New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

Posts

Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#1

Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

David Weaver

Just curious, I don't have a plano setup and I'm guessing most folks just lay out a face frame on a layout table.

It seems to me the ones that would fit in the width of the plano clamps could be done pretty easily with a couple of cauls.

I'm not thinking about figuring out the absolute best way to do them, I'm talking about a way that works well and is fast.

At the cabinet factory, everything in the entire place save a few door hinge machines and edge sanders was pretty much made either by the maintenance department or custom ordered tooling. So what I saw there does me no good.

(Yes, I realize that nearly none of the virtues of the plano setup are actually needed to glue face frames. Maybe an L shaped batten with surface clamps on a sacrificial table would be better).

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#2

not necessary

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't know what a plano is but what ever it is it is not needed to make cabinetry and door frames. If the M&T joints are well prepared the frame is self squaring with ordinary clamps. Once I realized that a perfect M&T was the key to success these assembles became trivial once the joint is cut.

Now an investment is good clamps is beneficial. For light to medium duty there are none better than those made by Universal Clamp, available wholesale from the manufacturer if ordered by the case of 10, or Woodcraft. For heavy duty the Hargrave steel I-beam clamps are best. I find the inconveniently heavy jaws on the Bessey's to be annoying and I don't use them for anything.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#3

Re: not necessary

TomD

I had to look up plano clamps, and did not see much there that would appeal to me. My walls are fully employed, so space would not be an issue for me. Otherwise, the clamps seemed less desirable than normal clamps. They look a bit like a big mac, you know, 1.5 hamburgers for the price of over two. In the case of the clamps, they looked generally cheaper in construction, but they have some features like the press function that either aren't necessary, or where "necessary" are the wrong solution. Properly milled parts and clamps that are square, are the best approach. I would agree though, that they look fully usable for frames if one already had them. Just so long as they have the power. If glue ever grabs, one sometimes needs a lot of power to bump the parts home.

I like Besey clamps a lot, they set up very square, lie flat or square on the bench, and the jaws are made of plastic over lighter metal so I do not find them all that heavy. Plus for most things the beam weight, on the light side, is just about right. My mainstay clamps are the old Jorgensen I-beam clamps. They are pro grade, but not as refined as the Besey, or probably some of the other similar models. But they work great in the right hands.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#4

Re: Bessey and Others - Plano Feedback

David Weaver

I have gobs of bessey and jet clamps, and a set of cauls that will also work very well for boards that are similar thickness (I usually just shim them if they aren't).

They are a bit fiddly, though, when gluing panels. My objective would be something that I can put the panels in minutes, no getting clamps off the rack or anything like that, just put them in and glue.

Everyone I've talked to who has a plano setup gushes about it.

If I have time, I'd much rather use warren's method (with rough boards), which is what I do. To do the kitchen in a house that I may not stay in that much, though, I will run the planer and throw the door panels in a plano setup on the larger doors. If I'm lucky, I'll get boards wide enough to do the raised panels in one shot on all of the narrower doors.

It chaps my rear a little bit to fool with the cauls and still have to clamp 3 or 4 clamps.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2knWdkGh7M

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#5

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

roger lance

David....the Plano is basically designed for panel glue-ups....don't see how it would be advantageous to use in making face frames....those are often made now with a Kreg jig on a large assembly table.....again, it depends on the size of your operation as to what tools you might buy/use.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#6

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

David Weaver

Yeah, operation isn't the right word. Rubber band and duct tape kind of place is more accurate.

I don't expect anything other than a device that will hold the face frame flat, it's not going to need great glue pressure because the joints will either be M&T or dowel, depending on my level of laziness once i start them.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#7

I have never used a caul

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Nor have I ever seen any shop use one either for panel gluing. I have been gluing up 3/8" drawer bottoms 21" deep and had no need for this complication on even such a thin panel. As you gain experience gluing up a panel it will become such a trivial exercise that only some bench acreage and some good clamps will be unnecessary.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#8

Re: I have never used a caul

David Weaver

Keep in mind that I am usually gluing from rough now, and all of the work is hand tools. A caul is handy to have when you're doing that and the wood isn't that great.

If I was gluing coming out of a power planer, which I will be doing, there would be no need for cauls, it would be a matter of partial tighten, rubber mallet, fully tighten.

I've done this before when I used to use mostly power tools, before I sold most of them off. I didn't use cauls back then, either.

I prefer the way the plano clamp appears to look. You put the boards in the plano, you're still going on the bench, and none of your other clamps are tied up. I'm partially going also on how excited people who have them are.

In terms of an actual industrial solution, the only thing I've ever seen in use looks like a ferris wheel thats short and wide instead of narrow and tall. You work on filling it and by the time the panels make it all the way around, they are dry. Those devices (the old ones at least) are as big as a van. The are fantastic, I would I could have one.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#9

Re: I have never used a caul

TomD

"I'm partially going also on how excited people who have them are."

Fair enough, though I would say overall there is more wrong with that approach than right. I can remember being on the cantankerous side of a lot of arguments, and generally the products endorsed fade away. There is a mutual love society with each new product, or newly discussed. Often all that is really happening is the 10 people who spent too much for it are all patting each other on the back, there was never the consensus there appeared to be.

"In terms of an actual industrial solution, the only thing I've ever seen in use looks like a ferris wheel thats short and wide instead of narrow and tall. You work on filling it and by the time the panels make it all the way around, they are dry. Those devices (the old ones at least) are as big as a van. The are fantastic, I would I could have one."

