New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A day with an artist on design

Posts

A day with an artist on design

#1

A day with an artist on design

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

As if I was not already intimidated by my lack of design talent I spent yesterday with an artist (sculpture) who also has an interest in furniture (she likes Stickley or Green and Green or one of the similar styles). She speaks fondly about some house in CA that has inspirational amounts of it. I was doing her some surveying favors and in return asked her to assist on some leg work for a contemplated desk. I had a bunch of modern desk pictures, most with a flared leg as well as some leg drawings and one leg model.

I was crushed as she ripped the desk pictures and most of my drawings. However, I learned a lot. In fact I was able to understand her criticism of the work I showed her. What I learned.....

1. As an artist she wanted to "push the envelop" making legs ever more delicate for example to the point of structural failure in use. However, her knowledge of practical furniture tempered these urges as she explained that what she would attempt as an artist would be different from what she would do if she was building a desk to use. (now I see why much studio furniture is impractical, in my mind at least).

2. I learned if I was intending to flair a leg it needed to be enough to "not look like a mistake". But why was I stuck on flaring a leg (see #3)

3. All the desk pictures were of work by young woodworkers. She pointed out how each had elements that didn't belong together. A flared leg on an orthogonal oak Stickly (or was it Green) style desk. What is this all about? In another case a "cloud lift" skirt added to an otherwise English style (even I thought this combination weird before I revealed it). These young woodworkers were experimenting with styles and assembling styles that they knew and liked whether they belonged together or not. I came to realize that I wanted to stick a flared leg on something because I wanted to stick a flared leg on something, not that it made sense to stick a flared leg on something. Same mistake these young woodworkers were making.

4. The main thing I learned, other than my ineptness when it comes to original design, is to question my motives when assembling design elements into a piece of furniture. If I want to flare a leg the rest of the piece needs to accommodate and be consistent this design. Note: the flared leg was dropped from the contemplated desk.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#2

Re: A day with an artist on design

CStanford

Scroll down a short way to see a cork top desk by Sam Maloof -- probably better called a writing table -- but anyway I think a masterpiece of simple, clean design. No one element really stands out. It all works together. That's design.

http://creaturesofprometheus.blogspot.com/2012/01/sam-maloof-exhibit-at-huntington.html

Re: A day with an artist on design

#3

Re: A day with an artist on design

CStanford

If you're interested in studying shapes you need to look at the work of Rupert Deese. Note that he was a ceramic artist, not a woodworker. This is a good thing.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#4

Re: A day with an artist on design

Sgian Dubh

"I came to realize that I wanted to stick a flared leg on something because I wanted to stick a flared leg on something..."

On the other hand Bill, what if the flared leg is a primary design motif? In other words, through your contextualisation and reasoning behind your design development, eg, aesthetic qualities, functional requirements, the need to fill a space with a suitable design, or any mixture of these factors, plus more you could incorporate into the design brief, the flared leg is logically chosen as a starting point for the design's evolution from first draft to finalised solution. Everything thereafter should in some way refer back to that "flared leg" initiation into the design process. The flare in the leg suggests to me there's likely to be a sweeping curved line(s?) to either repeat, contrast, reflect, link to, etc throughout the rest of the conceptualisation. Slainte.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#5

Re: A day with an artist on design

CStanford

I assume by flared leg you mean a shape that I tend to call a bell-bottomed leg. It's a great shape for a desk leg. No reason to pitch it out of the process at this point.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#6

One line really strikes me...

John in NM

"In another case a "cloud lift" skirt added to an otherwise English style (even I thought this combination weird before I revealed it)"

Sounds like you aren't inept at design, just not confident. I'd bet that you know what looks good already, trick is to refine that instinct and trust it.

