New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Rasps.....

Posts

Rasps.....

#1

Rasps.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

PW recently reviewed rasps. But for those ignorant of their applications, didn't explain why someone should pay $100 for what seems to be a disposable wood shaping tool. I don't know anyone that owns one. I never owned anything but coarse files. I glue 80 grit sand paper on a stick when a coarse file won't do. Does this cheap wood removal tool do what one of these expensive rasps will do, or not?

The rasps recently reviewed in PW cost as much as a spoke shave. It is hard to get enthused about a tool for $100 that will get dull and useless, especially for the frugal minded(presuming that like a file they will get dull and useless).

So, what is the use for what seems to be a high priced disposable tool? What do they do(where are they used) that justifies the cost of obtaining one (and why do they cost so much?). On the one hand I feel like I am missing out on some useful tool in spite of the cost. But I am failing to see the need. Maybe they are for woodworking operations that I don't do, carving etc?

Re: Rasps.....

#2

I have one...

John in NM

I use it regularly for shaping buttstocks. Cut the bit where the metal goes with a router and pattern, rough out with an angle grinder, shape with a rasp and spokeshave, then scrape and sand. I don't imagine I would use it as much for tasks that did not require eyeball curves.

The expensive ones do work much better than any machine made rasp I've used, but that is only a few, because they don't seem to work well for me. The one hand cut rasp I use cuts quickly but leaves a very smooth surface considering the speed of cut. The machine cut rasps I've used seem to cut slowly but leave huge corrugations.

The one downside I've found is that it is imperative to raise the grain, even after scraping or sanding. The rasp teeth seem to compress the wood in spots, and even when sanded or scraped smooth, I've ended up with raised ridges after applying a ferric acetate solution to curly maple. The solution raises the grain, so if it's not been done first and re-sanded, one ends up taking a couple steps back to correct it. Might not be a problem using an oil only finish.

Re: Rasps.....

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Rasps.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I have nicholsons numbers 49 and 50.Various floats and three italian rasps made by Auriou. One 9" with teeth slightly finer than my nicholson one 6" very fine and a tiny rattail. Every one of these has a particular purpose. They are a progression. If you hardly ever use rasps you don't need one but I do.The hand stitched rasps are worth the extra money in the way they handle the task.It has nothing to do with brand names or pretty tools.These rasps really perform well.

When I am shaping a particularly difficult spot the aurious are about the only tool that will work in some instances. If you ever get a chance I suggest you try one out. I think you will be surprised.---Jack

Re: Rasps.....

#4

Re: Rasps.....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Excellent for roughing out of odd shapes, and I understand the pricey ones will do fine shaping, too. I haven't paid the prices quoted for the rasps I own - but then, many of my purchases, including these, come from yard sales.

Re: Rasps.....

#5

per john Aniano

Wiley Horne -- So. Cal.

John Aniano, our resident high-end bowmaker (as in stringed instruments), made a stunning couple of posts a few months ago He discussed a hand-stitched rasp he made for a specific purpose, and also discussed commercial rasps. Here's his second post, and link to the thread:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/270021QKS8fcfkaaHCdJ1369098805/spage/1/sanc/465497/sbid/3000/md/read/id/465497/sbj/rasp-tooth-patterns-for-comparison/

John had high praise for Pechar rasps, a German company. I haven't heard of anyone with hand-stitched rasps that wanted to get rid of them. i sure don't. Files will get you a long way, though.

Wiley

Re: Rasps.....

#6

Re: Rasps.....

Ron Harper

I think guys who do mostly rectilinear work do not require them. I have seen Marc Adams shape curved surfaces with them. Amazing what he can do and how quickly he can do it.

Re: Rasps.....

#7

Re: Rasps.....

joel moskowitz

Razor blades are disposable. Good rasps aren't disposable. They last for years. When a customer wants to replace a hand made rasp that is worn they usually have had it for decades, even with professional use. We have even run tests on longevity of rasps and they last a long time before wear or dullness are a factor.

Re: Rasps.....

#8

craigd

Re: Rasps..... *LINK*

craigd

My weapon of choice is a StewMac fine rasp, $32 or $52 depending on size. I can hog off material or do fine-ish shaping depending on pressure. I use it for spoons, totes (saw and plane) and anything else that needs shaping. I think I've had them for around 5 years and they are, as far as I can remember, good as new. I also love micro-planes and files. I use lots of Norton 3X 80 grit on sticks but it wears out pretty fast so I do that after major shaping.

