New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

the mechanics of design

Posts

Re: the mechanics of design

#26

I find proportioning rules nearly valueless

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This is not a rebuttal of your thoughtful comments, but only a comment on my experience, which may be misguided, or not. At last count I was inching up on 100 pieces of furniture made. Few have been designed from "first principals" but all have involved adapting some design in size and often form to meet a need. I can't say that I have ever found a practical application for design "rules".

Take the various progression schemes and apply them to drawers. In a chest of drawers 5 high it will lead from drawers useless short to uselessly tall unless you are storing blankets in the big one and coins in the small one. A more useful scheme is to increment the size by the divider thickness, a technique revealed to me by an experienced cabinet maker, furniture restorer and furniture historian. No mathematical formula involved or scheme with a Greek name (we could call it the Buddy Floyd scheme but it likely was widely practiced centuries before his time).

I never found a useful application for the "golden rectangle" either. Again it leads to inconvenient and often impractical sizes of things. In my untrained eye its application did not lead to any more pleasing size of a table than the size that actually fit and was practical to use for the application at hand, for example dining.

I would be curious as to other's results when making furniture to serve some purpose in an allotted space, storing socks beside the bed or whatever.

Re: the mechanics of design

#27

On the repetition of embellishment

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Talented, or at least experienced designers, seem strongly attached to the idea of repeating a design element, in the desk under discussion, the flare of the foot, for example.

I was about to use the example pictured, a close copy of what is regarded as an attractive Virginia piece, of how this concept was not always true. My previous view of this piece was a flared French Foot, an concept I am trying to employ for the desk, on a rectangular and angular case. However, in retrieving this photo I have observed that the curve of the foot flows into the curve of the skirt, something I never noticed before. Yet all this "organic" stuff supports a rectangular box and it all looks grande to me.

Re: the mechanics of design

#28

Re: On the repetition of embellishment

Bob Hackett

And then you begin to notice things like the curved pulls and curve of the grain in the panels. Aren`t these curves things that qualify as levels of repeated detail in this design? :)

Re: the mechanics of design

#29

I'm with you Bill

Bob Lang

The "rules" seem to serve two purposes; they give people with out an "eye" for what looks good and functions well a place to start, and they give people that need something to teach or write about something to say. In the long run they are to design what paint-by-number paintings are to art.

Anyone can develop an appreciation for good design and the skills to create attractive furniture, but it takes practice. Look at as many pieces of furniture as you can, and use your own judgment. Your time will be better spent doing that than learning and using a "system" made up after the fact, or misapplied from architecture to furniture.

Bob Lang

Re: the mechanics of design

#30

getting closer with some help from my frineds

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


This effort has been in three parts- tools of the trade to use in creating a new design, visualizing and photographing the results and figuring out the shape to achive. I have never done a design before of this scale from scratch so these three parts were all new to me.

Stuff of the trade: Bench, tape, roll of paper, flat iron on steam to flatten rolled paper, usual drawing tools, drywall square to do the drawings. Scraps of wood to make the full scale models. Painting (poplar can be turned into Wenge with a dark crayon!)the model to make contrast and looking at it against a light background to focus the shape, photographing against a light background with telephoto to reduce parallax, etc. I am amazed my patience stretched this far.

Then several things came together. I realized that the "leg of my dreams" was a cousin of the curvy clawed leg I can't spell to be found on many Period pieces (I don't like them BTW, too formal for my taste). Its inside tapers from top to bottom and it flares out at its bottom. Robin provided this insight and a way to draw it. Whilst all this was coming together I had realized the model legs had been working on were to fat and I was slowly "drawing" them by grinding bits away on the disk sander and watching the shape develop. I can't draw a nice arc but I can band saw one or grind one on the disk sander. I was working my way up the leg narrowing it, not knowing where I was headed except the direction looked promising.

Finally I arrived at a leg not much different than before but tapering from bottom to the mortise. The difference was dramatic, but still too fat. Much like the bun foot experience 1/32 to 1/16" here and there on a curve can be dramatic. What had been a 1 15/16" leg became slimmed to 1 3/4 at the mortise, proportionally less elsewhere, and now it looked right against the drawer unit.

I am now satisfied with the result and learned a lot on the journey.

Re: the mechanics of design

#31

Perciving 3D shape ain't my problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I was a whiz in a crystallography class I once took for grins. Doing the mental rotations to determine symmetry was no problem. It's drawing that I can't do-literally. A straight line looks like a snake trail and an ellipse was supposed to be a circle. But once I discovered that I could band saw or grind arcs for evaluation I could make some progress.

Re: the mechanics of design

#32

Re:What's the planned dimensions?

