New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Posts

Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#1

Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Tony Wilkins

I'm about to get my vintage jointer up and running. Any advice of sharpening the Buck Bros cast steel blade out of it? Right now I am freehand honing on waterstones (6000 and 1000 grit).

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#2

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

david weaver

As long as you can polish the edge on both sides of the bevel, and as long as there's no pitting or voids, it should sharpen as easily as anything you'll find.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#3

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

To add to David's point of honing both sides of the bevel ....

This is one of those occasions where the Ruler Trick should feature high on your list of possible strategies to be used if the back of the bevel has not been flattened and honed. It can save a lot of time if the back requires much work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#4

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Jerry Gibbs

Why is flattening the back considered a one time operation and the attention focused on the bevel when re-sharpening? Don't both planes contribute equally to the fine point at the end? Jerry

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#5

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In theory......Once you have flattened the back the blade can be sharpened by only abrading away at the bevel until any rounding of the tip has been removed. To a first approximation if the bevel is abraded to where a burr forms the rounding of the dulled tip has been removed and the plane of the bevel will intersect the plane of the back.

However, most users do more or less to the back at each sharpening. Go to Steve Elliot's web site for some excellent pictures of the situation. You will find no universal agreement on how much to do to the back each sharpening. I'm lazy and only work the back on the finest grit to break away the burr.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#6

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade *LINK*

Kees

Here is a recent video from Larry Williams adressing the issue of the backbevel (among other things sharpening). Not an old blade of course.

Personally I don't like backbevels, for no better reason than that I just don't like them. So when restoring an old plane I spend quite some time on sandpaper and very coarse waterstones to get a reasonable area of the back flat without pitting or low corners. Takes quite some time though. At the spot where the chipbreaker has been resting for a couple of decades you often find deep pitting. I often grind back past this area, and grind a new bevel.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0ClNp_Eknw

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Dale Lenz

I'd start with the courses stone you have to get the intial bevel and then work your way up to the fines grit. I start with 600 and finish with 8000 or diamond dust paste. I've been hand planing for over 35 years and still like to use a plane iron sharpen jig myself.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#8

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

david weaver

I like larry's video. Those no. 1 washitas are getting difficult to find over here, but it's not a necessity to have one between a fine india and a scratched up translucent stone.

I've had three genuine washitas, a woodworker's delight, a mechanics delight and a norton no 1, and the norton no 1 was the fastest of the three for sure.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#9

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Tony Wilkins

Nice video Kees. Looks easy enough to give it a go - just translating oil stone to water stone. Also answers in part a question I asked over on SMC about maintaining a micro bevel.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#10

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Kees

He sure isn't taking many strokes, isn't he? And they say oilstones are slow...

I make one pretty stupid mistake in the polishing stage. Because it feels so good I make my microbevels too large, I just can't stop. This means more time in the next sharpening session to raise a wire edge again.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#11

Re: Big Differences....

david weaver

I'd imagine there is a big difference in how Warren uses his oilstones vs. how Larry uses his stones.

Any stone, even a chert or the hardest nakayama finish stone, is fast if you abrade it and have a fresh surface, but you give up fineness (that I know warren has mentioned protecting on his finish stones, and would be willing to bet that you'd not catch warren using an extra coarse diamond stone on the surface of his finishing stone).

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#12

Hard to beat model

Ron Harper

I have had the pleasure of being very close to several woodworkers of sterling reputations. Don McConnell is on that list. A honing system that he has developed merits careful attention. I have personally used

Tools from his kit. They are amazing.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#13

Michael Donaldson

Oh, how things have changed *LINK*

Michael Donaldson

Not too long ago, I posted about how scared I was of sharpening, and how infrequently I did it as a result. Well, that has changed. Part of the reason I disliked it was that I had to soak my waterstones, it was slow, messy, and I was always paranoid about dishing the stones. I have since switched to the Paul Sellers method, and really like it. I use DMT diamond plates in Course, Fine, and Extra Fine, and finish on a leather strop. I don't use any back bevel or rulers, and I do it all freehand. All my plane irons have a slightly rounded bevel now, but it doesn't seem to matter, I still have a good polished edge, and I can get it really, really fast (1-2min). Plus there is no mess, no water, no oil. Just a little window cleaner to float the debris. I also feather the edges of me bench plane irons slightly and that has helped eliminate the 'tracks' that they used to leave when planing faces.

