New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Scratching tulips

Posts

Scratching tulips

#1

Scratching tulips

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I for sure am practicing before I have at the drawers which are otherwise done. I am using the LN tool and it works well. I am not as fond of the LN straight line tool.

I found that it is best to lay out the patters by lightly scratching with dividers and then go to town with the cutter aligning it with the divider prick marks.

Next I need to practice installing the stringing. So far that part has not gone well. Also I need to come up with a way to finish the ends of the compass cutter cuts so they are deep and square at the ends. The LN cutter makes cuts that trail off a the start and finish due to the cross cut teeth in this cutter.

Re: Scratching tulips

#2

Re: Scratching tulips

Patrick Gibbons

Would a small veiner or vee take care of the ends? Your sample looks great to me. Also, a nice looking piece of walnut.

Re: Scratching tulips

#3

Re: Scratching tulips

William Duffield, between Lake Dexter & Lake N

For cutting straight lines, an alternative is the inlay stringing cutter attachment for the Veritas router plane. I can't tell you how well it works, because I haven't tried it out yet. Maybe next week. According to Steve Latta's DVD on the subject, for terminating the curved stringing kerfs, to make it easier, some serious strategic planning is necessary. Where one string terminates where it intersects another string, glue the terminating string in place before cutting the groove for the second string that continues beyond the intersection. The order you cut and glue in the pieces makes a lot of difference in the number of ends you need to cut precisely to length.

For terminating strings that do meet the above criteria, I have made custom chisels the width of the stringing, out of worn out triangular saw files. If you need them for curved stringing, you can relieve the sides by grinding to a very subtle "fishtail" pattern. No one (except us) will notice a few small imperfections, especially after they've been filled with hide glue and finished.

Re: Scratching tulips

#4

Re: Scratching tulips

Larry Barrett

Hardened masonry nails also can be ground into chisel shapes to deal with the stringing ends.

Re: Scratching tulips

#5

Picture?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I expected that I needed a 1/32" wide chisel for making the termination of troughs. But as obvious as that sounds I can't pictures what one would look like. The end would be 1/32" but the transition to something robust enough to use escapes my imagination.

Re: Scratching tulips

#6

Re: Scratching tulips

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have some if I can just picture what the finished chisel would look like.

Re: Scratching tulips

#7

Re: Scratching tulips

Larry Barrett

I have a drawer full of hardened nails that are rectangular in cross-section, and are about 1/16 x 1/8 at the tip. I think you could grind and hone the tip into a chisel shape, and even add a handle if necessary. If you want a few let me know.

Re: Scratching tulips

#8

end clean out

McKay

I ground an old band saw blade with a hook. I am able to scratch out the ends as well as clean the entire cut of debris.

Re: Scratching tulips

#9

Re: Picture?

William Duffield, between Lake Dexter & Lake N

Sorry, Bill, you'll have to wait until I can get back to the Loxahatchee Toolworks (probably Monday) where I can get access to tools and camera and a real computer with picture processing and posting capabilities. I've got 1100 miles and two days of driving ahead of me. According to my wife, I may need to shovel some snow when I get home to actually get into the shop.

Since you are only working a nominal 1/16" deep, the side relief to negotiate the relatively gentle curves is minute. When I make one, I first grind the teeth off one face of the file for about an inch to form the back of the chisel. Then I grind a bevel, taking metal equally off the other two faces. Then, I grind the sides at 90° or a bit less to the back, until I reach the width I need to match the stringing. I stick the tang in a handle and use it bevel down. Since the saw file is quite a bit longer than a cut cement nail, it's easier to work on the wheel and stones and the head doesn't get in the way of putting a handle on it. Otherwise, the cut nails would work as well. If one is not into sharpening one's own saws, finding a concrete nail might be easier than finding a worn out #4 double taper saw file. In either case, the major issue is overheating and taking the hardness out of them.

Re: Scratching tulips

#10

You'll be scratching it out,

Chuck Nickerson

not chiseling it out. So the tool does not need to be that robust.

Re: Scratching tulips

#11

Re: Scratching tulips

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

It's looking good! What did you use to make the straight line (rectangular) surrounding 'frame' in your photo?

Wiley

Re: Scratching tulips

#12

Re: Scratching tulips....what I'm liking...

roger lance

Looking good Bill....what I'm liking around here is people trying new things, building new skills....you're taking on string inlay, Ron is cutting dovetails, etc.....this week I've used a scrub plane and router plane for the first time (adjusting thickness of tenons)....this is a good atmosphere.....maybe I'll even try sharpening :D :D

Re: Scratching tulips

#13

LN straight line cutter, not my favorite tool

http://Bill Tindall, E.TN

I used the LN straight line cutter. I don't much like it. It's cross cut teeth don't cut long grain well and because they are cro9ss cut ground one side won't go to the end of the scratch.

