Re: +1 again, except... It's scraping
TomD
"Most people think, as your post suggests, that riving involves driving a wedge into a piece of wood and hoping for the best. Riving, the splitting rather than sawing of wood, involves other tools such as a brake which allow you to control the direction of the splitting."
You make my point. I agree, one can steer the split, this is why it is not different in those cases from what a bandsaw can do. The sell job is that riven parts are stronger, because the splits follow the grain. But as I said, as did you in the above quote, it only follows the grain under certain circumstances. In others you can steer it across an inch or more of wood. The actual advantage of riving, when it works, is that splitting wood is either faster and more efficient, or it is the only method if you have a downed tree at a distance from your nearest appropriate power tool. But within the capacity of either method there is no advantage in grain follow.
Another thing that tends to be misunderstood, is that grain follow is only a strength advantage where the part in question is at risk of breaking and better grain orientation would make the difference. Not all parts are going to break with imperfect wood. The only graded application I know of where perfect grain follow is required is archery (I think it is pretty extreme but there are lots of other things from hickory golf club shafts to hammer handles that would also benefit and for which there may be gradings). Bows need to be perfect and arrows should be, but can get away with less. Aircraft grade wood is about 20-1 runout by grade, which is actually pretty bad. That is the approx range for a wing spar or other structural part, if I recall correctly. Of course those parts are engineered to 5 or 6 times the design load, and are not expected to deflect much. Colloquially bows are said to be 7/8th broken at full draw.
Another interesting fact is that in order to have maximum grain follow, one technique used is to scrape to within a line. This is how character bows with severe grain issues are made to high gradings. Splitting would almost certainly fail to gain the grade, but a scraper will. notice how grain follow is preserved around the knot. This is a pretty tame example, but my search skills let me down..

I get a lot of wood from trees, tuesday night I scored some really nice logs of maple. This is my beech outing:

I also have to buy stuff, particularly for guitars, and ply for boats.