Sharpening can be a pretty hot topic, and many people are passionate about their methods. That's fine. But I THINK we could all agree on two general rules about sharpening:

1. When the front and back of the iron meet at a zero radius, its sharp.

2. The method that achieves the results in rule number one that you will actually use regularly is the right method for you.

I have several old plane irons I sharpen using this method, and have great results with them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvTcReENk9g


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvTcReENk9g

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#14

Right on Michael

Ron Harper

I will join you in not suggesting that folks use the thecnique that you and I have learned from Paul. You are right. There are half a dozen ways to do it. They all work and are probably not used enough. Like lots of guys out here, I have experimented with at least 4 different methods. I stayed with them long enough to be able to get edges that are wicked sharp.

My choice of Mr.Sellers' method is based on speed, lack of hassle and mess.. Ithas mademe a better woodworker because I hone more often because it is so eady.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#15

Re: Big Differences....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Any stone, even a chert or the hardest nakayama finish stone, is fast if you abrade it and have a fresh surface, but you give up fineness (that I know warren has mentioned protecting on his finish stones, and would be willing to bet that you'd not catch warren using an extra coarse diamond stone on the surface of his finishing stone).

Hi David

While I understand that a waterstone grit breaks down into finer grit as it is used, and that this may also occur with an oil stone, I am at a loss to understand how one can leave the surface untouched indefinitely as it will glaze over and stop cutting. How would you keep an oilstone clean?

Secondly, assuming that one must abrade the surface on a regular basis, whether one uses a Coarse or Extra Coarse diamond stone for general maintenance - flattening and deglazing - should make no difference to the cutting action as this lies in the grit of the stone and not the surface finish created by different grits. I say this but am also aware that one may alter the cutting action of a Tormek wheel with a stone - however this appears to crush existing grit in the same manner as a dry waterstone will become finer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#16

Re: Big Differences....

david weaver

Couple of things, I'm not convinced that this crushing to smaller finer bits really occurs. I think what's more likely is that the grit that's held in place becomes dull.

A vintage oilstone that has never seen anything but tools will still cut. I'd assume that this is due to the fact that the stone is still slowly releasing grit...very slowly.

As far as the coarseness of the diamond plate not determining the fineness of a stone's abrasive power, that's true on soft stones. On hard stones, the fineness of the cut is very dependent on how coarsely scratched the surface is. The recent discussion on the coors ceramic stones that spyderco designed and markets is a good example of that. On the hardest stone, the finish is more dependent on density and binder and surface smoothness than it is on the size of the underlying grit. If deep and abrupt scratches are in the surface of a very hard stone, the stone can cut to a much coarser level than its underlying grit. The difference on a soft stone is that the particles can get free of each other easily.

I know david barnett has confirmed this, but it's something that's easy to tell when shaving with a straight razor.

As far as abrading finish oilstones goes, the desire to do so is purely based on speed, as they cut quite a bit less fine with loose novaculite on the surface (razor sharpeners refer to it as slurry dulling, and the bigger the underlying grit, the bigger the slurry dulling effect on a given hardness of stone). Novaculite is known as one of the worst offenders as far as slurry dulling goes. For most woodworking it makes no difference, but for someone like Warren, who has been referred to by more than one person as having incredibly sharp tools, it's easy to notice.

Actually, it's easy to notice on any smoother doing anything, especially if you like a finish planed surface.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#17

Re: Big Differences....

Kees

Thanks for the info David, that's helpfull.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#18

Two questions from Larry's Video

Tony Wilkins

1. How does he do it so fast or conversely what am I doing wrong? Ok, so I know you can't answer the second question but when I've tried sharpening thus far I've taken longer to achieve what I think are substandard results? Is that brief a time on each stone average?*

2. Looked up the diamond lapping plate and jeeze louise -- $200! Is there a reasonable facsimile?

*and I'm using water stones that I thought were faster than Arkansas stones.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#19

Re: Two questions from Larry's Video

Kees

I also take longer to raise a wire edge, also using waterstones. Like David explained above, Larry dresses his oilstones on each use, which makes them coarser. And I guess Larry doesn't let his edges detoriate as far as I do. And then, he starts each time on an India stone, which is quite coarse. When I start on my Bester 400 I can also raise a wire edge much faster then on my Sigma 1000.