I sharpen files with a vinegar soak, with pretty impressive results. Mike Wenzloff sharpens his Auriou's in a citric acid bath.


http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Tools/Files/Dragon_Hand-cut_Rasp.html

Re: Rasps.....

#9

Re: Rasps.....

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I have one of the Gramercy tools hand cut rasps and it is a dream to use for shaping wood. saw handles, or cabriolet legs, tool handles, etc.

I was introduced at an early age to the usefulness of a rasp for shaping and fitting wood, but the machine cut rasps I learned with pale in comparison to the results from a hand cut rasp.

Bob in NJ

Re: Rasps.....

#10

Re: Rasps.....

wilbur

I have a feeling that the usefulness of a good hand stitched rasp is something that needs to be seen in person, and that once you see what it can do and try it for yourself, no further explanation will be needed. For a good analogy, think about trying to describe to someone what a really sharp paring chisel is, or what a well tuned plane can do, to someone who has never seen either of these tools in person.

But to take a stab at it, I'm tempted to take the Bill Tindall technique of demonstrating woodworking utility by noting that almost all professional woodworkers that I know of that incorporate curves into their work use hand stitched rasps, and that you'll take the rasps from them when you can pry them from their cold dead fingers. :D

(All meant in jest, Bill!)

By the way, I'm with Joel in noting that the description of a rasp as a "high priced disposable tool" is a bit unfair. High priced, maybe, depending on your tool budget. Disposable — not really. Eventually they'll wear out, but if that's the criteria for disposable, then chisels are throwaway items as well.

Re: Rasps.....

#11

Well said


Re: Rasps.....

#12

Re: Rasps.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

There are two separate, but related, issues in your question. The first is whether a rasp is necessary - better than a stick with sandpaper attached. The second is whether a hand stitched rasp is worth $100.

As others have mentioned, the rasp is not a throw-away tool. It should last a few decades. They may be re-sharpened - quite easily in fact, just dunk them in citric acid (as you would a decent file). I have Auriou rasps, which had had a fair degree of use on both flat and curved work over several years, for roughing out through to a near-finished state, and these are still to be sharpened.

I am sure that they are easier to use than sandpaper-on-a-stick, and produce more accurate and reliable results. Do they do away with sandpaper? Not in my experience, but it is only the final finish touch up where it may be necessary. Depends on the wood.

I cannot see myself going without these rasps in the future - a bit like returning to sharpening on sandpaper.

Are they worth $100? There is a big difference in the finish created by a machine-made rasp, such as the Nicholson (can you still get them?) and a hand-stitched rasp. So part of the answer is that the latter are the better choice. The thing is that they are handmade, and this takes time, and time and expertise is what you are paying for. I'm not sure if that makes them worth $100 but it does explain why they cost more than a Nicholson. One could rationalise amortising them over a couple of decades (and for that matter, do the same with the cost of sandpaper used). It does not make them cheaper. It just makes them more desirable.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasps.....

#13

3rd issue- service life

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Actually the most important issue is how long they stayed sharp. While I have no experience with these tools I own lots of files of various sizes, coarseness and shapes and Microplanes (a wonderful invention). When near new they cut wood well. When they are a little dull they are near useless and get re-purposed as metal files. It is painful when a $15 file becomes too dull to work well. You can imagine my angst if a $100 rasp quit cutting after moderate use.

What I am hearing is that these rasps are not the "Bridge City Tool" equivalent of a rasp, that is, a tool priced way beyond its function for the premium buyer. With their foreign cachet I presumed they might be. Also, I am hearing that unlike files they don't dull quickly, and hence should not be considered a disposable tool like a file.

Still, a piece of "Flex Back" 80 grit belt on a shaped stick makes wood go away fairly fast and leaves a surface that is easy to refine. I'll have to find someone that owns one of these rasps to try before I spring for one. It is hard to see why they cost more that what an excellent chisel cost.

Another thought....Where do they fit in the wood removal universe compared to Microplanes?

Re: Rasps.....

