New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Update on needing help on what to order next

Posts

Update on needing help on what to order next

#1

Update on needing help on what to order next

Tony Wilkins

Spent some time at the work bench today and got myself reacquainted with my OS jack plane. I'd like it to take a thicker shaving but I'm not willing to filed open the mouth any yet. I got it where it works very well.

Also spent some time with the Ohio Tool Co try plane. Sharp iron and chip beaker set correctly and it's working better. I'm still having to problems with it. (1) It's a bit ungainly to balance on the edge of a board with it's weight and height. (2) it's hard to set with so much wood to 'tap'; I was wailing on it with my adjusting hammer and it barely moved a bit.

So, after all is said and done I feel good about my smoother and jack. I'm not certain about my jointer/try solution. Are the two issues something I can (and would want to ) overcome with practice.

So that will leave me with (a) ordering a #7 from LN, (b) ordering a Krenov style jointer (expensive but I'm not sure I could make my own and have it work), (c) work on my technique with the wooden jointer (d) get a new wooden jointer for Philly with adjustments to make it easier for me.

BTW, I know there is a different technique for holding bailey style planes for edge jointing, is there a different holding technique for wooden jointers?

If I don't buy a try and with what money I have left over, I plan to order joinery plane goodies from LV (plough, fillester, shoulder, router)

TIA,

Tony

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#2

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

John in NM

I'd say work with the try plane before buying another. You'll probably find the LN jointer to be a beast.

Try the adjusting taps with the lever cap a bit looser than it would be in use, that should help the blade slide up and down a bit. Either loosen the lever some or back off the screw that it bears against.

I have to say it, don't buy a Krenov style plane. The whole point is that they are quick and easy to make. As I recall (and I may be wrong, I read this decades ago), Krenov's idea was that the desire to acquire every last metal plane for each specialized job shouldn't stand as an obstacle to woodworking, whether amateur or professional. Learn to quickly make a functional plane for the job at hand and get on with building was the idea. Making a Krenov style without the aid of power tools becomes much more of a task - especially if the reason to make the plane is the absence of the desired plane one might use to true the core block of the Krenov plane.

Just because the guys around here compare shaving thickness doesn't mean a new woodworker's skills and tools have to be up to the levels frequently claimed on the internet. Doing the work itself is much more important than the tools with which the work is done.

I can't drive a smoothing plane worth a darn (something always tears out), but I can make almost anything. I could have spent a lot of time practicing smoothing, practicing honing, shaving my arm hair off with the iron, and get to the point where I could smooth the nastiest gnarliest wood you could find.

But at that point, I wouldn't have made anything. I wouldn't know how to start making anything. I would only know how to practice using a plane or two. If the progress of actually finishing some projects requires the use of sandpaper, I am quite happy to use it.

Make a box or two. Nothing fancy, pine with butted and nailed corners. Make them the size to store planes, or chisels, or whatever. Make them for the practice and use them until you get sick of looking at them because you can now make something better. Until you can make something much better, you won't likely get tired of looking at them.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#3

Thanks John and on to a Chisel Question

Tony Wilkins

John, thanks for the encouragement. I did go out and play with the old try a bit and gave it the old college try so to speak. I felt a lot more comfortable with it the second time around, especially after setting it to a finer cut.

This leads me to another question. I currently have three chisels - two bench (1/4" and 3/4") from BS and one mortise (1/4") from LN. How much would filling out my bench chisels aid me in my woodworking? Or to put it another way, how much can I do with those two chisels?

I like to do business with Dave directly when I can but the latest update on more bench chisels is late summer. If I didn't wait for those, The Best Things has a 1 1/2" and a 5/8" still in stock IIRC. I'm also thinking about the LN and LV chisels, leaning towards the LN because I really like the handle on my mortise chisel.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#4

What to order....what to do....

roger lance

Tony.....you're like a young guy that has discovered women....which to date....I like her because she looks nice and she is blond and that really appeals to me and she smiled at me....I think she likes me.....maybe we should get married....hold up there kimo-sabe....take a breath.....you really need to do some dating.....go thru some good times and bad.....see what she's really like and how she really thinks.....maybe that blond hair will not be all that important....and in woodworking, you will be wise to take your time and make things....start building something and you will be able to answer these questions you have for yourself.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#5

Just trying to be wise with what I get


Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#6

Get some experience and you'll gain some wisdom.


Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#7

What is the minimum set of tools?

Tony Wilkins

I certainly can save the money and wait to spend it (even though I do admit to being like a kid in a candy store). There are things that I think I'm well equipped with like saws and bench planes (even though some part of me is curious to use a good metal plane).

Then there are things that I'm less sure about - like chisels. I know Chris Schwarz says you can get by with 1/4" and 3/4" (which is what I have).

My main goal now was to get the tools that are demonstrated in the video for the project I'm doing now - the Shaker Table that Schwarz does. When I survey the tools that I don't have that are used in the video, here's what I come up with:

Shoulder Plane for adjusting tenons for the apron to leg connection

Plough Plane for making grooves for the drawer bottoms

Router plane for leveling tenon cheeks

Skew block plane for the '140' trick on the dovetails

Of those, I could use a chisel to pare the tenon shoulders and cheeks reducing the need for the Shoulder and the Router. I can certainly do dovetails without the '140' trick so I could do without the skew block plane. I could saw and chisel out the grooves for the drawer bottoms. I could also level the bottom of them (or if patient completely cut) with the Router plane instead of the plough.

So I could do without all of those things. The question is: would I want to? What would I learn from not using those tools if I could acquire them?

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#8

Chisels...

John in NM

I have a bunch of 1980's vintage Sandvik chisels. Bought one of each size available from a used tool store that got them in some kind of bankruptcy lot. They were cheap, maybe $5 each, but definitely good chisels. I probably use the 1/2" more than the others, because it is a good size for a lot of things. Narrow enough for a lot of paring, but not so narrow that it's hard to register by eye for non-paring. Then I sometimes use a wider one, in the 3/4 to 1 range, depending on what I grab.

The point is that I don't actually need or often use all 7 or whatever I have. So I would just add a 1/2" to what you have. A 1/4" is very useful to have when you need it, so no waste there in having acquired one already.

The big wide one I have gets used for sharpening pencils. Seriously, that is just about it - the 1 1/2 width works well bevel down to sharpen them - narrower doesn't work. I sometimes use that chisel in construction to wale on a bit of 2x4 sticking out where is shouldn't, or use it to trim the cow's hooves (again, seriously :D ) if I can't find the Stanley hack chisel that I usually use for that.

As to brand, you may be asking the wrong guy - I like cheep :D

Best thing to me is to find high quality cheep, like those Sandviks or the Czech ones LV is now selling that Stephen recommends. I always drool over the Ashley Iles chisels, but never seem to spend the money on them. The exceptions to that rule for me have been when there is no good but cheap option readily available - such as with hand cut rasps, I bought the expensive one :D

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#9

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

roger lance

Tony....no one, but no one (including me) can tell you what the minimum number or correct number of tools are for you....you have to do that....and the best way is thru experience.....if by wise in your tool choices you mean will this tool be used by me to make things and therefore be a justified purchase?.....only you can answer that by knowing what you make and what you need to make it....if money is not an issue (only you know) and owning some of these tools will give you pleasure and satisfaction (only you know), then get the router, shoulder, and plough planes and get to working with them.....you said you have a couple of BS chisels....I had to think about that for awhile before I came up with Blue Spruce....I've never even seen a Blue Spruce tool (outside of a catalog), never touched one, never used one....I started out with a 4 chisel set of Stanleys that are favored by carpenters and got done what needed to be done.....I've now upgraded to some Pfiel Swiss Made....they get the job done on the dovetails I now make....and after I've used them for some years, I'll have developed some more insight into just what I really need or don't need in a dovetail chisel.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#10

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

John in NM

Although I'm not familiar with the project or how Schwarz approaches it, I can tell you that you can skip all those tools.

Your (new) 1/2" chisel will work fine for adjusting the tenon shoulders. I find use of the shoulder plane for this to be vastly over-rated, any benefits of using a plane for this task are (to me) outweighed by the challenge of work holding and tool holding and having to repeat whatever work holding method I come up with for each tenon. Now with your grip strength problems (if I remember correctly), that equation may well be different for you than me.

