Re: exceptions to the "rule"
Paul in NJ
At least one famous period furniture maker, SAPFM Cartouche winner Alf Sharp believes air dried wood is better. Here is a link to his business that sells air dried wood:
http://www.stonesriverhardwoods.com/air-dried-wood
I have had pretty good and pretty bad kiln dried wood. Some of it was just good fuel for my wood stove. My problem with commercial wood is that I have no control how it was cut or dried. Commercial wood is all about how much yield (profit) you can get from a log. It is rare to see boards wider than 10 or 12 inches in domestic hardwoods. The commercial furniture makers don't put much value on wide boards. They will glue up panels and stain them to bland uniformity.
I am pretty lucky because I live in the east (suburban NJ) where we have a lot of trees. There is always one falling in a storm or being removed for whatever reason. There are enough tree services around to cherry pick logs for portable bandsaw owners. I have a fellow in my woodworking club that owns one of these mills. He will saw the logs any way I want: any thickness, through and through, quarter sawn, for best yield, or any combination of the above. I just have to stack it, use a little common sense, and wait a little while. Big tree, wide wood! All this for $2.00 a board foot. Yes, $2.00 for walnut, cherry, sassafras, etc. I like the control from tree to finished furniture.
There are plenty of these mill owners where ever trees grow. Ask around at your local ww club. The bandsaw mill manufacturers will have names of sawyers near you, contact them. Unless you live in arid parts of this country you will be able to find wood to air dry. If you do live in arid regions you are probably paying high prices for hardwoods, why not give Alf some business and get some decent wood.
Paul Dzioba