#14

Sandpaper is not a substitute

Patrick Gibbons

Take a piece of hard wood, draw a heavy line on it with a pencil and then take some 80 or even 60 grit sandpaper and hand sand until the pencil line is gone. You can also apply the sandpaper to a stick and do this. Now take a good rasp, such as an American made Nicholson 49, and repeat the test. The pencil line can be removed with one stroke. Repeat the test with a great rasp and note how the surface is so much smoother. My point is that a rasp will remove stock faster, smoother and with great control. Shaping out a curve, one can sculpt with a rasp. Sandpaper is for smoothing. They are two different operations. I've had my Nicholson rasps for over ten years, longer than any piece of sandpaper I've owned. I used them just last night shaping odd-shaped pieces that will hold tools in a tool box securely. I would also mention the utility of floats. I have a very poor quality rasp of unknown make. If it were the only rasp I ever owned then I wouldn't use rasps. My Auriou rasp is the complete antithesis, just wonderful.

Re: Rasps.....

#15

Re: 3rd issue- service life

Patrick Gibbons

I had high hopes for Microplanes. They just don't perform as well as a good rasp. They have a totally different feel. Longevity for a rasp or a file is heavily impacted by rust. A file brush is a great thing. Obviously a clean rasp is less susceptible to rust. I've recently experienced why a good screwdriver is so much better than a mediocre one. If all you have is a mediocre screwdriver you use it, suffer the consequences and never know what you're missing. Then you use a screwdriver correctly for the first time. The bit fits the slot perfectly. There is no deformation. No slipping. Why have I put up with junk for so long? A good rasp is the same thing. Its performance is so superior to what you did before.

Re: Rasps.....

#16

Opening the can of worms

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Where do they fit in the wood removal universe compared to Microplanes?

Hi Bill

I do have a microplane, and it has not been used since acquiring Auriou rasps. By comparison it feels flimsy and lacks cutting power. On reflection, perhaps it should now be confined to the kitchen where it should do a decent job on the parmesan.

As I am sure you are aware, one does not simply purchase a rasp - one purchases rasps as a system. Coarse, medium and fine. It is like using different grits of sandpaper. However, choosing the rasp grains to suit is where the "fun" begins. The problem is that I could say get so-and-so grain, but the length of the blade affects the size of the teeth. A 10" long blade will have coarser teeth than a shorter 6" long blade.

The Aurious I purchased are a 10 grain in a 10" blade (rated "medium" but is my coarse rasp), a 13 grain in a 7" (rated fine but is my medium), and a 15 grain in a 6" blade (which is fine). I have since acquired a few others that fill gaps, but that is where I began, and they do a fine job. One has to learn how to push them to get the maximum benefit. And note that they come in left-and right handed teeth.

Don't throw away the good files. I have several dedicated to wood as well. The fine ones finish well. The coarse are not a decent substitute for a good rasp.

I have also had some time with the Liogier rasps, notably the Handlemaker prototypes (which were introduced on my suggestion to Noel Liogier). They are also excellent rasps, in the same class as the Auriou (my set predate the factory closing and re-opening). I have not used the Gramercy, which come highly recommended by others. I have also heard a positive report about another French maker, FTP.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rasps.....

#17

Where does one get a good screwdriver

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

In exasperation I once wrote Lee Valley and wondered why they sold slotted screws but not a driver to fit them. I was hoping some common source would sell a screw drive sized for common wood screws, a #4 being my first choice. I have considered finding someone with a milling machine and making some. I even bought the drill rod.

Re: Rasps.....

#18

Re: Rasps.....

Bob Lang

While the article didn't discuss longevity of rasps (my bad) I thought it made clear why these things are a valuable addition to your tool kit. The rasps I've been using on a regular basis since 2004 are still in excellent shape. Mike Wenzloff is the only guy I know of who has managed to wear one out.

I'm a pretty frugal guy myself, but this is one of the few areas where I believe that the high-priced brand is actually a bargain. In spite of my reputation for arts & crafts stuff, I do a fair amount of curved work, and for taking a curve from the bandsaw to a finished state, or for making curved shapes out of sharp corners, I know of no faster or more controlled way of getting from point A to curve B while leaving behind a nice surface.

There is a video on the Liogier site that shows what goes into making a rasp. It's not the kind of thing where you put a hunk of steel in one end of a machine and a finished tool pops out the other. The suggestion in the article to try one of the Blondell's from Lee Valley if you're curious and on a budget is one I would repeat.