I think most humans have a pretty good eye for proportion, most just never practice and analyze their reactions. Your artist friend sounds like a gem, I have a cousin like that - I learn a lot whenever I talk to her.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#7

Re: A day with an artist on design

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I recently posted a picture of a bar stool and I thought I would share how that design evolved to include a flared leg. The initial impetus for the design was a bar stool to go with a suite of designs that would all have natural edge slabs of wood incorporated in the design and would be a combination of welded steel and wood. Incorporating a faired leg seemed like a natural choice since curves tend to be more organic than hard straight lines so by having that curve in the leg it would pull in the curves of the natural edge slab. Then to repeat the same radius in the shape of other three sides of the seat tightened up the design and helped balance all the straight lines of the legs and stretches so that over all none of the shapes or lines look out of place. I oriented the legs radial to also emphasize a more organic design as well as a more non frontal design. Chairs and stools tend to have a front and a back but as objects of design they should not be frontal i.e. they should be equally interesting from all sides. If I had oriented the legs so the flair pointed to the right or left side the design would be much more frontal and less three dimensional.

I teach sculpture as well as 3D design at my local community college and I’ve thought about putting together a design workshop oriented towards furniture makers. I’d start with exercises in pure design with simple materials like folded paper and then quickly progress to furniture design through model making. Not sure if there would be enough interest to fill a class.

Robin

Re: A day with an artist on design

#8

Organic?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Organic is a word that has recently crept into my awareness of design language. Its meaning continues to escape me. The problem with a furniture design class is that it would attract people like me with an engineering mind, comfortable dealing with orthogonal structure and clueless about organic. It would never occur to me that a leg would have anything to do with the shape of a top. I bought a highly recommended book on furniture design and I got as much out of it as I would get from a book on astrophysics.

I believe that the ability to draw is essential to be successful in design. I can close my eyes and imagine the curved leg of my dreams but have no ability to transfer this mental picture to paper. Could I draw and ellipse I would be in business. This artist and I were working on finding the boundaries of a large piece of property located in a steep wooded area. It became useful to transfer the map of an adjacent piece that had at least a dozen boundary segments defining its highly irregular shape to another piece of paper- a job for drawing board, scale, straight edge and protractor. She just drew it free hand and it was near perfect.

Curiously, as I struggled drawing curved legs with aid of arc making devices I went to the band saw and free hand sawed out a leg. It was close, how ever it became ugly as I tried to refine it with spoke shave. The organic part of it suffered decomposition. I may have done better on a disk sander where I could see the whole profile as I worked on it.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#9

Re: Organic?

CStanford

No reason for this to escape you at all. How many square trees have you ever seen? We certainly need box-like articles of woodworking but we can and very often do still put line and curve into these projects as a homage to the source of the material. And it just plain looks good.

Look at a piece of nice, wide, and deep cove crown molding. Fill in the part that's missing from the cove in your mind.

If you've ever nailed a piece of cove molding on a project you were involved in something 'organic.'

Re: A day with an artist on design

#10

craigd

Re: Organic?

craigd

I like Charles definition.

"Organic design" to me means "flow" as in the eye doesn't stop as you look at a piece. Or your finger doesn't stop as you run it across the object. So a flat surface can be as organic as a circle but a corner isn't. Until you add a fillet or round over.

I can't draw worth a hill of beans so circle, ellipse and french curve templates are essentials. And I visualize something a lot better holding it my hand than in my mind or on a screen.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#11

Drawing + mockup and prototype

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Great story, Bill! I know exactly what you mean by having an itch to make something with X feature on it. Or add X onto something already in the works.

The best designer I personally know is Konrad Sauer. It's instructive to watch what he does. He is a very fine drawer and draftsman, and was formally trained at it.

But what strikes me about Konrad's process is how many mockups and prototypes he does. He does lots of drawings, elaborating and varying the initial concept; experimenting--narrowing down--figuring out where the key decisions lie. But I don't often see him go directly from drawing to construction. There is always a stage of mocking up, to get the various line weights, curves, and reveals right. And often a full prototype in a lesser material, that he can carve and play with.

Excellent post! Thanks.

Wiley

Re: A day with an artist on design

#12

Re: Organic?

Mark Hennebury

R. Buckminster Fuller Quotes

"A designer is an emerging synthesis of artist, inventor, mechanic, objective economist and evolutionary strategist."

"When I am working on a problem, I never think about beauty but when I have finished, if the solution is not beautiful, I know it is wrong."

