Re: What is the minimum set of tools?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
.....
Then there are things that I'm less sure about - like chisels. I know Chris Schwarz says you can get by with 1/4" and 3/4" (which is what I have).
My main goal now was to get the tools that are demonstrated in the video for the project I'm doing now - the Shaker Table that Schwarz does. When I survey the tools that I don't have that are used in the video, here's what I come up with:
Shoulder Plane for adjusting tenons for the apron to leg connection
Plough Plane for making grooves for the drawer bottoms
Router plane for leveling tenon cheeks
Skew block plane for the '140' trick on the dovetails
Of those, I could use a chisel to pare the tenon shoulders and cheeks reducing the need for the Shoulder and the Router. I can certainly do dovetails without the '140' trick so I could do without the skew block plane. I could saw and chisel out the grooves for the drawer bottoms. I could also level the bottom of them (or if patient completely cut) with the Router plane instead of the plough.
So I could do without all of those things. The question is: would I want to? What would I learn from not using those tools if I could acquire them?
Hi Tony
What you are essentially asking is for the collected experience of members here to choose the best tools for you. While there is some wisdom in this - buy the best you can and avoid having to replace them - the problem is that we are a collection of woodworkers, and there are many opinions here, some quite divergent. Do you have someone whose work style you wish to emulate?
For example, choosing chisels is somewhat like opening Pandora's Box - the wider you open it, the more options you have, and the more expensive it can become since you are looking at quality tools. I will only touch on bench chisels, but there are mortice and others one could also consider.
Some will argue that you can mix-and-match chisels, or purchase only the sizes you need. However I would say that it is better to keep to a set since the chisels retain a family feel, and balance and control are more important than the steel. If you like your Blue Spruce, then stick to them. Sizes? It really depends on what you plan to do with the chisels, but I need from 1/8" upward. I am not a fan of very wide chisels (1 1/4" the widest I feel comfortable with), but do have up to 1 1/2". If asked which size I use the most, I may answer 3/4", but the truth is that they all get used, and I want them around for when I need them.
Shoulder plane? Mine get a lot of use: from tenon shoulders to tweeking to tuning rebates. The wide one (1 1/4") can also trim tenon cheeks. If you were to start with one, I'd get a LV Small (1/2" wide). This, the smallest size, is just right for most shoulders and rebates - better visibility and feedback. It will not work well on cheeks. (When I reviewed this plane I suggested the 3/4" Medium as the best to purchase if you could have only one. Some argue that the "one" to purchase is a 1 1/4 Large. I bought the Large on my recent Canadian trip and love it, but for most work the Small is a better choice).
The LV Small Plow has no competition. End of story. You need it for drawers and boxes (large and small). Get it. I would argue that you should do so before a moving filester since it can do temporary double duty in that disguise as well.
Router plane? Many uses, tenon cheeks is just one. Not an essential plane in that you can get away with a chisel if you are adept enough, but worth getting if you want a sure-fire solution. I use one for dados, hinge mortices, inlay, and stopped grooves/dados as well. I have used both the LV and the LN. Both good planes. The LV is simply better: wider range of blades, and easier blade change. For now, get the 1/4" and 1/2" blades (you can add others later).
Skew block plane for "140 trick". Nah. There are other ways to align boards when dovetailing, that will cost nothing. Spend the money on something else.
Have you budgeted for sharpening gear? The Tormek was suggested. I have one and swear by it. It is expensive, however, and would blow most of your budget. You could get a dry grinder much more cheaply, however I think that you would not like to practice on your nice new and expensive blades! Another option is a belt grinder. These should remove the steel safely and, since you seem to be headed towards a honing guide (to form a secondary bevel), it is not important to create a hollow grind.
Waterstones: speak with Stu.
Hope this helps.
Regards from Perth
Derek