New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Posts

Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Stephen Shepherd

I for one like working with air dry wood as opposed to kiln dry for several reasons. Air dry wood doesn't seem to have the static electric charge on the shavings like kiln dried wood.

Also with air dried wood there isn't any refractory wood, so gluing and finishing doesn't experience the problems associated with kiln dried wood. Living in the arid West it doesn't take green lumber to air dry quickly.

Most of the wood I use is pine and spruce which I can get from local mills and they don't have kilns, so everything is green. Even the standing dead bug killed wood can be green.

Having worked both kiln dry and air dry pine, I much prefer the air dried wood, it works better under a plane, chisel, seems to drill without splitting and holds nails well.

Stephen

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#2

Agree

Ron Harper

I especially prefer air dried when talking about walnut. Kiln drying this wood seems to homogenize it. It becomes like red oak in that once you have seem one piece you have seen them all. Air dryed walnut remains delightfully different, showing traces of minerals and variations in shading. It also is much more hand tool friendly, or at least it seems that way.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#3

What!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your said, "Also with air dried wood there isn't any refractory wood, so gluing and finishing doesn't experience the problems associated with kiln dried wood."

How do you come up with such a claim!?! Millions of bdft of KD hardwood lumber each year are produced then glued and finished, uneventfully and successfully, into stuff. That's why it is KD, so that it can be uneventfully and successfully glued and finished.

Anything I have written applies to, an is about, hardwood lumber. I don't know anything about making furniture from softwoods or much about how softwoods(framing) are manufactured.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#4

You are confusing steaming with Kiln drying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Virtually all commercially produced walnut is steamed to darken the sapwood before drying. This process improves the working properties, according to a friend that manages a furniture factory working large quantities of walnut, while also making the color of the heartwood more uniform. (Makes sense for one can smell furfural around a steamer, a result of cellulose breakdown)

Exposing air dried walnut to the sun quickly bleaches the ephemeral shades of purple that air dried enthusiasts often claim as their reason for preferring the air dried product. As a result air dried and steamed/KD soon become equivalent in a piece of furniture exposed in a sunny room.

If anyone doubts these facts I will repost for the severalith time an experiment with steamed vs air dried walnut color. In a few months the color differences are barely detectable.

Or, do your own experiment. Mask part of an air dried board that has the desired colors and set it in the summer sun for a day. Unmask and compare the result.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#5

Refractory wood confusion

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Disclaimer: I haven't tested wood dried in various ways, have no expertise in this area. So I can't weigh in on the core issue here.

-------------

Stephen,

I looked up "refractory wood." The term seems to be used in two ways:

1. Hard-to-dry species (the harder to dry, the more refractory). I don't understand how one drying method versus another would cause a hard-to-dry species would be made easier or harder.

2. Reaction wood, caused by wood growth compensating for the stresses imposed, for instance (but not only), by a tilted branch/trunk; subdividing into tension wood in hardwoods and compression wood in conifers. Since the wood cells are different in reaction wood from non-reaction wood, I am puzzled by why air drying would cause the cells to behave like regular wood but kiln drying wouldn't.

Of the two uses of the term, I take it from the context of your use of it that you mean the second use.

Understand, I'm not expressing an opinion here; I don't know the answer, and am prepared to learn. But your statement puzzles me.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#6

Whatever.

Ron Harper

I have a table I made 2o years ago. Still has tinu streaks of red and varied color.

Of course, I am wrong... But I can see.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#7

Re: Whatever.  Etc...

Tom

I think Bill has a point in that some beautiful woods darken beyond recognition soon enough, and all these little details are gone. But not all woods are like this.

However, as usual, there is some careful writing in Bill's response.

1) The moment you choose two equivalent samples you are tossing out the major difference to start with. Homogenizing the colours is industrial woodworking at it's best and worst. But it is a sneaky trick as far as a test is concerned. Let's say you wanted to test some nice blonde streaked pieces, you would be out of luck.

2) Who cares what factories do to speed up production and improve profits. They make the horrible dross we are trying to avoid. Improving working qualities is so vague as to mean nothing. In a factory setting the cooking might make the automatic feed machines register with greater accuracy, or something. Wow, I gotta get me some of that! The obvious advantage is the increased yield. And some of these cesspools of woodworking excellence also stain their walnut to achieve various bogus effects. I think it is great there are still some people making a living doing this kind of work, and it hasn't all been offshored, but it is otherwise a pretty blank slate.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Stephen Shepherd

Wow millions of bf of lumber without a single glue joint failure or failure of a finish to adhere, that is truly amazing.

