New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Posts

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#51

citation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

R. Maeglin, Proceedings of the 15th annual Hardwood Research Council (1987) p100-108.

The instability of juvenile wood is why the hearts of hardwood trees are typically "boxed" at the mill, even if a clear face is showing(see discussion of sawing in my Article on hardwood lumber production in the Articles section. When I was sawing the log that yielded the board shown I chose to not box the heart and instead deal with the problems later.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#52

Re: Of all the people

david weaver

That is certainly the type of work where you get constant tactile feedback and can make a properly qualified statement.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#53

Re: Last Sentence is the Most Important

cstanford

Amen.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#54

Re: citation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Juvenile wood is abnormally fast growth near the pith that is characterized by large growth rings, unusually soft, low density wood, and excessive shrinkage on drying. It is much more common on softwoods.

In contrast your sample shows no fast growth rings at the area nearest the center. In addition, your sample shows more shrinkage on the side away from the pith, not shrinkage near the pith. No evidence of Juvenile wood.

Read Panshin and deZeeuw, or Hoadley.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#55

Re: citation

cstanford

Ran across this:

http://www.forestry.gov.uk/pdf/ICTQ1108_cameron.pdf/$file/ICTQ1108_cameron.pdf

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#56

Re: citation

cstanford

Here's another link:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/pdf1987/maegl87a.pdf

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#57

Re: Patrick Edwards on airdrying

cstanford

Out of date? Patrick Edwards still buys into it apparently.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#58

Re: Patrick Edwards on airdrying

cstanford

Ever heard of Alfred ("Alf") Sharp? He was the 2008 Cartouche Award winner from SAPFM. Other winners include Mack Headley, Gene Landon, Al Breed, Steve Lash, Phil Lowe.

Here's his lumber operation. It's all air-dried. Anybody on this board won a Cartouche Award?

http://www.stonesriverhardwoods.com/

Here's Alf's furniture website:

http://www.alfredsharp.com/

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#59

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Stephen Shepherd

Luthiers use air dried wood almost exclusively, also spruce piano sound boards are air dried.

Stephen

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#60

exceptions to the "rule"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a Mandolin maker locally that has a national reputation for fine instruments. He had a standing order with us and bought every stick of figured maple we received in our bundles of KD maple.

There is a lot of period furniture being made now days. Most of it is mahogany. I know of no source of air dried mahogany so I presume these people are building, apparently uneventfully, from KD stock.

The simple fact is that some people are going to obtain some green wood and the only choice they will have is to air dry it. If they know what they are doing, or they are lucky, it will turn out well and can be used for fine furniture. The vast majority of others will have no source of green wood to dry, and the sources of aid dried wood for sale are limited at best (which should tell you something about demand). These people will use KD wood with no more or less problems than the person that has access to air dried wood.

I suppose that since air dried wood is relatively scarce on the national scale it becomes human nature for those that have it to claim that they have something better than others, and proselytize a conversion to AD, regardless of the practicality of the proposal.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#61

Re: exceptions to the "rule"

Paul in NJ

At least one famous period furniture maker, SAPFM Cartouche winner Alf Sharp believes air dried wood is better. Here is a link to his business that sells air dried wood:

http://www.stonesriverhardwoods.com/air-dried-wood

I have had pretty good and pretty bad kiln dried wood. Some of it was just good fuel for my wood stove. My problem with commercial wood is that I have no control how it was cut or dried. Commercial wood is all about how much yield (profit) you can get from a log. It is rare to see boards wider than 10 or 12 inches in domestic hardwoods. The commercial furniture makers don't put much value on wide boards. They will glue up panels and stain them to bland uniformity.

I am pretty lucky because I live in the east (suburban NJ) where we have a lot of trees. There is always one falling in a storm or being removed for whatever reason. There are enough tree services around to cherry pick logs for portable bandsaw owners. I have a fellow in my woodworking club that owns one of these mills. He will saw the logs any way I want: any thickness, through and through, quarter sawn, for best yield, or any combination of the above. I just have to stack it, use a little common sense, and wait a little while. Big tree, wide wood! All this for $2.00 a board foot. Yes, $2.00 for walnut, cherry, sassafras, etc. I like the control from tree to finished furniture.