Bruce McCrory

The short reply: Our landfills and dumps contain the products of poor design, and useless objects. You are correct. Design rules aren't always the solution.

I think our eyes, as an extension of our mind's analytic processes, judge and direct what we find pleasing and useful; even to the exclusion of seeing, or assessing the whole.

Re: the mechanics of design

#33

Re:What's the planned dimensions?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

30" high, something more than 3' long but less than 4 feet. The center drawer needs to wide enough to accommodate a key board. about 22 or 24" deep depending on how the veneer widths work out. I have some awesome curly rift cut ash lumber that I will slice for veneering the top.

Re: the mechanics of design

#34

Design Systems

Steve Elliott

I have a file folder somewhere labeled "Bad Design Systems" filled with photocopies of articles and drawings that recommend different and sometimes contradictory ways to achieve good design. Next to it is a folder labeled "Ugly Furniture" with pictures of especially bad examples, at least to my eye.

While I don't consider myself a designer I have been building stuff from wood full time for almost thirty-five years now and have developed some opinions. My first "rule" is to trust my eye. As I've looked at projects over the years I've often thought one part was too fat or too spindly, or that the overall form was blocky and boring, or that some sort of balance between the parts was lacking. This isn't in reference to some ideal form or based on any abstract principles, it's just my gut reaction when I look at the piece. I think one of the reasons traditional forms are often attractive is that they developed over the years as one builder after another made just such judgments and altered the design slightly.

A drawback of traditional forms is that our lives are different from the lives lived hundreds of years ago. An 18th century kneehole desk might be a beautiful piece but if I had one I probably wouldn't do much work at it. The ornate styles of that time would fit into my life about as well as a powdered wig and knee britches. I live in a part of the country that wasn't settled by Europeans until well after the Industrial Revolution so any local buildings in colonial style are no more authentic than Disneyland. Making furniture that pleases me is about finding what I like, what fits into my way of living, what pleases my eye.

Twenty-five years ago I made a simple painted wall cabinet to hide a thermostat and used the Golden Rectangle to determine its proportions. I did full-size drawings to get the dimensions of the stile and rail doors right. As I look at that cabinet today all those things look good, but the 3/4" thickness of the case parts just screams "edge banded plywood" to me. That's what it is, but if it were solid wood with full blind dovetails at the corners the 3/4 dimension would still say plywood to me. Sometimes it's the things you don't think about that get you.

Re: the mechanics of design

#35

Re: Nice legs!

Bruce McCrory

Cool! It will be spectacular. Nice legs, BTW. Don't they (legs) cut out at a diagonal? And only at the front legs?

Re: the mechanics of design

#36

Re: Design Systems

Bruce McCrory

Not that we are close geographically, Steve, but I can't agree more about style. And environmental influences.

About every 20 years stucco invades the algae and moss-green Pacific Northwest. It's not as bad as Southwest Tex-Mex, but the algae always wins. We are in a New England phase now, with no residential eaves (blame the bean counters). However, historical use was at least 30-inch eave overhangs. Also, I don't think N.E. is as permanently damp as us.

Getting back to the writing-computer desk critique, I have always liked the looks of the bird-foot legs. I am just too myopic and know I will trip over them at every opportunity.

Re: the mechanics of design

#37

Google's Free SketchUp

charlie belden

Google's free SketchUp 3D modeling program is great for doing 2D drawings - to actual scale. If you have any mechanical drawing skills the learning curve is pretty flat. And there are plenty of YouTube videos on how to use SketchUp.

Here's an example of curved leg variations


And here are the SketchUp tools to do them with


Even if you can't draw a straight lone - using a straight edge - you can do clean

scaled drawings - honest.

Re: the mechanics of design

#38

good suggestion....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

but likely not for me. By the time I learned how to use it I could have drawn the project on my drawing board and had it installed. Son in law uses it regularly but he likes computers.

Re: the mechanics of design

#39

Re: good suggestion....

charlie belden

Yes, there IS a learning curve - that really isn't that steep - and there are PLENTY of video tutorials that will flatten the learning curve considerably. But the real beauty of it is how quickly and easily you can work out an idea - and do all sorts of variations.

With your curved legs problem - they're all about tangent points - where do the curves start and end relative to a straight edge above and foot width at the bottom. Should the Inside Curve start at the bottom of the apron, 1/3rd down from there, half way down the leg, 1/3rd the leg height up from the floor. Should they curve outward, inward or both - outside curve inward, inside curve outward, curve only the outside of the leg or curve only the inside of the leg?

