New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Free Labor

Posts

Free Labor

#1

Free Labor

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley made a comment two weeks ago that [18th century] American furniture was built by free labor. There is a big part of the apprenticeship equation which he ignores: the master was required to train the youth in the trade during the indenture. He also usually housed and fed them, but training and supervising is the big consideration.

Consider what it costs for hand tool training today. With tuition and housing, guys pay a thousand dollars or more for a one week workshop, or maybe three or four hundred for two days. Young people can go to colleges or trade schools, some of which are taxpayer subsidized. However, somebody has to pick up the tab for tuition, room and board. Some graduates only wish they left school without debt and with the real world experience that apprentices once had.

Today's woodworking factories avoid skills that take more than a few days to learn, but training hand workers and supervising them is a lot of work. And it is to your benefit to promote them to a position where they can work independently. The apprentice needed to be bound to a term so that the master was compensated at the end of the period for his investment in training at the beginning. I can remember George Nakashima moaning about how he lost thousands when a new worker, once so eager, lost interest after six months and walked out the door.

Re: Free Labor

#2

no such thing as Free Labor

mark hennebury

I had over the years several eager young people offer to work for me for free to gain some experience, and I did take on one or two. Here is my perspective:

First i think it depends on what type of work you do. I haven't been in to many shops, so this is just in my limited experience.

The higher level of technical expertise your work requires the more expensive and time consuming it is to train someone to be able to do it.

I have been in a few shops with lots of employees that do low skill work and you could take someone of the street and train them in the job in a couple of days at most; These places it pays to have free labor.

The fact is from a business perspective for the work that i did, it was simple not worth having them.

I couldn't leave them alone to do even the most basic of jobs without a lot of one on one time training them, so unless it was to be a long term relationship, it was simply far too expensive for me to invest the necessary time and effort upfront with the hope that they would stay and I would get some payback down the road.

That being said, I enjoyed the company and loved to teach so that part was of value to me.

The reality is the higher quality work you do the more it will cost you to have " Free Labor"

Re: Free Labor

#3

Re: Free Labor

joel moskowitz

In the 18th and 19th century the more desirable an apprenticeship (and joinery apprenticeships were considered good and a well respected shop had tons of applicants) the more likely the apprentice paid a fee, sometimes a fairly large one, in return for the indenture.

In larger shops it would be typical of apprentices to be trained by journeyman. This in itself was no bad thing. But the quality of training ran the gamut from idealized to totally corrupt. In at least one of my accounts of Victorian cabinetry apprenticeship, the writer remarked that he would get orders from the master to make stuff and in order to learn how he had to pay one of the journeyman to teach him. They regarded his questions as a major distraction to their own making their piecework rate and wanted compensation. Some of it was just spite and abuse.

The apprentices who got the best training and deal were sons of masters, training in their father's shop or at another guild member's shop.

Today in Europe, especially in German (which has some of the higher taxes but also the highest training subsidies ) most university education is free or nearly so, and many apprentice programs are subsidized by the state. It's not an accident that the German economy is the strongest in Europe.

There is one serious overall issue with apprenticeships. In a good shop doing a wide variety of work and apprentice can learn a lot. In good factory apprentiships, then and now, apprentices are rotated amongst departments to get a wide experience and training (and to find out what they are good at). However most shops specialize so there was and is always a good chance that what the apprentice learns is how to do a very narrow range of work, very very well, and doesn't get the breath of instruction you might get in a school (without the speed).

There is a lot to be said for formal apprenticeships. But it's not a universal answer. And someone has to foot the training bill. In general I think the idea of huge college depth is a sad commentary on how this country has turned it's back on the future.

Re: Free Labor

#4

Re: Free Labor

TomD

Certainly what people are paying for in modern schools is not skills to earn a living. Often then just go to more courses, don't even do the stuff they learned. I guess it is like teaching music, where only a fraction of the students actually do the practice. The prices reflect the fact that it is entertainment. There is also in most cases a star system. People go to see a particular person teach them dovetails or whatever. Whereas in the old system the work demanded that the apprentice learned and produced, and that the master was capable. One did not have to have bought a DVD first.

