Re: my experience differs
david weaver
Bill, I believe I said that professionals aren't universally using diamonds, which is different than saying they're universally using oilstones.
As far as speed, take an old stanley chisel, an extra coarse DMT, indias (medium or fine, either one) and a washita (a real washita, one labeled by pike or norton).
Scuff the surfaces of the washita and indias with the XC DMT and leave a slurry on top. A 600 grit diamond plate will not come close to the same speed as any of the three on any vintage american tools.
If you don't do what larry's doing, the diamonds might be almost as fast if the plate is new, but a broken in 600 grit ezelap is not nearly as fast stroke for stroke unless the steel is something that troubles the oilstones. It is not close. If you don't agree with what I just said, you need to try it again and you will.
If you use broken in stones, you won't get the same result as I just suggested, but then again, I didn't say to use broken in stones.




