New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

bench dogs

Posts

bench dogs

#1

bench dogs

Stuart Hough

I'm looking to make some round dogs for the bench. Would like any and all advice as to wood species and specifics as to size and configuration. Only thing I have nailed down is I have 3/4" round dog holes in the bench. Thanks in advance!

Re: bench dogs

#2

Re: bench dogs

Lars Parrington

mine are made of cherry, which i generally think of as being a fairly weak wood, but they've held up fine so far. so i expect almost any wood would be strong enough. if you're looking for ultimate strength, perhaps try hickory or ash.

i cut a flat on one side of the dogs at the top where they hold the workpiece, about 1.25" long. it is slanted a bit in such a way that the top of the flat spot contacts the workpiece first. i lined the flat spots with leather, which vastly improved their holding power.

i made a half-hearted attempt to put a spring on the side of the dogs so they would stay put in their holes. consequently, it only halfway works, but that hasn't started to bug me yet.

i find i have to go back and redrill the dog holes every month. as the benchtop dries out and shrinks, so do the holes, and the dogs start to get jammed. i suppose a normal 3/4" drill bit would work fine for this, but i use a 3/4" end mill chucked up in a bit brace.

Re: bench dogs

#3

Re: bench dogs

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

I made mine out of old broom handles that I turn down in my lathe to fit my holes. The unturned portion keeps them from falling through. I have a whole assortment of head "thicknesses" to suit any application. Make them in pairs though.

Work safe,

George

Re: bench dogs

#4

Re: bench dogs

Scott in Douglassville

I just cut up 3/4" hardwood dowels. If they're too loose, I add a bullet catch. If they get chewed up or lost, I just cut some more...

George, my dad used to live down the road from you, between Lowell and Ada. Wife and I used to love the "Lowell on a Roll!" sign when we'd come from Lansing.

Re: bench dogs

#5

My favorites

Ron Harper

I have 3/4 inch hardwood dowels and i add square tops to them. Usually by drilling a 3/4 hole in a small square and pinning it to the dowel with a small brad. Another way to do it is make an inch and a half square piece 3/8 thick. Drill a 3/4 hole 3/16 deep in the center of the square. Put dowel in hole and run small screw through the square and into the dowel. Probably could use epoxy and not need the screw.

Re: bench dogs

#6

Re: My favorites

William Duffield, between Lake Dexter & Lake N

Most of mine are the same, except for some details. I wedge the dowel to hold the block of wood, and I make the block rectangular instead of square, and drill the hole off center. That way, I can turn the dog 90 degrees to get a different spacing between dogs for holding irregularly shaped stock. i.e., the distance from the center of the dowel to each of the four faces is different.

Re: bench dogs

#7

Thanks to all!

Stuart Hough

Lots of good info I can use. I have enough dowel stock to make several pairs of dogs, and now have ideas for each different pair. I appreciate the use your knowledge!

Re: bench dogs

#8

Re: bench dogs

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Stuart

I built square dogs for the front of my bench, which is not what you want to know. However I also added round dogs as well, and in this case I am using brass dogs from Veritas.


I added leather to the faces, and this provides both grip and cushioning.

On my recent trip to Ottawa I came back with a new brass dog from Lee Valley, the Prairie Dog. These are handy as they simply pop up when needed.


All fit a 3/4" hole, which is also shared with my Gramercy and Veritas holddowns.

Just an alternative.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bench dogs

#9

Re: bench dogs

roger lance

Derek....I'm going off topic to ask you a question about the LV Beader Tool (05P04.50) which you gave a mini review.....it seems that your main concern with the tool was the short fence.....since there are two attachment points for the fence, could a wood fence be made and used on this tool as you did on the Stanley 66?? I'm thinking about buying the tool to bead the bottom of the curved aprons I'm making on my dining table....appreciate your insight.

Re: bench dogs

#11

Feeling frugal? Will Neptune scratching approach

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



We needed to scratch a bead in a class with Will Neptune and in a very few minutes he came up with something to fill the need. I have "refined" the tool by using a screw instead of the clamp.

Band saw blades make dandy scratchers. File the patterns with a chain saw file, sized to fit the need.

Re: bench dogs

#12

I was born feeling frugal.....

roger lance

making my own scratch stock is also under consideration.....this is sorta one time deal, so such a shop-made tool might work well here.

Re: bench dogs

#13

Re: I was born feeling frugal.....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It doesn't even need a holder. To make a bead on a rail, I snapped a piece off the end of a cheap handsaw and ground the right profile into it. Using a piece of wood clamped onto the rail as a guide, it worked just fine. The price was right, too.

Re: bench dogs

#14

Re: bench dogs...Say yes to Michigan!


Re: bench dogs

#15

Re: I was born feeling frugal.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Roger

I will give you more info on the Veritas beader on the weekend, but it may be enough to comment that my preference is to make a custom beader for each project. These take a few minutes. Steel is from a used 3/4" bandsaw blade.




Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ANewAngleOnScratchStock.html

Regards from Perth

Derek