"Most of my advances were by mistake. You uncover what is when you get rid of what isn't."

“Dare to be naive.”

Bill, forget your apprehension, let loose and play, you cant lose, only learn.

Experiment and don't worry about how you think it ought to look or how it will compare.

I played and experimented a lot with straight an curved lines

.

When i had an idea stuck in my head and i couldn't quite see it on paper, i made mock-ups and prototypes so i could see it full size, like the chair. This way you get to walk around it sit in it, see if it makes sense or needs to be radically changed. The chair i never never took any further, but the concept intrigued me.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#13

Re: A day with an artist on design

TomD

That is nice, and not something I would have identified as his. There is at least one piece there that is pretty ugly. And there is a magazine layout of his work with that of others that is on the net, where the work is pedestrian, to be kind. Of course it was also made with a lot less to draw on. Point being, even the greats had to learn at some point, and maybe not some, but certainly Sam, had to develop their signature style over a long period of time. The key is just to start out designing. I assumed that was what it was about from the beginning, the mags that have taken over are about making copies of the work of others. But if you started back in the 70s FWW, etc... were about original work.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#14

Re: Organic?

TomD

"Organic is a word that has recently crept into my awareness of design language. Its meaning continues to escape me."

I think of that as the thing seeming to be intended. An organism is a machine, a biological one. The leg has to be attached to something to function as a leg. Bardot might have more flow than Arnold, but they both would seem organic given their role. Body building is an example of an extreme where the very narrow waists do not necessarily seem the best design for the overall structure. This has not passed notice of various great artists at the cartoon studios who often mock that form as a result.

" The problem with a furniture design class is that it would attract people like me with an engineering mind, comfortable dealing with orthogonal structure and clueless about organic."

It is arguably the economic, not the engineering that created the ugliness. Much engineering is beautiful, often in boats or aircraft. The basic predator drone is quite beautiful, as was the spitfire. At some point the people making engines and tools decided they should be ugly for political reasons. But the Apple nonsense has at least rolled that back.

"It would never occur to me that a leg would have anything to do with the shape of a top. I bought a highly recommended book on furniture design and I got as much out of it as I would get from a book on astrophysics."

That is an particular example. since it is quite possible to make a beautiful table that has a top of about the same shape as sheet goods, and therefore it does not have to relate to the base, except that the base has to look intended for the roll of supporting that top. But in general, are you kidding? You would gladly slam a Gremlin back on a Caddy, if the numbers were right?

"I believe that the ability to draw is essential to be successful in design. I can close my eyes and imagine the curved leg of my dreams but have no ability to transfer this mental picture to paper."

A lot of teachers seem to think so, but I don't think it is true. It is probably a flaw in logic to say that since if you can draw something, you already can design it. Drawing is one exercise that will let you know what you do or don't know. So it is excellent. And if you want to sell designs, you have to give a client something, which may even affect certain fine artists. So there is that. To make your own stuff you are not taking on the whole world so you can keep the actual drawing skill to a fairly low level.

When I started designing canoes back in the early 80s I realized rather quickly that I had to have a number for everything if you like. Actually even earlier than that I wanted to draw a cat, and I realized that while I had lived with them, just facing a blank sheet of paper with no model, I didn't really know where all that cat stuff went. So you just think you can see it in your head, but it is not really there.

Getting back to the canoes, and you might like this, there are hundreds of numbers people don't know, what is the fineness ratio for a touring canoe, a marathon one? And something gross like a ratio is just the beginning, every square inch has to be defined and in it's correct place. 3D compound curves. So for starters you start to work with the numbers. Measure the heck out of stuff. If a table works, get some numbers. there isn't much point in applying the Golden Mean if your shoulders won't fit in a chair so designed.

"Could I draw and ellipse I would be in business."

It is a few clicks on a computer, then you can print it; or you can use a string and a few pins; or you can get as many curves as you can lay your hands on. I actually like ship's curves, though full sets are crazy expensive, but the small sets work well with the scale of furniture. One thing a person with some curves quickly finds is that they fit naturally on plan sets. Some of the great artists of the Yacht, and they were great, none the less their curves came right off the Ship's Curves. They set right down. So being a great draftsperson is not entirely necessary.

