(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
#1
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
I knew you'd never manage to keep to your promise
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
David,
Just one word? My count is 349, not counting the movie reference 
It's an interesting idea. As Lee Valley has demonstrated with its plastic-backed backsaws, intelligent use of plastic can lead to pretty nifty stuff; although Rob Lee was also right about woodworkers' resistance to the idea*, as demonstrated by the initial omiGAWD reaction to those backsaws in a lot of circles.
Having once owned a Stanley transitional jointer that was in severe enough winding over its length to see without any aids, I appreciate the idea of a plane made from material with some of wood's advantages but without its sensitivity to humidity.
I'll be interested in this discussion.
-------
*Not to mention Dustin Hoffman's resistance.
Re: Just one word...
david weaver
I am too lazy, and right now too poor of time to experiment with anything, but it would seem to me that if nothing else, designing a metal plane that had screw on versions of some of these plastics would be excellent. If they could be cut so the iron just bedded on the edge of them, maybe they'd have the light slickness of waxed wood, but with better durability.
Invariably, my biggest problem when I get tired is leaning on the plane. That makes the plane feel more dull than it is. Be nice to have that not be so punitive.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: interesting link
david weaver
Don't forget the plectra on harpsichords...
George Wilson once said something to me about harpsichords and plastic, but he might've been talking about the entire jack and not just the plectrum.
I can't for the life of me remember what he said, though. I think it might've been in reference to a complaining player who wanted to be able to play a traditional one in the rain or something.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Will never forget plectra...
david weaver
I could easily remember correctly just by asking george again, but supposition is much more fun. I think it might've been an issue with the harpsichordist complaining that the natural jacks didn't feel like the plastic ones he was used to.
Plastic may well be just as good to someone who has never played before (I wouldn't have a clue, though), but I've noticed a tendency in just about everything in the world that just as good but different is often described by just about everyone as being horrible.
Sometimes otherwise better or even dominant (game theory metric, not the chord based on the fifth scale degree) is described as such. Especially when someone or a group has income based on maintaining the status quo.
Re: Since the 1930s ..... *PICS* *LINK*
James Pickering
Stanley used various forms of plastic for chisel handles starting in the 1930s
(please follow the link below)

Re: Just one word...
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Poor Steve Knight once had the temerity years ago to breathe the merest possibility of using a phenolic for sole material. He never heard the end of it.
I just looked him up. Steve's in the CNC routing business now. Godspeed.
Wiley
Re: Miracle Fiber W
TomD
I'm all for plastics, mostly. I wanted to make a Corian plane, but this is one of those "My precious" materials in Canada that I never found a good source for at a decent price. I could probably have found an unloved noris at the time, more easily than scoring a sink cut-out at a decent price. In substitution I made a krenov plane with a wide custom Ron Hock blade, using impregnated diamond wood. This material is bot plastic and wood.
A simpler approach for the home shop in most respects its just to carefully seal parts of a wooden planes with epoxy. This can be done is such a way that the plane appears completely natural, and yet is resistant to moisture absorption.
Plastic is possibly stable, but it is not nearly as stiff as wood, and dimensional stability in use is more than moisture stability. I remind all of my experiments on cast iron vs wood, where the end numbers were virtually identical, on deflection under load, when comparing cast iron to wooden jointers. This is where the cheapness thing comes in, there are composites that have ideal capabilities but they are things like carbon fiber, epoxy, syntactic foam etc... An LV backsaw with some classy carbon fiber would have radiated quality (though I probably would not have splashed out for it, and I like my LV saw).
A lot of this is based on the common perception among woodworkers that wood is somehow a second rate material. This is true, really, but what is forgotten is that none of the materials being discussed here is even on the list. Wood is still the number two material for aircraft or boats, when compared to steel, aluminum, carbon fiber. Scale factors being the big issue. Making an aircraft carrier out of wood or the Spruce Goose, is not practical, if possible. But at certain scales wood often outperforms, and it is sad that so few woodworkers get it, or are advocates for Miracle Fiber W.
Resistence to plastics by woodworkers
James Pickering
Bill Houghton wrote:
".......... As Lee Valley has demonstrated with its plastic-backed backsaws, intelligent use of plastic can lead to pretty nifty stuff; although Rob Lee was also right about woodworkers' resistance to the idea, as demonstrated by the initial omiGAWD reaction to those backsaws in a lot of circles."
I recall the disdain that was directed toward Stanley plastic handled chisels by the older craftsmen at Tillotson's truck cab and body building works (Burnley, Lancashire, Northern England) as I commenced my apprenticeship there following WWII. Some of those old gentlemen were in their mid to late sixties and were skilled coach builders who had hand built horse drawn buggies, coaches, hearses and the like before motor vehicles were commonplace - for them, the only acceptable constituents for woodworking tools were wood and steel.
I really liked my Stanley No. 40 black plastic handled chisels - but I kept them in my tool box and used my Marples boxwood handled chisels instead when I was assigned to an old craftsman - just so I wouldn't have to undergo a lecture regarding the virtue of wood and steel tools versus "bloody cheap plastic".
James
Made by Kodak
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
The yellow plastic in the previous post of the Stanley chisel is cellulose butyrate. It was widely used for premium chisel and screwdriver handles by Stanley and Sears as well as others and even more recently by myself (see PIC). It is exceptional tough, but quite expensive. It was developed by Eastman Kodak and manufactured in their facilities in Kingsport TN. The plastic is made from cellulose, derived from wood (how appropriate). In fluorescent colors it provides a colorful contrast to the dull wood handles on more pedestrian chisels.

