New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

On emulating the past

Posts

On emulating the past

#1

On emulating the past

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

When we look at well displayed pieces of furniture in a museum it is easy to believe that their makers were making stuff the best way possible-after all it lasted 250 years- and that we should strive to emulate these craftsmen and their techniques. Indeed, there are pieces, often commanding 7 figure prices, that represent the pinnacle of craftsmanship in 1720. And, there are plenty of pieces made by good craftsmen doing their best to make a living by making furniture that customers would pay for.

Some museums have a mission to provide for the study of the stuff they have. These museums have a process to apply for the opportunity to study at the museum. I recently was granted permission to study the Chester County furniture at the Chester County Historical Society Museum which has a good collection of furniture, "spice boxes", and clocks. The purpose of the trip was to study "line and berry" layout techniques, but that is another story.


Drawers- I am fascinated by drawers. There are so many ways to make them and fit them with varying degrees of lasting success and pleasing appearance. It would not be difficult to equal the dovetails in this piece. Efficient is a descriptor that comes to mind. The bottom was installed with grain running with the sides and it predictably split. Still your socks would not fall through the crack and it was quicker to make.

The drawers in this pieces were made with a variety of wood, no doubt what ever was handy. Some sides were quartered oak, others poplar. Bottoms were oak, or poplar, and absurdly thick. But it was cheaper to bevel an edge than resaw to a thinner stock.


Runners were nailed to the side and this arrangement has held up admirably. However, there were no kickers installed for the arched drawers on the top and the drawer functioned poorly. I built one of these three arched drawer chests of drawers and framing the top to enable kickers was complex, and expensive, and obviously a way to cut cost if not done.

The dividers in this piece were installed with through mortise and tennon. Robust, no doubt, but not a joint I care to use.


In another piece I studied the drawer bottoms were fixed with a single nail through the bottom of the drawer side about midway. Predictably, as the drawer wore then nail didn't and all the drawer dividers had an 1/8" wide groove milled away where the nail traveled. What were they thinking!

Wood- Every piece in the museum suffered split wood. It is common to blame these wood problems on "central heat". It would be more accurate to blame these problems on insufficiently air dried lumber. Note the drawer in the above picture. There is a 1/4 gap at the top, likely a result of the drawer front shrinking after fitting. The cracks located in tops and sides and drawer bottoms had opened and stayed open. Clearly a result of the wood drying after assembly, not seasonal comings and goings.

One's objective could be to precisely reproduce some piece of furniture. However, if the goal is to make a piece of functional furniture similar to some previously made piece, it may be possible to make it better, and or easier, if not wedded to the techniques employed by its maker.

My personal philosophy is to learn form the past, not replicate it.

Re: On emulating the past

#2

interesting post

McKay

Very insightful. I was interested to see that no effort was made to hide the pivot point for the curved line.

Re: On emulating the past

#3

Re: On emulating the past

Bruce Mack

I make compromises in much simpler work for myself, mostly from lack of talent or lack of doggedness. Perhaps there should be time-outs in the process, when we ask "Is this my best?"

Re: On emulating the past

#4

Picking up the torch

Mark Hennebury

I have always looked at it from the point of view that we learn all that we can from those that came before, but consider it a duty to pick up the torch and move on.

We honor all the pioneering efforts of those that developed the craft to its highest level, by continuing to develop it, by building and advancing to the best of our abilities, as I believe they did in their time.

The human spirit is designed to push forward, to constantly seek better, faster , stronger, and sharper.

That is why we are in awe of the great furniture and architecture of the past.

Where we get our inspiration to be woodworkers and to push our own limits.

Surely we would be doing a disservice to not develop the craft.

To just stop and copy would would be the saddest and most shameful end to a noble craft.

Re: On emulating the past

#5

Re: On emulating the past

TomD

Air drying is air drying. It is sufficient to the environment. Come along and heat all the air, one is changing a central parameter. I am not sure how this is a failing of air drying. All wood is air dried by the time it hits the shop or end user. Kiln drying is not superior to air drying. In general the differences are not noteworthy, but there are cases were the results are worse, or preferable, but as far as wood movement is concerned, there isn't any advantage.

How good was this piece? It doesn't look all that distinguished. Not so much because of the details you point out. As you say there are many of the comon shortcuts. There is nothing new about that, but it is always interesting to see examples, and from a museum collection, all the better.