There are plenty of these mill owners where ever trees grow. Ask around at your local ww club. The bandsaw mill manufacturers will have names of sawyers near you, contact them. Unless you live in arid parts of this country you will be able to find wood to air dry. If you do live in arid regions you are probably paying high prices for hardwoods, why not give Alf some business and get some decent wood.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#62

Re: exceptions to the "rule"

cstanford

Don't worry about 'national scale.' You and I both have a source for air-dried wood right here in Tennessee -- Alf Sharp's operation (the 2008 SAPFM Cartouche Award winner by the way).

Here you go:

http://www.stonesriverhardwoods.com/

Here's Alf's furniture website:

http://www.alfredsharp.com/

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#63

I see Paul beat me to it


Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#64

If you put oven dry wood in a steam box

Keith Newton

After an hour, when you take it out, it will likely be around 18% MC. Well,,, you may say, why not just use KD for steaming? You can get internal checks from the quick gain on the surface expansion, which may not show up until later on in the process of shaping a part, then going back to step one of steaming is a royal pain.

If you started with AD at ~ 18% MC, then the steam doesn't change the gradient MC, so there is less chance of internal defect. Plus I suspect it may conduct the heat to be core better than dry wood, which would be a better insulator.

The heat is what plasticises the lignin, not the wetness. You can get it to bend with dry heat, but you can cause more problems with dry heat, like cooking it down to 0%, maybe checking the surface along the way, then what happens when it ends up in a home atmosphere, is that it will grow as it gains.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#65

I agree with Bill, tangential/radial shrinkage dif

Keith Newton

tangential/radial shrinkage differential. I'll also agree that there are some other difference in properties between juvi, and later on, but the cupping is mainly due to the two to one ratio being express around that curve.

A lot of woodworkers will generalize that green lumber will always cup away from the pith as it dries. But this isn't always so. You can, or I have cut plain sliced lumber where the annual rings were almost as flat as the green sawn face. Under that circumstance, it will dry as flat as a QS board will, but still shrink twice as much as the radial would.

And to take that even another degree, I have sawn boards from large trees which had buttress roots, or fluted sides, and they will cup toward the pith where the rings are reversed as they dry.

I know this is a hard thing to get your mind around, but I've been looking at it a long time. It is harder for us lumber users to understand, what we are looking at when studying a board. But Mother Nature didn't work out these details with a 4 x 4 in mind as the tree grew round.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#66

Re: Wood from the grassy knoll

Tom

"I suppose that since air dried wood is relatively scarce on the national scale it becomes human nature for those that have it to claim that they have something better than others, and proselytize a conversion to AD, regardless of the practicality of the proposal."

You always go there. There are no distinctions, just filthy cheats. While the arguments for economic advantage are always two sided anyway, with most of the real profit normally on your industrial side.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#67

Thanks for the link!!  You too, Charles!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Paul,

That's a great link to have, definitely a keeper. A trusted source, and the prices beat anything else available to me, KD or AD. I suppose he'll ship UPS loads.

Much thanks to you and Charles,

Wiley

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#68

Re: Wood from the grassy knoll

cstanford

Bill probably thinks Wal Mart carries quality merchandise just because they are the world's largest retailer, and of the 'impracticalities' of passing them by and shopping somewhere else. Just give in to the 'Borg. It will barely hurt for just a moment or two.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#69

Re: Thanks for the link!!  You too, Charles!

cstanford

I have plans to relieve the good fellow of a whole lot of ash and bend hell out of it.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#70

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

cstanford

John Makepeace apparently likes air dried wood:

http://www.johnmakepeacefurniture.com/john-makepeace-furniture-designer-maker-biography.html