Re: Organic?
TomD
"Organic is a word that has recently crept into my awareness of design language. Its meaning continues to escape me."
I think of that as the thing seeming to be intended. An organism is a machine, a biological one. The leg has to be attached to something to function as a leg. Bardot might have more flow than Arnold, but they both would seem organic given their role. Body building is an example of an extreme where the very narrow waists do not necessarily seem the best design for the overall structure. This has not passed notice of various great artists at the cartoon studios who often mock that form as a result.
" The problem with a furniture design class is that it would attract people like me with an engineering mind, comfortable dealing with orthogonal structure and clueless about organic."
It is arguably the economic, not the engineering that created the ugliness. Much engineering is beautiful, often in boats or aircraft. The basic predator drone is quite beautiful, as was the spitfire. At some point the people making engines and tools decided they should be ugly for political reasons. But the Apple nonsense has at least rolled that back.
"It would never occur to me that a leg would have anything to do with the shape of a top. I bought a highly recommended book on furniture design and I got as much out of it as I would get from a book on astrophysics."
That is an particular example. since it is quite possible to make a beautiful table that has a top of about the same shape as sheet goods, and therefore it does not have to relate to the base, except that the base has to look intended for the roll of supporting that top. But in general, are you kidding? You would gladly slam a Gremlin back on a Caddy, if the numbers were right?
"I believe that the ability to draw is essential to be successful in design. I can close my eyes and imagine the curved leg of my dreams but have no ability to transfer this mental picture to paper."
A lot of teachers seem to think so, but I don't think it is true. It is probably a flaw in logic to say that since if you can draw something, you already can design it. Drawing is one exercise that will let you know what you do or don't know. So it is excellent. And if you want to sell designs, you have to give a client something, which may even affect certain fine artists. So there is that. To make your own stuff you are not taking on the whole world so you can keep the actual drawing skill to a fairly low level.
When I started designing canoes back in the early 80s I realized rather quickly that I had to have a number for everything if you like. Actually even earlier than that I wanted to draw a cat, and I realized that while I had lived with them, just facing a blank sheet of paper with no model, I didn't really know where all that cat stuff went. So you just think you can see it in your head, but it is not really there.
Getting back to the canoes, and you might like this, there are hundreds of numbers people don't know, what is the fineness ratio for a touring canoe, a marathon one? And something gross like a ratio is just the beginning, every square inch has to be defined and in it's correct place. 3D compound curves. So for starters you start to work with the numbers. Measure the heck out of stuff. If a table works, get some numbers. there isn't much point in applying the Golden Mean if your shoulders won't fit in a chair so designed.
"Could I draw and ellipse I would be in business."
It is a few clicks on a computer, then you can print it; or you can use a string and a few pins; or you can get as many curves as you can lay your hands on. I actually like ship's curves, though full sets are crazy expensive, but the small sets work well with the scale of furniture. One thing a person with some curves quickly finds is that they fit naturally on plan sets. Some of the great artists of the Yacht, and they were great, none the less their curves came right off the Ship's Curves. They set right down. So being a great draftsperson is not entirely necessary.
These days there is design software for just about anything, often free. I was recently trying out G-Thang, and decided to design a Kasha guitar shaped Uke. I went at it in G-Thang, and I entered numbers, eyeball the result, etc... When I was done, I modelled a commercial plan, which I assume was just reduced from the sets that are available for classical guitars. I then merged them in a Cad program, You could virtually not tell the deference between the two. I have a good eye. And that is not so easy looking at small computer screens. But it also points to the fact that there are only so many ways for a design with even a few constraints to come out. So while maybe you will never be as good as your friend, it is not that difficult to be as good at the folks selling 110 dollar CNC machined, lexan pattern sets.