As for refractory wood it can be caused by kiln drying [case hardening] or by burning from power tools, etc. The paleo Indians would fire harden wooden spear points and the Egyptians used burn augers for lashing their boats together as did folks in the bronze age and the Vikings.

In the nineteenth century kilns were used to fire pottery, make lime and dry grain, kiln drying wood is a modern invention.

Stephen

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#9

more on Air Dry v Kiln Dry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The maximum temperature typically reached in a kiln is about 160 F. Dehumidification kilns are much less.

Case hardening is simply the result of drying at a rate that establishes a moisture gradient across the thickness. It can be done with air drying in the summer, and given that air drying conditions may not be controlled, one could make the case that it would be more common in summer air dried wood than carefully dried kiln dried wood. And the "carefully" is not a hedge. When a company has 1,000,000 bdft of hardwood drying they devote a lot of effort to carefully. Their knowledgeable customers will reject a product that isn't carefully dried. The advantage of the kiln of course is that at the end of the KD cycle the charge will be steamed to relax any drying stress.

There are two cases in this air dry-Kd debate. First, is properly KD commercial wood inherently inferior in any way to the do it yourself product? No, is the factual answer. End of story. This is not a valid justification for do it yourself, but there are others.

The second issue begins with, I have some green lumber. Should I air dry it of send it to a kiln. Here the choice is not clear.

In this case there are some significant advantages to air dried hardwoods. The most obvious is that a source of wood is more common that a kiln to dry piddly small quantities. Furthermore, places that might offer to dry piddly small quantities may not take the care that a corporate kiln takes. This is definitely the case where I live. I have seen lots of lumber ruined in these boutique kiln facilities. I have seen lots ruined by improper air drying too. If I have green lumber to dry it doesn't go to a local kiln because the product from these poorly managed kilns often IS inferior to the wood I KD or air dry myself. (It is fairly easy to set up a kiln to dry 1000-2000 bdft in the summer)

I would never risk kiln drying anything thicker than 2" in any circumstance. Few kilns are set up handle it.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#10

Patrick Edwards on airdrying *LINK*

Kees

In this video Patrick Edwards talks about airdried wood being much easier for handtools. Around 19:20 in the first video. The rest of these two videos is also nice to view.


http://shopclass.popularwoodworking.com/patrick-edwards-promo.aspx

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#11

Re: Patrick Edwards on airdrying

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think Patrick is overstating the case here. He says he doesn't usually get air dried lumber, so maybe he is less than an authority on this. I have used air dried lumber regularly since 1970, working exclusively by hand. In many cases the differences between air dried and kiln dried are subtle.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#12

How would one decide....?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have planed(power), sawed, etc. thousands of bd ft of domestic hardwood lumber. It is apparent from this experience that there are huge differences in working properties within a species that must depend on genetics and growing conditions. The primary variable is closeness of growth rings, but there are additional variables unknown to me. . Wood from slow growing trees is typically easier to work than wood from faster growing trees. I have seen very slow growth (1/16" or less rings) white oak that was light as poplar and it could be worked as easily. A finishing nail could be driven in it with no problem. On the other hand I have seen white oak "harder than the hubs of hell". Anyone that installs oak floors has experienced these differences first hand. Even poplar varies substantially. Trees that have grown exposed can be heavy and hard and difficult to plane, while "deep woods" trees are typically, but not always mellow. I recently purchases 3 walnut logs. The lumber from one is like oak- heavy and recalcitrant. One is typical. The other is like no walnut I have ever handled. It is as light as basswood and carves as easily (as reported by Mary May).

So what would it take to determine whether air dried was different than kiln dried? And what would be the specification for the air and kiln drying? Would the lumber have be "rushed in the KD process? Would it have been stress released after drying? How would it have been dried initially- free air drying at some time of year and place, predrier, straight to the kiln?

The variables potentially affecting working properties become staggering. My advice would be to worry more about genetics and growing conditions than how it got dry for the former overwhelm the latter.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#13

Ya gotta want it...