What it does is let you quickly and neatly draw - to scale - a lot of different ideas and do variations to tweak one or two you like - all without losing anything you've drawn before - and without wasting any actual wood.

And when you find a design you like, you can get the full size dimensions from the SketchUp model - and draw it up on a big piece of paper if you want - knowing where all the control points for things are at. If it doesn't look right, make changes to the 2D model and try again.


When folks used a feather quill and inkwell to write with, the idea of a lead pencil to write with probably seemed like a waste of time. You have to keep sharpening it, the lead breaks, lead can be smudged and get on your hands - and paper . . . When the ERASER came along the advantage of an eraseable writing medium became more apparrent. When typewriters came along, penmanship became less of an issue - and - with Carbon Paper - you could type things once - and get two, three or four copies - without having to type each one. LEARNING to type had a learning curve - but very few people have, let alone use, feather quills and inkwells anymore. When White OUT came along the use of typewriters got even easier. Then Word Processors came along and typewriters became Gargage Sale items. "Writing" became much more fluid, flexible. Think of a change, make it, without losing what you had, see it, read it - and if you don't like it - delete and go back to where you were.

Imagine what we might learn had the drafters of the Constitution kept copies of all the earlier drafts, perhaps color coded to identify who had the idea for the change and what the change was - initially. And if it where in Hyper Text, links could be built in to thoughts and ideas that went into the proposed change. Think of what would happen if the Supreme Court, rather than guessing what The Founders had in mind, could read their written thoughts - written as they were developing their idea - and putting it into words. Sure, we have The Federalist Papers, Jefferson's and Adams' writings. But what about the rest of the Founders.

Imagine if you could see the development of a Krenov or Maloof piece, and the decision points along the way - to see and maybe read about how the idea evolved to the finished piece.

For me, when I can SEE IT, I can tell when it doesn't look right. THAT is what 2D or 3D models provide.

Make the design work easier, and spend the saved time on making the actual parts and joinery, assembling and finishing - where your woodworking skills and finishing skill are absolutely NEEDED. And, BTW, you won't need to find a space to put a ahalf dozen or more Trial & Error prototype.

Re: the mechanics of design

#41

Google no more

Alex Y

Excellent points, Charlie. I tend to forget about the 2-D capabilities of Sketchup.

Just to clarify, Google sold Sketchup to Trimble about a year ago. So I guess we are back to calling it just "Sketchup" like we did before Google bought them.

Re: the mechanics of design

#42

Re: Google's Free SketchUp! Umm hmm.

Bruce McCrory

I have been CAD design and drafting for over twenty years, and 15 on a board. There are many of us electron pushers who use SketchUp only to open its drawing files, and look. I would love to use it for graphics. I have tried to leap the void since SU was version 1 or 2 and the big draw was sketchy line work.

Re: the mechanics of design

#43

Deer/  Horse Hoove Foot *LINK*

charlie belden

There are variations of the Chinese Deer/ Horse Hoove foot on furniture legs, some subtle and vaguely familiar and some very odd looking - to western eyes.


Chinese furniture design is illusory - what you THINK you see - IS NOT what is actually there. It also is very attentive to FLOW - there are few if any Part A butting up against Part B - preferring to mitering corners so the grain flows around it rather than butting into each other at 90 degrees. What may appear to be a piece of molding mounted on top of an apron is usually actually an integral part of the apron. What appears to be cock beading around a drawer is probably actually an integral part of the parts around the drawer front. By using these visual deceptions, Chinese design makes their pieces look more delicate while maintaining the physical structure and strength necessary for the piece to be functional - and durable.

The attached link is to a web page I put together on a piece I inherited from my parents. The detail drawings - with notes - should illustrate the "illusory" idea.


Chinese side board example

Re: the mechanics of design

#44

question(s)

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What do you know of the family piece? when made, sort of shop made in, anything else?

The mitered corner joint is fascinating. I have no doubt it is sufficiently strong but I don't know how any more than I understand how it would be made (probably straightforward when revealed).

Have you made any "reproductions" similar?

Re: the mechanics of design

#45

Re: Deer/  Horse Hoove Foot--Should be Article

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Charlie,

The sideboard is a most handsome piece of furniture. And your dissection, analysis, and drawings are just magnificent!

This really needs to be an article, if you would permit it. I know the Ecke book, whose principal value IMO consists of the drawings. Your own drawings are a good complement to Ecke, because they are more clear (in regard to the triple miter for example), and show a possible construction sequence.

Your analysis of the effect of beading in creating a lightness which is only apparent (since the actual members are heavy) is very valuable, not only in regard to Chinese joinery, but also illustrates a more general principle which could be used in many furniture styles. In fact, the chest of drawers that Bill Tindall made, utilizing a beaded carcase (as opposed to beaded drawers) makes use of this principle.

