New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Posts

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#26

Re: Of all the people

david weaver

I would imagine "a warren" weighs just as heavily as any of the names you mentioned. After all, he *is* making a living working wood by hand (not by supplementation otherwise as far as I know, and not be small expensive pieces).

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#27

Re: Reaching one's own conclusion

david weaver

At the beginning of this thread, we were talking about whether or not air dried wood has different working properties.

Now, instead of working kiln dried wood, we actually have to dry the wood to have an opinion?

How does someone who has dried a lot of wood but worked little of it by hand have a stronger opinion about how air dried vs. kiln works than someone who has worked both?

I agree with warren's assessment with what of it I've done (air dried vs. kiln dried beech, air dried vs. kiln dried cherry and air dried vs. kiln dried apple), it's usually subtle and is not constant across all woods. I'd also say with some certainty that the only way you're really going to be able to notice it is to dimension and finish it by hand.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#28

Re: Reaching one's own conclusion

CStanford

Good points and 5,000 bd. ft. of lumber is not much. That's how much it would take to start to understand the process. Maybe 5,000 feet each, of six to ten major species would be a beginning. I certainly don't have that sort of experience but I have enough dinking around to know that 5,000 feet is just that -dinking around.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#29

Re: Of all the people

CStanford

I don't disagree with that.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#30

Re: Yeah, see...

R Payne

If you are truly interested you can type into a search engine as easily as I can. Since you don't want to, I have to suspect you'd rather hold onto your notions that it makes no difference. And the amount of change may not make a difference to a woodworker but the changes are there.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#31

Maybe it's picking nits...

R Payne

But there are claims being made that kiln dried (properly) is NO different from properly air dried lumber. That isn't true. While I admit the amount of change is not likely to be noticed by most woodworkers (and I have to admit that what I've air dried are things not readily available commercially so I haven't worked the same species as kiln and air dried), to say that no difference exists is just wrong. A better way to say it is that the amount of difference isn't great enough to matter.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#32

you are of course correct

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For one thing volatiles are volatilized from the wood at 170F, a typical final for the wood in a kiln, that aren't at 80F. In the case of softwoods the higher temperature "sets the sap" where as in air dried the sap may ooze forever. In the case of hardwoods it is speculated that the removal of these volatiles is responsible for the lesser amount of moisture regain. During the steaming in the conditioning stage there is minor degradation of the cellulose. Lignin contains phenols which are prone to oxidation which presumably will occur more at the brief time the lumber is near the kiln temperature at the end of the cycle. Etc.

But for the big picture, for the person that has not formed an opinion through experience or revelation, will the KD process affect your ability to build stuff with hand tools? Oblique answer: The quality of either the air drying or kiln drying process coupled with the inherent variability of wood within a species are vastly more important variables to be concerned with.

As an example, when I contracted for someone to carve a molding for me I carefully selected a piece of lumber that had close growth rings, it had typical density, and from sawing and thickness planing it I knew it would work well no matter the tool. Its ease of working was noted by the carver and my care in selection was appreciated.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#33

more data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Shown is what some would consider a drying defect. This piece of oak is severely cupped as a result of drying.

It so happens that this is a piece of air dried oak. It was dried as part of a 300 bd ft pack of oak that had a special color I was interested in. A small pack like this one does not exert enough weight to mash lumber flat and keep it flat during drying. Had this board been part of a typical kiln charge it could have had tons of weight above it and it would have been mashed flat and kept flat. The conditioning step at the end of drying would have relaxed the stress of it being held flat against its will.

(this piece of lumber has juvenile wood at its center which shrinks more upon drying of any kind, resulting in the cup. Adjacent boards dried flat.)

Out of the props pile used for programs on drying I have given I could have also shown drying defects resulting from improper kiln operation, improper sawing, etc. The point is that there are a multitude of ways sawing, air drying and kiln drying can affect lumber quality and workability. Many of the KD defects one encounters can be traced to the air drying first step.

Dry it yourself and you can ruin or degrade lumber if you don't know what you are doing. Ditto at the kiln. Don't underestimate the ways you can screw up drying lumber. If you know what you are doing and have the luxury to do it, air drying will ensure a product as good as it gets(this is in fact what Peters was saying, if read carefully). So will buying from a properly managed lumber mill.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#34

Not at all...

John in NM

I do not claim there is no difference. I do claim that even a planing savant will be unable to distinguish the difference reliably in a double blind situation. Given that there are other variables, such as %MC, I believe that is a reasonable opinion to hold. But make no mistake, it is just an opinion :D

Rationalize the matter of a reference any way you like. Typically, those making a claim on a reference supply that reference rather than saying "look it up if you're not too lazy". Perhaps Bill has saved you the trouble? :D

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#35

Re: Reaching one's own conclusion

Tom

I don't think I have air dried that much, but it would be close. When you say you have do you mean you were there - or you cut your own wood, built your own kiln and selected the process? I'm sure I have walked through places that did that much a day, but I was just a customer.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#36

Re: How would one decide....?

Tom

"Wood from slow growing trees is typically easier to work than wood from faster growing trees."

Not true, it depends on the type of tree. Some woods like pine get harder/stronger from more growth rings, while others get undermined, like some ring porous woods. (I suppose the majority of the world's fine hardwoods occur where there aren't seasonal variation of sun exposure, which isn't out point here.)