You can adjust the tenon cheeks with the larger chisel. Perhaps difficult than with a plane, or more difficult to keep the tenon cheeks co-planar and flat, but definitely do-able. If necessary, make the tenons smaller than specified, say 3/4" rather than 1". That may help with using the tools you have on hand, and it will not compromise the strength if the table is a small one, like an end table or hall table. If this is a large dining table then stick to the plan for tenon size.

Skip the 140 on principle. I have one, a dusty one - guess why it's dusty :D They are not especially useful, and whatever trick is done with one can probably be done with one of 3 other tools.

Now the plough is the best way to do what it does. But you can saw and waste out with the 1/4" chisel. I find that kind of sawing tough with a handsaw, compared to stuff like cutting dovetails or even tenon cheeks. I would still tell you to try the saw and waste method, but if you were to buy one tool out of that list, I would say buy the plough plane.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#11

Thanks Roger and John

Tony Wilkins

Hope I didn't come of as argumentative. I'm just chewing on the facts and you guys' experience. I'm glad you said that about the plough John - the kid in me wants to play with that one.

One thing I'm pretty sure I'm going to get is the set of David Charlesworth DVD's from LN. I saw snippets of them when someone put them up on youtube and I was very impressed. Thinking that might make up a little for not being able to go to classes.

One thing I thought I'd throw out there is that I am getting the more expensive, prettier tools as a bit of a 'payoff'. I've been saying for thirty years (since I was a teenager) that someday I'd learn woodworking. Finally now that I'm being put out to pasture from the Army I can.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#12

Could move up a project

Tony Wilkins

I've been planning to get some 8/4 maple and the benchcrafted hardware and do the moxon vise. I could use some of the money and do that after I finish my table. I'll have to chew on that one some.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#13

Yes. Twice


Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#14

About that table

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony,

How long is the top on that Shaker Table? Is it the White River one?

Wiley

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#15

The table top is 18" square


Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#16

Then you can face and edge join

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

the top pieces with a No. 5, with plenty to spare. I mention this because you seem to have an affinity with the No. 5.

Wiley

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#17

Re: I believe that...

Tom

one of the useful destinations in one's development is to get to the point where you no longer want to buy more stuff. In particular repeats. I don't know what gets you there in particular. Like you, I love trying out different stuff, and particularly as a newbie, probably hoped that there were magic bullet tools out there. I also think there is this great joy at getting certain new tools, and one tries to recapture that experience. But at the end of the day, you will probably loose interest in this. And the sooner the better.

I think it pays to find some way to kill the fascination with all this distracting tool stuff. Maybe one has to go through it. I know making my own tools works for me, because I don't feel commercial stuff is better and I am willing to accept the flaws in tools that I make that I might not accept in commercial tools. That could be a certain amount of bias, but practically speaking, if one can make the tool from scratch, one will avoid stuff that rubs one the wrong way. I think that is also why people buy the "best" tools, they say to themselves that at least then they can forget about the tools, but the marketers wont let one alone. There is always something "better".

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#18

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

Tom

"(even though some part of me is curious to use a good metal plane)."

If you can really use a wood plane, I can't see why you would want to drop down to inferior metal planes. For most uses wood planes are superior, but one can sympathise with people who want the belt and suspenders of some kludgy dials and levers. But if you already know how to work a wooden plane, why one earth would you debase yourself...

"Then there are things that I'm less sure about - like chisels. I know Chris Schwarz says you can get by with 1/4" and 3/4" (which is what I have)."

I like th 1/4 and the 1/2 the best, but there is a reason that they sell sets, and that guys then break up those sets to come up with pretexts for articles. Writing articles is a different mater than working wood. I would certainly complete a few sets of chisels.

"My main goal now was to get the tools that are demonstrated in the video for the project I'm doing now - the Shaker Table that Schwarz does. When I survey the tools that I don't have that are used in the video, here's what I come up with:"

good approach, so long as the given project is not too oddball.

"Shoulder Plane for adjusting tenons for the apron to leg connection"

I saw and don't adjust them. If they turn out badly, I saw them in contact.

"Router plane for leveling tenon cheeks"

Very generally useful tool. This is one, like a router table, that can be leveraged in a lot of ways.

