Re: "having stuff that holds its value"
david weaver
Just being able to figure out what holds value and what the value will be when you need it to be turned into something liquid is a bizarre concept.
I hear the term all the time "this will be a great investment".
OK...really? One example would be antique bikes. For a while in the last two decades maybe, antique bikes were way up and people bought a bunch of them. I don't know what the rarest of the rare is of those, but most of the "rare" have watched the bottom drop out.
Infill planes are down. The term is always brought up for houses (we should know better than that, houses depreciate, land appreciates), it's brought up for musical instruments (which are an exercise in babysitting if you don't play them yourself, and a lot - you'll instead be volleying musical instruments around in various states of needing repair or working their way toward it).
And he demand for 18th century style furniture is down. So, maybe 18th century stuff itself, at least the finest of it is still worth a lot, but that's not something most of us will ever have, unless you have plain pieces like my parents have, where you can't tell their origin, and you don't know if they're 150 years old or 225 years old. But the new stuff, when are reproductions going to appredciate? It's a push marketing thing to sell that stuff. If I'm the buyer, I should be able to tell you I want something, especially if it's something big, subject to damage, and something that could be lost in a house fire.
In the last 7 years, I've watched the houses of two of my neighbors burn, both for separate electrical reasons - right across the street. Stood there and watched the second one burn with the neighbor a few steps away. Do I really even want valuable stuff in my house? It doesn't improve my quality of life. I think a lot of these kinds of thoughts are those that are made now by middle and upper middle class that would have the discretionary cash to support an artisan, but just have no clue why it would have any value to them. (and they shouldn't, they should be concerned first and foremost with their own financial security, not that of craftspeople - leave that to the rich).
The upper class will support some artisans (be it hand made car makers, etc, or whatever), but they'll be buying things none of us will make or buy. So to have a school that is putting kids out there doing the stuff makes no sense to me. It's subsidization of a market that benefits who? The folks who want to build will build, and as warren implies, they'll probably learn what they really need to do separate from school when they find a desire and a demand and can tie the two of those together.
I personally really question how much "stuff" I'd need to have in my house, and when it comes down to it, the stuff that's high value really doesn't amount to much. If somebody throws out the stuff I've made (both the tools and the few pieces of furniture), I guess I really don't care. It could just as easily burn up and float away in a cloud of black smoke.