My initial thought...
John in NM
Is that, engineering properties aside, no one will be able to overcome the wood/brass prejudice. A delrin infill plane made by a custom maker might sell to collectors, but I doubt there is much revolution to be found in woodworking, especially handtool woodworking.
I would love to know someone with an injection molding setup. I make some parts out of casting urethane, and I've about had it with the mess. Oh well, keeps the overhead really low, which injection molding does not 
Trouble is, plastic is simply not sexy, at least not to the likes of us. I think that is why the gag in the Graduate was funny then, as it is funny now. No one can get excited about plastics. Kind of quaint now to watch the old version of Sabrina, with Humphrey Bogart raving about how great this new plastic made of sugar cane is....
Re: Made by Kodak
James Pickering
Thank you for that valuable information Bill.
James
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: You may well be right [appended]
TomD
""Trouble is, plastic is simply not sexy, at least not to the likes of us."
Speak for yourself, John! A lot depends on the shape, texture and the function. You obviously haven't shopped in some of the stores or catalogs I've seen. Germany? Japan much? Scary."
Are these premium products... inflatable?
I am guessing nobody here shops some of the places you shop...
"Seriously, imagine grown hand tool woodworkers who can't put down, can't quit playing with a resin-cast moulder that looks, feels and works unlike anything you might imagine a moulding plane to look like or be, and at less than double digits USD to make."
I could imagine that. I think molders are the right place to go, because few people really have a good set with crisp fits, so there really isn`t a choice on the flips side. A lot of products start with cheap in there somewhere, but it gets lost on the way to the market. I'm sure that if the Dollar Store could sell them, they could be made for a buck each. They make solar charging patio lights for a dollar.
" Of course, non-disclosure agreements were involved."
Too late for that!
"Would they have the cachet, provenance and collectibility of the real thing? Of course not. But then, further imagine a half set of highly-functional H&Rs priced below the cheapest decent block plane."
The Rali plane is something that could have sold for nearly a buck. And it is seriously arguably the best plane design to come out since the 18th century. But it ends up costing the same as a Record, and they didn't sell many. I think the time is right though for molding planes. I know I want them, but I am not spending a couple of hundred and up for each one.
Hadn't thought of molders...
John in NM
Extruded acrylic would make a pretty cool molder.... You could color code them too 
But the point is, if one is going for "downmarket" - meaning inexpensive tools for everyday use - there is no point in competing with the power market - even in the third world. If one is going for high end niche, its brass and rosewood, maybe some stainless. And crazy rope knurling on the knobs 
Now if you could come up with a durable printable plastic, you'd be in business. Injection molding is insanely expensive, as you no doubt know, due to the tooling costs. I don't know a lot about the plastics used in 3-d printing, but if one suited, that would be way cheaper than any kind of molding that would produce decent results.
Don't care .....won't do plastic
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Hadn't thought of molders...
greg forster
many years ago on this forum, I broached the idea of using Corian for boxing on moulding planes
and went into hiding immediately afterwards.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Of course
Ron Harper

Re: You've nailed it
TomD
A lot of hobby guys are printing molds, that is pretty routine.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Yes it is *LINK*
Leo Cuellar
Great ideas, David!!! The mind boggles at the possibilities. And as for sexiness, when you had one that you really wanted to doll up, you could have it printed in titanium or stainless.
I can hardly wait until my 3Doodler gets here.
3Doodler