New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

the mechanics of design

Posts

the mechanics of design

#1

the mechanics of design

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


I can report that I am not getting any better at the mental part of designing but useful improvements have been made in the mechanics. I have been unable to find any large white paper. This brown stuff from Lowes wears out pencil lead at a high rate but it erases easily and completely. It has a curl set in it that makes it hard to handle.

My large bench plus a drywall square makes a dandy drawing board for this large desk design. If I didn't have the bench I would have employed a sheet of plywood or MDF.

I can't draw, period. However, I can sand and watch a profile develop as I sand away bits of leg material. Sanding on a disk sander has been more effective than spoke shaving because I can see the profile develop on the disk sander.

So, I have made a bunch of legs from paper, plywood and poplar from some old stair treads. I am satisfied (which means satisfied not thrilled) with two. See any you like? It is like the bun foot. I would know it when I see it but don't know what needs changing to get there.

Re: the mechanics of design

#2

Re: the mechanics of design

John Pappas

I like the first from the left best, the fourth from the left is also appealling to me.

Re: the mechanics of design

#3

4th from the left, poplar


Re: the mechanics of design

#4

Re: without being able to draw....

david weaver

...it's very hard to design much.

I can't draw that well, either, but I know that anything that I've ever had a successful stab at has been the result of something that I could draw ahead of time, be it a moulding profile, the sides of a plane, etc. If I started out with something and then tried design by subtraction of material, it never looks right.

I am somewhat resigned to copying, as George Wilson has suggested, if I can't draw something.

Re: the mechanics of design

#5

I like the 4th from left too...

John in NM

There are a couple in there that could work, but the 4th one is what I like best.

What would happen if you added some taper? Personally, I like traditional tapers, smaller at the bottom, but larger at the bottom seems to be in vogue now. Of course if you are going for a traditional look, you may not want to mix the splay and taper in any case.

Re: the mechanics of design

#6

Re: without being able to draw....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

1. Doesn't have to be sweeping curve to have an effect:

http://www.christies.com/lotfinder/furniture-lighting/a-huanghuali-square-corner-leg-table-fangzhuo-17th18th-5540650-details.aspx

2. How you terminate can make all the difference:

http://www.google.com/search?q=chinese+table+leg&client=safari&rls=en&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=MAaIUafIJffj4APLhoG4Dw&ved=0CFAQsAQ&biw=1641&bih=813#imgrc=ACgCfLo4PWGEDM%3A%3B1GCKXLzEoVtCoM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fshard4.1stdibs.us.com%252FarchivesE%252Fupload%252F8200%252F10_13%252Fleg300%252Fleg300_l.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.1stdibs.com%252Ffurniture%252Fasian-art-furniture%252Ffurniture%252F19th-century-chinese-round-table%252Fid-f_772519%252F%3B768%3B768

Wiley

Re: the mechanics of design

#7

Re: the mechanics of design

William Duffield

The second from the left and the one all the way on the right. The poplar one, fourth from the left is the ugliest of the bunch.

Re: the mechanics of design

#8

#1 that's one butt ugly table

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have a saw horse with better looking legs (illustrating that tastes vary....widely)

Re: the mechanics of design

#9

Bill, you'll kill Christie's auction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

with comments like that. And destroy the market for period Chinese pieces.

Wiley

Re: the mechanics of design

#10

Suggestion

Alex Y

You might do well to paint all your prototypes the same color, so you can react more purely to shape. I think the fourth from the left that lots of folks here like looks a little fat in the area of about 20% to 50% up from the end.

But that might be an optical illusion from that sapwood/heartwood line in the poplar.

Re: the mechanics of design

#11

More data to evaluate

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

While rending opinions has been helpful to me, most may have little interest in these legs. However, the process of visualizing the piece may be more generally useful. To that end I add what I found to be much more useful data. I think the cut-out on the light background is the most helpful for visualizing what the desk will look like. Note:The flared model leg is only flared in one direction where in practice it would be flared to the front also.

The comments I received were helpful to me. make more if you will.......