"Skew block plane for the '140' trick on the dovetails"

I have the plane for this, but I never use it. I would not buy it unless I knew that I had to have it. If I had to ask, I wouldn't buy it.

"Of those, I could use a chisel to pare the tenon shoulders and cheeks reducing the need for the Shoulder and the Router. I can certainly do dovetails without the '140' trick so I could do without the skew block plane. I could saw and chisel out the grooves for the drawer bottoms. I could also level the bottom of them (or if patient completely cut) with the Router plane instead of the plough.

So I could do without all of those things. The question is: would I want to? What would I learn from not using those tools if I could acquire them?"

Presumably these tools arrived because people wanted to make more money, and found real solutions to real problems. Once you break it down into a pro and con leaning experience, it becomes pretty personal. I mean, you are going to put more bread on the table with the plow plane. I doubt there is any money in the 140 trick. But maybe it would make you a better person...

I'm not being snide here. I think it is a real problem. What is the basis for the evaluation. More aesthetic method; want fancy tools; want to do things in a complicated way; make more money; reduce skill required; learn new skill; reduce strain on body, make more durable product; keep tool clutter to minimum; save 140 dollars for cigarettes or college fund; reproduce original tool marks; ....

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#19

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.....

Then there are things that I'm less sure about - like chisels. I know Chris Schwarz says you can get by with 1/4" and 3/4" (which is what I have).

My main goal now was to get the tools that are demonstrated in the video for the project I'm doing now - the Shaker Table that Schwarz does. When I survey the tools that I don't have that are used in the video, here's what I come up with:

Shoulder Plane for adjusting tenons for the apron to leg connection

Plough Plane for making grooves for the drawer bottoms

Router plane for leveling tenon cheeks

Skew block plane for the '140' trick on the dovetails

Of those, I could use a chisel to pare the tenon shoulders and cheeks reducing the need for the Shoulder and the Router. I can certainly do dovetails without the '140' trick so I could do without the skew block plane. I could saw and chisel out the grooves for the drawer bottoms. I could also level the bottom of them (or if patient completely cut) with the Router plane instead of the plough.

So I could do without all of those things. The question is: would I want to? What would I learn from not using those tools if I could acquire them?

Hi Tony

What you are essentially asking is for the collected experience of members here to choose the best tools for you. While there is some wisdom in this - buy the best you can and avoid having to replace them - the problem is that we are a collection of woodworkers, and there are many opinions here, some quite divergent. Do you have someone whose work style you wish to emulate?

For example, choosing chisels is somewhat like opening Pandora's Box - the wider you open it, the more options you have, and the more expensive it can become since you are looking at quality tools. I will only touch on bench chisels, but there are mortice and others one could also consider.

Some will argue that you can mix-and-match chisels, or purchase only the sizes you need. However I would say that it is better to keep to a set since the chisels retain a family feel, and balance and control are more important than the steel. If you like your Blue Spruce, then stick to them. Sizes? It really depends on what you plan to do with the chisels, but I need from 1/8" upward. I am not a fan of very wide chisels (1 1/4" the widest I feel comfortable with), but do have up to 1 1/2". If asked which size I use the most, I may answer 3/4", but the truth is that they all get used, and I want them around for when I need them.

Shoulder plane? Mine get a lot of use: from tenon shoulders to tweeking to tuning rebates. The wide one (1 1/4") can also trim tenon cheeks. If you were to start with one, I'd get a LV Small (1/2" wide). This, the smallest size, is just right for most shoulders and rebates - better visibility and feedback. It will not work well on cheeks. (When I reviewed this plane I suggested the 3/4" Medium as the best to purchase if you could have only one. Some argue that the "one" to purchase is a 1 1/4 Large. I bought the Large on my recent Canadian trip and love it, but for most work the Small is a better choice).

The LV Small Plow has no competition. End of story. You need it for drawers and boxes (large and small). Get it. I would argue that you should do so before a moving filester since it can do temporary double duty in that disguise as well.

Router plane? Many uses, tenon cheeks is just one. Not an essential plane in that you can get away with a chisel if you are adept enough, but worth getting if you want a sure-fire solution. I use one for dados, hinge mortices, inlay, and stopped grooves/dados as well. I have used both the LV and the LN. Both good planes. The LV is simply better: wider range of blades, and easier blade change. For now, get the 1/4" and 1/2" blades (you can add others later).