When the modern masters started lavishing all kinds of work on pieces; finishing all sides to the same level; Using wood of outstanding quality on all the parts, this practice stood out. It can't do any harm, and simply has to do with the purpose of pieces:

- I talked to a young friend who is in cheerleading competitions. I asked her what team she supported... Wrong question, she had never cheered for a team and just does competitions.

- Since I started making spinning wheels the whole sector has changed, it is now like bowl turning with little practicality to it.

- And then there is bowl turning...

We are getting off easily in the cabinet field if the main expression of over achievement is a little extra quality.

Re: On emulating the past

#6

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

TomD

One hears about furniture making in Philadelphia, say, and they had their own regional style, I gather. But back a few hundred years, the place was a backwater. This was driven home to me when my cousin got her Order of the British Empire, and in the background of one of the photos, there was a piece of furniture in a waiting room at Buck Palace that was from Mars compared to anything I had ever seen before. In 35 years I am not sure that I have ever seen any top furniture seriously discussed in any woodworking magazine. We need a series of Clousseaus to go to Buck Palace, and places in Europe, and report back of the shortcuts taken in the foundations of the actual masterpieces of the age. I won't be that surprised if even these pieces have shortcuts, people love to put the money were it shows. I wonder whether the frames supporting the canvases of great artistic masterpieces are commonly made of primary wood and elaborately joined...

Re: On emulating the past

#7

compass points

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

One could consider them part of the line and berry decoration. Fortunately they survive and provide a simple means of determining how the pattern was laid-out on the drawer, which was the purpose of the study. It appears, as I previously proposed, that these drawer patterns were, by and large, laid out with ruler and dividers with only a few compass radii being used for the set of drawers. At least on the patterns I investigated the patterns were not established free-hand. This is good news in that it means an "engineer" can lay out the pattern; it does not require an artist.

Re: On emulating the past

#8

Engineer...artist

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"This is good news in that it means an "engineer" can lay out the pattern; it does not require an artist."

The two are not mutually exclusive. Good engineers and good artists both use the tools that will meet their goals. Myself, I think your work veers toward well-engineered artistry.

Re: On emulating the past

#9

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

In the main, not even close to British furniture of the comparable period. Certainly not technically close.

British and French cabinetmaking of the 1700 and 1800s was the technical pinnacle of hand-wrought woodworking.

Re: On emulating the past

#10

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

A lot of the stuff we drool over and reproduce here wouldn't have made it above stairs in England.

Re: On emulating the past

#11

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

William Duffield, Going to Winter Haven

Have you read Gustav Ecke?

Re: On emulating the past

#12

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

Yep.

Re: On emulating the past

#13

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

wilbur


Qing Dynasty furniture. Inlay, carving, mitered joints all over the place. From a technical standpoint, it would be hard to beat this.

Oh, and this was done in sandalwood, which is up there with other rosewoods and hickory in terms of hardness.

Re: On emulating the past

#14

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

Carving powerhouse for sure. I can't see enough of the joinery to make a comment, but I'm familiar with how these were typical done in Asian styles and they require mucho skill.

Re: On emulating the past

#15

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

I particularly like this piece. The buyer did as well. It sold for 74,500 GBP. Technically challenging but much more pleasing to my eye than the piece you posted:

http://www.sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2013/mark-birley-collection/lot.416.html

Re: On emulating the past

#16

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

wilbur

Joinery close up of the table.


The leg forms a miter with both stretchers. And then the carving starts.

This piece is in the Shanghai Museum. If you ever get a chance to see an exhibit of real Chinese furniture, you should. Looking at them in the flesh will blow your mind.

Re: On emulating the past

#17

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

wilbur

That's not too bad, but I don't see any joinery in this piece that seems more technically difficult than the Qing Dynasty pieces I posted. The marquetry is nice, but I would wager that carving on the scale of the Chinese table takes more time and effort. Also, the inlay on the screen takes the same sort of skill set as marquetry, except that they were cutting jade for the inlay pieces.

Aesthetics are another matter entirely, of course. To each his own. Personally, neither piece would fit well in my house.