"So what would it take to determine whether air dried was different than kiln dried? And what would be the specification for the air and kiln drying? Would the lumber have be "rushed in the KD process? Would it have been stress released after drying? How would it have been dried initially- free air drying at some time of year and place, predrier, straight to the kiln?"

You would have to start with the objective difference. There are massive commercial processes that proceed directly from wet wood, and drying is not done. There are other conditions where drying is not really an issue if the wood is to be seasoned for such a long time that it will not be worth the bucks to do anything but air drying. But for those processes where there might be distinctions, you would have to set up the objectives. Kiln drying is not a single process, some versions like vac drying may be relatively similar to air drying, just a lot faster (anyone know if one can steam bend vac dried wood?). Other processes are more like cooking. At the end of the day it is interesting to speculate what would be the outcome of such tests, but it is unlikely anyone will undertake the broad range of tests required for the many possible uses.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#37

Re: you are of course correct

Tom

"But for the big picture, for the person that has not formed an opinion through experience or revelation, will the KD process affect your ability to build stuff with hand tools? Oblique answer: The quality of either the air drying or kiln drying process coupled with the inherent variability of wood within a species are vastly more important variables to be concerned with."

Would your pals like Curtis B agree who work wood in wet state. They will not want to work it dry either from a hand tool perspective or a joinery perspective.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#38

Re: Maybe it's picking nits...  And who cares?

Tom

I do think there is a difference that matters, but in the history of woodworking, the convenience or pleasure of the woodworker was not of any great interest. We need to in addition find distinctions that mater to the end user, and I think these exist, but I would need more up to date info.

It would also be interesting to know who the kiln operator considers his customer, to whose will is he bending his process.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#39

Re: I heard that once...

Tom

"Scientific studies have been done on the effects of heat on lumber and they consistently find heating wood makes it harder and more brittle. It the change is enough for a wood worker to notice is more subjective but kiln drying wood, if heat is used does change the working properties of the wood."

And there are activities where this stuff matters like archery flight shooting. I don't know what this stuff tells a woodworker, but heat treating wood is common in a number of activities, though to Bill's point, other stuff like moisture content at the line is far more so.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#40

Re: Patrick Edwards on airdrying

Tom

That is a very fine book but it is certain to be out of date. I would trust some of what he said about design, business, etc... But wood science not so much, to start with that comment is pretty equivocal.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#41

Re: more data

Tom

Yeah, there is a classic case of why I don't use industrial lumber all that much. I would not want that piece in anything I did, unless I resawed it anyway, which is possibly what I would do. As far as keeping it flat, what I do , and it must create it's own stresses is saw wood to 1.5 or 2. It mostly stays flat in the light stacks you describe. Then when I need to use it I process it further.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#42

And bending wood?

Kees

And what about bending? You always hear, bending killn dried wood isn't prefered. Green wood is best, air dried is reasonable. So, wouldn't that mean there is a real difference?

(I show my complete ignorance on the subject with questions like this)

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#43

Good question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I know a chair maker and he bends commercial KD wood for the legs and splats with no problem.

In the above referenced book on KD there is one statement on bending. It is stated that for bending the wood can be kiln dried to a moisture content of 12-18%. No additional information on whether this is an economic consideration(cost more to dry more) or it bends best from this state.

I have no doubt that traditional chair makers have even more notions than typical woodworkers so I would be inclined to take their conclusions with a grain of salt.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#44

Re: more data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Your illustration does not show a juvenile wood problem. It is a classic illustration of differential shrinkage in the radial and tangential directions. All flat sawn boards exhibit this same cupping to a greater or lesser degree according to how far they are from the center of the tree. As shown, the upper surface of your board is closer to a radial surface than the lower surface, and thus had less shrinkage.

Shrinkage due to juvenile wood is most often seen in softwoods. It involves excessive shrinkage in the longitudinal direction, causing bowing, not cupping.

Had your board been restrained during drying and remained flat, it still would have been a low quality board because of its vulnerability to warping with seasonal humidity swings.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#45

you will see it soon.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

on the main message board converted into a bench for daughters new house.

When we sold lumber I wound up using the odd pieces that would be difficult to sell to inexperienced woodworkers. I will have no difficulty turning this piece of lumber into a useful piece of furniture.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#46

a matter of degree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The fact that the piece is cupped is explained by the tangential/radial shrinkage differential. The severity is consistent with this differential being enhance by the juvenile wood in this piece.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#47

Juvenile wood

Warren in Lancaster, PA

With regard to juvenile wood, you don't know what you are talking about.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#48

Re: Of all the people

david weaver

Not that I'm downing Patrick Edwards or Alan Peters, I'm not surprised to find that they prefer air dried woods, and aside from being able to ask a question in context to the Warrens and the Georges, I'd defer to them also.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#49

Re: Of all the people

cstanford

Peters describes his formal apprenticeship in the Barnsley work (working by hand with virtually no electricity during his entire 5 1/2 year apprenticeship) as including sawing and hacking sapwood off baulks with an axe and putting up lumber to dry. And in his own shop he says to have been able to remember, years later, as he was pulling stock out of the lumber shed the decisions he had made in how to saw a particular log, etc.

It's good that we don't ignore this sort of thing. It's as real as real gets.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#50

Last Sentence is the Most Important

david weaver

It's a low quality board. If I came across a board like that, it would be used for shop furniture or the edge ripped off to make a narrow rift oriented board.

I would be disappointed to receive a board like that if I were buying lumber and not able to pick. If i were able to pick, I'd never buy it.