Re: Free Labor

#5

Re: Free Labor

TomD

"Today in Europe, especially in German (which has some of the higher taxes but also the highest training subsidies ) most university education is free or nearly so, and many apprentice programs are subsidized by the state. It's not an accident that the German economy is the strongest in Europe."

In general I think it is just their seriousness. They work harder, and with more purpose. My dad's generation was like that. When he was running the university he passed up many pay raises to show a good exampel, during the 70s and 80s. The subsequent generation sold people on the idea that tuition should rise 10 fold so that they could "compete" for the best people (though this dodge did not require anyone to compete for their current job). A lot of people just coast and hope that immigration will drive up property prices, and they can retire off the value of their property. I don't think it is the system so much as the people in it.

"There is one serious overall issue with apprenticeships."

I don't think that is the main problem. Apprentices don't pull their weight any more. We have a system where we lavish opportunity on the young and do not expect anything in return. I was watching (really) an ad's worth of that family of 18. They were in China where they seem to be stars because the average Chinese can't imagine the wealth of parents with 18 children to slave for their benefit. Yeah right. A combination of the one child policy, and the idea of intergenerational obligations in China. The benefit of providing the opportunity to the young is that they will pursue creative endeavours and invent the I-phone, or Donkey Kong. But no kid will stay in an apprenticeship much longer than they are interested in it, which is years before they have reached a pay-back period. That isn`t a bad thing or bad kids. But in 35 years I have yet to hear of anyone who has had an economically viable experience offering apprenticeships in NA

Re: Free Labor

#6

Re: apprenticeships.....

Edward in Vancouver

I completed a Cook's apprenticeship in Luzern (Lucerne) Switzerland from 1985-88. This is a 3 partner deal: The apprentice, the employer, and the Gov't, who supplies the formal education ( 1 day per week in a technical school) plus the testing and qualifications. By the age of 15 students must choose either to go into an apprenticeship or go on to further education, the choice is pretty much 50/50.

My pay for the 1 st year was 680 Swiss Francs per month, at that time a coffee or a beer cost about sfr 2.50. Each year the pay went up another sfr 100. But once I completed my apprenticeship, my pay shot up to sfr 2,400.

A lot of bonuses to this system. For one thing, the apprenticeship costs nothing (money wise, that is). Another is that at the age of 18 you have the foundation of your trade established, a qualification to show for it, and are earning a decent salary--no Starbucks jobs, and you have no debt. Yet another bonus is you are still employed after completion, although many choose to leave once completed.

Canada never had an established apprenticeship system, but a lot of smart people are starting to figure out it's a good system with a lot of benefits....

Re: Free Labor

#7

Don't dismiss the "modern" woodworking teacher

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have used the woodworking instruction available now days to good advantage to learn and make stuff. These classes can move one up the learning curve quickly and put one on the right path to learning a skill. If the technique is taught by a professional the path learned will be efficient and reliable. I took a day class with Nick Cook, came home and practiced some, and made a spool bed, and numerous things that followed. What I was learning on my own had been bad lathe habits. I took a week class in the Mack Headley shop. I came home with a French Footed wall cabinet as good as that they sell for $2000 as well as the skills they use to make French Feet, drawers, doors, veneering and general cabinet framing, and numerous other tidbits. In the most recent example the $200 I spent for a day with Steve Latta left me with the skills to do line and berry as good as what I saw on Period pieces.

Indeed some waste their time in classes but that does not diminish the value to others.

Re: Free Labor

#8

Modern US "apprenticeships".....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

We have equivalents. If there is a business need it will get met. How may vary with location and era. So ,while we don't send our children off to some master to become employable we have alternatives that accomplish the requirement for producing masons, carpenters, and mechanical engineers.

For the trades we have 2 yr technical schools. One excellent example is the school that Steve Latta teaches at. Each year the classes build a house. The plumber students plumb, the woodworking students make trim and cabinets, the masons mason, etc. The school seems to be prospering and students finding jobs in their trade. Locally our technical college trains welders, lab technicians, computer wizards, etc. These programs are closely aligned with the needs of local businesses.

