more on Air Dry v Kiln Dry
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The maximum temperature typically reached in a kiln is about 160 F. Dehumidification kilns are much less.
Case hardening is simply the result of drying at a rate that establishes a moisture gradient across the thickness. It can be done with air drying in the summer, and given that air drying conditions may not be controlled, one could make the case that it would be more common in summer air dried wood than carefully dried kiln dried wood. And the "carefully" is not a hedge. When a company has 1,000,000 bdft of hardwood drying they devote a lot of effort to carefully. Their knowledgeable customers will reject a product that isn't carefully dried. The advantage of the kiln of course is that at the end of the KD cycle the charge will be steamed to relax any drying stress.
There are two cases in this air dry-Kd debate. First, is properly KD commercial wood inherently inferior in any way to the do it yourself product? No, is the factual answer. End of story. This is not a valid justification for do it yourself, but there are others.
The second issue begins with, I have some green lumber. Should I air dry it of send it to a kiln. Here the choice is not clear.
In this case there are some significant advantages to air dried hardwoods. The most obvious is that a source of wood is more common that a kiln to dry piddly small quantities. Furthermore, places that might offer to dry piddly small quantities may not take the care that a corporate kiln takes. This is definitely the case where I live. I have seen lots of lumber ruined in these boutique kiln facilities. I have seen lots ruined by improper air drying too. If I have green lumber to dry it doesn't go to a local kiln because the product from these poorly managed kilns often IS inferior to the wood I KD or air dry myself. (It is fairly easy to set up a kiln to dry 1000-2000 bdft in the summer)
I would never risk kiln drying anything thicker than 2" in any circumstance. Few kilns are set up handle it.