New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

warpage, how can I save/prevent.

Posts

warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#1

warpage, how can I save/prevent.

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Hi all,

I recently made some cherry TV trays. They are 1/4 x 14 x 18 with a 1/4 x 1/2 strip of cherry around the edge. All surfaces were sealed with 3 coats of poly. They were originally flat through the coating process. I worked in an environment with about 25% humidity according to a digital humidity gage. I brought them into my house within a week they both warped indentically as the picture trys to show. I know I should have used quarter sawn wood but I thought this wasn't necessary. >(


What do you think guys and girls????

Work safe,

George

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#2

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi George,

Was the cherry frame surrounding the raw unfinished wood at the time you began applying oil/finish? If so, I'll bet that the tray bed expanded a bit when wet, and bowed (rather than warped) within the constraining frame--the tray bed had no place to go. If this is so, it wouldn't have mattered about the quarter-sawn, indeed it would have been worse with quartersawn material because the lateral expansion would have been greater.

Reason I ask this, is because I had a similar catastrophe in the past few days, caused by a constraining frame that I should have applied later, rather than earlier. Will tell my tale pretty soon.

Course, I could be totally wrong. But if it's the frame, you'd need to saw the frame off one of the trays (if PVA glue, or heat it off if hide). At that point, see what the tray bed wants to do, and make another decision depending.

Wiley

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#3

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

That is extreme. But in any case it is going to be difficult to keep a 1/4" thick piece of solid wood flat unless constrained in a stiff frame. If constrained something will give as Wiley explains. Hence, the solution is to make "plywood" and frame that.

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#4

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

Lars Parrington

how were the trays stored in the house? if one side was more exposed to air (or air circulation) than the other, then that is probably the cause of the warpage. storing them in the reverse configuration for a while should cause them to flatten back out.

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#5

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Hi all,

The edge was indeed on. This is something to remember!!!

The curious thing is both warped the same way while they were stored on edge. I think the edge is the issue.

To the saw for an experiment.

Work safe,

George

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#6

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

William Duffield

That's another reason I don't have a TV :D

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#7

Re: the extra stress can be too much


Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#8

Followup thought

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi George,

You've almost surely thought of this, but just in case.....Something you could do going forward, is to groove the frame deep enough so that the tray bed has some room to move. Let the tray bed float in the frame. Dovetail the frame together at the corners, and use glue only to hold the dovetail joints together. For example, put pins on the ends of the long sides, and tails on the ends of the short sides (or the other way round, whatever strikes you).

Wiley

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#9

Re: Followup thought - epoxy

TomD

+1. If that thing did not warp it would probably blow. You can't zero tolerance frame a piece of solid wood on 4 sides, over time expansion and contraction will blow that up.

One thing that does help is to seal endgrain with epoxy. I am not routinely suggesting this, there are traditional methods. But should you have to do this kind of thing, epoxy will retard end grain moisture absorption and give the piece of better chance. What I do is finish a piece right down to the wax. Then I cut the ends off very carefully so that no tear-out occurs. I use a fence and very sharp router bit to just whisker the end smooth. I wrap the end with masking tape and press it down. Then I apply a good grade of boat building epoxy, while the end is standing up. I allow it to sink in until a slight amount puddles on the endgrain. I let that harden, then I used the router to whisker the end again, and then I polish the end with wet/dry paper on a block and some oil or wax. Works well on trestle table instead of a breadboard joint. If course, in your situation you can just glue the heck out of the endgrain as you assemble the piece.

However, no amount of epoxy will stop the wood absorbing moisture. even if you drip the whole part in epoxy. Epoxy is permeable, though very much less so than other materials. But over time, it normalizes to enviro conditions. However, often all one needs it to slow the process down, and in that case it can be effective.

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#10

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

TomD

The other thing, if it was stable in your shop, it will be stable in your house, if the same moisture conditions prevail (at least up until you have a seasonal change). With stuff like this. I season the wood in the house. I get it to rough dimensions then put it in the room where it will end up. 25% is too low for comfort and fine woodwork, you need around 45%, but the realities of that will depend on local conditions.

Also, when you mill the wood, it will change, sometimes. Often the environment in the wood is different than the surrounding eviro. So if you had heavier sections say 3/4 and reduced to 1/4" You would have to have that at say 3/8 for a while and replane it flat to 1/4 after the 3/8 had stabilized. If you, for instance, resawed the 3/4 that panel would be potentially very unbalanced.

Of course the banding pretty much doomed this project over time, but would not make it go like a chip, normally.

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#11

Re: Followup thought

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I was thinking the same, except the frame might need to be a bit more robust.

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#12

Re: My edge really needs to be ......

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

allowed to float, like a bread board end.

The wood sat for a couple of weeks to stabilize. After it was glued up it still was quite flat. Then the warpage started, but it started about a week or so after it was in the house.

I am going to cut the edge off and reattach it. I will give the results of the experiment.

Work safe,

George

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#13

here is how I make thin panels

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

your problem has nothing to do with the frame or the finish or uneven air flow it, has to do with the the use of plain sawn boards.

I make 1/4" thick glued up panels fairly often and I rarely have any warpage issues. The technique I use is one I learned as a patternmaker. I start with a plansawn board between 4/4 and 84 and I cut it into 5/16" wide strips. Each of these 5/16" thich strips will now be quarter sawn. I do simple rubbed glue joints and I don't use any clamps. I do the glue up on the top of may table saw or drill press ( I have an unusuall drill press that has a 24" x 24" table) this will of course leave stains on the wood as well as the table but to me my table saw is a tool not a show piece. even with a good coat of rubbed down past wax the panel will stick to the table swa and you will need to use a scrap of wood and a hammer to break it loose.

For a 20" wide panel I make two 10" glue ups then send them through my planer for a 1/32 trim on each face to end up with 1/4" panels. I then glue the two panels together again doing a simple rub joint, this time I place weights on each panel near the seam but not on the wide panel. I scrape /sand this last seam to end up with flat quarter sawn panels.

I'll look for a pic of of my panels with a frame around it. After three or four seasonal cycles it is all just fine and none of the glue joints have failed.

Robin

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#14

Re: here is how I make thin panels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Robin,

Outstanding post! Possibly related question: Do you ever veneer with sawn veneer? Say, 3/32" to 1/8" thick, somewhere in there. If so, what do you prefer for substrate? Do, or would, you use the homemade quarter sawn grain orientation for that purpose, too? Rob Millard does this at times.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: warpage, how can I save/prevent.

#15

Re: My edge really needs to be ......

TomD

That would work. We had a tray like that when I was a kid, basically a picture frame with handles on it.