New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

"Improved" Version of LN Workbench

Posts

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#26

Jack Guzman from Maine

windows

Jack Guzman from Maine

Phil,

You can always find a place to put stuff but light is a precious commodity.I spent years in my windowless dungeon.When I got a chance to add a room to my shop it put in as many windows as would fit. I use window sills for small tool storage. Hang clamps from racks over the window.---Jack

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#27

"Amen" to that

Alex Y

Phil, you said

this is not just a tool to build furniture, its an accomplishment in itself, and I hope it inspires me and my heirs to do some some high quality woodworking over the many years ahead.
There are some who say that a bench should just be sturdy, with a couple of layers of ply topped by a replaceable layer of hardboard. And that's probably the best kind of bench to build to work on your lawn mower engine. But for fine woodworking, you hit the nail on the head. I tend to be somewhat messy, but the bench I built stays cleaner than anything else in the shop. Mine doesn't look as nice as yours, but the pride of what went into it does inspire me when I'm in the shop.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#28

Re: How does a sander flatten?

William Duffield

The drum sanders, often referred to as "Time Savers", after an early brand, are not designed to flatten. That job should have already been done by a jointer, a planer, and judicious use of clamps during glue-up. The sander is designed to get an already trued surface flat, removing planer scallops, compression and burnishing, glue squeeze out, minor tearout, etc. to minimize the amount of work with fine grits in a ROS to get the surface ready for finishing. They do not use the high pressure feed rollers that a planer uses, and thus do not temporarily flatten a cupped board. Likewise, they cannot fix a bowed or a twisted surface. Instead, the work is gently transported under the sanding drum (or drums) on a conveyor belt, usually made from a large sanding belt.

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#29

Re: How does a sander flatten?

Phil

Interesting. I was told by the folks in the shop that is does flatten like a planer: leaves flat surface but not necessarily two parallel surfaces. Operator dialed in how much he wanted removed in thousandths of an inch for each pass. Here is pic of the type of machine I'm talking about (found this on web: not the exact machine I used, but close enough)


img

Re: "Improved" Version of LN Workbench

#30

Re: How does a sander flatten?

William Duffield

What he told you is mostly true, but there are a few subtle differences between the two classes of machinery. First, a planer will take off an eighth (or even more on narrow stock) in one pass, while a drum sander shouldn't be asked to take off more than a thirty second. If you try to take off too much, you will overheat and load up the abrasive. On the other hand, if you try to take off too little with the planer, the toothed infeed rollers and the antikickback pawls will leave marks in the surface that will require additional sanding to remove.

The most important difference is in how they handle cupped boards. The planer has a massive frame, and applies so much pressure with the infeed and outfeed rollers that it squashes the cup right out of the board while it passes through the cutter. The board then springs back when it exits the planer, and the cup is still there. The drum sander only takes off the middle of the crown, or the edges if you feed it in with the crown down. This effect, however, is almost negligible on a 4" thick bench top, so, yeah, you can simplify your understanding of what is happening in your particular case, and say they both work the same way. When you work with thinner material, the differences become much more pronounced. Two more differences that can be important: First, direction of feed is important in a planer. If you feed in the wrong direction, you can get much more tear out, but grain direction is not important to a drum sander. Second, on very thin stock, the intermittent force of the planer blades striking the surface of the stock can actually shatter it. Again, this is not a problem with a sander.

They are both blind to twisted, warped and bowed boards, and of course to the edges. Those are all defects that must be removed with a jointer before feeding the boards to either a planer or a drum sander.