New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Sharpening advice for old plane blade

Posts

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#26

Re: my experience differs

david weaver

Bill, I believe I said that professionals aren't universally using diamonds, which is different than saying they're universally using oilstones.

As far as speed, take an old stanley chisel, an extra coarse DMT, indias (medium or fine, either one) and a washita (a real washita, one labeled by pike or norton).

Scuff the surfaces of the washita and indias with the XC DMT and leave a slurry on top. A 600 grit diamond plate will not come close to the same speed as any of the three on any vintage american tools.

If you don't do what larry's doing, the diamonds might be almost as fast if the plate is new, but a broken in 600 grit ezelap is not nearly as fast stroke for stroke unless the steel is something that troubles the oilstones. It is not close. If you don't agree with what I just said, you need to try it again and you will.

If you use broken in stones, you won't get the same result as I just suggested, but then again, I didn't say to use broken in stones.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#27

Re: Two questions from Larry's Video

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Larry does take very few passes on each stone. He does take much more on the backs than the bevel. I think he raises the angle quite a bit so that he is sharpening only the very tip of the edge. If you look at the video around the 6:12 mark, it appears that he is sharpening in the 40 degree range. His reporting of clearance problems with planes bedded at 45 degrees suggests high angle honing also.

Most workers would take more strokes on each stone. I counted strokes on the video and for myself. I usually do 20 or 30 times as many strokes on the coarse stone, and 4 or 5 times as many strokes overall. Overall it takes me about half as much time to sharpen an iron. I do not abrade the Arkansas stones.

As to using a diamond stone to abrade stones, I think you said you used water stones. I don't think it help your speed to use a diamond plate, but it would be helpful for flatness.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#28

Re: Two questions from Larry's Video *LINK*

Kees

No wonder it takes so long, he's chatting all the time! And indeed it looks like he raises the iron quite a bit, but I wouldn't dare to put a number on it.

I made a little video some time ago and it took me 5.30 minutes from picking up the plane to making shavings again, doing some grinding and using two stones. I think sharpening shouldn't be a race.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ehSrX1Dx78

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#29

Re: "wasting" diamonds

John in NM

"There's got to be a reason that so many professional woodworkers don't just use diamonds."

In my experience they do use diamonds. Most have their carbide cutters and M2 jointer/planer knives sharpened professionally, probably using diamond wheels. That they are ignorant of the actual process is their loss, but perhaps they make up for it with some level of bliss :D

Also, the handful of trim carpenters I ran across in my brief stint in a paying shop all used diamond plates for jobsite touch ups of chisels. The primary reason is that they are not messy, and they work quickly while they last. Loose grit methods are more conservative of $$$, but aren't really marketed OTC to tradesmen the way the bonded plates are.

I have yet to personally meet a professional woodworker who actually uses a plane often enough to worry about how to sharpen it. While I'm sure they exist, they are very thin on the ground in the US. Authors do not count. I'm talking about a person who spends 2000 hours a year producing wood product at a wage of $10-$20 an hour - maybe more now, shows you I'm 10 years out of date :D

If I were still in a paying shop, I would be using diamonds for sharpening. Since I'm currently just another amateur, working for pleasure, I use the oilstones I have already and keep the diamond grit for cutting stones. I do occasionally lap an oil stone on my 325 plate, but on the whole I don't want to mess up any of the lapidary plates by rubbing chisels on them :D

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#30

Cheap diamond options... *LINK*

John in NM

Get a bit of cold rolled mild steel plate. Get some diamond grit and WD-40. For speed I would look at getting 600 grit diamond, you can polish with water stones since you have them.

A steel plate will work well enough to see how you like it. If you are a scrounger, you can find one for free. If not, an off cut from a welding or machine shop might cost a few bucks, or a 12 pack.

For a fast honing, hollow grind the blade, spray a little kerosine on the plate and a tiny dab of grit (assuming you get the stuff in the syringe rather than loose grit). Otherwise, use a very light sprinkle of loose diamond. Spread it around a bit with a finger, and then use like an oil stone. Wipe off the plate when you are done.

A single grit of diamond will cost less than $20 shipped. Don't bother with large quantities, it takes years to use up a syringe.


http://www.lopacki.com/polishes/

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#31

Re: "wasting" diamonds

Tom

My problem with the sharpening of waterstones with DMTs is that in all the versions I have tried, the waterstone ate them up , which may also explain why they stopped sharpening the steel. The bond is not diamonds, and the waterstone grit seems to have ripped it apart. I tried several times, now I don't care who tells me what, or how improved they are, I am not going down that path again. I am, using the Japanese stone rubbing system which works fine. Also it helps to use the whole stone.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#32

Re: About testing edges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It could be done also by measuring the wear from microscope images. Lee Valley research department likely already has the data.

Re: Sharpening advice for old plane blade

#33

Re: Oh, how things have changed

david charlesworth

Michael,

Paul uses as many strokes on his strop as Larry uses in total.

best wishes,

David