If you never, ever make curved surfaces you could do without a rasp. If you do work curves, you shouldn't be without one or two (well maybe three or four). If you're ever in Cincinnati, drop by and you can try mine.

Bob Lang

Re: Rasps.....

#19

Re: Where does one get a good screwdriver

Patrick Gibbons

I'm still on the quest. It was revelation to me that the bit must fit not only the length of the slot but the width as well. Gunsmith screwdrivers are generally well made, the bit does not taper at the point. One has the option of grinding the tip but some drivers are specially tempered at the tip which can be lost with the grinding. Lee Valley has intro'ed some new drivers and Grace makes sizes more appropriate for cabinet size screws. Many European companies make drivers with great handles. All in all, I second your choice to "roll your own" and will probably end up that way. Apparently gunsmiths grind their own tips on an as needed basis. I've seen some super expensive boutique drivers on the Internet. They don't look nearly as good as some drivers I found listed in a 1950's Bridgeport Hardware Manufacturing catalog.

Re: Rasps.....

#20

Re: Rasps.....question for the wise

John Pappas

A question from one with little, but some, experience with rasps. How do the Japanese Saw Rasps (those made up with ten saw blades) compare to other rasps...compared to machine cut and compared to hand stitched? On the surface, the concept seems to be sound. I imagine they may not be effective on some inside curves.

Re: Rasps.....

#21

Re: Rasps.....

steve mackay

I've got a couple "nice" rasps. They are a joy to use. One of my "go to" tools is a "busted in half", four-in hand rasp. Had it for years and would never part with it. Then we move to riflers. All different shapes (I think theres about twenty in my collection now). All are for odd shapes and curves. Getting into "that space" no other tool will get to. Think "model & pattern" work (it's what I do). Disposable ? If we're using them for wood, not in my lifetime. They are steel and wood is wood. An expensive, hand stitched rasp ? Sure, if you'll get use out of it. I'd love to have one (I've no doubt it would be sharper and easier to control) but I wouldn't use if often enough to justify the cost.Rasps are for when you move away from "flat" work and into three demsnional "curvy" stuff. Like the day you decide a ruler isn't enough and you go out and buy a set of French Curves.

Re: Rasps.....

#22

no problem with the review.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

..it caused me to take a second look at a tool that I thought at $100 was for the Bridge City buyer, and French or Japanese to boot.

The problem is that they look and work like a file, something that some of us my regard as an essential, but disposable, tool. At $100 I thought I would never use it for fear of dulling it and adding it to my large and growing dull file collection.

The confirmation that it will indeed have a long service life helps in the cost/ benefit analysis. I suppose that just like a serrated blade edge lasts "forever" a multitude of pointy teeth stay more aggressive than file teeth.

Thanks to all who contributed. Maybe others benefited from the additional information. Should I spring for one the PW Article will guide the purchase.

Re: Rasps.....

#23

Re: Rasps.....question for the wise

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

The Japanese saw rasps work great for shaping on plaster sculpture. On wood they are not rest to control and leave a very rough surface. Even though they are made up of a bunch of saw blades and i'm adept at sharpening a saw the rasps are difficult to impossible to sharpen with a file. I have managed to get out a bit sharper with a dremel, but you lose the set and you can guess how well that works.

Robin

Re: Rasps.....

#24

Another possibility, Iwasaki carving files

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill and all,

I am extremely intrigued by these, but haven't bought as I have Auriou rasps on hand.

But the Japanese know what sharp means, and I would bet that these tools perform as advertised. Does anyone know? Who has them?

Here is a description from Dieter Schmid's site (he's very good in presenting his wares),

http://www.fine-tools.com/carvingfile.html

and here's some pricing from Highland Hdwe. (numerous other US vendors also):

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/search.aspx?find=iwasaki

$30 to $40 US per tool.

One good thing about the rasps though: they are pointy and the Aurious at least toothed to the edge--you can get into pierced work and saw into a sharp acute corner with them, actually defining the final shape.

Wiley

Re: Rasps.....

#25

Re: Another possibility, Iwasaki carving files

Paul Dzioba

Hi Wiley,

I have the flat carving file but I find I don’t use it very much. I was intrigued how sharp it was when I perused it at WIA a few years ago. It is almost too sharp and sometimes feels ‘catchy’ in use. It is a pretty good bed ‘float’ for plane making though.

Paul Dzioba