On emulating the past
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
When we look at well displayed pieces of furniture in a museum it is easy to believe that their makers were making stuff the best way possible-after all it lasted 250 years- and that we should strive to emulate these craftsmen and their techniques. Indeed, there are pieces, often commanding 7 figure prices, that represent the pinnacle of craftsmanship in 1720. And, there are plenty of pieces made by good craftsmen doing their best to make a living by making furniture that customers would pay for.
Some museums have a mission to provide for the study of the stuff they have. These museums have a process to apply for the opportunity to study at the museum. I recently was granted permission to study the Chester County furniture at the Chester County Historical Society Museum which has a good collection of furniture, "spice boxes", and clocks. The purpose of the trip was to study "line and berry" layout techniques, but that is another story.

Drawers- I am fascinated by drawers. There are so many ways to make them and fit them with varying degrees of lasting success and pleasing appearance. It would not be difficult to equal the dovetails in this piece. Efficient is a descriptor that comes to mind. The bottom was installed with grain running with the sides and it predictably split. Still your socks would not fall through the crack and it was quicker to make.
The drawers in this pieces were made with a variety of wood, no doubt what ever was handy. Some sides were quartered oak, others poplar. Bottoms were oak, or poplar, and absurdly thick. But it was cheaper to bevel an edge than resaw to a thinner stock.

Runners were nailed to the side and this arrangement has held up admirably. However, there were no kickers installed for the arched drawers on the top and the drawer functioned poorly. I built one of these three arched drawer chests of drawers and framing the top to enable kickers was complex, and expensive, and obviously a way to cut cost if not done.
The dividers in this piece were installed with through mortise and tennon. Robust, no doubt, but not a joint I care to use.

In another piece I studied the drawer bottoms were fixed with a single nail through the bottom of the drawer side about midway. Predictably, as the drawer wore then nail didn't and all the drawer dividers had an 1/8" wide groove milled away where the nail traveled. What were they thinking!
Wood- Every piece in the museum suffered split wood. It is common to blame these wood problems on "central heat". It would be more accurate to blame these problems on insufficiently air dried lumber. Note the drawer in the above picture. There is a 1/4 gap at the top, likely a result of the drawer front shrinking after fitting. The cracks located in tops and sides and drawer bottoms had opened and stayed open. Clearly a result of the wood drying after assembly, not seasonal comings and goings.
One's objective could be to precisely reproduce some piece of furniture. However, if the goal is to make a piece of functional furniture similar to some previously made piece, it may be possible to make it better, and or easier, if not wedded to the techniques employed by its maker.
My personal philosophy is to learn form the past, not replicate it.





