Re: what is/defines a "wagon vise"?
Tom
What I don't get is where the name comes from. In the Landis book it was referred to as an enclosed tail vise. Doesn't look like a wagon or anything.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: what is/defines a "wagon vise"?
Tom
What I don't get is where the name comes from. In the Landis book it was referred to as an enclosed tail vise. Doesn't look like a wagon or anything.
Re: a question - LV double screw
Tom
I have the LV double screw on my current vise. It's a very satisfactory vise, though it doesn't really work for where I have the bench placed, but that is just my situation. The two dogs part isn't that great, but it is a pretty cool vise because it works, and does not reduce usable surface area. It can also be tacked onto any relatively thin top, and works well in that application.
Re: a Getting wound up.
Tom
By the way, one way to reduce screw movement, if you have an abundantly long bench is to, say, stagger your dogs by 4 inches, then stagger the dogs in the enclosed tail vise by 6 inches, or some such. The result is that you only have to generally move the tail 2 inches to pick up a dog. And other spacings would get you even smaller increments.
A comment
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
It makes a pretty good vise the main limitation being that it stick out the end of the bench by the amount the screw is withdrawn.
The production wagon vises mentioned so far - Benchcrafted, Lee Valley, HNT Gordon - do not do this. That is the reason I chose a wagon vise .... it allowed me to build a benchtop 6" longer than one with a vise screw that extended 6" past the bench.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: a question *LINK*
Larry Barrett
Bill, you might be interested in the home-made wagon vise that Will Myers built for his Moravian workbench. I think he lives in your neck of the woods, so you might be able to get a first hand look. Link below to an article on Wictor Kuc's site. The link starts in the middle of the article, where Will discusses his wagon vise.
http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/wMyers/art/moravianBench/moravianBench-11.asp
Re: what is/defines a "wagon vise"?
Patrick Gibbons
I seem to remember it being used by wheelwrights and was thus termed a wagon vise. I'm not sure why this was preferred. Maybe it's in Chris Schwartz's writings somewhere.
Chris Schwarz on Wagon Vises *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
You're on the right track, Patrick. Chris Schwarz' writings popularized this vise, and I believe Chris is the one who gave it the name 'wagon vise'. Chris adapted this name from French terminology.
In the Sep., 2006 article below from www.popularwoodworking.com, Chris describes a wagon vise retrofit to an existing bench. His inspiration was a vintage catalog illustration (which he includes) from La Forge Royale. This illustration shows a woodworker's bench with a "presse a chariot" (maybe Denis C. can help here...chariot vise? carriage vise?...) Anyway, to give this vise an anglicized name, Chris dubbed it a wagon vise.
Re: A comment
Tom
Yeah, but this vise is the one you try out for 25 bucks, realistically before you do your first 75 dollar vise, and then do your first 1K hardware vises. Obviously those vises are better if you have commited to the concept and want to pony up the cash. Bill as yet does not have a tial vise, and likes cheap.
REpopularized the vise - lots of prior users
Quite right! "The Workbench Book" by
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Scott Landis includes a discussion of an 'Enclosed Tail Vise'--as pointed out above by Tom--on pp. 130-31. He shows photos and engineering drawings of the enclosed tail vise he found in use by David Powell of Leeds Design Workshop in Easthampton, MA.
He goes on to say that the vise is remarkably similar (looks like a dead ringer to me!) to the 'Loffelholz vise', engineered in Nuremberg, Germany, ca. 1505 AD. Landis shows a plate of the Loffelholz vise on p. 9 of The Workbench Book.
So the vise has been around since at least 1500AD, and Mr. Schwarz has, as you stated, 'repopularized' it. And assigned a one-word name for it, which he adapted from a French name for the vise.
Wiley
Re: Quite right! "The Workbench Book" by
david weaver
This whole conversation reminds me of the Honky Tonk Man's answer when they asked him if he came up with his wrestling gimmick.
His answer was..."no, I stole it from another guy, just like the guy I stole it from did...nobody comes up with anything original" 
Re: Quite right! "The Workbench Book" by
Tom
I don't find the wagon part particularly helpful addition to the thing. That link didn't get me to the original article. What is the French basis for it?
Re: Chris Has been this way also
Tom
Here is the "Janofsky vise", but it is in CS's fine blog which has the advantage of making it real. 
http://www.popularwoodworking.com/workbenches/schwarz-workbenches/wagon-vise-version-4-0
Re: Quite right! "The Workbench Book" by
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Tom,
It's the link at the bottom (below my name) that you want. The 'www.' link in the text was inadvertent.
Wiley
Re: I'm thinking his French needs a little work...
Tom
Thanks Wiley, I'm slow sometimes.
So here is a Presse a Chariot in all it's glory:

Seriously.
I don't think it is a Chariot Vise, particularly not a vise for making same, though I guess one could make whatever. It is a vise that uses a moving block. That is the chariot, and possibly that is what everyone took it to be, and I am the only one left out. I sometime goof american word usage. I'm having a blank spot at the moment as to what to call that thing, but chariot isn't even in the running.
The other unhelpful aspect of this is that basically all the scew vise hardware that attaches to wooden jaws is driven that way. The CV is a different type of vise for sure, but the idea of a block riding in rails and moved by a screw is common to most pieces of metal vise hardware, that are designed to work wooden jaws.