In the technical disciplines we have coops. Coop programs are often used by companies to recruit their engineering needs. For example, neighbor is in mechanical engineering. Beginning in his freshman year he will spend one semester per year at a company(he will be doing robot automation at TRW this summer). Each year his work there will change and each year he gets a pay raise which in the last year will be a rate similar to a starting employee. These coops usually lead to a job offer at the company upon graduation.

Re: Free Labor

#9

Free (?) Labor in the Middle Ages

Clementine

This is the way it was done in the Middle Ages according to Will Durant:

The fraternal spirit among the masters did not prevent a sharp gradation of membership and powers in the craft guilds. At the bottom was the apprentice, ten to twelve years old, bound by his parents, for a period of from three to twelve years, to live with a master workman, and serve him in shop and home. In return he received food, clothing, shelter, and instruction in the trade; in the later years of his service, wages and tools; at the end of his term, a gift of money to start him on his own. If he ran away he was to be returned to his master and punished; if he continued to abscond he was forever debarred from the craft. On completing his service he became a journeyman (serviteur, garçon, compagnon, varlet), passing from one master to another as a day (journée) laborer. After two or three years the journeyman, if he had enough capital to open his own shop, was examined for technical ability by a board of his guild; if he passed he was made a master. Sometimes the candidate was required to submit to the governors of the guild a “masterpiece” a satisfactory sample of his craft. (Will Durant, The Age of Faith, 636).

Re: Free Labor

#10

Re: Modern US "apprenticeships".....

Hank Knight

Federal government programs discourage traditional apprenticeships. I don't want to start a discussion about Affirmative Actiion, but this story both heartbreaking and instructive.

One of my clients received a Notice from the the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) that they were in violation of the Federal Affirmative Action requirements. My client is a long-time federal contractor and had maintained an Affirmative Action Plan in its general operation for years. They had been audited by the Feds and never had any trouble with the AAP requirements. They were perplexed. I arranged a meeting with the OFCCP agent and learned that the violation stemmed from the client's federally sanctioned and approved apprenticeship program, the flagship of the client's recruiting program. I told the agent about my client's excellent history relating to its Affirmative Action obligations and the agent was unimpressed. As it turned out, in order to operate a federally sanctioned apprenticeship program, an employer must maintain a SEPARATE Affirmative Action Plan specific to the apprenticeship program and submit to periodic audits and reviews by the Feds.

For those of you who have never dealt with Affirmative Action Plans, you should know that they involve enormous amounts of record keeping and paperwork, including accounting for and tracking each applicant for a position by race, ethnicity etc. and engaging in affirmative outreach to recruit minority applicants who are under represented in the work force. The plans must be filed with the Feds and a compliance report filed each year. They are an enormous administrative hassle and expensive to maintain. After weighing the cost of complying with the Affirmative Action requirements of the apprenticeship program and balancing the costs against the benefits of maintaining the program, the client decided to scrap the apprenticeship program.

Re: Free Labor

#11

Re: modern technical schools

Edward in Vancouver

One of the major obstacles in my field--cooking- is the problem of "front end loading" at the schools. A student is crammed full of knowledge during a one or two year period with an absolute minimum amount of hands on working experience. Upon completing the course, the student is let loose on the employer where skills such as working fast, multi tasking, and thinking on your feet have to be learned.

Usually, the best graduates are the ones who have had previous working experience prior to the course, and/or ones who worked part time during the course.

Re: Free Labor

#12

Re: Free Labor

roger lance

This week-end, I repaired some drywall....a minor skill....but one learned working with my contractor father. I began working with him when I was 7 years old carrying cement blocks to where he was laying up a basement wall. In those days, it was common for sons to work with their dads....often making a partnership in the business as the years passed. My father did not pay me....in my teen years, he'd give me a $20 after work if I had a date on a Saturday night. But my dad was there to help me build my house....something I could not have done without him. This topic makes me think of all the country kids growing up on a farm and all the chores and farm work they do....and all the skills they develop as a result. What seems to be missing in todays world is the act of working....I've lived in my nice middle class neighborhood for 30 years and have yet to have a kid come to my door to be hired to cut my grass or shovel my driveway....things kids did long ago to earn a couple of bucks.