And no idea about the diamond plate. I use a DMT coarse/xcoarse and it is flat and works allright on my stones.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#20

Re: Two questions from Larry's Video

david weaver

Tony -

Kees pretty much said it on speed. Larry doesn't work too much metal with the stones, let the grinder do it and leave you only with the important part to do on the stones. You'll end up getting there out of laziness when you sharpen. Call it craftsman's efficiency, you'll get faster and better at it just as a matter of practice and avoidance of unnecessary work.

The diamond hone looks like diasharp extra coarse, vs. the very expensive diaflat. Not sure how much the diasharp costs, but it's probably about $60 or so for an 8x3 on amazon. The extra coarse and coarser are a little more expensive than the finer ones.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#21

"wasting" diamonds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I remain mystified why people are wasting a diamond stone "sharpening" another stone, rather that cutting out the middleman and using it to sharpen the blade to begin with.

Indeed, what the diamond is doing is sharpening the stone. A hard(hard meaning the binder) stone will not shed grits as they wear. As soon as the grits loose their pointy edges they don't penetrate the metal to mill off shavings. The situation is not unlike a dull chisel or plane blade. A friable stone, be it a bench stone or wheel for a grinder, sheds grits, and/or the the particles continue to fracture, to maintain pointy edges on the abrasive surface.

For example, in the case of the older generation of water stones the binder was soft and the stone shed worn grits. In the case of the seeded gel ("SG")/ceramic abrasives the particles fracture in use to expose new pointy edges. I expect that the newer high tech water stones are based on SG technology.

There may be a chorus of baloney about how the plowing action of dull oil stone grits result in some edge improvement, that may indeed be discernible in a planing contest or a straight razor. But for people like Kees and I that sharpen when we are driven to by the blade not cutting, any of these ephemeral benefits of boutique sharpening are lost in the first few feet of planing and are hence irrelevant. (I hope someday Steve or Lee Valley confirms or denies this statement with data)

The bottom line of it is if you are sharpening as a means of making stuff the place to go for sharpening advice is some experienced person making stuff with the same tools and techniques that you intend to use. Otherwise you may find that you will be wasting a lot of time and expense with trials and errors getting to where they got to. To that end I see pros gravitating to diamond stones for sharpening metal, not stones.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#22

Re: "wasting" diamonds

david weaver

I think the answer is because oilstones are nicer to use (so long as what's being sharpened is relatively simple steel and not 65 hardness).

There's got to be a reason that so many professional woodworkers don't just use diamonds.

Not that it goes with oilstones, but there are things that don't respond well to diamonds, like 65 hardness white steel, but that take a great edge with little wire edge off of gentler abrasives.

On softer simple steels, the oilstones refreshed the way larry does it will cut faster than a broken in diamond plate, too. A fresh medium or fine india will outcut a 600 grit diamond hone by a factor of probably 4 to 1. Even on something like a finer stone, like a shapton ceramic 1000 stone, the shapton will outcut a 600 grit diamond hone on simple softer steels by at least double, and it's a lot nicer to use. The situation is reversed if the subject steel is changed to high speed steel, though.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#23

my experience differs

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have two Norton India stones that I used to use and now never use. For tools a diamond plate replaced them and for kitchen knives some sort of Chinese water stone replace them. Clearly my results differ, no matter the steel being sharpened.

And my experience disputes the presumption that "professionals" , at least those that have machines in their shops, have remained wedded to oil stones. Given the multitude of water stone varieties now available from the multitude of sources it is clear to see where the market is now. Remains to be seen how much of this market is replaced by diamonds.

I picked up the Chinese water stone at a show at closing for an astonishingly low price off list price. I suspect it may be similar to the modern high tech water stones now common from Japan (probably stole their technology). It cuts kitchen steel fast and stays flatter than the soft binder stone it replaced. Must be a SG abrasive.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#24

Re: "wasting" diamonds

Kees

What David sais. Diamond plate is a nice and fast way to clean and flatten your stones. For sharpening a diamond plate is only ho-hum. The DMT quickly lost its original agressiveness and now feels slow and ineffective on steel. And because I mostly work with vintage tools, the stones are very nice to use.

I don't use the diamond plate as often now I free hand sharpen. Only when I think I get more camber in the blade then what I want.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#25

About testing edges *LINK*

Kees

Bill, if someone would do some testing with how long an edge remains fresh after sharpening to various degrees of polish, they should meassure the forces on the blade like Kato did. Watch how the vertical force on the blade changes.

According to this paper, a sharp edge keeps pulling into the wood for 50 to 100 meters. After that it is pushed out, meaning the clearance angle is gone. 50 to 100 meter is a lot of planing.


http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html