New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Rasps.....

Posts

Re: Rasps.....

#26

Re: Another possibility, Iwasaki carving files

Bob Lang

The Dieter Schmidt description is good, but I would throw in almost. almost as fast as a rasp, almost as smooth as a file. I reviewed the little floats on the PW blog here:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/article/milled-tooth-plane-makers-floats-review

I thought I had written about the larger, but it seems like I haven't.

The Iwasaki's are very nice, but seems a bit "grabby" to me. I love them on flat surfaces, but not so much on curves. I'll have to take another look at how they behave on curves. If I had never used a hand-cut rasp they might seem acceptable, but I've been spoiled.

Bob Lang

Re: Rasps.....

#27

Re: Basically a curved float..

david weaver

..when a float is what you want to use, they're nice.

But there are other ways to get old vixen files, etc, that are very sharp and can do the same thing.

I don't find them as nice to use as a rasp, and I don't have any really expensive rasps, just some third world hand cut rasps and the gramercy saw handle rasp (which is a really nice better-than-third-world rasp to have if you make anything with closed handles).

The rasp goes where you point it, it doesn't skip or grab. As nice of a surface as all of the different milled tooth tools leave, there's always a stray mark or two to get rid of with a scraper or sandpaper. I'd rather just use a rasp and files and sand or scrape if needed.

Re: Rasps.....

#28

Re: Another possibility, Iwasaki carving files

wilbur

I have a few Iwasaki files. They are different enough from rasps that I would say using rasp technique with these files and expecting them to work is like trying to pare with a mortise chisel instead of a chisel set up for paring. You can do it, but there are better ways to use that tool.

In my hands, you need a really light touch to use these files effectively. However little downward pressure you use with a rasp, you need to have even less with the Iwasaki files. But once you get used to them, the finish they leave is really remarkable.

There's an illustration on the Lee Valley site showing how the Iwasaki files work that probably explains why there's such a difference in use:


These files are really more like a bunch of chisels set in a row, kind of like the disposable razor blades with 3-5 blades in them. This is much different than how a rasp removes wood.

Re: Rasps.....

#29

Re: Rasps.....

Paul Dzioba

Hi Bill,

Where to begin. No comparison to 80 grit on a stick. Who wants all that grit on their bench anyway?

Let’s start with the dulling part of files and rasps. That is not an issue with me, my file and rasps last a long time with the exception of saw files. First off is storage; store them so they don’t make contact with each other. That is the quickest way to dull them. I put them in a tool roll when travelling otherwise they reside in a drawer in slotted dividers. Keep them clean. Use a bristle brush to clean and dislodge the debris but never one of those metal file cards. The metal bristles in those are pretty hard and put some wear on your files and rasps. Segregate your tools to use. Don’t use your wood files on metal and visa-versa. These tools cut in one direction, lighten up on the pressure for the return stroke. Use your files and rasps on the appropriate woods. Soft and resinous woods just gum up the teeth while harder woods clear the teeth well and almost self clean.

I have tried the top tier rasps and they are very nice and you can tell the difference. Some of them are in my future acquisitions. The Nicholson 50 rasp is my workhorse. It is not too expensive at $35.00 from Jamestown Distributors. Its main limitation is that the teeth don’t go right to the edge so you can’t work right into the corner. From the Nicholson 50 I go to a Grammercy 8” modelers rasp at $49.95 from Tools for Working Wood. These are hand stitched in Pakistan from stainless steel and are almost as nice as the top tier rasps. I then progress to a mill bastard and sometimes a mill smooth. With files and I believe rasps, the shorter the length the finer the teeth.

I love my files and rasps; I don’t know what I would do without them. They allow me to almost dispense with sandpaper.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Rasps.....

#30

Nicholson Super Shear

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Haven't tried any of the rasps mentioned here, same for the Iwasaki, but the Nicholson Super Shear is pretty impressive in my view. A bit hard to find, here's a source:

http://apexhandtools.com/brands/CF_Files/model_detail.cfm?upc=037103219442

They come in lengths from 8" to 14", they are made to be used mainly with non-ferrous metals but work great with wood. Press hard and they really eat wood, a gentle touch leaves the wood almost like it's been planed.

DC

Re: Rasps.....

#31

Re: body shop supply..

david weaver

is a good place to get a lot of those milled tooth files.

about 4 years ago, I got 12" vixen branded two sided milled tooth files for about $5 each on ebay.

And found a gigantic 14" super heavy version (actually, there were about four dozen of them) in a local antique shop. I only bought one. They were $1 each, unused and no rust.

Big ones are far too big for furniture work, but I've managed to use them twice in non-furniture stuff.

Still rather use a rasp and files for most work.

Re: Rasps.....

#32

The bar at the Westin has a pretty good one...


Re: Rasps.....

#33

Grace makes cabinet screw drivers.

Chuck Nickerson

Slotted #2 - #14. Available from TFWW and Best Things.

Wonderful stuff!

Re: Rasps.....

#34

Tooth geometry is different.

Chuck Nickerson

Rasp teeth cut, sandpaper particles abrade.

Rasps and file can be resharpened by Boggs Tool Sharpening.

Last batch I took in was $.25 per inch.

Old files at $1, $2.50 to sharpen, and $3 for a Skrooz-On handle,

and they're better than new.