Re: How good was American furniture anyway?
CStanford
You post almost seems to imply that there was no merchant class in Great Britain. There was, and they bought furniture too. And with earned money.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: How good was American furniture anyway?
CStanford
You post almost seems to imply that there was no merchant class in Great Britain. There was, and they bought furniture too. And with earned money.
Re: How good was American furniture anyway?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Charles,
Of course they did. Eighteenth century Britain was a true superpower, immensely wealthy. They had everything there was to have. And I meant no derogation by my remarks.
America by contrast was none of those things. Barely a fledgling, not a nation yet. Some people were doing very well financially, but their income was directly sensitive to the vagaries of politics and war, which is why I brought out the example of the effect of the Jefferson and Madison embargoes, and War of 1812 on the New England merchants, and hence on the market for upscale furniture. The wealthy Virginia planters generally lived in hock to London factors, according to statements by Geo. Washington. But now look at Britain: This was the period of the Napoleonic Wars (which was the root of the hostilities between Britain and US, since the US wanted to trade with both sides), and I have never read where the top English furniture makers of the time suffered greatly due to the wars, though I may be gainsaid on that point by someone who knows more about it. Perhaps Joel?
I might also have mentioned that Britain--like France, Germany, and presumably China--had a deeply-rooted guild and artisan tradition which would no doubt have produced more, and more highly-skilled craftsmen than could have been supported by the overall wealth of the colonies. The Seymours themselves were ex-pate Brits, and hired other ex-pate Brits as journeymen. [Wages for skilled people were higher in America than in Britain, and this gave rise to the loss of British seamen during the Napoleonic period to American shipping, the subsequent impressment of American (and ex-pate Brit) seamen by the Royal Navy in order to get them back, which contributed to the embargos and eventually war.]
In short, America at the time was a bunch of working people going for it. They succeeded greatly, but at the time the relative wealth of the American colonies and early Republic bore no comparison to that of the major world powers, of which Britain was perhaps foremost. And this wealth disparity naturally results in the difference between American versus the elaborate furniture styles of Georgian England, Louis XIV & XV France, dynastic China, and the German example made for the King--it was republican style versus Empire, in each case.
Again, no derogation intended to anyone.
Wiley
Re: How good was American furniture anyway?
CStanford
"I might also have mentioned that Britain--like France, Germany, and presumably China--had a deeply-rooted guild and artisan tradition which would no doubt have produced more, and more highly-skilled craftsmen than could have been supported by the overall wealth of the colonies."
That's essentially the point. There were practically nameless and so-called 'country firms' (practicing outside of London) that were capable of a Goddard-Townsend level of craftsmanship. Visit Sotheby's website frequently and you'll see what I mean.
The economics of the whole thing are interesting but if the discussion is about the essence of the depth and breadth of craftsmanship then there is virtually no comparison.
there is no absolute metric for judging "good"
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Seems some of you are judging the goodness of furniture by how much it was adorned with intricate carving and or inlay, ie how much it cost to make. One could justifiably choose style or some other metric and declare these over the top pieces "over the top" and dismiss them from the goodness challenge on styling or function. Personally I have never seen a piece of furniture "better" than a Townsend knee hole desk I saw in a museum. The proportions, carving(not over the top) and wood were as good as it gets. Covering it up with intricate carving, inlay and attachments would have made it more costly but not better.
The best of the American furniture fetches 7 figure sums. No idea how this valuation compares to the court furniture of England, France or China, but it is enough to suggest some think the best American furniture is at least very good. Then consider it was made in cities whose population was only 50,000 in a country one generation removed from the wilderness.
"one generation removed from wilderness"
jack curtis
I'm not sure that native americans would necessarily agree with that description.
Re: there is no absolute metric for judging "good"
CStanford
Sheer rarity accounts for a lot of the value of American antiques that sell in seven figures.
English furniture typically fetches less and that's entirely the point -- there is more of it and more that was consistently made well.
Rarity aside, there is not a whole lot about the 'best' of American antiques that weren't achievable by a whole raft of British firms.