't be more pleased with the outcome. Having built this, I do have a new appreciation for how thin the profit margins must be at LN for the pre-made bench. Huge investment of time and effort to build this, but I'm not the fastest woodworker.

[img[URL=http://s1118.photobucket.com/user/PJPictures/media/IMG_3023_zpsa58ba3b3.jpg.html][/URL]

[img[URL=http://s1118.photobucket.com/user/PJPictures/media/IMG_3020_zps68ec9077.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#2

Phil's Workbench

roger lance

Congratulations, Phil....you did a great job....beautiful bench....hope you spend uncountable hours using it and have a well earned sense of pride and accomplishment each and every time you gaze upon it.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#3

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Charles Stanford

That's a real 'beaut. Classic, no-nonsense, un frou-frou'd cabinetmaker's workbench favored by the likes of Alan Peters. No reason that bench can't last two or three woodworkers' lifetimes.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#4

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Great bench Phil. Stout and solid. Great vises. Nice proportions. Looks like it will be wonderful to build on.

What is its length, width and height? Thickness of the top?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#5

Phil's bench- It is a beaut!


Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#6

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

Thanks Derek. Bench is 6' long x 2' wide by 35" high, with a 4" thick (solid) top. Took quite a while to mill out the space for the front vise hardware: not sure I want to ever do that again. Tail vise not as thick as rest of bench since I had to mill out large portion of that jaw for vise mechanicals, but still pretty sturdy.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#7

Re: Phil's Workbench

Phil

Thanks Roger. Its already in use. First project: making a batch of dogs.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#8

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

Thanks Charles. I lean toward Shaker most of the time, so in fact this is about as fancy as I've ever done (I try to stick to 90 degree angles whenever possible). I'll be toning it down for the next project.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#9

Thanks!


Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#10

Almost Forgot: Shout-out to .....

Phil

Almost forgot: shout-out to:

Parkerville Wood Products: good folks at this establishment in Manchester, CT did a bang-up job sanding the top of my bench with their nuclear powered 42” sander: just a 32nd off the top and bottom got it flat (not bad at al)

Connecticut Valley School of Woodworking and FWW Blog: Bob VanDyke at the connecticut valley school of WW and FWW blog on a bench build led me to realize the value of having top sanded to ensure flat top.

Lie-Nielsen Toolworks: vise hardware up to the same high quality as their other products: particularly impressed with use of needle bearings which make for smooth vise action.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#11

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

William Duffield

Very nice bench, Phil. I'm sure it will serve you well. Nothing beats hard maple.

There are a couple of things that bother me about the "Scandinavian" bench, but then all bench designs are compromises.

- What is your strategy for jointing the edges of log boards?

- What is your strategy for dovetailing chests and the carcasses for cabinets?

I suspect you will eventually decide you need to build a board jack or a deadman. The board jack will be a bit of a trick, since I'll bet you haven't put a groove in the bottom of the top very close to the front, and your front stretcher is a well set back from the front face of the bench.

- I notice that the dogs in your tail vise have the same modulus as the dogs along the front of the bench. That spacing doesn't save you any cranking effort over only one dog hole. If you spaced two of them at half the spacing of the modulus, or spaced three of them at 2/3 and 4/3 of the modulus you would be able to change board lengths by moving one dog and a lot less spinning of the vise handle.

- Are you planning to add round holes for holdfasts?

Please understand that this is not meant to be a criticism of your bench design. I just though that this was a good place to start a discussion of pros and cons of different bench designs. I've worked on and built benches that have much more serious shortcomings than yours. I've also worked on benches with flat front surfaces and leg vises. I've worked on Nicholson benches, German benches, English benches and kludges. Note that I am not a proponent of the Roubo; it is not the be all and end all of bench designs, but it can be made to work. Also, edge jointing isn't a critical operation, especially if you have a powered jointer. And, you can clamp a Moxon vise to the top of any bench for dovetailing.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#12

How does a sander flatten?

Alex Y

Beautiful looking bench! I'm envious. But a question: you said

Parkerville Wood Products: good folks at this establishment in Manchester, CT did a bang-up job sanding the top of my bench with their nuclear powered 42” sander: just a 32nd off the top and bottom got it flat (not bad at al)


Not familiar enough with these beasts, but I don't understand how they flatten. I know my little lunchbox planer just gives me a relatively smooth surface that duplicates the twist and bow of the opposite face. Do the sanders like you reference have a huge table that lets you establish a plane rather than just thicknessing? Or do you have to flatten first with planes before sanding for smoothness?

Just curious.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#13

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Sir William says: - I notice that the dogs in your tail vise have the same modulus as the dogs along the front of the bench. That spacing doesn't save you any cranking effort over only one dog hole. If you spaced two of them at half the spacing of the modulus, or spaced three of them at 2/3 and 4/3 of the modulus you would be able to change board lengths by moving one dog and a lot less spinning of the vise handle.

If I could have a re-do of my bench (which, BTW, is a lot like Phil's) it would be the dog spacing. I didn't think that through when I built it about 30 years ago, and every time I use it, it bites me in the butt. I might have to dig another dog hole into the tail.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#14

Re: How does a sander flatten?