Skew block plane for "140 trick". Nah. There are other ways to align boards when dovetailing, that will cost nothing. Spend the money on something else.

Have you budgeted for sharpening gear? The Tormek was suggested. I have one and swear by it. It is expensive, however, and would blow most of your budget. You could get a dry grinder much more cheaply, however I think that you would not like to practice on your nice new and expensive blades! Another option is a belt grinder. These should remove the steel safely and, since you seem to be headed towards a honing guide (to form a secondary bevel), it is not important to create a hollow grind.

Waterstones: speak with Stu.

Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#20

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

cstanford

I'll send you an email with Charles Hayward's list of a suggested 'bare minimum' hand tool kit and then tools to add on later. 'Ole Charlie wasn't afraid to tell you what you needed.

Bear in mind that most of the people giving you advice in this thread have as impressive a collection of power tools as they do hand tools and use them way more often than they are willing to let on. Nothing wrong with it - blended woodworking has been the standard for decades. Nothing has really changed.

It's amazing how much slog a Hammer tablesaw with slider, Laguna bandsaw, etc. will take out of "hand tool" woodworking.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#21

Re: What is the minimum set of tools?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You do need a plough plane for making grooves. The other tools you mention are not needed and could not be considered as part of any minimum set. I have never used a shoulder plane or a "140 plane" or "trick", and I made thousands of tenons before buying a router plane for carving work.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#22

Tormek Question

Tony Wilkins

I'm still looking at getting a Tormek T7 or a coarse water stone and flattener from Stu. Watched the Highland video and the Tormek is quite impressive. I ordered the Veritas MK II jig a couple of weeks ago and it should be here Monday so I'm wanting to try it out a bit on the waterstones.

Thanks for all the insight. Thanks especially for the patience as I ask all these newbie questions and I'll cop to obsessing a bit about the decision.

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#23

More to the same point

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony, you're facing a zillion choices and combinations, each with its adherents and sometimes nay-sayers. Each piece of advice represents a sincere conviction on someone's part, though the advice often contradicts.

How to break through all this overload of choice? The way forward is to find out what works for you. What works, what you reach for, whether you can rationalize it or not. You have said that you kinda like that trashed No. 5, busted tote and all.

So get a good sound No. 5, so you can work on your Shaker project. Get good with that plane. The experience gained, both from the plane and from the Shaker project, will begin to show you the remainder of the path forward. Build on your successes and your mistakes--it's all experience.

Don't get a 140. It's OK, but rarely the only thing that will do. What is the 140 trick, by the way? Rebating the inside edge of a drawer side to be dovetailed? Just guessing. If so, there are other ways to do that, or just don't do it.

The shoulder plane is a bit different. In this way: it can do more than trim tenon shoulders. It can also serve as a rebate plane, which is something that will be used from time to time, and nothing else will do its job. Clamp a fence down, and it will do anything, and do it better, than the 140. By the way, trimming tenon shoulders with a chisel is a high-skill/high-risk business. With the shoulder plane, just remember to put supporting sticks on the outside of the rail, so you don't break off slivers of rail when the plane exits the cut. Or else make partial cuts, always starting from the outside, and don't exit. Otherwise, you'll be down in the shavings, looking for that special sliver that you need to glue back on (and not finding it). Medium shoulder plane is a pretty good idea in my opinion, if you don't already own a good rebate plane.

People will also say, 'don't trim shoulders, practice your sawing so the shoulder is good right off the saw.' You can get that good after you do a whole bunch of them, but not before.

On the plough, are you doing 1/4" grooves? Because you like the metal bench plane, you may also prefer a metal plough, in that it's more compact. It's a smaller object in your hands if that matters. I prefer woodies, but the smaller size and compactness of the metal plough is something you might think about.

Wiley

Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#24

Good advice here


Re: Update on needing help on what to order next

#25

Another wierd thought

Ron Harper

I know that this will be controversial. C'est la vie..... If i were a young guy and a newbie who knew what I know now. I would spend a lot more energy and money in buying beautiful wood than I would in buying tools. You nanfind a good foundational tool kit at one good flea market. Beautiful wood?.. Harder to find.