These days there is design software for just about anything, often free. I was recently trying out G-Thang, and decided to design a Kasha guitar shaped Uke. I went at it in G-Thang, and I entered numbers, eyeball the result, etc... When I was done, I modelled a commercial plan, which I assume was just reduced from the sets that are available for classical guitars. I then merged them in a Cad program, You could virtually not tell the deference between the two. I have a good eye. And that is not so easy looking at small computer screens. But it also points to the fact that there are only so many ways for a design with even a few constraints to come out. So while maybe you will never be as good as your friend, it is not that difficult to be as good at the folks selling 110 dollar CNC machined, lexan pattern sets.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#15

revealing another shortcoming

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't have the patience to make something twice. I have done it, once with a Krenov wall cabinet and a second time with a tray stand, but on both occasions I painted the poplar test piece and used it. I don't see an opportunity to rescue anything useful from a mock up of a desk. What I might do is to do two legs and the long rail. I did that on a plant stand and realized that some parts needed to be lighter.

What I have found on curved legs is that a small amount of curvature makes the point so that it is easy to overdo something curved. I made 4 test legs once for a coffee table and not trusting my eye settled for the least curved. Should have made 5, with the last even less curved that the 4th.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#16

wood deceptively strong

Chris Friesen

I think your artist friend may be selling the material short. You can taper down to a *very* slender leg if you do it right. Hickory can take over 9000 psi in compression (with the grain). Heck, even pine can do 4500 psi, which means that a short section of 2x4 should be able to support over 11 tons.

One of my favourite designs from a structural standpoint is this bed by David Fay, where the pieces are designed so that they're thicker where necessary for the joinery, then slim down where the extra material isn't needed.

http://www.davidfay.com/piece.php?id=30

Alternately, something like the Simple Shaker End Table from Popular Woodworking (where the legs taper from 1 1/8" down to 5/8") stands out to me as having beautiful proportions. Make the legs smaller than that and it would just look fragile, but much thicker would look "chunky". As it is, it's perfect.

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/HiRes-SEPT2004-Seg2.pdf

Re: A day with an artist on design

#17

mockup with something quick

Chris Friesen

Nobody says you need to make the mockup out of wood. Use cardboard and foam and tape it together.

Anything that gets you something big enough that you can evaluate it realistically, see the play of light and proportions as you move around it, etc.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#18

Re: revealing another shortcoming +1

TomD

"I don't have the patience to make something twice."

I would have a limit on the size of mock up I would be willing to do, I guess. I am working on some prototypes for... Let's call them "hand bags" in leather, very heavy leather. I am adapting designs that were cut to be sewn by hand, for machine, I made extensive recuts for more of a gamer rig. All this is helping me build my overall skills and get used to a sewing machine I have only done a few yards on. So yea, I am doing stuff several times. At the end of that I will have a unique to me design. And I will have learned a lot about what kind of allowances to make for different weights of leather, or the needs of my machine, etc... So I get more out of it than just the mock-ups.

Yesterday, I did my very first leather carving, also my very first portrait, and one of my very first drawings of a subject vs something I am making. It sucks, but I think it will improve if I do it over about 5 times.


I also drew a beam for a trimaran yesterday, which is solid ground for me. So a I try to keep a variety of projects going so it doesn't get too tedious.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#19

Re: mockup with something quick

TomD

Yeah, knock the basic structure together, then print out some patterns and tape them over the square legs kind of deal.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#20

Re: So are teenagers

TomD

So true about strength, the one thing one has to be careful of is that the parts remain in column so the loads are actually in compression. Curves are a challenge that way. I am always scared at the stuff that happens when furniture is dragged, large vibrations etc... Few people today will treat clothes or furniture with care. Stuff is assumed to be steel tubing or disposable. When stuff is made by hand, a mentality appropriate to that should accompany it's use.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#21

compressive strength largely irrelevant

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

It is hard to imagine a compression wood failure in a piece of furniture. But wood splits readily and flexes even more readily. It is a trivial task to build a floor that will hold a tank but a considerable amount of timber is needed to make a floor rigid. Same for a table leg. If too slender the table will not be rigid, an annoying flaw in my mind. If drug across the floor, a not unlikely experience, a slender leg could split or the mortise in a slender leg fail.