John in NM

If you want there to be a difference enough, I'm convinced that the most rational and scientific of us will convince ourselves that there is in fact a difference.

The easiest double blind method in this case, is take one of these guys who swears up and down that they themselves can tell the difference and put it to the test - several boards properly air dried, properly kiln dried, and badly kiln dried. Those orchestrating and observing the test cannot know which is which either, only after the fact.

Of course, setting up such a test would take a huge amount of expense and effort, all to settle a rather silly disagreement. Since no one is ever likely to take the trouble to set it up, I can confidently say that I will put money on the outcome of this theoretical test :D

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#14

Re: Ya gotta want it...

R Payne

A year or two back I read a scientific article on the differences between kiln and air drying. It went into the changes in the chemistry from the heat of kiln drying. There is a difference. Does it make a difference?

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#15

I heard that once...

John in NM

A guy told me that some other guy told him about reading it once :D :D :D

I don't doubt that you believe it, perhaps for very good reasons. I do not have those reasons, and experience tells me there is little if any difference. Therefore I don't believe it.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#16

Re: I heard that once...

R Payne

Scientific studies have been done on the effects of heat on lumber and they consistently find heating wood makes it harder and more brittle. It the change is enough for a wood worker to notice is more subjective but kiln drying wood, if heat is used does change the working properties of the wood.

I think Neil deGrasse Tyson said something to the effect of it doesn't matter to science if you believe it or not, it is still true.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#17

Re: I heard that once...

Kees

Thanks everyone for the intelligent replies.

In the end I still don't know anything for sure, but I liked the videos. :D

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#18

Re: Patrick Edwards on airdrying

cstanford

Alan Peters on air-dried wood in his book Professional Cabinetmaking:

Chapter 8, Techniques

"I still do not trust kiln dried timber although I use it from time to time. I also know that with many species and dried under the perfect control the results can be fine. Perhaps it is the perfectly controlled conditions that are so often lacking which leads to my mistrust and bad experiences."

This was accompanied by black and white photos showing boules air drying in his lumber storage facility.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#19

Yeah, see...

John in NM

That was an invitation to track down a reference to this scientific article you're talking about. It is quite likely that this perceived difference is nothing more than the placebo effect working on rather romantically minded woodworkers :D

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#20

Of all the people

cstanford

.... in this thread with an opinion on air-dried lumber I would definitely defer to Patrick Edwards and Alan Peters, unless of course there is anybody lurking who literally are or will be be historical figures in fine cabinetmaking like these two.

A "John" here or "Bill" there, vs Alan Peters and Patrick Edwards?

Let's get real.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#21

heating vs drying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This reference is one of the best on the technology of drying lumber- air, kiln and various other ways.

There may be some confusion among "KD wood", "steamed wood", and "heated treated wood" (like hot, well above normal KD temperatures). Steaming and heating above KD temperatures is reported to alter the physical properties of the wood.

I could not find anything in my KD literature that suggested any discernible difference in the physical properties of air vs KD wood that were at the same moisture content.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#22

Reaching one's own conclusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It might be useful to the bystanders of this discussion for the participants in the discussion who have personally dried more than 5000 bdft of lumber to raise your hand. (mine is up).

For those that do not have access to fresh sawed lumber to air dry I suppose your choice is to suck it up and use commercial lumber, or write about woodworking instead of doing it.

For those that have access to green lumber, if you believe it will be "better" in some way if you air dry it you can begin to discover all the ways that air drying can go wrong. It can be rewarding, and eventually cost saving, to learn so I don't discourage doing it your self.

For those that are actually making stuff, you will soon reach your own conclusions based on experience. If you are struggling making stuff while someone else in the club isn't, the cause is more likely lack of experience than KD lumber.

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#23

Re: Reaching one's own conclusion

cstanford

Really a silly argument since, in essence, you are saying Alan Peters and Patrick Edwards don't have any experience 'making stuff.'

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#24

Re: Reaching one's own conclusion

cstanford

Both of my hands are up. 5,000 bd. feet? Is that all?

Re: Air Dry v Kiln Dry

#25

At the same moisture content...

John in NM

I suspect you've got it right there, %MC has a lot more to do with perceived differences in working properties than does drying history.

It's unfortunate that so many people confuse anecdotal accounts and personal opinion with proof. The former are not without value, but they are not proof.