Pictures 1, 2, 3, 4











Re: the mechanics of design

#13

Re: More data to evaluate

John Pappas

#3. Perhaps you can't draw, but I think this is quite attractive. I like the way the legs meet the rail. Ties things together.

Re: the mechanics of design

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

elephants

Jack Guzman from Maine

A friend has some pieces of antique chinese furniture and most of them are animal themed. I noticed a similar leg design on some of those pictures in your second link that make me think of an elephant's trunk. No idea of the significance just an observation .---Jack

Re: the mechanics of design

#15

It's definitely a very different tradition

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've always found the Chinese "tucked under" table legs odd, too. I'm not sure I'd say ugly; just different. Maybe it's my childhood, living here on the West Coast with more exposure to Asian cultural cues, that makes me see it as different rather than ugly.

Re: the mechanics of design

#16

Re: It's definitely a very different tradition

Wiley Horne -- So. Cal.

Where do folks think the cabriole leg came from? Another animal form.

Wiley

Re: the mechanics of design

#17

three


Re: the mechanics of design

#18

Lets get Bill drawing

Mark Hennebury

So first lesson is to understand that drawings is based on structure;

its strictly mechanical; lines, grids angles.

Every line and curve adheres to a rigid grid even faces and flowers.

Some people can do it naturally, they see in three dimensions and intuitively know the structure and don't need to draw it to fill in the contents. Others have to lay out the structure, at least at first until you get the feel for it, as you practice you require less of the structure, just the basic outline.

So to get you drawing furniture you need to learn to see three dimensional objects in space and see how they would appear on a two dimensional flat plane; Perspective drawing.

First thing to understand: The eye doesn't transmit directly to the brain.

So you need to unscramble the transmitted message.

One method to practice that is fairly easy and extremely old is to draw on glass;

Set a sheet of glass vertical on a stand in front of an object that you want to draw, lets say a cabinet.

Set it up at a distance from the cabinet so that you can look right through the glass and see the whole cabinet.

At arms length from the glass, between you and the glass put a sheet of cardboard vertical with a pinhole in the center. It doesn't have to be cardboard it could be anything, it is just something with a pinhole/ viewhole in it.

So the setup; cabinet, glass, cardboard, you.

You look through the pinhole in the cardboard through the glass at your cabinet.

Now with a fine felt tip marker trace on the glass the outline of the cabinet you see through the pinhole.

This method is very easy to get a rough idea of perspective drawing and was used by some of the greatest artist in the world.

The pinhole fixes your viewpoint and forces you to draw from one point of view. I helps train your brain to see things in the way you need to transmit three dimensional objects onto a two dimensional plane.

You can also do it on paper: with a grid drawn on the glass ( or a wire grid, its just for reference) and the same grid drawn on a sheet of paper laid on the table; You look through the view hole and draw what you see in each square of the grid onto the paper as in the picture below. This makes sure that the basic placement of your object is all in the correct place and proportion.


Try it and let me know how you get on.

You might want to do a freehand drawing of the cabinet first then do one using this method and compare the difference.

If you want to learn more:

There is a very good (old) book that has a wealth of perspective drawing information in it.

it is available for free online: http://archive.org/stream/cabinetmakerupho00sher#page/n5/mode/2up

Re: the mechanics of design

#19

China

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The cabriole leg came from China. The Queen Anne and Chippendale styles are adaptations of Chinese furniture and motifs. In the 18th century Europeans were obsessed with Chinese arts.

Re: the mechanics of design

#22

the way I prefer to teach drawing

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Drawing by using a grid system is one way to create a drawing and in many cases it is a very good way to render images but it does not help to develop three dimensional thinking skills. What it effectively does it to render a three dimensional object into 2 dimensions by seeing and then thinking of that three dimensional object as a series of 2 dimensional lines. What I prefer to teach is to render an object into shapes and to then draw those shapes, such as rendering the human figure as a series of tapered cylinders, cubes, and rectangular boxes with space between the different shapes. Then add different planes to each surface of each shape to develop the three dimensional object on a 2 dinensional drawing surface. One thing that can really help you see the different planes in an object is to look at the areas of light and shadow rather than the object for what it is.