Re: On emulating the past

#18

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

I think that sometimes Asian joinery is difficult for difficult's sake, especially in the furniture. That has never impressed me much. I've seen some woodworking puzzle joints that beat both of these pieces in terms of sheer difficulty. That's not really what I'm getting at. At least not totally.

Re: On emulating the past

#19

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

wilbur

The main reason for the type of joinery used is to bury end grain. For example, if you look at traditional Asian furniture, you'll see frame and panel construction for a table top, instead of a glued up board. A glued up board would have endgrain showing at the ends. Breadboard construction to cover the ends would not have sufficed, since the ends of the breadboards are themselves exposed.

There were two reasons for this. First was aesthetic. Exposed endgrain was considered to be a sign of crude construction. The second was practical. By hiding the endgrain, you minimized wood movement in a part of the world where humidity swings could be quite high, which is a concern when the available wood used for furniture was not as well behaved as straight grain mahogany.

One thing for sure is that the joinery was not meant to be complex for complexity's sake. Asian woodworkers had the same motivations to be efficient in their methods of work as anyone else. I should also point out that this joinery was figured out by the Ming Dynasty, which was several hundred years before the pinnacle of western woodworking, as you define it.

If you're not impressed by that, then why should anyone be impressed with the technical skills of British and French cabinetmaking of the 1700-1800's?

Re: On emulating the past

#20

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

David Weaver

Agreed wilbur, it's impressive no matter what, and a western view of english or continental cabinetmaking being better "just because you want it to be", with more agreeable wood doesn't make it better than chinese woodworking. The porcelain from the ming and qing era is no less than incredible, either.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/dd/Museum_f%C3%BCr_Ostasiatische_Kunst_Dahlem_Berlin_Mai_2006_041.jpg

Same with the boxes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:FFM-QingRotlackDose.JPG

Neither of the styles (18th century furniture nor ming or qing dynasty stuff) would ever fit in my house, it's straw-manning of the highest degree to try to wedge some english piece ahead of the Chinese goods.

Re: On emulating the past

#21

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

I'm impressed by the execution.

Re: On emulating the past

#22

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

CStanford

I'm impressed by this furniture too, but I don't like it:

https://www.google.com/search?q=louis+xiv+furniture&hl=en&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=Hb1RUYr_N6PSyAHY9oDAAQ&sqi=2&ved=0CAcQ_AUoAQ&biw=1343&bih=707

Re: On emulating the past

#23

Wilbur....hate to be carving on this and

roger lance

hear somebody say, "OOPS".

Re: On emulating the past

#24

Re: How good was American furniture anyway?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

American furniture was suited to the pocketbooks of the buyers. It was built by free labor--in a land where skilled labor was always in demand--and bought by earned money. John and Thomas Seymour of Boston (ex-pates from Axminster, England) sold fine furniture to the monied classes, the money being based largely on shipping and import/export business. Mr. Jefferson's Embargo on trade with England, starting in 1807, followed by the War of 1812, devastated New England shipping and the incomes of his customers. The Seymours' never recovered and died poor. The money which bought furniture was earned money. His customers were nowhere near 'gentlemen' by English standards--they worked.

There is certainly 'better' furniture (more elaborate and more finely finished) to be found in England, France, China, and, oh yes, let's not forget Germany,

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=ede_1355659804

nations with kings, emperors, noblemen, and land barons.

As Wilbur said, that magnificently elaborate Chinese dynasty table would not fit in his house. But indeed, it wouldn't fit anywhere in America at all, at least during the period-furniture era. By the way, there is cleaner-lined period Chinese furniture, with equally wonderful joinery, which would work. See Gustav Ecke, for example.

Wiley

Re: On emulating the past

#25

Good point Wiley

Patrick Gibbons

Furniture in Texas in the 19th century was mostly locally made. When people wrote GTT (gone to Texas) on their doors and headed west they seldom brought furniture with them. Most Texas counties had several one-man cabinet shops in business. Pine was the most common wood with other hardwoods. The completion of the railroads in the 1880's brought an end to this local sourcing of furniture and brought in Midwestern products. Styles were actually up to date, particularly from German-trained cabinetmakers. Not only were need and means a determinant, but the ability to ship furniture was limited. One could not expect a piece to be shipped to Texas and arrive whole and pristine. I expect the situation in other parts of the country were similar to that here in the Lone Star State.