I think there are industrial solutions that are far closer to a plano than the bar clamp. These devices take into account low skill labour, quality control (that otherwise would require care), and the ability to move panels safely out of the way. So the plano is probably more mainstream in that regard, as you say.

Now myself, if I wanted some ideal world, I would more likely prefer one that incorporated rubbed joints. They yield the best product, require the least gear and space. I would settle for a radio frequency glue dryer if they don't cause cancer.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#10

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#11

Re: I have never used a caul

TomD

Probably a good product, but the fact it has been out for 15 years does not stop the frenzy, that is just a crowd dynamic.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#12

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

John in NM

I worked for a shop for a couple years that had a Plano set up. I don't recall anyone using it for anything but panel and top glue ups. I would imagine it would work fine for face frames or frame and panel sub assemblies, assuming your joints are tight enough to be self aligning.

It would certainly keep frame assemblies out of the way while the glue dries.

For face frames going on plywood boxes, I mostly use pocket screws. Full MT joinery is overkill and time consuming for a frame that will be glued to a huge plywood box anyhow. But that's just me, I used to have more time available for projects and put less of a premium on in :D

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#13

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

David Weaver

Yeah, I may use dowels. I'd consider pocket screws if I were making them for pay and time counted, but I refuse to ever use pocket screws in anything that I ever build for myself. They just turn me off. If it takes an extra hour per frame to do M&T, I'll probably do it. They don't need to be super perfect joints internally because load on the frames will never be more than the door, and they'll be glued to the box.

I was always blown away when I was in the cabinet factory by the fact that the face frames were pretty much expected to be held on indefinitely by a fat bead of hot melt with really no quality joint fit at all.

But they held well on the older cabinets I've seen.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#14

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

John in NM

I used to feel that way about pocket screws too... eventually I realized they are simply another means of joining wood, they have their advantages and disadvantages, same as MT, dowels, biscuits, or what have you. Being by far the quickest and easiest, they do tend to get over used and mis-applied.

I would guess that a full MT face frame will add much more than an hour to your construction time. Dowels will be on a par with pocket screws for time, maybe a bit longer, and I think the results will be as good. I typically assemble the frame and apply it to the cabinet box, then sand the joints flat if needed. I've found dowels to be significantly weaker than screws for a face frame, but as long as it holds long enough to get it on the box, that point is of little relevance.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#15

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

TomD

The point is, plywood boxes with face frames are for the most part not even the classy way to make plywood boxes. And all that stuff is destined for the dump, in short order, when the look fails to further please. Which is to say that pocket screws are probably the right way to go for that kind of thing. If one is going to produce something for planned obsolescence, one should at least plat the obsolescence. And I am saying all that without intention to offend.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#16

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

david weaver

If anyone puts cabinets in their kitchen thinking that they are not destined to head for the dump upon the arrival of the next female occupant after a house sale, they're kidding themselves.

Extra time and money wasted on cabinets is much better spent on things that can go on a moving truck.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#17

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

TomD

Exactly.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#18

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

david weaver

So, yeah, I don't mind if they're the kind of lego construction sort of things. I should be able to do all of them with hardware and finish for about $2500.

To buy them after someone else did that would cost about three times as much, maybe more. I get to control the materials and use *good* cherry from a local supplier that will color match, too.

I've seen some pretty nasty stuff passed off as high quality cherry, with sap in it and huge color variations, very narrow boards used in the laminations and drawers that are put together out of boards made from very short cutoffs that are spliced by a finger joint machine. Those particular cabinets cost a woodworking buddy of mine $14,000 for about 1 1/2 times as many cabinets as I'm using and the ply on them was pretty ugly.

When I worked in the cabinet factory in the 90s, low end cabinets were just junk, mid grade cabinets were particle board sides but very much attention paid to high quality doors, drawer fronts and frames, and high grade cabinets were built in custom by an amishman. Back then, the cabinet factory was making the transition from particleboard to hardwood ply, it was only a 10% upcharge on a cabinet. Most people still weren't willing to pay, but each year the % of the cabinets on the line that were ply went up.

Anyway, you're exactly right that these are just going to be a hardwood box with a face frame and doors flopped on the front. Much like these:

http://www.instockkitchens.com/maple-discount-rta-kitchen-cabinets/cat_4.html

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#19

Plywood

John in NM

I like 1/2" baltic birch plywood for the boxes. Liked it even better when it was $15/sheet :D

Its still fairly reasonable compared to veneer ply, and while it doesn't finish up quite as nice it's good enough for my own use. I think it's now around $35/sheet.

There are a couple gotchas - thin so you have to be a bit careful with staples (if you are going even cheesier than pocket screws :D ), and not quite as flat as one would prefer. I can't remember the last time I had some flat plywood. Anyway, once the box is screwed to the wall and shimmed, any tweak from the plywood being less than perfect has gotten ironed out.

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#20

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

Michael Brady

With hand tools I haven't. Couldn't figure out where to plug them in. What's a plano clamp.. or a face frame, for that matter?

Re: Anyone do face frames in plano clamp?

#22

Face frame..

david weaver

face frame is a wooden frame that goes on the front of a cabinet. If the cabinet has adjacent cabinets, it's the part you see other than the door or drawer fronts.