New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#26

Re: Hadn't thought of molders...

jack curtis

Now if you could come up with a durable printable plastic, you'd be in business. Injection molding is insanely expensive, as you no doubt know, due to the tooling costs. I don't know a lot about the plastics used in 3-d printing, but if one suited, that would be way cheaper than any kind of molding that would produce decent results.

This technology has fascinated me for 20 years now. The cool thing about this technology as applied to woodworking planes is that a plane of multiple parts could easily be designed and built. It would be easy to build duplicate common parts, then combine them for different planes, say hollow and rounds.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#27

craigd

Circuit board plane

craigd

I'd like a smoothing plane made from a pile of laminated printed circuit boards. I don't think it is healthy to machine but it does have nice properties. And I do think it would look cool.

Interesting tidbit about molds: a machinist friend of mine has a 3D printer that uses paper (glue down a layer of paper, cut the edges, glue on another sheet, repeat). (Example parts include a two shouldered bolt with captive nut that turns). Anyway, he would make temporary molds for White (the truck people), who would cast a one off part to test before investing the $100K to make a metal mold.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#28

Re: CNC

TomD

Yeah, power tools, particularly wood cutting ones, beyond speed, are mostly of limited interest to me. But CNC is huge because it allows one to go from concept to a finished object directly. Usually normal power tools want to tell you too much about what the thing needs to look like and how it needs to be made. It's all relative, but the degree of intrusion is key for me.

David, I have all the reels I need, but I could use a CNC bamboo taper cutting machine.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#29

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#30

Re: Just one word...

Rob Lee

Hi David!!

Provocative post....I like it...

I would say though that my aversion isn't to plastics - it's to the tooling - which is hugely expensive, and can limit design options (mold release/part line constraints)...

We do have designs for a full set of hollows and rounds in multiple materials right now....

Cheers -

Rob

(going to read the balance of the thread now!)

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#31

Re: You've nailed it

Rob Lee

Hi -

Printing tooling is something we've done here - to make some low volume parts. I'd post a picture.... but it would blow a possible utility patent.... :)

One of our 3D printers uses ABS plastic - which can be drilled and tapped easily. Still not as strong as an injection molded ABS part - but if used with care, is surprisingly robust.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#32

Question about another LV product....

roger lance

Rob....There is a thread below on making a small wooden router plane that used your router blades. Currently, LV offers a small router plane that doesn't make use of the great selection of router blades you offer for your large router plane. Does LV plan to offer a small router plane that would use these blades in future ?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#33

Plastic is good

Patrick Gibbons

I really love Disston's D-95 saws with Disstonite handles. Millers Falls' Buck Rogers tools make me drool. Are these better tools? I don't know. But the point is that plastic has already been successfully done. There's no reason that 21st century tools can't grow on this base. The U.S., last I checked, was the place to source good plastic in the world. It's a strength we have. Well made tools that were produced here in the U.S. that had a price advantage because of their plastic content would get my attention.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#34

Re: Question about another LV product....

Rob Lee

Hi Roger -

That's a tough one to answer....but for the moment - "no" is the safest.

We do have some other router plane concepts that use different blades (though they are square shanked)... but not scheduled for production at this time.

Cheers -

Rob

(who just gave a tour, and saw two new products!)

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#35

gantry mill?  Lee Valley get on it

TomD

Sorta, I think they run on a 2 axis set-up, with one being X, and the other Z; Left Right, Up Down. There are a few out there. One of the impacts is that one can design tapers on 1 inch, or any increment, vs the current 6 inch format. That might be overkill for many sections, but I am sure there are transition points that would benefit from that kind of thing. Since most people are designing in CAD anyway, I think the thing has legs if it ever get generally accepted that inch increments are the way to go.

http://www.rlnunley.com/nm42901.jpg

A CNC project has been on my to do list, seriously, for about 5 years, and the years just go by. There is the usual Canadian sourcing issue, and I probably chose some blind alleys also, I am really interested in this seemingly simple home made mill, but it actually turns out to be really expensive. I keep waiting around for the industry to supply parts, but they are not comfortable with the model where they supply parts, they want to be the entity that comes up with a 2-10 K machine everyone will want. And while that makes sense, I don't see CNC in quite that light. I think the whole thing is more open source. And I think someone like Lee Valley should realize that and sell parts that are somewhat easier to use, but allow one to configure specific tools. Unfortunately it is probably too late. What is that really saying? Someone should come up with a way of making this easier for 50 year olds? Like those smart phones with big buttons and small feature sets...

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#36

scott grandstaff

Couple thoughts

scott grandstaff

Design would call the tune, 100%

Topping wood in the hearts and minds of the average guy? This is a tall order.

But they did it with screwdrivers, socket drivers, and hacksaw handles. They took a shot with chisels and there are plenty of plastic handles around.

Color and profile would be the key. It can't just look good,

it has to look completely spectacular!!

If this chisel handle were carved in ebony, and on a decent chisel, it would be residing in the Smithsonian. The design is airtight when viewed from up close. A goal to shoot for in design.


I carve handles for all kinds of tools. Everyone knows I do.

Design is the key. Material matters and it better be good material, but in the end, design rules.





yours Scott

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#37

Re: Acrylic

William Duffield

Pen turners, who used to work in exotic, highly figured woods, have migrated whole-heartedly to acrylics, in unusual colors and patterns. They still use all the tools and supply chain for the wooden pens, but evidently the "market" is driving them to wholly synthesized materials.

I still prefer a turkey quill :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#38

Re: Couple thoughts

TomD

I personally would not use a chisel that had that handle, in wood or anything else. It does not look practical to me. Which if nothing else, raises the question of cost again, if the every punter has a different opinion.

My own feeling is that a new material works best not when it cheaply replaces some luxury example (though we see that often enough and in the mass market it probably accounts for many fortunes), but when it brings something totally new to the table. So the cast iron, atrocious Bailey type planes, clearly makes new things possible that wooden block did not allow. Or if a someone comes up with a plastic that replaces the blades, and has the sharpness of ceramic, and the toughness of iron.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#39

Beautiful saw handle, Scott


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#40

"We do have designs for a full set of hollows..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"We do have designs for a full set of hollows and rounds..."

Rob, you are a cruel, cruel man. Just when I think my wish list at Lee Valley is more or less complete, you find new temptations to dangle before us.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#41

Re: "We do have designs for a full set of hollows.

Rob Lee

It could have been worse Bill....

I could have posted pics of the 4000 molding planes ready for the next antique sale....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#42

Re: "We do have designs for a full set of hollows.

TomD

Let me guess Nunavut this time? :)

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#43

Re: "We do have designs for a full set of hollows.

Rob Lee

Are you concerned that we're going to have a sale, and you'll have access to Nunavut???

:D :D :D