Uses of "chariot"
Denis Chenard in Ottawa
This is one word that is used for all kinds of stuff... A hand truck is a chariot. A trolley is a chariot. A shopping cart is a chariot. And a chuck wagon is a chariot. And so on. L'Office québécois de la langue française has 48 definitions for the term.
In general, the word is used to describe a moving device ( can be on wheels or not) that holds something else for some purpose. Movement can be restricted by some kind of track to restrict movement to one dimension. So the moving head of that wagon vise would be the chariot in this case.
As for the use of presse, I prefer the word étau. But then, even the French use presse for a woodworking vise, which I think is wrong. But that's a discussion for another day...
DC
The trick from Richard really works!
Kees
With all the talk about tailvises, everybody completely forgot about this neat little trick from Richard Maguire.
Well, I didn't. And finally I found some time and a clean bench to do a trial. I made a board with the cutout from some leftover maple. Drilled two extra holes in my bench because none were at a convenient position. Holdfast I do have, so I did some tests with different boards. And it worked perfectly well! Long grain and crossgrain, no problem.
I was curious how it would hold up with a longer board. So I got a 1.20 meter long and 10 cm wide stick and planed it crossgrain and endgrain with no problems. It moves a bit on the benchdog at first until it finds a steady spot. Only with very thick crossgrain shavings right at the end near the benchdog I could work it loose.
So I'm going to make a benchdog with a few spikes in the head to see if that makes the system even more stables.
I am so happy with this trick because my endvise is a dog. It sags, it wracks, has lots of slop in the threads and doesn't turn very smooth. It makes planing a board slow work. And it doesn't work very well crossgrain, so I need some battens anyway to keep the board in place. The system from Richard is fast and stable.
Re: Uses of "chariot"
Tom
Thanks, nice to have that confirmed. That is how I take it also, the description is of the mechanism, not the purpose. As in rotary table being a table that rotates, not one that holds Rotarians, though it could be. And given that the movable mechanism is not called a chariot in the US... Anyway, once a word gains a widespread currency it's the word, the rest is a mater of curiosity.
What about a top
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I haven't thought my way through this situation.
The ability to hold secure a top in the range of half a meter or more wide for some piece of furniture is a common need for furniture makers using a mix of power and hand tools. The concern is how much variance in width does this device accommodate? Would one need several rows of dog holes to be able to hold stuff in the range of widths of individual boards to furniture tops?
Re: What about a top
Kees
I think it is highly adaptable to all kinds of situations. You can make the batten longer or shorter. You can clamp it with holdfasts or with an F-style clamp on the other side of your bench or at the end. And for the benchdog I would first driill just one hole and add more when you need them. Just give it a try. If you don't have a bechdog yet, clamp a batten across the bench.
Re: a question.....a suggestion
roger lance
Bill....I don't know how serious you are about altering your bench by adding an end vise.....I know that you have resisted this idea in the past. But, if you are thinking about it, I'd like to make a suggestion.....and that is to not do it half-way (you know the real phrase). I'd suggest that you temporarily remove your Record vise....then add on the structure that will become your enclosed vise (wagon vise) and dog hole strip and then remount the Record. The bench may be so wide at this point that you might want to trim down the back side of the top....up to you. I think an enclosed vise is a good choice as you do not have to make the entire top in a way to accommodate it (I enclose a picture of my Frank Klausz end vise to illustrate that the top was built around that vise....complicated).....

I like an enclosed vise as you can work directly on it.....not so in my case.....there are some great choices on the market....but expensive.....so perhaps your own design or use existing hardware.....I think you will be happier with the result.
too cheap
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I looked at the price of hardware and promptly abandoned any thoughts of adding an end vise. There hasn't been anything yet that I haven't figured out how to restrain on the bench, with some effort and creativity.
I do have a advantage over most in that I have a very wide bench-42". So, a set of dog holes in front of the vise has met the need in most situations.
problem resolved then.....
roger lance
I remember when Norm Abram went from using a nice European ww bench complete with vises and dog holes to what is essentially an assembly table.....and he did not look back. You are right that each of us has to decide what works best for them and then go with that.