Both approaches to teaching drawing are valid. The grid system is more in line with how a painter will teach drawing and the shape system is more in line with how a sculptor will teach drawing. I mention it here because designing furniture is more sculpture than painting and so learning how to see and think three dimensional will help you to design and build better furniture.

Robin

Re: the mechanics of design

#23

Re: #3, but more outward bulge just below apron 


Re: the mechanics of design

#24

Here`s my take on things.

Bob Hackett

Just seeing a single leg is not much help for me other than to say "nice legs" or "nice wood". I know more than a few less than visually attractive people (when you take in the entire picture) who have a set of legs to die for. I like to take everything in context, see the "big picture" and see how things relate to each other before I can even begin to offer advice. Seeing your mock ups of the apron helps me get further along this path.

I personally like to see something repeated or echoed in a project. It`s these small things that both tie a completed piece together and also set it apart from all the other work out there. If I was going to flare or curve a leg I would first ask myself why I felt I needed to do it. I`d then ask myself where I would be repeating or echoing that curve in other areas of the piece. I usually like to do this in odd number combinations like groups of 3 or occasionally 5.

Some of my most successful projects also have different levels of repeated details as well. As an example; Your flare at the base of the leg is what I would consider a rather bold level as it is plainly visible and takes place at the point where the desk connects to it`s surroundings, the floor. In my mind the piece then either begins or ends with a flare/curve. I would ask myself how can I repeat this flare/curve on the other end of things. It doesn`t have to be as bold at the other end, a moderate echo would do just as well.

A third level for me would be more subtle, something someone would have to look for. The curved transitions pieces from leg to apron would be an excellent example of this on something like a table where you may have to lean down a bit to see the detail because it is hidden by the overhang. As I said,subtle.

Once you discover little surprises like this it sets them as an idea or thread that runs through the entire piece and lets people know you thought in depth rather than just added details in isolation or as an afterthought.

As an example of how this works outside of furniture, when I was building custom motorcycles I many times used a common angle as a thread that tied the whole bike together. The front fork and rear backrest would be the bold start and finish that shared a common angle. The subtle level of detail was that the front portion of the frame or seat post shared that same angle but in the case of the front of the frame that angle was there but reversed. Beginning and ending it was plain to see the match, in the center you had to look harder for it and when you found that matching or contrasting detail it became an "ah-ha" moment.

Because you were able to see in depth in became readily apparent that the builder also thought in depth. Then you began to see that same angle repeated in things like angles of pedals, handlebars, brackets and paint design that all followed it. These are the types of things that make all the difference with both the judges and your peers.

For me things like this also define the difference between a serviceable piece made by a moderately skilled craftsman and the work of an artisan or journeyman.

Re: the mechanics of design

#25

Re: More data to evaluate

Bruce McCrory

The fillets in the apron will be difficult to install and keep in one piece. Wood face-glued to leg and carved, or reduced from oversize leg, they will pose trouble. As an engineer, think what happens when a radiused concrete apron terminates in such an extreme angle. The shallow angle crumbles.

Second, will that detail (fillets) repeat, or play elsewhere on the piece? Do they contribute to the structure?

Also, see the design in terms of function. Each part must first serve a structural purpose, or use. A designer plays with the structural elements, using forms and rules that are ancient even to the Greeks and Romans. An artist, in my thinking, plays games with the forms, and function; and, not necessarily with pleasing results.

Proportions are design; and design is proportions. The project is either table, or desk. With seating, the height is 29" to 31" for adults. Using proportions, the "golden carcass" (British "carcase") the height usually equates to 3/8s, or 5/8s of the longest plane. Are we shown the longest elevation, 8/8s? The table could be roughly 7-feet (84") at 8/8s. .375 x 84 = 31.5, the height being 3/8s. At 5/8s height, the table length could be 48 inches. At 48, your mock-up proportions look close. Is the table depth going to be 30 inches (5/8s)? 18-inches at 3/8s ... a foyer desk (hall desk)?

Do-dads, and bling are the fillets, and Krenov-style legs (bird feet). The design book that was cited had plenty of bling rules, and how-tos for each.

This is enough jabbering....