Phil

In a sense it acts like a planer providing a flat surface, but not necessarily parallel to the opposing surface. The fact that they only had to take about 1/32" off each surface suggests that I got the glue-up pretty flat to begin with. A half hour on one of these sanders sure beats me attempting to flatten it with hand planes (lots of changes in grain direction all over the top: would not have been a fun adventure.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#15

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

You ask many good and interesting questions, but I'm afraid if I attempted to answer them in detail, there would be no doubt left regarding the shallowness of my understanding as it pertains to the fine art of bench design.

Perhaps the best way to answer your questions is to tell a short story. Some time ago, I thought it might be a good idea to investigate water stones for sharpening (at the time I was using scary sharp). After reading all the articles and following all the multiple page forum posts on the various materials and grits and colors and sources of the dozens of different stones, I decided to punt and stick with sandpaper sharpening: it was just too complicated. No regrets.

Over the 15 years or so I've been woodworking, I've always wanted a real joinery bench, but it always got pushed to the back burner. I've read at least two books on bench design, multiple magazine articles, and countless forum posts on the best/latest designs from Roubo to Rube Goldberg. When it finally came time to put pen to paper, it started to look like the water stone adventure all over again. Time to punt again. The base design is simply what my minds eye told me the base should look like. The top is a knock-off of the LN improved bench. I figure you can't go too far wrong copying LN. I am planning on adding a sliding deadman (stay tuned for a future post on that). But I thought building what I built was better than spending excessive time trying to build the ultimate bench (paralysis by analysis is to be avoided at all costs).

My bench has lots of function and the form that I like. Form to me is as important as function: this is not just a tool to build furniture, its an accomplishment in itself, and I hope it inspires me and my heirs to do some some high quality woodworking over the many years ahead. I know that does not answer your questions, but I hope it addresses the intent of your inquiry.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#16

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

To be honest, I think I spent about 15 minutes on the spacing of the dog holes. The spacing on the tail vise is per the LN spec. The spacing on the field of the bench is per an article by Chris Schwartz. I had to fit the last one without interfering with the base or the vise screw, so after some adjusting, I came up with the spacing you see in the picture. Its a hobby: I have lots of time to spin that vise handle: I need the exercise anyway.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#17

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I didn't think about the spacing, either. I built the version that is in one of the Tage Frid books from the early '80's. Yours is much nicer than mine; you did a very nice job.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#18

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

wilbur

If it wasn't for my workbench, I'd be highly jealous of yours. But I am really jealous of all the natural light you have in your workshop.

Nice job!

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#19

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

wilbur

Nothing beats hard maple for a workbench, except Douglas fir. ;)

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#20

Phil's Workbench

roger lance

Phil....I really like your bench, your reply below (re waterstones), and your bright and orderly shop.

No bench design is perfect. All have some short coming. But your design will do 95% of what you ask of it well....and what is wrong with that???.....and the shortcomings can be dealt with as they present themselves.....your creativity will see to that. I offer below a photo of a bench slave which can be made in a multitude of designs to help support long stock....


To you and Bruce, if the dog hole spacing is not optimal on your tail vise (time will tell), how difficult would it be to remake the tail vise block???....not that difficult....a PITA, but doable.....remember there is a very good woodworker, who posts here, that glued in his dog hole strip backwards.....but he simply corrected his mistake and moved on....the mistake was not that important, but solving it was.

Enjoy that bench, Phil.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#21

Re: Phil's Workbench

William Duffield

That's what I meant by a "deadman". There are lots of names for it, and lots of designs. I've worked on benches with tool drawers underneath, and the only contrivance I had for holding boards on edge was to pull out one of the drawers and rest the board on that. I needed to clean shavings out of the drawers on a regular basis.

Phil has some good points: While his dog spacing may not be "optimal," it certainly works well enough for all hobbyist purposes, and even for professionals. Even if you have a large, complicated job to do, most repetitive operations will be done on parts that are the same thickness, or length, or width, and you don't need to move the vise jaws a long distance until setting up the next batch operation. Almost no one thinks about optimizing dog hole spacing, especially when they design their first bench, and the vise hardware almost always gets in the way.

The only reason bench plans specify dog hole spacing is because people using the plans ask. The practicality is it is based on whatever piece of scrap the builder found laying around the shop and picked up to make the jig for excavating the dog holes. In a modern setting, that might be a 1x4, so he ended up with 3-1/2" spacing. In a more traditional setting, where the dog holes might be sawn out, a pair of dividers might be used to walk off the spacing, and adjusted until the holes took up most of the space between the vises.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#22

Re: Phil's Workbench

Phil

Speaking of nice benches, your bench is the one I'm building when I decide to go all Shaker: outstanding. Your bench slave looks like it was custom made: for my bench! I have this idea that I can come up with a sliding deadman design that is at once a work of art and at the same time do-able in about a half an hour from scraps laying on the floor: I'll keep everyone posted on that when I have something to report.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#23

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Phil

Thanks. I went overboard on the windows on that project: left me with little wall space for storage. But it is nice to be working at the bench, with a view of the woods, and the occasional bear family that saunters by.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#25

Re: Phil's Workbench

Phil

Funny: that was a teachable moment. Believe it or not, when I was routing the dog holes, I remembered that episode, and checked 3 or 4 times that I didn't have everything backwards and upside down. Isn't that the best way to learn: from others mistakes? :)