I have been experimenting with other tooth designs. With a Dremel, a Dremel cut off disk and a piece of 1" 0.032 band saw stock I can cut out the cutter insert blank in just a minute. If I knew more about filing teeth I am confident I could file a better pattern than what was ground on the LN cutter. For now I use the LN cross cut cutter as is for the cross grain and a two rip teeth cutter I filed for the long grain.

I will be with Steve Latta this time next week and will learn much more about the topic. Will report then.

I made another modification to the LN tool but yet again I have lost the ability to post pictures. Should it return I will post the modification. It enables one to hold the tool more securely against the work.

Re: Scratching tulips

#15

A warding file is very thin & might work


Re: Scratching tulips

#16

Re: Scratching tulips

Mike in Southern New Jersey

Hi Bill,

I hope to make some Line and berry drawers some day. This is not meant to be critical, but it seema as though the tool has left some significant "holes" in the surface where the points rotate.

How do you deal with them?

Mike

Re: Scratching tulips

#17

Re: LN straight line cutter, not my favorite tool

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

Have you seen the Veritas inlay tools and compared them with the LN?

Lee Valley do offer three inlay chisels of .025", .032" and .040" widths.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=69875&cat=1,250,43298,43314,69873

The Veritas inlay tool system:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=69874&cat=1,250,43298,43314,69873

The Lie-Nielsen inlay tool system:

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?cat=549

Anyone compared the two kits?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Scratching tulips

#18

comparison

http://Bill Tindall, E.TN

I was told by a person that does line and berry inlay that the LV cutter cut slower than the LN. Having experienced the LN cutter I can believe this is the case for cross cuts and circle cuts but not long grain cuts. I got the best and fastest long grain cuts with just a point mounted in a marking gauge, and control was better.. I find the LN cutter difficult to hold against the wood until I made a modification to it. It has a barely adequate fence rabbit to sit on the board. I found it teetery. I would advise anyone to make their own as an alternative to either LN or LV.

For banding drawers where one spacing is required for all the drawers I will make a home made cutter with rip teeth for long grain and cross cut teeth for across the grain. I think I can make the cutter in minutes.

Re: Scratching tulips

#19

hole philosophy`, etc.

http://Bill Tindall, E.TN

Well, if you look at any original you will see compass point holes. If you look at drawer sides you will see marking knife lines. Moldings were obviously nailed on. Etc. It is part of the construction that historically was acceptable to be seen. Even tool marks were evident upon close examination.

In modern times we seem to want our furniture to look as "perfect" as plastic laminate with no tell tale signs of how it was made or that it was made by hand. I call it the "studio furniture" influence where the furniture is decorator art instead of simply a chest of drawers to put socks in.

When I hand scraped the living room floor I was left with a chatter mark here and there. It was at this time that my hand tool philosophy was established. I could have sanded them out and been left with a "perfect" floor, but didn't. I thought, hell, someone may look at this floor some years hence and discover that some nut case scrapped it like it was 1820.

I don't make any effort to remove scribe lines on drawer sides, or perfectly plane and scrape/sand sides to perfection. It will be abundantly clear that the drawer was hand made and fitted . I might even leave a pencil mark here and there, for example a drawer part number or a note, to be discovered in the future.

My drawer fronts will have holes in them. If they could be seen from a range of 4' I might consider doing something about avoiding them. If they get "discovered" upon closer examination and the discoverer says, "so that's how this was done" I will be delighted. Alternatively, the troughs can be cut with a router or one can temporarily glue something where the points will fall and mow it off later.

Re: Scratching tulips

#20

Re: LN straight line cutter, not my favorite tool

William Duffield, on the way home

You might have lost the ability to post photos because WoodCentral doesn't recognize your user id. Somehow, you've managed to modify it, and it now has http:// in front of your name. You might try fixing that. Bill H. might give you more details.

Re: Scratching tulips

#21

Re: hole philosophy`, etc.

barryvabeach

I made a narrow chisel from an old file, since you don't go very deep, I only made the very end - say 1/2 inch or less, the right width. It works pretty well. First I used an inlay tooth cutter to make the groove, though it gets shallow at the ends, you have at least started the cut. You then make a stop cut at the end of the run with this chisel, and then use paring cuts to deepen the groove to get to the depth you want.


img

Re: Scratching tulips

#23

Re: Profile photo of chisel

barryvabeach

Bill, this is the side view, again, only the very end does the work, so it can be much beefier as you approach the handle. I usually use it bevel down when paring out the waste. BTW, the chisel handle is dirty, but I glued up the handle with inlay to remind me that this chisel is for string inlay.


img

Re: Scratching tulips

#24

that was even more helpful

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I will be grinding away on a needle file soon. I tried making something similar from a band saw blade. The metal was too soft and the edge didn't hold.

Re: Scratching tulips

#25

modification to LN straight string cutter

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


When I used the LV marking gauge with a scratcher installed I found it nice to hold each end for control. This LN tool is one handed and I have a hard time keeping it securely registered against the small rabbit which acts as the fence.

I replaced the brass screw that holds the blade on with a 3" bolt and jam nut and a turned piece of wood to grasp. With a two hands grasp I have better control.