Re: Free Labor

#13

Re:It is not the teachers

TomD

Your area seems to have an almost unique concentration of serious people like yourself, and people in your club or area who are world class. That is not the norm.

There is nothing wrong with people going to schools for the entertainment value, and it is certainly true that the whole level of individual skill in the hand tool area is getting really high. So people are learning something somewhere. It may even have topped out above the necessary level. But that is different from pretending that seminars and courses with star presenters are the modern day apprenticeship.

Re: Free Labor

#14

Re: Modern US "apprenticeships".....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My guess is that for the seminars you attended, Bill, there were more affluent retirees than young people trying to learn a trade. Steve Latta does teach the youths at Thaddeus Stevens College. The College is owned and heavily subsidized by the State of Pennsylvania, so the tuition and room and board is only 15,000 per year. In addition, many students probably get Federal grants and free interest loans, more subsidy that some taxpayers would like to see disappear. My point is that training the young in a trade is a large expense. It was once borne by the master (no free labor). Now the parents, the government and the trainee have to take up the slack.

Re: Free Labor

#15

Thaddeus Stevens...where do the..

david weaver

... where do the graduates go? There is one person out here who is making a go of marketing 18th century furniture. There may be others, but I've never seen them.

He is the maker of this piece. I only looked him up after going to penns colony, wondering who would take such nice stuff to what is more or less a festival of kitsch.

https://www.horton-brasses.com/resources/projects/williamandmary

Young guy. I didn't drop by his booth because I didn't really have any reason to. I do wonder who would buy furniture of this type around here, because this city has had a habit of demolishing old areas, and there is not a huge appreciation for older things like there may be in philadelphia or boston, nor is there a collection of houses 200 years old.

I might be a cynic for saying this, but I don't know that many people will be able to make a go of making furniture like that unless they subsidize it teaching retirees one trick at a time in high dollar courses, or go into repair work....or both. And it might sound crass, but if t. stevens college dropped that kind of thing, I wouldn't lose sleep over it, I don't think it does favors for anyone getting into the job market now, because it's not likely that society is going to favor the style anywhere other than in museums in the next 40 years.

I suppose landing at a museum, or at least getting a contract of regular work to maintain older pieces is probably an ideal situation.

Re: Free Labor

#16

Apples and Oranges

Bob Lang

From my conversations with Steve, his program at Thaddeus Stevens is very much geared to preparing the students to go out and earn a living in commercial cabinet or furniture shops. There are a few junior college programs around that country that have this goal and meet it successfully. There are others (better known among hobbyists) that teach how to make extremely nice pieces of one-off furniture that very few people are willing to buy.

The mindset in Europe is quite different regarding skilled trades as an occupation. I don't think you can legally open a cabinet shop in Germany without having served an apprenticeship, and meeting the standards to be a "master" craftsman. Here in America, all you need is a two car garage, a table saw and a router.

Bob Lang

Re: Free Labor

#17

Re: Apples and Oranges

david weaver

And a blog. Don't forget about the blog. Blogs make experts faster than achievements or experience ever did.

Thanks for the clarification, by the way. I had kind of wondered whether the guys coming from the TSC program were being groomed for industry (sounds like it), and if the folks doing the spectacular but harder-to-sell work were maybe a minority there (besides, we'd see more of the work, I'd think).

For some reason, I always think of this picture when I hear about the TS college of technology, maybe because I've driven past it so many times and never seen the actual school.

http://www.lincolnhighwayexperience.org/place/442

Not remotely similar.

Re: Free Labor

#18

Re: Thaddeus Stevens...where do the..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a friend who went to Stevens. He is a fine 18th century carver. His time at Stevens predates Steve Latta's tenure. My impression is that he learned carving after graduation.

Re: Free Labor

#19

Re: modern technical schools

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My brother is a chef who learned his craft in an apprenticeship in California, serving under a chef who learned cooking as an apprentice in France. My brother has held every position from sous chef through executive chef to food and beverage director at exclusive clubs, restaurants and hotels. He once told me that he had hired and fired a high percentage of the grads of cooking schools because, while they possessed the theoretical knowledge, they also had no practical skills to speak of. He didn't have time to teach them; he needed someone who could cook.