Re: A day with an artist on design

#22

Re: mockup with something quick

Bob Hackett

Two things that a mock-up will give you that a drawing will not is the ability to see how light will play from different angles on the real thing and, if you`re building for yourself, family or a friend, the ability to set the piece in the environment it will live in and see how it relates to the things that will surround it.

For some people, having the opportunity to see things in 3D and in their home will either settle their minds on making decisions relating to things like details or send them off on a completely new direction because they can then see how and why something they had in their mind will just not settle into their home.

The "making things twice syndrome" is a common thing with folks pride themselves on making original work, even if that work has drawn it`s inspiration from a classical or historic piece. I have a wood sculptor friend who`s work has sold for 5 figures for a piece you can hold in one hand. He once told me that he had a hard time developing his self discipline to the point where he could draw a sketch involving a bit of detail and not allow his mind to say "We did it, we`re done with it, now let`s move on" . He realized rather quickly that by giving in to this he had abandoned some really interesting concepts without even scratching the surface of their true potential. Giving in to the urge to "move on to the next challenge" rather than explore the present one was one of the things that had held him back from moving up to the next level and realizing his true potential.

He went on to tell me; "Now I try to go to that place where time means nothing, where it`s just me and the piece I have in front of me. There is always more work, material and inspiration out there. I try to focus on honoring what is here and now and not become distracted by the rest of it. As long as I continue to be patient, receptive and breathe the things that really matter for this piece will come through".

Re: A day with an artist on design

#23

Re: wood deceptively strong

Bob Hackett

You bring up some very interesting points.

First consideration is to use the most appropriate materials prepared in an appropriate manner. Want a rigid table, use a type of wood that doesn`t flex as much rather than wood that looks good or has the color you want. You can always use the finish to make it fit your decor. Try riving the wood or naturally grown things like the flare at the base of a stump rather than sawn lumber from the local distributor it if you want thin yet strong for parts like legs. Boatbuilders have been doing that sort of thing for centuries with great success in both the strength and beauty departments.

That work by David Fay appeals to me because it`s joinery mimics the traditional ironwork of punching and drifting the material leaving the mass and strength of the metal where it is needed most rather than drilling a hole and creating a place of reduced strength. This type of ironwork is quicker, stronger and most people take to it because it looks and feels more "organic". (there`s that word again) :)

Re: A day with an artist on design

#24

Re: riving is oversold

TomD

Following grain is good, but riving is oversold:

1) some woods don't split well, like elm

2) in small sections, or where unequal portions need to be remove (probably the main case with legs), riving does not follow the grain.

3) Any curve tends to be hugely harder to pop a split out of. Sometimes it just pops, but I have had pieces a that were small and just would not go. twist is worse, though mild twist is no disadvantage structurally or aesthetically.

But +1 on your point, I just think one is often better off with a bandsaw, drawknife, etc...

Re: A day with an artist on design

#25

Riving is often misunderstood and undersold

Bob Hackett

Most people think, as your post suggests, that riving involves driving a wedge into a piece of wood and hoping for the best. Riving, the splitting rather than sawing of wood, involves other tools such as a brake which allow you to control the direction of the splitting.

I would offer that when you; A- select a piece of wood with appropriate grain flow, B- practice controlled riving using skill and technique aided by a full understanding and compliment of tools the results will be a beautiful and exceedingly strong piece that can only enhance a project. This is especially true if you plan to steam and bend a part to further shape it. In this as well as several other respects riving is seriously undersold IMO.

This particular part of the thread really begins to define the difference between a WWer who begins by felling a tree and one who begins at the nearest lumber dealer. I have come to believe they may in fact be completely different animals gnawing at different ends of the same bone. :)