Thanks very much for posting this. There really isn't anything else like it anywhere (that I have seen). Again, if you are willing, I will suggest to Ellis it be an article, or contained somewhere on this site as a reference to Chinese joinery.

Wiley

Re: the mechanics of design

#46

Re: question(s)

charlie belden

Bill wrote:

>What do you know of the family piece?

>when made,

>sort of shop made in,

>anything else?

>The mitered corner joint is fascinating. I have no doubt it is sufficiently strong

> but I don't know how any more than I understand how it would be made

>(probably straightforward when revealed).

>Have you made any "reproductions" similar?

Most of the pieces, actually a dining room set, a bedroom set and a living room set, all in the same style, wood and finish, were ordered from a company in Singapore, through a Hindu store in Panama, probably in 1974, a year before my father retired from the Panama Canal Company (owned and operated by the U.S. government). The pieces were drop shipped to their new home in Dothan, Alabama.

I have no idea where they were actually made, but, I suspect given the wood used and evidence of pretty good handwork inside the cabinets and drawer openings, that most of the parts were handmade, though some carving on the door panels of the sideboard were probably done with a router set up and hand sanding. The four drawers of the sideboard each fit in a specific drawer opening, another indication that the piece was hand made and a "one off", though I'm sure other very similar pieces were also made for other clients. On the bottom inside edge of each drawer opening there is 1, 2, 3 or 4 shallow saw cuts. The bottom inside edge of the drawer fronts have corresponding shall saw cuts.

Subtle detail - and unlike pen or pencil marks - can't wear off.

The triple mitered corners are an old traditional chinese furniture joint with hidden mortise and tenons and a double tenon on top for attaching the top of the sideboard (or a table top). The triple miter joint wouldn't be really THAT difficult to make. But it's the apperent cove moulding - that is actually an integral part of the "apron" that complicates things considerably - and precludes using a router to do the coving - unless custom knives for a shaper were used to create the profile of the intergrated apron and cove molding part.

http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Joinery/ChineseJoinery/Sideboard/ApronLegDetails.gif

Here's one way to do the triple miter joint

http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Joinery/ChineseJoinery/cLegApronTripleMiterWtenons.gif

The real challenge to doing a replica would be finding the wood they used. It's VERY dense and really strong, yet cuts clean with very sharp tools (I made some cuts in an underside edge and back with a very sharp chisel)

I also inherited some much older chinese pieces - a set of drawers with a linen chest in the top - and spring loaded hidden drawers activate by pressing the center of a carved flower. There's also a silver chest that is most likely a hybrid - chinese carved panels in cedar, the rest in some unknown hardwood, probably done in India, given all the chip carving in those parts.

The chinese furniture is finely made, the pieces likely made in India are good - where it's visible - kind of sloppy where it's not normally visible.

The chinese table tops are all frame and panel - able to expand and contract with changes in humidity.

What I like about chinese pieces is that most of the tricky stuff is out of sight - no showing off - just very very function - yet very pleasing to the eye - grain flowing around the piece - details disguising what's REALLY there.

Re: the mechanics of design

#47

Re: Deer/  Horse Hoove Foot--Should be Article

charlie belden

Wiley (and any one else who wants to use the stuff I put together);

I did the drawings to understand the pieces I have. If it is of use to another woodworker, well that's icing on the cake for me. Feel free to use it anyway you care to.

Re: the mechanics of design

#48

Charlie and Bill

Mark Hennebury

Hi Charlie,

Nice piece of furniture, great info and drawings on your link.

I was always fascinated with Chinese and Japanese furniture and the intricate joinery that was mostly hidden from view leaving the clean flowing lines of the design your focus.

Bill,

The triple mitre is a great joint, and is actually fairly straightforward to do; I played around in the 70's with different versions of what Charlie has shown. I made coffee and end tables using a simplified version of the legs, apron and top setup, done with regular visible mortise and tenons, and i also did a few pieces with variations of the triple mitre joint. I only have a couple of really poor photos, but you can see the joint.

I have done a model to show the typical construction of the ones in the side table in the photo.












Re: the mechanics of design

#49

Mark - request to use your illustrations

charlie belden

Mark:

I'd like to include your illustrations - and attribute them to you of course - with the joinery stuff on my personal (not commercial) site. Would that be OK with you?

Re: the mechanics of design

#50

Re: Charlie and Bill

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

That sure makes a nice table leg. I see how it goes together but how it is laid out so it all comes together still baffles.

Bill...who struggles with just a miter coming together just right.