Re: Free Labor

#20

you need to get out more

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I can name many professional Period furniture makers. For starters here in TN there is Alf Sharp (self taught) and Buddy Floyd (apprentice under the famous guy form Knoxiville featured in an early FWW but I can't recall the name). There is the family Mack Headley shop with Jeff, and Steve Hamilton. They were busy with a desk and table when I stopped by last month. In near by PA there is Andersen and Stauffer. In New England Al Breed, Will Neptune and a host of others. North Bennett graduates several each year. A check of any of the furniture books (for example 500 cabinets or 500 tables) featuring furniture will reveal several more. The defunct magazine "Home Furniture" featured Period furniture makers.

That said, these styles are currently out of fashion. I am told that prices for typical antique Period furniture are down substantially so I suppose the demand for reproductions has lessened.

I think the Federal Period furniture could inspire modern versions of it with less embellishments and up to date carving that would be attractive to today's client. The problem is that the Period makers I know of are firmly stuck somewhere before 1820.

Re: Free Labor

#21

Re: you need to get out more

david weaver

I don't mean one person in 10 million, I mean in a metro area of 2.3 million people, I'm not aware of any of them except the one guy at penns colony. If I got on google or went to CW, maybe I could see a bunch of folks all at the same time.

I can't imagine why I'd do that, though. I've not got a great deal of interest in furniture that's ornate for its own sake.

What I do see is a lot of gallery furniture that is tasteless mixes of stuff like curly maple and purpleheart. Whatever it is, I did wonder if there was some gob of period furnituremakers coming out of TSCT, but it sounds like there's not. I'm not surprised.

Re: Free Labor

#22

Somebody is using the hardware

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Londary Brass, Horton Brass, Ball and Ball, Whitechapel only sell Period Brass. Somebody must be using it to support these companies continued existence.

Re: Free Labor

#23

Re: Somebody is using the hardware

david weaver

Yeah, that's a separate issue, and by all means, if they sell the hardware, good.

If people want to make period pieces, good.

But I think it's a waste to subsidize the schooling if a master/apprentice system can't be supported.

Which goes back to what warren said about the classes (not TSCT, but the one-trick each classes) being supported by retirees and not by droves of starry eyed kids who are going to work 12 hours a day making period furniture.

Re: Free Labor

#24

I am missing the point

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't understand the point either you or Warren are trying to make. The supply of people doing Period work, or any other variety of work, seems to be meeting the demand. The quality of the work is as good as ever. However these people are being trained varies and is not as it was in 1720. (Unless they are a music or athletic protege parents don't give up their children to "masters" at age 12 any more.) What's the issue?

I suspect cheap machines and excellent communication has rendered the apprentice program of 1720 unnecessary and obsolete. Alf Sharp got to the level he is at with out the 1720 model for getting there, or formal training. Ditto Fred Stanley and likely many others. Their work equals any. Again, so what, if the demand is being met successfully. If it wasn't something would change to meet the demand.

For the record, in the day class I took from Steve Latta there was a professional furniture maker and graduate from North Bennett looking to learn the skills necessary for Federal legs. There were at least two young students similarly learning this aspect of Federal furniture presumably for future profit. I didn't get to know the other students. Some appeared retired, others not.

Re: Free Labor

#25

Re: I am missing the point

david weaver

This has gone in circles so much that I can't even remember the main point.

But I agree, there is plenty of supply. What I thought might be the case (lots of people going to TSCT to do period work) sounds like it's also not true, which is good, because it doesn't seem like there's a shortage of self-sufficient types doing the work with huge backlogs. Instead, it seems that the most common model for financial success is to:

1) either do refinishing or restoration and get a steady job doing it somewhere

2) teach other people to do the same type of woodworking and do better financially teaching than doing

Otherwise, we're probably just arguing disjointed points and getting further away from making sense.

I do wish we could see more of warren's work, though. And I don't say that in a trolling way to suggest it doesn't exist, I know it does. We just don't see as much as I'd like to and I like the super credible points of view that we get from folks like George and Warren. (George also went to college and was a math and shop teacher for a while. I couldn't point to many classes george took based on my conversations with him, except that he credits one very harsh master/instructor who taught him to be a lot more demanding of his design).